Press "Enter" to skip to content

Locked Doors, Bolted Fences: Exclusion in Modern American Neighborhoods | Martha Isaacs | TEDxUNC


growing up my home was an animal house

tarantulas veiled chameleons bearded

dragons corn snakes mice rats ferrets

ducklings you name it we took in cats

rescued from the aftermath of Hurricane

Katrina quails that my friend’s parents

do not allow them to keep and dogs save

for medical experimentation the only

time I would see my father cry was when

a duckling would fall victim to a birth

defect or a swooping owl looking for

prey oops this duckling was born with

its feet facing upwards so we fed it by

hand until it passed away a few days

after it emerged from the egg recently I

so missed the feeling of holding

something small that I got a long-haired

Syrian hamster matcha in my senior year

of high school I brought in my chicken

puff saved from a slaughterhouse in for

show-and-tell I wanted to show my

classmates the sheer Wonder and the

chickens small eyes as she scanned her

new environment our classroom everyone

was enjoying puffs explorations

including my professor until puff

squawked and released warm feces onto

the floor I didn’t mind though I had

seen worse my family had dealt with it

all from bunnies with botfly infections

two dogs that had been run over by cars

anyone in any condition was welcome in

our house I recently realized that it

was my parents insistence on radical

inclusion on welcoming in the ill

injured and unwanted creatures that has

prompted my own interest in urban

planning and housing affordability our

home was a place we could use to house

to heal to protect and to snuggle these

creatures that could not find shelter

elsewhere these process

seemed to make sense from an efficiency

perspective if you have an available

space might as well fill it up with

those who will utilize it so I wonder

why do humans push away difference why

do people want to ban others from

entering the US based on their religion

why do residents feel uncomfortable

living near public housing developments

why do universities create lists of

individuals banned from campus but

neglect to support undocumented students

why has the concept of home becomes

something to protect and to exclude one

one example of this exclusion manifests

in defensive architecture or the

practice of physically designing space

so that it is no longer inhabitable

examples in courtyards and plazas across

the world include pointed spikes on

ground materials or park benches that

are impossible to sleep on this is an

attempt to control who uses which spaces

at which times especially discouraging

people experiencing homelessness from

lingering in public areas but would you

blame someone without a park bench for

taking refuge would you blame someone

without a bed for taking refuge on a

park bench even the concept of public

space has never been truly public the

ancient Greek Agora and Athens the

prototype for public interaction areas

was only available to free white male

citizens I think that this mindset both

in ancient Athens and now stems largely

from fear social critics ranging from

criminology scholar marie lee to

documentary and michael moore discuss

the rise of the fear of violent crime in

the US and the if it bleeds it leads

mindset prevalent in North American

media news sources aside

in actuality violent crime peaked in

1991 and fell in the following decade

while it has increased recently in some

cities the homicide level in Chicago is

still much lower than it was 25 years

ago this graph depicts the decrease in

the national homicide rate since 1995

but proponents of a narrative that

elevates these numbers appeal to a fear

of black men a fear of immigrants a fear

of people experiencing homelessness the

same fear that fuels exclusion and

homogeneity according to political

science professors Alton heindl

communities with larger black

populations in still greater fear in

white citizens when the formerly

depressed Northeast Corridor if H Street

in DC was redeveloped the new businesses

newcomers to the area reported black men

that they assumed to be completing drug

deals turns out they were merely

standing on street corners walking

through their neighborhood just as they

had before new waves of gentrification

entered residents and fear can even use

the built environment to physically

exclude difference from their

neighborhoods today more than 10 million

housing communities in the US are in

gated communities where AB gate or fence

physically obstructs outsiders various

euphemisms for marketing gated

communities include landscape resort

community master planned community or

secluded intimate neighborhood realtor’s

mark these communities and market them

their privacy and security definitely

not their sense of place or

opportunities for interaction

capitalism’s drive for profit

accumulation fuels commercialization of

lock boxes and security systems as

homeowners invest in privacy rather than

the essential social capital for social

cohesion in the local example of Durham

North Carolina you can see a racial

divide of difference that

IFS spatially across the city several

factors are at play here historically

black neighborhoods that were literally

zoned for black homes because of their

poor drainage and whiter more wealthy

areas around Duke University Latino

populations are also clustered but there

is not a single Latino representative on

the durham city council in my hometown

of Baltimore Maryland systemic racism is

responsible for the red lining and

highway construction that has divided

the city by race and the lead paint that

disproportionately affects those

neighborhoods that are majority black

Baltimore’s Seoul metro line does not

stop in wealthy white neighborhoods

because of suburban Knights stigma

surrounding public transit and the fear

of inundation by inner city dwellers

when Freddie gray was killed in 2015 he

was arrested in the same neighborhood

that he grew up in trapped by lack of

social mobility stemming from poor

spatial mobility spatial disparities

affect quality of life the median income

for black families in Baltimore is not

even half that of whites and this will

not change unless facial disparities can

diminish and people can share the jobs

schools and health care that booth

for starters we can reclaim strange

streets from automobiles and make them

for people again one of my urban

planning role models Alex Washburn who

you des heard speak has left his office

as the chief urban designer of New York

City and set up an open house in his

home in Red Hook Brooklyn he invites

people to come to his home and discuss

Hurricane sandy recovery and the influx

of capital from the new neighborhood

IKEA store social bonds created through

engagement build community and I don’t

think we can do this with big fences

around our houses better block a group

that empowers communities to transform

their car centered spaces creates bike

lanes trees outdoor seating areas and

open businesses so that instead of

wanting to cross the street in fear of

another resident people want to linger

in public spaces better blocks model

encourages the social interaction that

drive social cohesion and they’re not

the only group that thinks this way

Daniel Aldrich another UNC alum and

current director of the Center for

resilient study is at Northeastern

University asserts that social not

merely physical infrastructure just as

you heard from alex Washburn drives

resilience if communities can’t talk to

other diverse minds we won’t be able to

share the resources that are essential

for success one example of the value of

social capital exists in yanami Sanriku

a japanese coastal town that was

destroyed after the 2011 tsunami and

earthquake in the wake of mass

destruction as Minami Sanriku residents

to not know whose land was whose they

started crafting together building a

community art space and creating a

mascot octopus kun as a symbol for unity

they ended up selling the brand and a

toy and gaining enough revenue to

rebuild their homes according to Harvard

Law Professor Gerald E froob there is no

legal definition of

munity it is instead an informal

phenomenon that must be intentionally

pursued I’m not trying to suggest that

everyone to leave their doors unlocked

all the time we still need to be aware

of our surroundings but small pushes

towards connection might or might start

to dissolve the individualism found on

suburban curvilinear streets be like the

residents of octopus kisan raghu make an

octopus kun for your neighborhood walk

on the street and talk to you you see

work in a community garden make dinner

for the family next door that just moved

in if your town allows it consider

raising ducks might be a great

conversation starter with the neighbors

thank you [Applause]

Please follow and like us: