Press "Enter" to skip to content

Becoming vs Being | Anupam Raghuvanshi | TEDxBMU


when John Lennon was a child his mother

told him that the only key to happiness

the ‘kathy hold the key to life is

happiness when John went to school they

gave him an assignment along with the

whole class and the assignment was all

about what do you want to become when

you grow old and John wrote happy the

teachers called him and then they asked

him John you did not understand the

assignment and John Lennon replied you

know what you don’t understand life in

our life today in this tangible world we

all are eventually wanting to be happy

and joyous but the road to this

happiness is not direct though so

everybody wants respect in society they

want sufficient amount of money now

sufficiency with money is a very

subjective term nobody knows how much is

too much they all want to be famous in

their own state by doing whatever

they’re doing everybody wants to be

satisfied they want to be secure and

only when they have achieved all these

things they want to be happy and joyous

the past three decades of economic

development in India has done a lot to

India then what we know about it and the

best of the impact is that it has given

birth to this great Indian middle class

this great individual class has learned

to dream that’s another beautiful thing

that has happened and the three

components of this great Indian will

class the dream of course I’m talking

about the three components are number

one they all have wanted to build their

own home or house in an urban area

they’re still wanting to the second is

they all wanting to have a very great

and third in the last they’re wanting

very great quality education for their

children and this great integral class

is going all the way they’re doing

everything possible working day and

night to make all or some of these

components of their dream come true now

they’re seriously nothing wrong with the

first in the second part in relative

sense of course but when it comes to the

to the second one sorry third one

educating the child there is a serious

flaw I have come across a lot of quotes

in my life I really have been reading

these quotes from here and there from

different perspectives and societies

hello Joey and two of these greatest

scores that I’ve come across are

subscribed to to children

the first quote is every child comes or

takes birth with a message that God is

still not fed above human beings but

decide has not comes to this world all

alone is brought into this world so the

second code becomes much more

interesting and that reads that the

decision of having a children a child

the decision of having a child is like

letting the heart walk out of your body

forever now this is a very very serious

code I don’t know how and what we

understand about this but I would want

all of you as lot of people have been

doing to close your eyes this last time

and not only to listen to me but to feel

through my words that I am going to say

and please do it you have worked very

hard as a part belonging to that great

Indian middle class you have got

yourself educated you’ve got across a

lot of barriers faced the challenges and

you have made a great life out of it

you’ve made a good home and you have an

amazing kid boy or girl repents you’re

wanting everything your is investing

you’re doing everything for your child

to do great in life

you want him to face the toughest of

competitions to qualify to get educated

in one of the best places possible the

biggest of the and the greatest of the

institution you have ever known the

world has known for that matter and you

also want that he should be getting a

good job in one of the fortune 500

companies with a very very fat package

to satisfy all his material needs

whatsoever of today and of course as it

goes in Indian society you also want him

to get married in time and also want him

to have kids good kids you want all

these things to happen with your kid and

there is nothing wrong with that and

then suddenly this happens

this is a classic video just open your eyes and look at this this was short a

eyes and look at this this was short a story that really shook me as a

story that really shook me as a counselor as a mentor and this was a

counselor as a mentor and this was a video that this child is making just

video that this child is making just before he committed suicide I would have

before he committed suicide I would have really wanted to listen to that but then

really wanted to listen to that but then was it been very buddy gruesome also at

was it been very buddy gruesome also at the same time in this video is talking

the same time in this video is talking about how his how his grandparents

about how his how his grandparents always used to say that he could not do

always used to say that he could not do anything how he has ditched everybody

anything how he has ditched everybody when they wanted him to do so well in

when they wanted him to do so well in life and how he could not do anything in

life and how he could not do anything in life how he has given up and how it has

life how he has given up and how it has been so much so very so very tormenting

been so much so very so very tormenting for him for him to live this life and to

for him for him to live this life and to go to to undergo the kind of trauma that

go to to undergo the kind of trauma that he is undergoing right now and and and

he is undergoing right now and and and he’s so much he remembers his mother he

he’s so much he remembers his mother he said that the only person attaching me

said that the only person attaching me still with this life is you but still

still with this life is you but still what I’m undergoing right now is much

what I’m undergoing right now is much much more than that attachment and let

much more than that attachment and let me just end it all up he also gives a

me just end it all up he also gives a message to his father they do you know

message to his father they do you know what you have one more son you take care

what you have one more son you take care of him very well he doesn’t goes on to

of him very well he doesn’t goes on to say how to take care of a child very

say how to take care of a child very well but he has a question and he says

well but he has a question and he says that then you take care of him very well

that then you take care of him very well he also gives a message to his younger

he also gives a message to his younger brother that hey I am doing this do not

brother that hey I am doing this do not even think of anything which is closer

even think of anything which is closer to this committing suicide I’m not going

to this committing suicide I’m not going to show you the the the suicidal point

to show you the the the suicidal point but then like I’m just leaving you with

but then like I’m just leaving you with this video to to make a context which is

this video to to make a context which is going to be very very clear they said

going to be very very clear they said that there is nothing as heavy people

that there is nothing as heavy people say that there’s nothing as heavy as the

say that there’s nothing as heavy as the as the coffin of your own son or a

as the coffin of your own son or a daughter or in own shoulders there’s the

daughter or in own shoulders there’s the heaviest thing in life for any human to

heaviest thing in life for any human to have and after this you suddenly want

have and after this you suddenly want him to be back you are ready to give up

him to be back you are ready to give up everything you are make making all

everything you are make making all amendments you are ready to change

amendments you are ready to change yourself absolutely and want him back

yourself absolutely and want him back but he’s gone you want to be with him

but he’s gone you want to be with him him to be living you cannot do anything

him to be living you cannot do anything now but you did not do anything when it

now but you did not do anything when it was required the most

was required the most you could not see him sleeping in fetal

you could not see him sleeping in fetal positions for days you could not see him

positions for days you could not see him losing his charm for a period of time

losing his charm for a period of time you did not he used to be a bundle of

you did not he used to be a bundle of joy and you did did not recognize when

joy and you did did not recognize when there was a behavioral change in him you

there was a behavioral change in him you kept on telling motivational stories on

kept on telling motivational stories on his face you kept on telling him as to

his face you kept on telling him as to how somebody has gone on to do this

how somebody has gone on to do this crack this competition whatever and so

crack this competition whatever and so he can also do it your child did not die

he can also do it your child did not die all of a sudden had this video been

all of a sudden had this video been played

played you could have listened to that your

you could have listened to that your child definitely did not die all of a

child definitely did not die all of a sudden he was dying since last many days

sudden he was dying since last many days or probably many years but you could not

or probably many years but you could not recognize and why he died because then

recognize and why he died because then he was dying because he was trying to

he was dying because he was trying to live up to the expectation which was way

live up to the expectation which was way beyond his capacity and belief capacity

beyond his capacity and belief capacity and potential and belief it is you who

and potential and belief it is you who believed him to be doing something and

believed him to be doing something and never he did so the quest always has

never he did so the quest always has been become you know between this

been become you know between this becoming and being the parents focus on

becoming and being the parents focus on what their child could become based on

what their child could become based on an assumed future not on what they could

an assumed future not on what they could be based on their Flair and interests of

be based on their Flair and interests of today instead of providing theirs their

today instead of providing theirs their kids wings and giving them courage to

kids wings and giving them courage to fly the parents treat their kids like

fly the parents treat their kids like kites with a string attached in their

kites with a string attached in their hands and they go on increasing the

hands and they go on increasing the distance of the kite with them but still

distance of the kite with them but still still their string is in their hands

still their string is in their hands they never realize that whether his kite

they never realize that whether his kite or their kite which they are holding is

or their kite which they are holding is able to take that kind of a pressure and

able to take that kind of a pressure and tension which they are exerting every

tension which they are exerting every time there they are releasing this

time there they are releasing this particular string from their hands and

particular string from their hands and the distance is increasing and

the distance is increasing and eventually one day it breaks and the guy

eventually one day it breaks and the guy goes forever

goes forever this is a very interesting picture if

this is a very interesting picture if you can look at a classic Indian

you can look at a classic Indian classroom model where the teacher is

classroom model where the teacher is asking symbolically this is a very

asking symbolically this is a very symbolic poster some of you have seen it

symbolic poster some of you have seen it also this crow monkey penguin elephant

also this crow monkey penguin elephant fish a seal Anna Anna and a dog and the

fish a seal Anna Anna and a dog and the teacher is saying for a fair selection

teacher is saying for a fair selection you all have to take up this test of

you all have to take up this test of climbing on the street Albert Einstein

climbing on the street Albert Einstein once said everybody is a genius but if

once said everybody is a genius but if you judge a fish by its ability to climb

you judge a fish by its ability to climb a tree it will make him it will make him

a tree it will make him it will make him whole life believe that he is a stupid

whole life believe that he is a stupid how can you in this world possibly ask a

how can you in this world possibly ask a fish to climb on a tree but definitely

fish to climb on a tree but definitely children mature at a different age their

children mature at a different age their biological age is symbolic though so if

biological age is symbolic though so if we have all 10 year olds all 20 year

we have all 10 year olds all 20 year olds in front of me it is very very easy

olds in front of me it is very very easy for me without analyzing them to assume

for me without analyzing them to assume that they all hold equal competencies

that they all hold equal competencies but actually what lies within them is a

but actually what lies within them is a different maturity level which is

different maturity level which is symbolic to this particular picture that

symbolic to this particular picture that is their smartness is directly related

is their smartness is directly related to grades is another very very bad thing

to grades is another very very bad thing that has happened to them to the to the

that has happened to them to the to the nation right now competencies such as

nation right now competencies such as creativity and problem-solving qualities

creativity and problem-solving qualities are either sidelined or even they are

are either sidelined or even they are graded not enhanced or encouraged

graded not enhanced or encouraged another one is a very very interesting

another one is a very very interesting poster again if you can look at this

poster again if you can look at this these are all sheep trying to come out

these are all sheep trying to come out of the rear of the of the barn now what

of the rear of the of the barn now what is happening here is that there is only

is happening here is that there is only one gate and they’re all following each

one gate and they’re all following each other interesting thing is there is

other interesting thing is there is absolutely no boundary so they’re all

absolutely no boundary so they’re all trying to zip in through the gate only

trying to zip in through the gate only thereby creating a lot of confusion and

thereby creating a lot of confusion and chaos at the gate and that leads to a

chaos at the gate and that leads to a competition also those from right and

competition also those from right and left could have easily walked over and

left could have easily walked over and made their own path it could have been a

made their own path it could have been a displacement reduce the distance and

displacement reduce the distance and also they could have faster travel but

also they could have faster travel but no out of my all these years of

no out of my all these years of counseling experience and thousands of

counseling experience and thousands of students a girl walks into me and she

students a girl walks into me and she says that she’s not having any friends

says that she’s not having any friends why because of a simple reason there’ll

why because of a simple reason there’ll be a distraction to her

be a distraction to her in there come in our competition another

in there come in our competition another child tells me that he has not watched

child tells me that he has not watched movie since last two years although he

movie since last two years although he so much wants to watch it how many times

so much wants to watch it how many times children have come and come up to me in

children have come and come up to me in fact and say that you know what how many

fact and say that you know what how many times I have tried to search on internet

times I have tried to search on internet of the safest and the and the easiest

of the safest and the and the easiest method to die and this is all happening

method to die and this is all happening all all under our nose a degree maybe a

all all under our nose a degree maybe a passport to a job why because this is

passport to a job why because this is what picking and not seeing it happening

what picking and not seeing it happening and agree maybe a passport to a job but

and agree maybe a passport to a job but may not be a passport to success and

may not be a passport to success and definitely it is never a passport to

definitely it is never a passport to happiness the whole idea of Education

happiness the whole idea of Education does is status and and money the old

does is status and and money the old scriptures in India also says that when

scriptures in India also says that when they are the dot ammonium Vania day a

they are the dot ammonium Vania day a teapot rhythm patrut wattle mop Northey

teapot rhythm patrut wattle mop Northey Vinod thermometer so come it says the

Vinod thermometer so come it says the context is education leads to happiness

context is education leads to happiness but it does not automatically makes you

but it does not automatically makes you happy it undergoes a process we are a

happy it undergoes a process we are a part of this universe and it’s the way

part of this universe and it’s the way we connect with the universe defines our

we connect with the universe defines our happiness and definitely this happens

happiness and definitely this happens with what profession we choose after all

with what profession we choose after all that we have learned through the

that we have learned through the education that we have got the whole

education that we have got the whole context of learning has to be understood

context of learning has to be understood for this the whole context of learning

for this the whole context of learning is layers of learning the first layer of

is layers of learning the first layer of this learning is of course education it

this learning is of course education it comes through that institution of

comes through that institution of learning which a person cannot create or

learning which a person cannot create or recreate for himself it includes all the

recreate for himself it includes all the teachers books professor school colleges

teachers books professor school colleges everything the second layer is the

everything the second layer is the exposure that the people should

exposure that the people should definitely get because they learn in one

definitely get because they learn in one ecosystem and when they transact what

ecosystem and when they transact what they whatever they have learned from one

they whatever they have learned from one ecosystem in diverse ecosystems then

ecosystem in diverse ecosystems then their net learning increases why because

their net learning increases why because the point of views is a absolute new

the point of views is a absolute new discovery that they undergo and the

discovery that they undergo and the third and the last layer of learning is

third and the last layer of learning is experience when they applicate whatever

experience when they applicate whatever they have learned now what happens here

they have learned now what happens here is it never turns into experiential

is it never turns into experiential learning because most of the time what

learning because most of the time what people learn never inspires them well we

people learn never inspires them well we have two fairly understand I started the

have two fairly understand I started the talk with John Lennon every child is an

talk with John Lennon every child is an artist unless he is told he is not an

artist unless he is told he is not an artist so

artist so try to bridge the gap for them to

try to bridge the gap for them to experience this happiness let us be the

experience this happiness let us be the catalytic advantage for them and and

catalytic advantage for them and and help our child find who is and to do to

help our child find who is and to do to let him be trust me he’ll one day become

let him be trust me he’ll one day become whatever he is trying to become and he

whatever he is trying to become and he will become that thank you

will become that thank you [Applause]

Please follow and like us: