
[Music]
[Applause]
[Music]
tell me what’s really good I am a very
happy failure 40 years ago I took off to
the Amazon to convert a tribe of Indians
called the pita ha to Christianity I was
going to translate the Bible for them I
was going to tell them about the fact
that they don’t need to fear death that
they’re going to go to heaven after they
die and and contribute my life in
exchange for their happiness that was my
goal so we boarded up this small Cessna
single-engine aircraft in December of
1977 and I was going to go see these
people for the first time I had some
anxiety I was excited I didn’t know what
I was going to find and we took off in
two hours later we landed on this small
jungle strip in the middle of the Amazon
and the first thing that I realized was
I was very airsick and we opened the
plane doors and we were surrounded by
dozens of pitas talking to us in a
language that I couldn’t make out a
single syllable asking me questions
pulling on me and I picked up a stick
off the ground and I said this is a
stick and they said it and I dropped it
and they said it he migit Gabi and I was
on my way to learning the language as
they as they started to show me around
the village one man pulled me by the arm
and he he showed me a large rat a 15
pound rodent actually called apakah
roasting on a fire I could smell the
hair blood was still coming out of the
mouth and it sort of turned my stomach
this got me outside of my comfort zone
very quickly I my idea of a good meal is
white bread and chicken gravy and eating
a rat wasn’t wasn’t there in fact later
that day when I was putting mustard that
I had brought from the city on a bologna
sandwich you can see I was adapting very
slowly
a woman came up behind me and she said
look Dan’s eating bird and I looked
at the mustard and listened to the sound
and I could see where she got that
impression but when I turned to talk to
her her hand was full of a roasted rat
head and she was sucking the brains out
so she was grossed out by my food and I
wasn’t terribly pleased by what she was
eating what I have found over the years
is that information is hard to come by
new information is hard to come by when
we surround ourselves by people who look
like us and talk like us and eat like us
and think like us there’s very little
room for additional learning but when I
was surrounded by the PETA ha every
single syllable I heard every day long
was new information to me it was a
chance to learn the language turned out
to be one of the most unusual languages
anyone has ever studied it was my
privilege to go there I asked the word
for skin and I got away and I asked the
word for ear and I got away and I asked
the word for hand and I got away and as
the word for Brazil nutshell and I got
away and then I asked the word for me
and I got chit and I asked the word for
a dog excrement and I gotcha
I asked the word for enemy eventually
and they said McGee I and so I said how
do I say friend
McGee I and the tones are vital to every
vowel in the language if you don’t have
the right tone it’s only to high and low
you don’t get the language and because
it has tones it can be whistled it can
be hummed whenever they wanted to lose
me they just started whistling and I
couldn’t follow what they were saying I
also learned that the language has a
syntax a grammar that’s very different
from any other grammar that’s been
studied so for example I can say in
English you drink you paddle your canoe
you may drown but in peat aha you can
only say you drink you paddle your canoe
you may drown that sounds like a subtle
difference but it’s caused all sorts of
controversy in cognitive science to say
that the people choose to talk like that
and then I started working on numbers
and I thought that number one was the
word win and I thought the number two
was the word weigh and I thought the
word for many was boggy so but it turns
out that way just means a few when means
a few more and bagi so means piling
stuff on top of each other a lot of
stuff of people without numbers not even
the number one this was greeted with
tremendous skepticism scientists came
from Columbia University Stanford from
MIT and they did all sorts of
experiments to try to prove me wrong but
in fact that’s the way the peat aha are
and the first language ever documented
without numbers was found it showed us a
different way of thinking it showed us
how extensive the perimeters of the
human experience are and how many
lessons there are to learn from people
very unlike ourselves the words for
color you know my hair used to be red
and they told me that it was a beta site
so I put that down as red and then I
found something that was black and I
said co-pi is something that was white
and they said colby i but then i noticed
they changed the words very frequently
and finally I realized these aren’t even
words these are descriptions they might
say my skin is transparent or you can
see through it or they might say that my
hair looks like blood or they might say
that
the river color of the river is the
color of not being ripe they use
different ways to describe different
things and I started to link these
things to a single principle which I
call the immediacy of experience
principle which is not that they can’t
think about the past or they can’t think
about the future but they prefer not to
talk about things in the distant future
in the distant past for which there is
no evidence so for example one day I
said so who created the world this is a
good missionary question and they said
what do you mean I said you know there
were no trees somebody made the trees
you were there when there were no trees
you’ve seen the jungle without trees how
old are you and okay so it turns out
they don’t believe anything was ever
created they don’t have a concept of God
there’s no need for him and they’re in
their system and as a missionary I was
talking to them a lot about Jesus so one
day a group of men came in and they said
hey Dan so Jesus did he look more like
us or did he look more like you I said
well you know some people said he looked
more like me and other people said he
looked more like you yeah but you’ve
seen him so what does he look like I
said well actually I’ve never seen him
but your father saw him no my dad never
saw him either well who saw him I said
nobody he’s lived a long time ago well
if he lived a long time ago and nobody
saw him why are you telling us about
and it occurred to me that all the
evidence that I had accumulated in Bible
School and in all my prayers and and all
my activity as a Christian didn’t hold
up to the evidentiary requirements of
this group of a few hundred hundred
hunter-gatherers in the Amazon they
weren’t they weren’t convinced by this
at all so finally one day they came in
and they said hey Dan
you know we like you but we don’t want
any Jesus we don’t want to know about
this stuff you know it’s okay for
Americans they like to believe that
stuff but Peter how don’t believe that
stuff and so I had to focus on other
things and what I had gone there to do
was to tell them about no fear of death
but then it turns out they’re not afraid
of death death is just a natural part of
life so I wanted to help him learn how
to be happy but when I took researchers
from MIT there they said these must be
the happiest people on earth and I said
well how would you how would you study
that and they said we’ll just measure
the time they spend smiling and laughing
I bet it’s more than anybody else so I
had no happiness offer from I had no
fear of death so I try to talk to them
about a judgment and and how to live and
this the most important commandment
among the PETA has don’t tell anybody
else what to do everybody does life’s
hard enough just live your life the best
you can so that didn’t work either and
eventually I came to realization if it
doesn’t work for them it probably
shouldn’t be working for me and I became
an atheist so the only convert I ever
got
my only convert was me so so I’m a
failure there’s no Pina ha believers
there’s no church they don’t none of
that stuff work but I learned a lot
about language so I decided like maybe
there was some useful profession I can
enter so I became a linguist and an
anthropologist and and began I’m just
trying to understand their culture and
in even greater detail and realizing
that new information is again as I’ve
said hard to come by if you sit in a
room with people who look just like you
who are your gender who are your age
your economic background the chances of
getting really new information are
minimal because everybody already agrees
it’s like a famous philosopher friend of
mine said once I don’t read anything
because if they disagree with me they’re
wrong and if they agree with me I
already knew that often that’s that’s
the way we think until somebody forces
us to think differently so how can we
possibly bring newness to our life how
can we without going through the Amazon
transform our experience and our
relationship to the world in such a way
that we open channels of new information
many computer scientists define learning
as change behavior after exposure to new
information so where do we get this new
information well one suggestion is
especially in a place like Philadelphia
look around you and find people
different from yourselves make friends
of different genders of different sexual
orientations but especially make friends
with families and one thing I suggest to
people you don’t have to travel outside
the United States find a family that’s
willing to tolerate you for a week and
go live with them for a week and live
under their rules and taste their food
and more than taste their food learn to
like it and if they’re from a different
religion learn to respect how they
believe and understand how they believe
so you’re not just a tourist in their
home you’re actually living in their
home by their rules I had to do this for
the very first time with the Southall
Indians of southern Mexico my family we
went to live with the South halls we
spent several nights with them we had
sleeping on the dirt floors we had rats
running around we had all sorts of
experiences we hadn’t imagined
but at the end of the time we learn to
respect them and their beliefs they
learned a little bit more about us of
course the food wasn’t a problem with
the cell tall’s because they’re
descendants of the Mayas and they eat
tortillas black beans and chillies and
that is the that is my favorite food in
the world so that wasn’t that wasn’t
terribly a challenge but then when we
look around us and think about corporate
corporations and governance and and how
we can bring this kind of newness into
our lives take it take a look at the
typical boardroom or or and if everyone
around that board table looks the same
you can bet that this is not going to be
an innovative company if you look at
college admissions if most of the people
coming in are young white males there’s
not going to be a lot of innovation
their diversity is essential to ensure
for every one of us new information a
constant flow and a constant challenge
we don’t it’s too often we all feel like
missionaries we want to go out and
change the world
when in fact we have to begin as
students and not only begin as students
but spend the most of our life with
students I find that the smartest people
I know are among the best listeners the
people who cultivate relations with
people unlike themselves so the pita had
changed my life I’m a failure as a
missionary I’m a mediocre scientist but
I have learned a tremendous amount
through the world of through the eyes of
the pita ha who called themselves he I
chair the straight ones and we are all
away which means crooked so they’re
ethnocentric thank you very much
[Applause]
[Applause]
[Music]
tell me what’s really good I am a very
happy failure 40 years ago I took off to
the Amazon to convert a tribe of Indians
called the pita ha to Christianity I was
going to translate the Bible for them I
was going to tell them about the fact
that they don’t need to fear death that
they’re going to go to heaven after they
die and and contribute my life in
exchange for their happiness that was my
goal so we boarded up this small Cessna
single-engine aircraft in December of
1977 and I was going to go see these
people for the first time I had some
anxiety I was excited I didn’t know what
I was going to find and we took off in
two hours later we landed on this small
jungle strip in the middle of the Amazon
and the first thing that I realized was
I was very airsick and we opened the
plane doors and we were surrounded by
dozens of pitas talking to us in a
language that I couldn’t make out a
single syllable asking me questions
pulling on me and I picked up a stick
off the ground and I said this is a
stick and they said it and I dropped it
and they said it he migit Gabi and I was
on my way to learning the language as
they as they started to show me around
the village one man pulled me by the arm
and he he showed me a large rat a 15
pound rodent actually called apakah
roasting on a fire I could smell the
hair blood was still coming out of the
mouth and it sort of turned my stomach
this got me outside of my comfort zone
very quickly I my idea of a good meal is
white bread and chicken gravy and eating
a rat wasn’t wasn’t there in fact later
that day when I was putting mustard that
I had brought from the city on a bologna
sandwich you can see I was adapting very
slowly
a woman came up behind me and she said
look Dan’s eating bird and I looked
at the mustard and listened to the sound
and I could see where she got that
impression but when I turned to talk to
her her hand was full of a roasted rat
head and she was sucking the brains out
so she was grossed out by my food and I
wasn’t terribly pleased by what she was
eating what I have found over the years
is that information is hard to come by
new information is hard to come by when
we surround ourselves by people who look
like us and talk like us and eat like us
and think like us there’s very little
room for additional learning but when I
was surrounded by the PETA ha every
single syllable I heard every day long
was new information to me it was a
chance to learn the language turned out
to be one of the most unusual languages
anyone has ever studied it was my
privilege to go there I asked the word
for skin and I got away and I asked the
word for ear and I got away and I asked
the word for hand and I got away and as
the word for Brazil nutshell and I got
away and then I asked the word for me
and I got chit and I asked the word for
a dog excrement and I gotcha
I asked the word for enemy eventually
and they said McGee I and so I said how
do I say friend
McGee I and the tones are vital to every
vowel in the language if you don’t have
the right tone it’s only to high and low
you don’t get the language and because
it has tones it can be whistled it can
be hummed whenever they wanted to lose
me they just started whistling and I
couldn’t follow what they were saying I
also learned that the language has a
syntax a grammar that’s very different
from any other grammar that’s been
studied so for example I can say in
English you drink you paddle your canoe
you may drown but in peat aha you can
only say you drink you paddle your canoe
you may drown that sounds like a subtle
difference but it’s caused all sorts of
controversy in cognitive science to say
that the people choose to talk like that
and then I started working on numbers
and I thought that number one was the
word win and I thought the number two
was the word weigh and I thought the
word for many was boggy so but it turns
out that way just means a few when means
a few more and bagi so means piling
stuff on top of each other a lot of
stuff of people without numbers not even
the number one this was greeted with
tremendous skepticism scientists came
from Columbia University Stanford from
MIT and they did all sorts of
experiments to try to prove me wrong but
in fact that’s the way the peat aha are
and the first language ever documented
without numbers was found it showed us a
different way of thinking it showed us
how extensive the perimeters of the
human experience are and how many
lessons there are to learn from people
very unlike ourselves the words for
color you know my hair used to be red
and they told me that it was a beta site
so I put that down as red and then I
found something that was black and I
said co-pi is something that was white
and they said colby i but then i noticed
they changed the words very frequently
and finally I realized these aren’t even
words these are descriptions they might
say my skin is transparent or you can
see through it or they might say that my
hair looks like blood or they might say
that
the river color of the river is the
color of not being ripe they use
different ways to describe different
things and I started to link these
things to a single principle which I
call the immediacy of experience
principle which is not that they can’t
think about the past or they can’t think
about the future but they prefer not to
talk about things in the distant future
in the distant past for which there is
no evidence so for example one day I
said so who created the world this is a
good missionary question and they said
what do you mean I said you know there
were no trees somebody made the trees
you were there when there were no trees
you’ve seen the jungle without trees how
old are you and okay so it turns out
they don’t believe anything was ever
created they don’t have a concept of God
there’s no need for him and they’re in
their system and as a missionary I was
talking to them a lot about Jesus so one
day a group of men came in and they said
hey Dan so Jesus did he look more like
us or did he look more like you I said
well you know some people said he looked
more like me and other people said he
looked more like you yeah but you’ve
seen him so what does he look like I
said well actually I’ve never seen him
but your father saw him no my dad never
saw him either well who saw him I said
nobody he’s lived a long time ago well
if he lived a long time ago and nobody
saw him why are you telling us about
and it occurred to me that all the
evidence that I had accumulated in Bible
School and in all my prayers and and all
my activity as a Christian didn’t hold
up to the evidentiary requirements of
this group of a few hundred hundred
hunter-gatherers in the Amazon they
weren’t they weren’t convinced by this
at all so finally one day they came in
and they said hey Dan
you know we like you but we don’t want
any Jesus we don’t want to know about
this stuff you know it’s okay for
Americans they like to believe that
stuff but Peter how don’t believe that
stuff and so I had to focus on other
things and what I had gone there to do
was to tell them about no fear of death
but then it turns out they’re not afraid
of death death is just a natural part of
life so I wanted to help him learn how
to be happy but when I took researchers
from MIT there they said these must be
the happiest people on earth and I said
well how would you how would you study
that and they said we’ll just measure
the time they spend smiling and laughing
I bet it’s more than anybody else so I
had no happiness offer from I had no
fear of death so I try to talk to them
about a judgment and and how to live and
this the most important commandment
among the PETA has don’t tell anybody
else what to do everybody does life’s
hard enough just live your life the best
you can so that didn’t work either and
eventually I came to realization if it
doesn’t work for them it probably
shouldn’t be working for me and I became
an atheist so the only convert I ever
got
my only convert was me so so I’m a
failure there’s no Pina ha believers
there’s no church they don’t none of
that stuff work but I learned a lot
about language so I decided like maybe
there was some useful profession I can
enter so I became a linguist and an
anthropologist and and began I’m just
trying to understand their culture and
in even greater detail and realizing
that new information is again as I’ve
said hard to come by if you sit in a
room with people who look just like you
who are your gender who are your age
your economic background the chances of
getting really new information are
minimal because everybody already agrees
it’s like a famous philosopher friend of
mine said once I don’t read anything
because if they disagree with me they’re
wrong and if they agree with me I
already knew that often that’s that’s
the way we think until somebody forces
us to think differently so how can we
possibly bring newness to our life how
can we without going through the Amazon
transform our experience and our
relationship to the world in such a way
that we open channels of new information
many computer scientists define learning
as change behavior after exposure to new
information so where do we get this new
information well one suggestion is
especially in a place like Philadelphia
look around you and find people
different from yourselves make friends
of different genders of different sexual
orientations but especially make friends
with families and one thing I suggest to
people you don’t have to travel outside
the United States find a family that’s
willing to tolerate you for a week and
go live with them for a week and live
under their rules and taste their food
and more than taste their food learn to
like it and if they’re from a different
religion learn to respect how they
believe and understand how they believe
so you’re not just a tourist in their
home you’re actually living in their
home by their rules I had to do this for
the very first time with the Southall
Indians of southern Mexico my family we
went to live with the South halls we
spent several nights with them we had
sleeping on the dirt floors we had rats
running around we had all sorts of
experiences we hadn’t imagined
but at the end of the time we learn to
respect them and their beliefs they
learned a little bit more about us of
course the food wasn’t a problem with
the cell tall’s because they’re
descendants of the Mayas and they eat
tortillas black beans and chillies and
that is the that is my favorite food in
the world so that wasn’t that wasn’t
terribly a challenge but then when we
look around us and think about corporate
corporations and governance and and how
we can bring this kind of newness into
our lives take it take a look at the
typical boardroom or or and if everyone
around that board table looks the same
you can bet that this is not going to be
an innovative company if you look at
college admissions if most of the people
coming in are young white males there’s
not going to be a lot of innovation
their diversity is essential to ensure
for every one of us new information a
constant flow and a constant challenge
we don’t it’s too often we all feel like
missionaries we want to go out and
change the world
when in fact we have to begin as
students and not only begin as students
but spend the most of our life with
students I find that the smartest people
I know are among the best listeners the
people who cultivate relations with
people unlike themselves so the pita had
changed my life I’m a failure as a
missionary I’m a mediocre scientist but
I have learned a tremendous amount
through the world of through the eyes of
the pita ha who called themselves he I
chair the straight ones and we are all
away which means crooked so they’re
ethnocentric thank you very much
[Applause]
Please follow and like us: