Press "Enter" to skip to content

Why Colleges Should Stop Using Textbooks | Naseem Saloojee | TEDxQueensU


hey there being in a nice auditorium

like this in front of a beautiful crowd

like yourselves takes me back to my

first week on campus I sat in an

auditorium not dissimilar to this one I

filed in there in the middle to the back

i sat beside a guy and a girl and I

listened to a professor and the

professor started talking he started

reading from a set of slides and over

the course of class we realized that he

was reading from a set of pre-prepared

slides that came with the textbook and

the slides summarized the textbook

chapter that we were supposed to have

read before we got there the girl to my

left fell asleep the guy to my right

filled around his laptop I did not go

back to that class again the word

lecture the origin of the world let that

word lecture is electus which in Latin

means that which is read here we have a

lecture hall in the Middle Ages as you

can see there’s a professor standing

with a book from what she’s reading and

students who are taking notes here we

have a lecture hall today notice

anything similar here we have a

professor standing in front of our cloud

of students those students are again

taking notes and that professors reading

this time maybe it’s from a set of

PowerPoint slides so we’ve got all of

this power in our pockets we’ve got more

information in our fingertips then

generations before us could ever have

imagined yet this is what’s happening in

the classroom makes no sense to me 11:00

now this is the number of times that a

student will check his or her phone

during class ninety-two so the

percentage of students the percentage of

students who send a text message during

class now think about that for a second

there about five of 500 of you here in

this room I’m basically giving you a

lecture what that means

that 460 of you are going to send a text

message at some point during my speech

eight seconds this is the average

attention span of a student in class

I kid you not it’s down from 12 seconds

in 2000 so what I’m telling you is that

we had four more seconds and you guys in

my day now clearly things have changed

right I’ll give you another stat and

that’s 79 who here is felt anxiety when

you’re without your cell phone okay a

good number right 79 percent is the

percentage of generations ears who feel

anxiety when separated from one cell

phone so clearly we have changed as a

society for better for worse technology

is impacting us in ways we never could

have imagined the ways we learn are

changing yet the way we teach has not

evolved in hundreds of years I want to

talk to you about some small changes

that are already happening some big

changes that could happen and five

things that I think will happen in a big

way over the next five years first off

this is something I think many of you

would like to see happen we will see the

end in the next few years of the

traditional textbook here we have a

chart that some of you might have seen

it Maps textbook prices as you can see

there’s CPI over the last 35 or so years

the cost of goods and services in our

society has risen by about two hundred

and fifty percent right so slowly but

surely there’s been a rise in prices

certain certain other areas of the

economy like housing have seen slightly

faster optics than that and then we have

textbook prices textbook prices over the

last 35 years have risen in over 900

percent so three times as fast as

everything else in the economy textbooks

rise in price so why is that textbook

publishers have taken advantage of

something that economists refer to as an

agency cost the person who makes the

buying decision the professor is not the

same person who actually pays for the

product a student and these two customer

groups have very different wants

NEADS now you would think that with this

agency cost and with these rising prices

these textbook publishers they just must

be making a killing right well here’s

Pearson stock price and you can see that

big dip it dipped 30% in a single day

ten days ago these guys are under threat

so we think they must be making money

but they’re not so why who here has

bought a used textbook before yeah nice

everybody put their hand out that’s good

so did I so with all of these people

buying used textbooks the textbook

publishers have been forced to iterate

on their model so they’re now releasing

new versions of textbooks every two to

three years every couple of years you’ve

got version 7 of algebra going to

version 8 now what does that do it

reduces a ton of new costs into the

system distribution well prior to that

editing prior to that graphics design

prior to that finding authors who are

going to rewrite these textbooks when

you add up all of the costs it’s pretty

clear why these guys have an

unsustainable business model and the

publishers are constantly trying to get

ahead of students but they’re failing

students aren’t just buying used their

photocopying books they’re scanning them

they’re downloading torrent ‘add ebooks

they’re sharing books some students

don’t even buy the books at all so

they’re under threat the physical

textbook is going the way of the dodo

right but that’s not the only reason why

these guys are our under threat

second is that user-generated content

will become the norm now it’s

unfathomable to me why this hasn’t come

sooner I got four years people have been

talking about how there must need to be

a Wikipedia of textbooks alright so you

guys all know the story of Wikipedia and

how it completely destructed the

encyclopedia industry right the

encyclopedias would produce these nice

beautiful versions that would go up on

people’s shelves much the way that

textbooks are sitting up on your shelves

for

– version 3 version 4 and then boom a

snap of a finger they were gone but it

hasn’t happened in universities yet

there are movements around open

educational resources but they haven’t

gripped us they haven’t taken over in

the way that we expected them to the why

so first off in higher ed there’s a very

high bar for quality textbooks need to

be peer reviewed and that comes at a

cost

secondly it’s about the priorities of

your professors the priority of a

professor is research research research

maybe teaching comes down fourth or

fifth on the list right unfortunately

and as a result of the professor’s

priority set any Content that’s

delivered needs to be accompanied by a

suite of resources to make it easy to

deliver that’s why what I believe we’ll

see over the next few years is the

emergence of teaching platforms

interactive teaching platforms that will

allow professors to create content edit

content collaborate on content creation

and ultimately distribute that content

out to students these platforms will

have all of the bells and whistles that

professors require and they’ll also come

with built in marketplaces a marketplace

which will allow professors to make a

little bit of money from peer of you or

even creating content but not so much to

gouge students and so what you’ll see is

that $300 general chemistry textbook it

goes down to one tenth the price but

with better quality and greater

interactivity what also we can see with

the emergence of everything online from

Google when in which you put your daily

thoughts and who can probably tell you

more about each of us than we can tell

it ourselves to Facebook we’re putting

in all of our personal information

Instagram you know uploading all of your

photographs we’ve shown that we’re

willing to trade our privacy for

products that deliver significant

benefit to us in one way or another we

haven’t seen that in higher ed yet but a

reason the Lucien’s study has showed

that 98% of students say they would give

more personal

information if it were to enhance their

educational experiences that’s what

we’re going to see the emergence of

platforms that will track whether

students are coming to class for better

for worse I wouldn’t have liked that

whether they’re participating class

whether questions are right or wrong or

outside of class how people are

progressing through their texts where

the stumbling blocks are and getting all

of this data will help identify which

students are struggling which ones are

not which ones are likely to pass which

ones are likely to fail ultimately it

will help us intervene to stop students

from failing out of school next you guys

have seen a VR exhibit outside of here

today we have glue Google glass oculus

rift these things are operating right

now at the periphery soon enough these

will come to the core and VR will need

to be integrated into the classroom

let’s think about a surgeon for example

he’s performing a surgery that he or she

hasn’t done before so it’s it’s

something complex in the past this

person would have had to read a textbook

maybe talk to a peer look at a couple

photographs and then jump in there

putting the life of that person under

the operating table at risk now surgery

students can put on their helmets and

practice the surgery as many times is

needed to get it right the first time

I believe that classes across the board

will be transformed in this very way

next is new methods to engage students

you know we talked about the changes in

our attention spans we talked about our

reliance and mobile devices yet the vast

majority of professors do not allow

mobile devices in the classroom this

also must change I like to think of

Harvard physicist Eric Mazur here he he

talks about the way that he really he

likes to run his class says look I will

ask my students a question I’ll see how

people did and then I’ll pair the

students who get the question right with

those who got the question wrong and I’m

gonna have the students who got the

question right teach those who go out

the question wrong how to do things

students start teaching themselves it’s

only through use of technology when

you’re standing in a large lecture hall

that you can start facilitating some of

those interactions that you can

facilitate collaboration that you you

can enable group work that you can get

students out of sitting and listening to

somebody and into participating with one

another and taking advantage of all the

brainpower that’s in the room at that

very time next we should it also comes

down to the skills now bringing all of

this together what you think about the

skills that are required for the next

generation so a large body of research

around education to employment and to

summarize it it’s that schools

oftentimes believe that they’re

equipping students with the right skills

to enter the workforce but when you

survey students after they enter the

workforce and you survey employers they

often say the opposite that students are

not prepared for the demands of today’s

workforce and that’s just today with

artificial intelligence the workforce

will change dramatically in the next few

years from Robo surgeons to algorithms

that enable the financial industry to a

great example is Ross the intelligent

attorney which scours all sorts of legal

documentation and is paired with IBM

Watson supercomputer to become this

high-powered paralegal that can do the

vast majority of paralegal functions

today when you think about examples like

this it’s no wonder that a recent Oxford

study said that but 50 percent of jobs

in the u.s. which should hold true here

in Canada as well

will be automated by artificial

intelligence and technology in the

upcoming years so what does that mean

for today’s student we need to stop

teaching students to regurgitate this is

not about a professor reading from a

book and students writing down this is

about teaching critical skills critical

thinking skills it’s about teaching

students to be adaptable it’s teaching

students to become creative problem

solvers it’s having students experiment

to learn how to do these things on their

own so when I imagine the new lecture

hall I imagine a student comes into the

lecture and rather than telling the

student to put his or her device away

the professor says all right let me quiz

you on it I’ll ask you a question maybe

a little poll works through a quiz I’ll

have you collaborate you pair the

students into groups of three or four

and they work through exercises together

as a professor I can engage back and

forth in discussions I can answer

questions I can provoke dialogue and

then start looking at the data of that

class and saying okay these are the

areas in which people are are getting

concepts today and these are the areas

in which we need to hold in a little bit

more and maybe at some point in the

class you throw out slap on your VR

headset and you say okay if I’m in a

chemistry class let’s take a look at

what a molecule looks like up close in

person or if I’m in history class maybe

I’ll go back a couple hundred years and

see the way that things were actually

like and experience them firsthand

well we need to imagine is ways to

integrate the technologies that we have

into the lecture which allow will allow

students to be taught the way they need

to be taught and the way that they

actually learn thank you

[Applause]

[Music]

[Applause] [Music]

Please follow and like us: