
[Music]
my name is Douglas Brooks and I’m an
American boat builder writer and
researcher for the last 20 years I have
been studying traditional Japanese boat
building my research involves working
alongside craftsmen from throughout
Japan
in order to document their design
secrets and techniques in my view this
work is crucial because Japan’s last
generation of boat builders is
disappearing and almost none have taught
apprentices I am the sole apprentice for
all six of my teachers craftsmen from
Sado Island Rhode iesous Tokyo Almaty
Okinawa and ewot day these men have
exposed me to the traditional Japanese
apprentice learning
my first trip to Japan I went to Sado
Island at that time I was working as the
museum boat builder at the Maritime
Museum in San Francisco
and before I left for Japan a friend
gave me a photograph from a Japanese
magazine it showed a woman floating in a
large barrel gathering shellfish
the caption of the photo said simply
Oggy village Sado Island and I was
determined to go to Sado to see if these
strange little boats existed
I took this photograph my first morning
on thought oh Island
these are tourist tugboats but every
morning all along the OG Peninsula
people get into boats like these and go
to sea to gather seaweed and shellfish
most of these people are women
that first trip to Sado I met mr. Koh
Ichi Fuji the last builder of tugboats
two years later I came back to Sado with
an interpreter and I interviewed mr.
Fuji about his life and work he told me
that when he was studying with his
master his teacher refused to teach him
any of the critical dimensions used in
building the tub boats he told me that
he used to sneak into his master’s
workshop at night with a candle and
study his layout
he called this new Sumi giggle or stolen
lessons
that same trip a maritime historian took
me to Kochi City and introduced me to
the last boat builder there that man had
drawings of his boats all drawn on a
plank of wood he showed me his drawings
his father’s drawings
even his grandfather’s drawings
but as I looked at the drawings I saw a
problem you couldn’t build a boat from
any of them
because critical lines were missing I
pointed this out to the boat builder and
he said to me you’re right the missing
information are my secrets I was really
stunned by what these craftsmen were
telling me in the West we have a long
tradition of recording the crafts at
home I have dozens of books describing
in every detail all of the facts of
western boat building and maritime
museums throughout North America and
Europe have published literally
thousands of drawings of traditional
boats but here in Japan the craft was
completely undocumented and moreover the
crafts have depended entirely upon the
apprentice system and without a new
generation of apprentices the craft was
at risk of disappearing
people often ask me why my teachers took
me a foreigner on as their apprentice I
think the answer is twofold first many
of my teachers were second third and
even fourth-generation boat builders
they understood better than anyone the
amount of knowledge about to be lost
second when I met my teachers most were
in their 70s and I think I was the first
person to express a serious interest in
their work for that reason the fact that
I was a foreigner did not matter to them
what was more important was what that we
were both boat builders in my research I
have traveled to 45 of Japan’s 47
prefectures meeting and interviewing
almost 60 boat builders and I have never
had a craftsman refer to me as gaijin or
foreigner and for me the opportunity to
study with such amazing craftsmen has
been irresistible
all six of my apprenticeships started
the same way with my teachers telling me
how I was expected to behave in the
workshop
they all told me that my previous
experience building boats in America
would be of no use to me they even said
that my experience building other kinds
of Japanese boats did not count because
these were not the same boats that they
built finally they all stressed one
requirement we would work together in
complete silence and I was not to
interrupt them with questions unless
absolutely necessary what this meant was
that outside of break times there would
be no speaking in the workshop
ironically this meant that language was
not an obstacle in my apprenticeships I
didn’t necessarily need to speak fluent
Japanese because my teachers weren’t
going to speak to me and while they
tolerated some questions
if I did ask for an explanation the most
common answer they gave me was simply
wait and you will understand
for those who haven’t experienced it
it’s really difficult to appreciate the
intensity of this kind of learning first
it puts all of the responsibility for
learning on the student you have to
concentrate and pick up every detail of
what is going on let me give you an
example in Tokyo my teacher taught me
how to sharpen the plane blade using the
water stone 35 strokes on the bevel then
turn the blade over and five strokes on
the back one day I was sharpening a
plane blade while my teacher was working
on the boat I lost count but I continued
anyway stopping when I thought I got to
about 35 I turned the blade over but my
teacher stopped me that was 34 strokes
he said start over
with his back to me concentrating on his
own work he had been counting while I
sharpened
it taught me two things first that it
was possible to listen and observe with
a depth of understanding that I had
never imagined
in that moment he knew something about
me that I did not know about myself
and second I was to be absolutely
obedient to my teachers methods and
wishes
I realize now that the first lesson in
the Japanese apprenticeship is humility
to a westerner
the Japanese the Masters treatment of
The Apprentice can look like neglect
certainly the apprentice is put in very
difficult situations but I’ve come to
realize that in my culture teaching is
about giving students facts and skills
as quickly and efficiently as possible
whereas the Japanese apprenticeship is
of values based education first forcing
the student to obey then teaching him
how to observe and how to concentrate
the obstacles and difficulties the
apprentice faces are the lessons
thing about building tugboats is
braiding the bamboo hoops that hold the
boats together
when I apprenticed with my teacher mr.
Fuji
he gave me one hoop to braid while he
braided the other two my wife videotaped
him working but it all happened so fast
that I really didn’t understand it and
so there I was my first apprenticeship I
had gone to Sado to document how to
build tugboats and I didn’t understand
how to do the thing that literally holds
the boats together back home I watched
the videotape over and over I used
pieces of plastic strapping instead of
bamboo trying to practice how to braid
hoops I must have watched that tape
dozens if not a hundred times but
finally I got it
the long hours I spent watching the
videotape were like the years the
apprentice spends watching his master
slowly gaining insight into every facet
of the work
right now in 30 minutes I could teach
all of you how to braid a bamboo hoop
really but if we return to your from now
probably none of you would remember how
to do it I like to think that there is
nothing I know better than how to do
this and why because my teacher wouldn’t
teach me because of the desperation I
felt to learn how to do this because of
the hours and hours I spent watching
that video making mistakes to taking my
mistakes apart and starting all over
again
this kind of learning engaged every part
of me
a few years ago the Takenaka carpentry
tools museum in co bay mounted an
exhibition of japanese tools at harvard
university the exhibit was titled the
thinking hand
it’s like the way I think about braiding
barrel hoops it’s not something I know
in my head the knowledge is as much
physical as intellectual
I used to think it was enough to simply
go to Japan and document how traditional
boats are built before they disappeared
but surprisingly my teachers didn’t take
any of this very seriously many of them
would point to my camera and say it’s no
good taking pictures you have to train
your eye what they were trying to tell
me was they wanted me to develop a
deeper more intuitive understanding of
the craft ultimately I am so grateful to
my teachers for humbling me for making
me uncomfortable for forcing me to look
and concentrate in the end they made me
think like The Apprentice they wanted me
to be and they taught me the ancient
lesson of how to listen for the meaning
in the silence arigato gozaimashita
[Applause]
[Music]
my name is Douglas Brooks and I’m an
American boat builder writer and
researcher for the last 20 years I have
been studying traditional Japanese boat
building my research involves working
alongside craftsmen from throughout
Japan
in order to document their design
secrets and techniques in my view this
work is crucial because Japan’s last
generation of boat builders is
disappearing and almost none have taught
apprentices I am the sole apprentice for
all six of my teachers craftsmen from
Sado Island Rhode iesous Tokyo Almaty
Okinawa and ewot day these men have
exposed me to the traditional Japanese
apprentice learning
my first trip to Japan I went to Sado
Island at that time I was working as the
museum boat builder at the Maritime
Museum in San Francisco
and before I left for Japan a friend
gave me a photograph from a Japanese
magazine it showed a woman floating in a
large barrel gathering shellfish
the caption of the photo said simply
Oggy village Sado Island and I was
determined to go to Sado to see if these
strange little boats existed
I took this photograph my first morning
on thought oh Island
these are tourist tugboats but every
morning all along the OG Peninsula
people get into boats like these and go
to sea to gather seaweed and shellfish
most of these people are women
that first trip to Sado I met mr. Koh
Ichi Fuji the last builder of tugboats
two years later I came back to Sado with
an interpreter and I interviewed mr.
Fuji about his life and work he told me
that when he was studying with his
master his teacher refused to teach him
any of the critical dimensions used in
building the tub boats he told me that
he used to sneak into his master’s
workshop at night with a candle and
study his layout
he called this new Sumi giggle or stolen
lessons
that same trip a maritime historian took
me to Kochi City and introduced me to
the last boat builder there that man had
drawings of his boats all drawn on a
plank of wood he showed me his drawings
his father’s drawings
even his grandfather’s drawings
but as I looked at the drawings I saw a
problem you couldn’t build a boat from
any of them
because critical lines were missing I
pointed this out to the boat builder and
he said to me you’re right the missing
information are my secrets I was really
stunned by what these craftsmen were
telling me in the West we have a long
tradition of recording the crafts at
home I have dozens of books describing
in every detail all of the facts of
western boat building and maritime
museums throughout North America and
Europe have published literally
thousands of drawings of traditional
boats but here in Japan the craft was
completely undocumented and moreover the
crafts have depended entirely upon the
apprentice system and without a new
generation of apprentices the craft was
at risk of disappearing
people often ask me why my teachers took
me a foreigner on as their apprentice I
think the answer is twofold first many
of my teachers were second third and
even fourth-generation boat builders
they understood better than anyone the
amount of knowledge about to be lost
second when I met my teachers most were
in their 70s and I think I was the first
person to express a serious interest in
their work for that reason the fact that
I was a foreigner did not matter to them
what was more important was what that we
were both boat builders in my research I
have traveled to 45 of Japan’s 47
prefectures meeting and interviewing
almost 60 boat builders and I have never
had a craftsman refer to me as gaijin or
foreigner and for me the opportunity to
study with such amazing craftsmen has
been irresistible
all six of my apprenticeships started
the same way with my teachers telling me
how I was expected to behave in the
workshop
they all told me that my previous
experience building boats in America
would be of no use to me they even said
that my experience building other kinds
of Japanese boats did not count because
these were not the same boats that they
built finally they all stressed one
requirement we would work together in
complete silence and I was not to
interrupt them with questions unless
absolutely necessary what this meant was
that outside of break times there would
be no speaking in the workshop
ironically this meant that language was
not an obstacle in my apprenticeships I
didn’t necessarily need to speak fluent
Japanese because my teachers weren’t
going to speak to me and while they
tolerated some questions
if I did ask for an explanation the most
common answer they gave me was simply
wait and you will understand
for those who haven’t experienced it
it’s really difficult to appreciate the
intensity of this kind of learning first
it puts all of the responsibility for
learning on the student you have to
concentrate and pick up every detail of
what is going on let me give you an
example in Tokyo my teacher taught me
how to sharpen the plane blade using the
water stone 35 strokes on the bevel then
turn the blade over and five strokes on
the back one day I was sharpening a
plane blade while my teacher was working
on the boat I lost count but I continued
anyway stopping when I thought I got to
about 35 I turned the blade over but my
teacher stopped me that was 34 strokes
he said start over
with his back to me concentrating on his
own work he had been counting while I
sharpened
it taught me two things first that it
was possible to listen and observe with
a depth of understanding that I had
never imagined
in that moment he knew something about
me that I did not know about myself
and second I was to be absolutely
obedient to my teachers methods and
wishes
I realize now that the first lesson in
the Japanese apprenticeship is humility
to a westerner
the Japanese the Masters treatment of
The Apprentice can look like neglect
certainly the apprentice is put in very
difficult situations but I’ve come to
realize that in my culture teaching is
about giving students facts and skills
as quickly and efficiently as possible
whereas the Japanese apprenticeship is
of values based education first forcing
the student to obey then teaching him
how to observe and how to concentrate
the obstacles and difficulties the
apprentice faces are the lessons
thing about building tugboats is
braiding the bamboo hoops that hold the
boats together
when I apprenticed with my teacher mr.
Fuji
he gave me one hoop to braid while he
braided the other two my wife videotaped
him working but it all happened so fast
that I really didn’t understand it and
so there I was my first apprenticeship I
had gone to Sado to document how to
build tugboats and I didn’t understand
how to do the thing that literally holds
the boats together back home I watched
the videotape over and over I used
pieces of plastic strapping instead of
bamboo trying to practice how to braid
hoops I must have watched that tape
dozens if not a hundred times but
finally I got it
the long hours I spent watching the
videotape were like the years the
apprentice spends watching his master
slowly gaining insight into every facet
of the work
right now in 30 minutes I could teach
all of you how to braid a bamboo hoop
really but if we return to your from now
probably none of you would remember how
to do it I like to think that there is
nothing I know better than how to do
this and why because my teacher wouldn’t
teach me because of the desperation I
felt to learn how to do this because of
the hours and hours I spent watching
that video making mistakes to taking my
mistakes apart and starting all over
again
this kind of learning engaged every part
of me
a few years ago the Takenaka carpentry
tools museum in co bay mounted an
exhibition of japanese tools at harvard
university the exhibit was titled the
thinking hand
it’s like the way I think about braiding
barrel hoops it’s not something I know
in my head the knowledge is as much
physical as intellectual
I used to think it was enough to simply
go to Japan and document how traditional
boats are built before they disappeared
but surprisingly my teachers didn’t take
any of this very seriously many of them
would point to my camera and say it’s no
good taking pictures you have to train
your eye what they were trying to tell
me was they wanted me to develop a
deeper more intuitive understanding of
the craft ultimately I am so grateful to
my teachers for humbling me for making
me uncomfortable for forcing me to look
and concentrate in the end they made me
think like The Apprentice they wanted me
to be and they taught me the ancient
lesson of how to listen for the meaning
in the silence arigato gozaimashita
[Applause]
[Music]
Please follow and like us: