Press "Enter" to skip to content

The Power of Acting Local | Andy Burnham | TEDxManchester


thank you very much herb afternoon

everybody

apparently what what my voice will be

telling you now from the last

presentation so bear with me as I just

get my my notes in order it’s a real

honor actually to be invited to speak to

you as herb said not many politicians

are asked to do that also quite

intimidating I have to say although I

should start with some thanks to Donald

Trump because he hasn’t asked lowered

the bar of what counts for a a

thoughtful political contribution these

days it’s a pretty low bar now and I’m

sure hopefully can get over it I’ll

start with something that you may not

expect to hear from somebody like me and

that is I’m disillusioned with politics

now some of you might think oh yeah sour

grapes because he lost to korban and I

can assure you it’s not I’ll just share

with you one anecdote from the

leadership contests of 2015 you know

herb you mentioned being the

front-runner or the favorite well I’ve

been in that position before and that

didn’t go too well but I was in the

middle of that rate and I knew I was

kind of struggling but I’m still

fighting there was two weeks to go you

know Jeremy was getting all the support

but I was in a church in Sheffield

packed house and I’ve was kind of going

for broke really knowing that I really

had to cut free and really try and win

people over and I gave what I thought

was a pretty good speech I’m really kind

of spoke from the heart and at the end

of it the hands went open the chair said

okay well first question Jeff at the

back and it was bare minds of the church

just to remind you Jeff says I Andy I’ve

been listening to you for the last 20

minutes and um yeah really agree with

everything that you’ve said and the way

that you’ve said it as well so but do

you realize that you’ve been speaking

for the last 20 minutes under a sign

and I can’t win Oh Alec Hannah felt at

that point it was the game was the game

was kind of the game was up but to come

back to that point why am i

disillusioned with politics I’m

disillusioned because I’ve come to the

conclusion after 16 years in Westminster

the Westminster is incapable

institutionally of solving the issue

that I came into politics to fix and to

tell you what I mean by that I have to

tell you my my story if you like my

journey is hope said I was born in

Liverpool don’t hold that against me

those of you who were sent you have a

vote in in May but when I was one my dad

got a job in Manchester so I moved

halfway I’ve classically been at both

both cities my earliest political memory

was watching boys from the black stuff

with my mum and dad they weren’t

political activists in any way we

weren’t particularly political family

they were just ordinary labour voters

but it kind of planted a seed that there

was something wrong really the unfair

about the way people were treated

through the 80s the miners strike I was

living in there in the lis area where

there were lots of coal mines so that

that you know built that feeling that

something wasn’t quite right

1987 to my great surprise somebody at

school suggested I apply for Cambridge

and I didn’t think I could go to

Cambridge but then I applied and somehow

got in and went to Cambridge 1988 you

know it was kind of the first kind of

for me the first real awakening that

there were two worlds here in this

country really two worlds and I couldn’t

really relate one to the other the one

where I’ve grown up and the one that I

was now in in Cambridge I wasn’t used to

being in supervisions

in Cambridge where these people the same

age as me would stride into the room and

just hold forth with these opinions on

everything you know it took me a year to

work out they were talking complete

rubbish but it sounded a lot brilliant

for that for that year and I always had

that kind of imposter syndrome you know

I’ll get the tap on on my shoulder and

you know I struggle to kind of find my

feet in that world but then we get to

1989 in the Easter holiday from my first

year in Cambridge Hillsborough happened

and I was back at home I’m an Everton

supporter by background I was at the

other semi-final on that day

and I was sat in the pub that night

April 15th 1989 as my friends came home

from Hillsborough and these stories of

horror were just then laid before us and

obviously as you know within a matter of

days those same people were being blamed

for what happened the newspapers started

to blame them and when I got back to

Cambridge

I was then back in that world and people

start is repeat what the newspapers were

saying in these kind of rarefied rooms

and and I was like no you’ve got all

wrong you don’t understand and it’s the

frustration of those two worlds really

kind of you know it’s hard you know I

really kind of found it hard to kind of

reconcile one from the other the country

very very divided and act I suppose it’s

that kind of sense of injustice of

things aren’t fair for people from a

certain part of the country that in the

end politicized me and took me on a path

towards politics and eventually I was

elected came into Parliament 2001 and

while I’m very proud of many things that

we did when I was in the government and

an MP I became aware that these two

worlds still existed and the Cambridge

world was basically the Westminster

world as well there was a connected

world a world of people who knew each

other and knew how to get things done

and knew how to make things work for

them and an unconnected world back at

home where people didn’t have those

doors opened for them and didn’t know

those people in positions of power and I

kind of thought while I was still very

proud of lots what Labour did that we

would change that world we’ve challenged

that privileged world and we would start

to open it up and to be honest what I

saw as a backbencher then as a junior

government minister was basically what

New Labour was doing which was trying to

ingratiate itself with that world rather

than challenge it really if I’m

absolutely honest with you and that

constantly posed a problem for me

because I kind of as I say always live I

always felt I’ve kind of been in a

bridge between these two worlds of our

country kind of living in both of them

simultaneously and you know it always

produce these conflicts within me but

these two worlds of mine came into

absolute direct collision in 2009 when

as herb says bike

quirk of fate I was invited as the

culture secretary to go to Anfield on

the 20th anniversary now I was advised

by the government not to go and I

agonized about whether I should go

because I knew the government had

nothing to say and I knew what all of

those 30,000 people in that stadium

would think but on the same hand the

personal side of me couldn’t not be

there knowing what I knew and knowing

how my friends thought I was at school

with still felt you know the thought not

being there through cowardice was like

impossible for me to kind of contemplate

but then the thought of being there was

also impossible because I knew I had

nothing to say so it’s like the ultimate

dilemma the clash of these worlds in

which I’ve kind of constantly lived

between and in the end I kind of sat

down with my brothers and my mum and dad

as I always do in these difficult

occasions and I kind of said we went

through it and I said look I want to be

there but what can I say

and my younger brother said to me look

it’s quite simple really go if you’re

gonna do something for them if not stay

away because it would be worse and it

was at that moment basically I kind of

resolved to go and in the end do

something I kind of knew that something

was going to happen that day but I

almost kind of wanted it to happen and

then when I came back to Westminster

when everyone had seen what had happened

on the 20th anniversary I then went into

this process of trying to set up the

Hillsborough independent panel and I

can’t tell you what that was like and

how hard that was given the personal

feelings I had about the issue and the

people I knew who were still traumatized

by it when I was in meetings with

cabinet colleagues and senior civil

servants who were trying to block every

single thing that I was doing and I was

looking at them impassively just trying

to do this and then I was thinking of

the people I knew back home and on more

than one occasion I went back to my flat

at night and out of sheer frustration

just wept because I just couldn’t

reconcile what was what was unfolding at

more than one occasion I considered

resigning from the cabinet over it but

eventually we did establish it in the

way that I wanted it to be established

and eventually the truth was told I’m

telling you this story just illustrate

my main point which is what what I’m

coming to really a question is I just

asked you all to ask us if we had

a proper political system this country

how could it possibly how could it

possibly leave an entire city 30 miles

from here

crying injustice for 30 years 20 years

sorry with nobody listening how could it

how could a representative democracy let

that happen

and then you know how if you then take a

step on from that you know how can this

system still represent us properly if

that’s the way that it works where it

hears the voices of some people the

connected world but not that unconnected

world you know the rooms of Parliament

the committee rooms are even used for

the cover up on Hillsborough and that

shows you how in my view Parliament is

incapable of of dealing with with an

issue like this and it kind of brings me

to my kind of central contention really

and it’s that Westminster politics as it

is the Westminster system is absolutely

incapable of responding to the challenge

of our times it’s responsible in my view

for the referendum result because the

communities that that kind of fought

back through the referendum they’re the

ones that have never had a true voice in

the parliamentary system if you think

about Westminster and Whitehall it’s

three institutions the House of Commons

the House of Lords and the government

Civil Service and in two of those

institutions they are completely

unaccountable and and unelected and yet

they make the vast majority of the

decisions and some parts of the country

have got hundreds of voices battling for

them in those two worlds the House of

Lords in the government civil service

but most of the poorest parts of our

country have one voice their MP and

nobody else and this system that we’ve

got is never going to deliver for them

ever it really is not you know in a

highly centralized political system

which is what we’ve got in this country

where you know we don’t have regional

government we have one government in

Westminster only one of the worlds of

our country can dominate down they both

can and it’s that highly connected world

that dominates everything and so the

Whitehall and Westminster system in my

view will never give true and

an equal representation to those those

outlying poorer parts of the country

they will forever be playing second

fiddle to the to the to the connected to

the connected world and that’s why I

don’t believe Westminster can fix the

challenge it’s responsible for the

referendum because it goes far deeper

than concerns about Europe this is a

deep-seated anger about feeling

abandoned by the kind of political class

so it created it and now it can’t fix it

look at what’s happened since the

referendum the people campaigning for

justice on or Greve ferry link to

Hillsborough same police force for five

years earlier they were just told to go

away nobody died go away look at what

else has happened we’ve had grammar

schools introduced without an electoral

Monday you know this this world is

closing ranks again and actually from my

point of view Hillsborough is the one

that got away

Hills brothers one we forced open but

actually they’re closing ranks again now

and it won’t the same won’t happen for

others so I’ve concluded the way to

change this world is not to stay within

it and fight within it but to challenge

it from the outside and that’s why I’ve

decided to put myself forward for the

for the mayor of Greater Manchester the

arrival of devolution in England in my

view is the biggest chance we will ever

get in this country to rebalance it from

south to north and I’m determined to

devote what remains of my political

capital to that mission to show that if

you give us the chance to do things for

ourselves we will do them better than

the rest of the country we will

definitely make better decisions than

Whitehall and Westminster wait you know

Whitehall and Westminster is like for me

in an era of multi-channel TV it’s like

trying to broadcast four channel TV to

the country you know one voice in a posh

southern accent trying to speak for

everybody it’s just not going to work we

need to do something fundamentally

different and devolution is our chance

to do something fundamentally different

you know a small example I would want to

set a goal here in our city of saying no

rough sleeping by 2020 and asking

everybody to contribute in their own way

to achieving that goal because when you

get to if you achieve things like that

we can make much that what I think

people who wanted to be a beacon of

social justice to the rest of the

country and I think in the end politics

will change more by taking inspiration

from what happens in Greater Manchester

rather than direction from Westminster

that I think is how the country will

change

I think cities around the world if you

look are increasingly the biggest force

for social change if you look on issues

like climate change this is where the

progressive and new thinking is coming

from it’s not coming out of of

government systems which are struggling

to make sense of this fast changing

world change will increasingly come from

the from the bottom up so what I would

say to you all is regardless of your

politics and regardless of who wins in

May give give your energy to it because

it will be what we all make it we need

to build it up and we need to demand

real change in the way this country

works and a real voice for the

communities that haven’t been heard for

for many years

I’ll finish on this on this point you

know it’s easy to kind of be cynical

about will this lead to any real change

but what I want to remind you of is the

fact that Manchester has a proud history

of changing politics and changing the

world it is the home of radical

forward-thinking

in the early nineteenth century it was

the place where the co-operative

movement was founded to make food more

affordable to ordinary working people in

the late 19th century the Trades Union

Congress was founded here just about

less than a mile from this from this

building and that gave a voice and

representation toward inari working

people in the 20th century the

suffragette movement was based here and

that gave a voice and a vote to half of

the population and what I’m saying is in

the 21st century this city should lead

the devolution movement to give real

power and a real voice to the

communities that Westminster has left

behind I think we’ve reached a point now

where it’s not

cynicism about politics isn’t just the

politicians problem

it’s your problem too because the

collapse of trust in the political

system is poisoning the atmosphere on

our streets it’s causing hate and

division wherever wherever we look we

can’t just sit back and let this happen

we have to try something something

different so what I’m saying I suppose

in summary is it is time for something

different

devolution in England is the best hope

that we’ve got Greater Manchester is at

the forefront of it which gives us a

unique opportunity for responsibility to

show that we can make it work this place

has changed the world in the past before

and I believe it can do so again I

believe it needs to do so for the good

of our society and the health of our

democracy it will be stronger the more

that all of you invest your energy in it

so that’s my final message today come

and join the devolution revolution thanks very much indeed listen

Please follow and like us: