
this room who hasn’t seen the poster
with it’s bright white letters and it’s
sharp red background keep calm and carry
on or we’ve seen a number of variations
keep calm and smile on keep calm and
rock on and for this crowd right keep
calm and steady on or even what’s
becoming my personal favorite sod calm
and get angry but behind the popular
resurgence of this British slogan a
slogan that was invented but actually
never used during the Second World War
and one which didn’t really become
popular until 2008-2009 lies a really
important and neglected history it’s not
a simple story about being calm in the
face of the uncertainties and dangers of
modern life it’s not that keeping calm
is the antidote to everything or even
possible but does the slogan I think we
can use to understand a specific history
about how the age of air power shift is
a relationship between individuals and
their States in ways with which we are
still grappling about a hundred years
ago the First World War assured in air
raids attacks on civilian spaces and
bodies that made securing borders
obsolete in the first places that
experienced air raid such as Britain as
you can see in this 1915 photo of a
Zeppelin or airship and searchlights
that were being used to identify it
this meant improvising a response to
keep a population as safe as possible
what role would non-combatants play in
the wars after 1918 what could states
ask of their entire populations from
children to the elderly to men and women
from all walks of life the response was
the creation of Civil Defence a kind of
civic mobilization that tried to
incorporate the message you should keep
calm in order to carry on I didn’t
realize when I started to do this
research that this ended up being part
of my family history
I’m historian of the First World War and
of gender and more generally when I came
across accounts of women experiencing
areas during the First World War
I knew I wanted to learn more but I was
finishing my book at home and under fire
when in a casual conversation with my
father I learned that my grandmother
Sara gracel had been a civil defense
volunteer in Brooklyn New York
during the Second World War so I’m
wearing her pin in honor of her service
and in her memory and also you can see
that there are a number of other emblems
that other volunteers wore during the
Second World War they embodied the
slogan of the u.s. Civil Defense Corps
which was every civilian a fighter it’s
a really interesting shift in what it
means to understand war and certainly
the family connection made me think
about my work and its legacy in a new
way because civilian spaces and bodies
have always been targets of warfare what
change was during the First World War
new forms of technology helped turn
domestic spaces into battle zones The
effect of using air power first airships
and then airplanes against Sylvan
populations troubled contemporaries
public accounts of the first attacks and
throughout the duration of the war
condemned these as criminal acts
committed by a barbaric enemy by
emphasizing the kind of damage done to
what were deemed the most vulnerable of
victims young female homes and the
ordinary people who occupied them when
serious air raids on Britain began in
January of 1915 the media coverage
emphasized such things as a boy killed
while he lay in bed or babies being
seriously injured at the end of May when
London experienced its first air raids
six people were killed but the death
that received the most attention was
that of a three-year-old girl Elsie
Lillian Leggett who died of burns and
suffocation despite the fact that her
father had rushed into a home to try to
save her in response to this new phase
of waging war the Manchester Guardian
urged its readers to respond as follows
and I quote the true answer to every act
of frightfulness is to increase our
efforts to meet the enemy in the field
and show ourselves unmoved in our homes
this call for civilians subject to war
waged against them to be unmoved began
to characterize most of the subsequent
responses to the air raids as they
continued and at roughly the same time
that air power was coming into its own
so too were submarine attacks and that
same spring the Lusitania was sunk and
poison gas was unleashed on the western
front a chemical weapon that could not
be contained just to the battlefield
there is a sense that war was now
becoming one without limits but there
was no organized way to respond there
are no warnings there were no shelters
there were no evacuation there was
simply no policy how was the state going
to ensure that the community would
continue functioning despite these new
threats it improvised things it printed
signs that could tell people when it was
safe to go about after an air raid
delivered among other things five Boy
Scouts on bicycles but by 1917 when
daylight raids by airplanes began there
was a new call to issue public warnings
but in private not everyone could agree
and there was concern about particular
types of the population and how they
would respond the mayor of a London
borough wrote to the Home Office on the
26th of June that year that quote when
has only to remember the unfortunate and
prejudicial effect upon health
especially in the case of delicate women
that the general warning would
undoubtedly create for one to realize
the much evil would probably result by
needlessly causing disturbance and there
was a thick file of people responding to
whether it was a good idea to warn
people an impending danger that may or
may not materialize what would be the
effects on women how could you get
people to keep calm and carry on and you
can see the tremendous power that air
raids had because of their shock would
be new and in fact terrifying in the
letters
that are found throughout archives in
England including those of Edie Bennett
who is a young wife and mother living
the East End of London married to a
gunner in the Royal feed Field Artillery
she wrote to her husband from her perch
in a home under fire messages that
convey all too well that the idea that
you should stay calm was not always
possible in a series of distraught
letters in July of 1917 she told him oh
darling this life is getting too
terrible for words and one’s nerves
cannot stand much more when I shut my
eyes can see these huge things like
great black words right over us and
coming all directions to London and God
help us next time for you’re absolutely
beaten and no mourning whenever baby and
I stood in the passage clenched tightly
together expecting the last of our lives
and every hour we do not know but will
be our last don’t think I have any fear
but should like once more to see you of
this wicked war will it ever end and in
a letter not that long after she
continuing in the same vein life seems
just one misery night and day and
forever and fear but I suppose you must
try and keep smiling for your dear sake
there’s a way in which this is a
reversal of the normal order of things
she was in some senses in more danger
with her little girl than her husband
was in a war zone a traditional war zone
it was not till the aftermath of this
summer that the British government
decided that it had to provide clear
public warnings along with other
measures that were meant both to keep
the public safe and to minimize panic
yet well official warnings the
organization of shelters grants of
financial aid and public Symphony helped
the air raids first victims it was clear
that civilians were no longer safe that
their government cannot completely
defend the homeland from attack
furthermore a now significant air power
disrupted these divisions between a home
front populated by women and children in
need of protection
and a battle zone filled with male
warriors women like Bennett could absorb
the message they
needed to keep smiling but there had to
be something more to do to help ordinary
folks like her cope by the end of the
first world war at the age of airpower
had arrived and there were some visible
reminders in the immediate aftermath
such as a monument erected to the
schoolchildren of poplar a place in East
London where an infant’s nursery school
had been directly hit by a bomb well the
official toll of dead from this air raid
are miniscule compared to the huge
numbers of combatants and millions of
combatants death in this war it’s not
the numbers of dead that matter but the
terrifying new circumstances that
surround them
post-war air theorists and military
planners argued that this way to wage
war was going to succeed because of its
unrelenting capacity to demoralize the
enemy population and force them to
collapse and see their own governments
for peace or cause these governments to
just disappear what might stop such a
result was the development what became
known as civil defense and plans for
this started in many places including
Britain in the aftermath of the first
world war one of the first meetings
British planners determined that this
was the message civilians had to hear
they must realize that they are living
within the zones of active operations
and therefore must expect to suffer
casualties and that the enemy people is
being subjected to similar but harsher
treatment that they themselves are
called upon to support and that victory
will fall to the nation with the greater
powers of endurance those actively and
to large extent secretly engaged in the
process of planning for the next war had
to determine what would allow a civilian
population to injure what they construed
as a devastating war that might involve
incendiary bombs high explosives and
even chemical weapons in short how to
prepare them to face a war of
annihilation
civil defense measures became more and
more public in Britain and elsewhere in
an increasingly tense interim
context in the late made actually to
late 1930s and in places like Britain
that were democracy is there is heated
even vocal opposition to the very idea
of civil defense opponents claimed that
to prepare for such a war was to
encourage its rival but what’s
remarkable but the transnational
development is that after the first
world war he committed to relying on
ordinary people to keep calm and carry
on when Britain released its first
public statement about civil defense or
what it called at the time air raid
precautions it was clear that the notion
that there could be no guarantee of
immunity for anyone any longer was going
to be the rule one example of the public
conversation that followed this idea can
be found in a newspaper editorial that
appeared directly responding to the
release of this document this is a
reminder of the peril that hovers above
there used to be a specious phrase
civilized war after the first bombs fell
in 1914 after the first gas attack
common sense would no longer believe in
it the invention of the airplane has
made more unspeakably barbarous women
children the age the sick the animals
all are now in the line of fire war has
less conscience today than at any other
time the war being planned for was not
going to discriminate but the
fundamental question remained
how would or could an entire population
respond when these proposals became
enshrined and legislation again in
Brinton which didn’t take which took two
years to achieve in 1937 parliamentary
debates about the passage of this
legislation involved the following
statement the new factor of terror from
the air means that as in all war it is
the spirit of the people that in the
last resort makes victory possible in
practice the British government did
again countries across the world they
began to recruit an army of volunteers
for civil defense creating among other
things the key role of a warden an
individual with responsibilities that
link this
date in the home that looked after a
post or a neighborhood that were trying
to make themselves um take
responsibility for their large role and
local communities and there’s perhaps no
better sign of just how open this was
then Britain’s women’s voluntary service
for civil defenses housewives unit which
encouraged ordinary wives and mothers to
work part-time and they were to hang
this sign in their windows so people
knew that they were trained and that you
could seek help from them it crucially
recognised that wives and mothers were
now frontline fighters this is a theme
reiterated from the dawn of air power
and again the cornerstone of the u.s. is
own civil defence Corps every civilian a
fighter during the Second World War
women and men across the borders of age
and class and ethnicity and geography
volunteered to help keep each other safe
ER at its core the invention of civil
defense relied upon a new relationship
between the state and the individual it
insisted on the mobilization literally
of everybody on behalf of the nation at
war and it promoted the idea that since
nothing could prevent danger from
reaching us we had an obligation to keep
each other safe keep calm and carry on
only works if most of us carry on and at
least some of us keep calm while few
states still practice the civil defense
that we associate with the Second World
War the drills of the Cold War the
principles and means of uniting an
entire population to face war or to face
danger that underline is developments
continue to overshadow our lives in a
post-911 world all of us are vulnerable
to attack and so all of us have been
enlisted in an effort to keep society
safe from the signs and public transit
and in every major airport that asks us
to be aware of and report suspicious
parcels and behavior we live with
visible reminders that even in our
modern wars against terrorism and less
visible non-state agents the expectation
that the ordinary man woman and child
must calmly face risks is one of the
most important legacies of this
transformation
keep calm and carry on has become a
shorthand for do not live in fear or do
not let fear stop you from living as
individuals we’ve become deputized
agents of the state responsible as best
we can for helping each other survive
this can be do alleged we’re being
taught or asked to be suspicious and
attentive to danger but this could also
mean using our prejudices or bias
scapegoating people and it’s certainly
easy to criticize the simplicity of
telling anyone in danger to just keep
calm and carry on but the history behind
this concept also means recognizing this
sense of community that underlay it that
we survive by keeping more or less calm
and facing our fears together that we
need a solidarity to carry on this is
not new but it’s only about a hundred
years old and it’s one of the first
world wars most significant and
forgotten legacies thank you
[Applause]
you [Music]