
[Applause]
imagine your favorite book or story what
if you never read it what if the ending
were different from the one you know how
would that change your feelings about
the work or about the author about the
characters when we hear the word
censorship we think of the most dramatic
examples of book burning authors thrown
into jail the best works of literature
suppressed forever we can recite the
titles of famously censored works like
the adventures of huckleberry finn or
the grapes of wrath of mice and men
lolita even Harry Potter yes Harry
Potter believe it or not was censored
for it satanic elements for exposing
children to the occult it is hard to
imagine that books that seem so harmless
to us now once caused riots leading to
the death threats on the life of the
author all because they were considered
too dangerous for the reading public
take for example Maurice index where the
wild things are or dr. Seuss’s hop on
pop beloved children’s books considered
too violent or too obscene or age
inappropriate for young readers hop on
pop was removed from library shelves
because it purportedly encouraged
violence against fathers this is a book
that former first lady Laura Bush told
Time magazine in 2006 was her favorite
book of the year precisely because it
evoked all kinds of warm memories of her
husband reading to her daughters at
bedtime you just never know how a book
will be received once it’s out there
because we can’t control the sensors
interpretation of a book but my point is
that in crucial ways books do shape our
lives as children and in some ways we
can’t imagine our lives today without
them and yet some
although written came very close to
being forbidden to readers forever now
we’re all familiar with the kind of
censorship in which a state government
decides a book should not be read but
what if your favorite book were altered
even before it became the book you know
what if it started out as something
quite different from the book that you
read and that you love what if it
contained language or scenes which which
shocked you or stunned you horrified you
what if it made you cry instead of laugh
at its ending I’m talking about a kind
of censorship that most readers are not
aware of because it happens while a book
is not yet a book and in manuscript form
editorial sensors are the editors and
the publishers who take the raw literary
material and alter it more fit sometimes
they change it to the point where it
bears very little resemblance to the
original now there are some famous cases
of editorial censorship that might
surprise you the Brothers Grimm so they
collected and retold some of our
favorite fairy tales from childhood like
Rapunzel Cinderella Sleeping Beauty Snow
White just to name a few yet the reading
public has only recently discovered the
first published editions of these tales
and originally these stories were very
dark cannibalism incest fratricide I’m
saying they were grim but we know from
these first editions that these authors
were not censored for instance in
Rapunzel Wilhelm Grimm shows something
happening between the prince and the
girl and the tower that is not so
innocent and these details were edited
out in subsequent editions their stories
were full of violence and sex and horror
but we have to remember that children
were not the intended audience and also
the Brothers Grimm were not the authors
of these tales they merely Colette
did them these were stories handed down
from generations and of generations in
Europe they merely collected them in one
place now the Grimm stories we know
today have been sanitized just in order
to be read to children at bedtime
censorship happened at the level of
editors we might think thank goodness
those editors intervened because I know
that I would have been one very
traumatized five-year-old a more recent
example of this kind of censorship
concerns the Nobel prize-winning author
Albert Camus he was now girion born
Frenchman writing in the 1940s 1950s
just after World War two he wrote plays
he wrote novels he wrote short stories
philosophical essays he was an extremely
popular writer in France his novel the
stranger l’étoile J sold millions of
copies worldwide and it was translated
four times into English even the British
band The Cure wrote a song based on the
novel killing an arab it is considered
one of the most influential books of our
time the Nobel Prize Committee awarded
him dishonor 1957 for important literary
production which with clear-sighted
earnestness illuminates the problems of
the human conscience in our times he was
known for his philosophy of the absurd
which in this country is unknown as
existentialism a label he hated he was
also known quickly in this country as a
European writer aligned with European
values and expressing a kind of European
sensibility but in reality he was a man
of the Mediterranean he had more in
common with other French colonists
living in Algeria at this time just on
the brink of separating definitively
from France he was the furthest thing
from a French existentialist but this is
what his editor Blanche Knopf thought
would sell best so this is how she
marketed him to his new english-speaking
audience and here’s a picture of Blanche
arm-in-arm with cameo at the Nobel Prize
ceremony
1957 if we take a look at some of the
letters that she exchanged with chem
Moo’s literary agent we can see that she
cared less about accurate translations
and a faithful representation of the
author and more about selling books she
wrote in one letter dated July 9th 1945
as for the translation of cow Moos
Latrell J I should certainly in
principle oppose showing a translation
to the author of the original I cannot
think of an easier way to generate
trouble a little knowledge is dangerous
and a lot of knowledge even more so in
matters of this kind I am sure that
Stuart Gilbert can be counted on to do a
good job well we know he did not do a
good job readers familiar with the
original quickly denounced the
translation they claimed he must have
barely known French to have so butchered
it one writer said the translator has
committed numerous and serious errors of
translation and has even denatured the
work of Khemu either in changing
handkerchiefs in two bookcases in
suppressing a revolution in favor of a
wildfire or even introducing snow in the
context of Iran and that’s a coastal
Algerian city that wasn’t there in the
original mr. Gilbert gives a false and
mistaken image of kamu and i find it
terrible that this is the only image
that the immense English public will
receive I consider this a literary
scandal it would be 43 years before a
new translation would come out and in
the meantime what we have is a book that
in some ways betrayed the reality and
the voice of this very important writer
now there are subtle ways that an editor
can rework the material to fit a
different audience sometimes it means
taking a manuscript and cutting it down
significantly sometimes eliminating
forty percent of the original manuscript
just to fit the attention span of the
new audience
kemas case this gives the impression
that his essays are all chopped up and
truncated his philosophical arguments
seem unsubtle and what we have really
missed is his sharp sense of the reality
around him for instance he felt
particularly strong about the future of
his native Algeria just as it was
gaining independence from france and
establishing itself as an independent
nation he wrote passionately about his
solution to what he called the Algerian
crisis but we Anglophones didn’t have
access to these essays for 50 years
after Algerian independence a Nobel
Prize winning author and his his works
were censored for 50 years but what
happened to his friend fellow writer and
Rashid is perhaps worse here’s a letter
that shows what Blanche can opted to his
work she writes to his translator thanks
for that note about she’d for The
Counterfeiters which we are using but I
had to take out the homosexual and
communist part I guess 1947 was not a
good time to be writing about communism
or homosexuality but this kind of
repackaging of an author’s work happens
all the time we just aren’t aware of it
as readers of the final product writers
are at the mercy of their editors just
as musicians are trapped often by their
producers artists are inherently
disadvantaged for this reason now what
we have to remember about this whole
story of the relationship between writer
and editor that when it comes down to it
the editor has the final say when it
comes to publishing a book his or her
motivations often come down to profit or
what he or she thinks will appeal to a
reader in other words the book that gets
published is the one that the editor and
the publisher thinks will sell best and
make the most for the company editors
have that much power over an author’s
work
now back to chem you he was trying to
say one thing but his English audience
heard something else now did that
diminish or tarnish his reputation as
the writer of universal themes maybe
maybe not but we will never know but
these editorial cuts and mistranslations
tell us that there lies a vast distance
between what Camus wrote and what his
publisher published in his name it makes
us wonder what other favorite books of
ours are merely a distorted echo of the
author’s words here are some ways for us
to become more reflective literary
citizens start by asking questions of
what we read am i reading what the
author wrote or how he or she or under
understood it we’re portions of the
original left out in what I have in
print was a dangerous book written and
then suppressed and then replaced with
another book perhaps with a softer
message what is the history behind this
work I love so much believe it or not
some research on the internet will get
you these answers what I’m saying here
is that language is so powerful and
books are dangerous but that is why we
love them we owe it to ourselves to
learn the back story in order to get the
full story behind the stories we love
thank you
[Applause]
[Music]
you [Music]