
some of radio glaciologist that means
that i use radar to study glaciers and
ice sheets and like most glaciologists
right now I’m working on the problem of
estimating how much the ice is going to
contribute to sea level rise in the
future so today I want to talk to you
about why it’s so hard to put good
numbers on sea level rise and why I
believe that by changing the way we
think about radar technology and our
science education we can get much better
at it so when most scientists talk about
sea level rise they show a plot like
this this is produced using ice sheet
and climate models on the right you can
see the range of sea level predicted by
these models over the next hundred years
for context this is current sea level
and this is the sea level above which
more than four million people could be
vulnerable to displacement so in terms
of planning the uncertainty in this plot
is already large however beyond that
this plot comes with the asterisks and
the caveat unless the West Antarctic Ice
Sheet collapses and in that case we
would be talking about dramatically
higher numbers they’d literally be off
the chart and the reason we should take
that possibility seriously is that we
know from the geologic history of the
earth that there were periods in its
history when sea level rose much more
quickly than today and right now we
cannot rule out the possibility of that
happening in the future so why can’t we
say with confidence whether or not a
significant portion of a continent scale
ice sheet will or will not collapse well
in order to do that we need models that
we know include all of the processes
conditions and physics that would be
involved in a collapse like that and
that’s hard to know because those
processes and conditions are taking
place beneath kilometers of ice and
satellites like the one that produced
this image are blind to observe them in
fact we have much more comprehensive
observations of the surface of Mars than
we do of what’s beneath the Antarctic
ice sheet
and this is even more challenging in
that we need these observations at a
gigantic scale in both space and time in
terms of space this is a continent and
in the same way that in North America
the Rocky Mountains Everglades and Great
Lakes regions are very distinct so are
the subsurface reasons of Antarctica and
in terms of time we now know that ice
sheets not only evolved over the
timescale of millennia and centuries but
they’re also changing over the scale of
years and days so what we want is
observations beneath kilometers of ice
at the scale of a continent and we want
them all the time so how do we do this
well we’re not totally blind to the
subsurface I said in the beginning that
I was a radio glaciologist and the
reason that that’s a thing is that
airborne ice-penetrating radar is the
main tool we have to see inside of ice
sheets so most of the data that’s used
by my group is collected by airplanes
like this world war ii era dc-3 that
actually fought in the Battle of the
Bulge you can see the antennas
underneath the wing these are used to
transmit radar signals down into the ice
and the echoes that come back contain
information about what’s happening
inside and beneath the ice sheet while
this is happening scientists and
engineers are on the airplane for eight
hours at a stretch making sure that the
radar is working and I think this is
actually a misconception about this type
of field work where people imagine
scientists peering out the window
contemplating the landscape it’s
geologic context in the fate of the ice
sheets we actually had a guy from the
BBC’s frozen planet on one of these
flights and he spent like hours
videotaping us turn knobs and I was
actually watching the series years later
with my wife and a scene like this came
up and I commented on how beautiful it
was and she said weren’t you on that
flight
I said yeah but I was looking at a
computer screen so so when you think
about this type of fieldwork don’t think
about images like this think about
images like this this is a radar gram
which is a vertical profile through the
ice sheet kind of like a slice of cake
the bright layer on the top is a surface
of the ice sheet the bright layer on the
bottom is the bedrock of the continent
itself and the layers in between are
kind of like tree rings and that they
contain information about the history of
the ice sheet and it’s amazing that this
works this well the ground-penetrating
radar that are used to investigate
infrastructures of roads or detect
landmines struggle to get through a few
meters of earth and here we’re peering
through three kilometers of ice and are
sophisticated interesting
electromagnetic reasons for that but
let’s say for now that ice is basically
the perfect target for radar and radar
is basically the perfect tool to study
ice sheets so these are the flight lines
of most of the modern airborne radar
sounding profiles collected over
Antarctica this is the result of heroic
efforts over decades by teams from a
variety of countries and international
collaborations when you put those
together you get an image like this
which is what the continent of
Antarctica would look like without all
the ice on top and you can really see
the diversity of the continent and an
image like this the red features are
volcanoes or mountains the areas that
are blue the open ocean if the ice sheet
was removed this is that giant spatial
scale however all of this that took
decades to produce is just one snapshot
of the subsurface it does not give us
any indication of how the ice sheet is
changing in time now we’re working on
that because it turns out that the very
first radar observations of Antarctica
were collected using 35 millimeter
optical film and there were thousands of
reels of this film and the archives of
the Museum of the Scott Polar Research
Institute at the University of Cambridge
so last summer I took a state of the art
film scanner that was developed for
digitizing Hollywood films and
remastering them into art historians and
we went over to England put on some
gloves and archive and digitized all of
that film so that produced 2 million
images high-resolution images that my
group is now
working on analyzing and processing for
comparing with contemporary conditions
in the ice sheet and actually that
scanner I found out about it from an
archivist at the Academy of Motion
Pictures Arts and Sciences so I’d like
to thank the academy for making this
possible and as amazing as it is that we
can look at what was happening under the
ice sheet 50 years ago this is still
just one more snapshot it doesn’t give
us observations of the variation at the
annual or seasonal scale that we know
matters now there’s some progress here
too there these recent ground-based
radar systems that stay in one spot so
you take these radars and you put them
on the ice sheet and you bury it cache
of car batteries and you leave them out
there for months or years at a time and
they send a pulse down into the ice
sheet every so many minutes or hours so
this gives you continuous observation in
time but at one spot so if you can pair
that imaging to the 2d pictures provided
by the airplane this is just one
vertical line and this is pretty much
where we are as a field right now we can
choose between good spatial coverage
with airborne radar sounding and good
temporal coverage in one spot with
ground-based sounding but neither give
us what we really want both at the same
time and if we’re going to do that we’re
going to need totally new ways of
observing the ice sheet and ideally
those should be extremely low cost so
that we can take lots of measurements
from lots of sensors well for existing
radar systems the biggest driver of cost
is the power required to transmit the
radar signal itself so it’d be great if
we were able to use existing radio
systems radio signals that are in the
environment unfortunately the entire
field of radio astronomy is built on the
fact that there are bright radio signals
in the sky and a really bright one is
our Sun so actually one of the most
exciting things my group is doing right
now is trying to use the radio emissions
from the Sun as a type of radar signal
so this is one of our field tests at Big
Sur that PVC pipe ziggurat is an antenna
stand some undergrads in my lab built
and the idea here is that we stay out at
Big Sur and we watch the Sun set and
radio frequencies and we try and detect
the reflection of the Sun off the
surface
the ocean now I know you’re thinking
there are no glaciers at Big Sur and
that’s true
but it turns out that detecting the
reflection of the Sun off the surface of
the ocean and detecting the reflection
off the bottom of an ice sheet are
extremely geo physically similar and if
this works we should be able to apply
the same measurement principle in
Antarctica and is not as far-fetched as
it seems the seismic industry has gone
through a similar technique development
exercise where they were able to move
from detonating dynamite as a source to
using ambient seismic noise in the
environment and defense radars use TV
signals and radio signals all the time
so they don’t have to transmit a signal
of radar and give away their position so
what I’m saying is this might really
work and if it does we’re going to need
extremely low-cost sensors so we can
deploy networks of hundreds or thousands
of these on an ice sheet to do imaging
and that’s where the technological stars
have really aligned to help us
there’s earlier radar systems I talked
about were developed by experienced
engineers over the course of years at
national facilities with expensive
specialized equipment but the recent
developments in software-defined radio
rapid fabrication and the maker movement
make it so that it’s possible for a team
of teenagers working in my lab over the
course of a handful of months to build a
prototype radar okay they’re not any
teenagers they’re Stanford undergrads
but the point holds that these enabling
technologies are letting us break down
the barrier between engineers who build
instruments and scientists that use them
and by teaching engineering students to
think like earth scientists and earth
science students who can think like
engineers my lab is building an
environment in which we can build custom
radar sensors for each problem at hand
that are optimized for low cost and high
performance for that problem and that’s
going to totally change the way we have
survived sheets so look the sea level
problem and the role of the cryosphere
in sea level rise is extremely important
and will affect the entire world but
that is not why I work on it I work on
it for the opportunity to teach and
mentor extremely brilliant student
because I deeply believe that teams of
hyper talented hyper driven hyper
passionate young people and solve most
of the challenges facing the world and
that providing the observations required
to estimate sea-level rise is just one
of the many such problems that can and
will solve thank you [Applause]