Press "Enter" to skip to content

American Spies | Jennifer Granick | TEDxStanford


[Music]

[Applause]

we are all activists now thank you

I’ll just stop here from the families

who are fighting to maintain funding for

public schools the tens of thousands of

people who joined Occupy Wall Street or

marched with black lives matter to

protest police brutality against

african-americans families that join

rallies pro-life and pro-choice those of

us who are afraid that our friends and

neighbors are going to be deported or

that they’ll be added to lists because

they are Muslim people who advocate for

gun rights and for gun control and the

millions of people who join the women’s

marches all across the country this plan

we are all activists now and that means

that we all have something to worry

about

from surveillance surveillance means

government collection and use of private

and sensitive data about us and

surveillance is essential to law

enforcement and to national security but

the history of surveillance is one that

includes surveillance abuses where this

sensitive information has been used

against people because of their race

their national origin their sexual

orientation and in particular because of

their activism their political beliefs

about 53 years ago dr. Martin Luther

King jr. gave his I have a dream speech

on the mall in Washington and today the

ideas behind this speech of racial

equality and tolerance are so

non-controversial that my daughter’s

study the speech in third grade but at

the time dr. King was extremely

controversial the legendary and

notorious FBI director J Edgar Hoover

believed

saved or wanted to believe that the

civil rights movement was a Soviet

communist plot intended to destabilize

the American government and so Hoover

had his agents put bugs in dr. King’s

hotel rooms and those bugs picked up

conversations between civil rights

leaders talking about the strategies and

tactics of the civil rights movement

they also picked up sounds of dr. King

having sex with women who were not his

wife and J Edgar Hoover saw the

opportunity here to discredit and

undermine the civil rights movement the

FBI sent a package of these recordings

along with a handwritten note to dr.

King and a draft of this note was found

in FBI archives years later and the

letter said you are no clergyman and you

know it King like all frauds your end is

approaching the letter even seemed to

encourage dr. King to commit suicide

saying King there is only one thing left

for you to do you know what it is you

better take it before your filthy

abnormal fraudulent self is bared to the

nation but the important thing is dr.

King was not abnormal every one of us

has something that we want to hide from

somebody and even more important J Edgar

Hoover wasn’t abnormal either the

history of surveillance abuses is not

the history of one bad megalomaniacal

man throughout his decades at the FBI

j.edgar hoover enjoyed the support of

the presidents that he served Democratic

and Republican alike after all it was

John F Kennedy and his brother Robert

Kennedy who knew about and approved the

surveillance of dr. King

Hoover ran a program called COINTELPRO

for 15 years which was designed to spy

on and undermine civic groups that were

devoted to things like civil rights when

rights movement and peace groups and

anti-war movement and and the

surveillance didn’t stop there Lyndon

Baines Johnson during the election

campaign had the campaign airplane of

his rival Barry Goldwater bugged as part

of his effort to win that election and

then of course there was Watergate

burglars were caught breaking into the

Democratic National Committee

headquarters at the Watergate Hotel the

Nixon administration was involved in

covering up the burglary and eventually

Nixon had to step down as president

COINTELPRO and Watergate were a wake-up

call for Americans surveillance was out

of control and it was being used to

squelch political challengers and so

Americans rose to the occasion and what

we did was we reformed surveillance law

and the primary tool we used to reform

surveillance law was to require a search

warrant for the government to be able to

get access to our phone calls and our

letters now the reason why a search

warrant is important is because it

interposes a judge in the relationship

between investigators and the citizens

and that judges job is to make sure that

there’s good cause for the surveillance

that the surveillance is targeted at the

right people and that the information

that’s collected is going to be used for

legitimate government purposes and not

for discriminatory ones so what this

means is that this this was our system

and what this means is that President

Obama did not wiretap Trump Tower the

system is set up to prevent something

like that from happening without a judge

being involved but what happens when

we’re not talking about phone calls or

letters anymore today we have technology

that makes it cheap and easy for the

government to collect information on

ordinary everyday people

your phone call records can reveal

whether you have an addiction what your

religion is what charities you donate to

what political candidate you support and

yet our government collected dragnet

style Americans calling records for

years in 2012 the Republican National

Convention highlighted a new technology

it was planning to use facial

recognition to identify people who are

going to be in the crowd who might be

activists or troublemakers and to stop

them ahead of time today over 50% of

American adults have their face print in

a government database the Bureau of

Alcohol Tobacco Firearms and Explosives

concocted a plan to find out what

Americans were going to gun shows by

using license-plate detectors to scan

the license plates of cars that were in

the parking lots of these events today

we believe that over 70% of police

departments have automatic license plate

detection technology that they’re using

to track people’s cars as they drive

through town and all of this information

the license plates the face prints the

phone records your address books

your buddy lists the photos that you

upload to Dropbox or Google photos and

sometimes even your chats and your

emails are not protected by a warrant

requirement so what that means is we

have all of this information on regular

people that’s newly available at very

low expense it is the golden age for

surveillance um now every parent’s going

to understand what this means when you

have a little baby and the babies young

that child is not able to climb out of

its crib but eventually your little girl

gets older and she’s able to climb out

of the crib but you tell her don’t climb

out of the crib

okay and every parent knows what’s going

to happen some of those babies are going

to climb out of the crib right that’s

the difference between ability and

permission well the same thing is true

with the government today it used to be

that our government didn’t have the

ability to do widespread massive

surveillance on hundreds of millions of

Americans and then abuse that

information but now our governments

grown-up we have that technology today

the government had the ability and that

means the law is more important than

ever before the law is supposed to say

when the government has permission to do

it and it’s supposed to ensure that

there’s some kind of ramification we

notice when those laws are broken and

there’s some kind of ramification or

punishment the law is more important

than ever because we are now living in a

world where only rules are stopping the

government from abusing this information

but the law has fallen down on the job

particularly since September 11th the

law has fallen down on the job and we do

not have the rules in place that we need

and we are seeing the ramifications of

that so fusion centers are these joint

task forces between local state and

federal government that are meant to

ferret out domestic terrorism and what

we’ve seen is fusion Center reports that

say that if you you might be dangerous

if you voted for a third party candidate

or you owned a don’t tread on me flag or

you watched movies that are anti-tax

these same fusion centers have spied on

Muslim community groups reading lists

and on Quakers who are resisting

military recruiting in high schools the

Internal Revenue Service has

disproportionately audited groups that

have tea party or Patriot in their name

and now Customs and Border Patrol is

stopping people as they come into the

country and demanding our social

networking passwords which will allow

them to see who our friends are what we

say and even to impersonate us online

now civil libertarians like myself

have been trying to draw people’s

attention to these things and fighting

against them for years this was a huge

problem during the Obama administration

but now the problem is worse president

Trump is a person who prides himself on

the ability to get even he has said that

if someone hits you then you hit them

back five times harder than they ever

could have imagined all of this

information that is in government

databases about all of us could be

repurposed to be used against people who

challenge or oppose president Trump’s

policies when the New York Police

Department spies on Muslims or a police

department uses license-plate detectors

to find out where the officers spouses

are those sorts of things that is

extremely dangerous but when a president

repurposes the power of federal

surveillance and the federal government

to retaliate against political

opposition that is a tyranny and so it’s

we are all activists now and we all have

something to fear from surveillance but

just like in the time of dr. Martin

Luther King we can reform the way things

are first of all use encryption

encryption protects your information

from being inexpensively and

opportunistically collected it rolls

back the golden age for surveillance

second support surveillance reform did

you know that if you have a friend who

works for the French or German

government or for an international human

rights group or for a global oil company

that your friend is a valid foreign

intelligence target and what that means

is that when you have conversations with

that friend the US government may be

collecting that information

um and when that information is

collected even though it’s conversations

with Americans it can then be funneled

to the FBI where the FBI is allowed to

search through it without getting a

warrant without probable cause looking

for information about Americans and

whatever crimes we may have committed

with no need to document any kind of

suspicion the law that allows some of

this to happen is called section 702 of

the FISA Amendments Act and we have a

great opportunity this year because

section 702 is going to expire at the

end of 2017 which means that Congress’s

inertia is on our side if we want reform

and we can pressure our representatives

to actually implement important reforms

to this law and protect our data from

this redirection and misuse and finally

one of the reasons why things have

gotten so out of control is because so

much of what happens with surveillance

the technology the enabling rules and

the policies that are either there or

not there to protect us our secret or

classified we need transparency and we

need to know as Americans what the

government is doing in our name so that

the surveillance that takes place and

the use of that information is

democratically accounted for we are all

activists now which means that we all

have something to worry about from

surveillance but like in the time of dr.

Martin Luther King there is stuff that

we can do about it so please join me and let’s get to work thank

Please follow and like us: