
as children growing up in Fiji we were
left to largely entertain ourselves and
I would inevitably find myself drawn to
the seashore some of my earliest and
fondest memories are actually of my
auntie Ava featured in this photo here
taking me to her village on the island
of moto Rica in the loma VT group there
I would spend my time following the
older women around in the village
watching them as I went out onto the
reef flats to glean for sea urchins for
sea cucumbers and for numer a type of
edible seaweed I would follow them into
the mangroves and watch in absolute awe
as these women would wrestle mud crabs
with their bare hands I also have a very
vivid memory of mine to tether making me
to crawl up through these River Rapids
to find these quiet pools behind there
she very slowly and carefully made me
lift up these these through grass reeds
growing along the edge of the river to
find a myriad a very small shrimp hidden
within it she explained to me how her
aunt’s had taught her how to catch those
shrimps and she in turn was passing on
that knowledge to me you have to
remember this is a time in the 1980s
when marine biology of any sort was not
taught at school so everything that we
learnt about our oceans actually came
from our elders around us and whatever
they were willing to share with us and I
found myself this sponge just hungry for
knowledge about the marine life on our
doorstep and in my plane ground as an
adult I started working on coastal
fisheries
and I started to spend a lot of time in
rural villages and Fiji and I sort of
realized very early on in my career that
I was really spending a lot of time with
the Chiefs in the village and the men in
the village and this is because the way
this way at the village and the culture
is structured a lot of the decisions
around natural resource management have
been made historically by men and
continue to do so in in our modern day
times if we held workshops
I found that was still spending time
with the men the women were actually too
busy cooking for those workshops that
they actually couldn’t participate in
fact rural women in Fiji I think are
some of the busiest people that I know
because if they’re not cooking or
they’re looking after their children or
their homes they’re tending to their
gardens or they’re out fishing on their
for food for their families so about two
years ago we started to do a lot of work
to look at seafood supply chains in Fiji
and in particular the sea cucumber and
the mud crab fisheries and what this
involves is developing these very
detailed questionnaires in which you go
around and you interview everywhere
every player that’s involved in the
fishery from the Fisher and from when I
say the word Fisher I mean both
fishermen and Fisher women to the
processor to the exporter to the
middleman to the seller
and if you using structured
questionnaires you can actually start to
find out who is involved in the fishery
what they’re investing what are they
doing and also you get to really
document and really draw out how all
these different complicated
relationships that they have with each
other as we started to do this work
looking at seafood supply chains we
started to quantify the role that men
and women were playing in these
fisheries for example with the sea
cucumber fishery we found that 35% of
the fishers were interviewed were
actually women and these are women they
were harvesting actively harvesting and
selling for the Asian export market when
we started looking at the mud crab
fishery we actually were even more
surprised the figure was even higher in
Fiji at least 80 percent of fishers are
actually women again actively harvesting
mud crabs and selling mostly to our
domestic market here in Fiji
so given this role the women are playing
that I’ve just described they’re very
active in these fisheries then it makes
me ask a number of questions why women
are so involved in fisheries
are they so poorly recognized nationally
if women are so involved in our
fisheries then why are they not afforded
the same opportunities for training and
capacity as fishermen and then if women
are involved in both subsistence and
commercial fisheries why are they not
equally represented of why they’re so
poorly represented when there’s
decisions that need to be made around
Fisheries Planning and fisheries
management so I think there are many
reasons but what I’m going to do is just
really share and focus on three firstly
I think because of the way we do our
national summaries when we do national
statistics we tend to only focus on
commercial fisheries the things that
bring in money so this means we tend to
undervalue of subsistence fisheries by
undervaluing our subsistence fisheries
we then undervalue then the role that
women are playing in these fisheries
secondly if we are dealing with data we
tend to just aggregate the data we tend
to aggregate them into one group and
just lump them together as fishes as a
result when most of us sort of see the
word fishes then we we tend to just
think oh they were just talking about
the fishermen and not the not the fisher
women and then I think also because our
cultural norms are so ingrained in us I
think that often when we go out into
these communities we just accept the way
things are we’ve known there
historically this is how they’ve been
done if you work for an international
organization like myself you’re going to
be even more cautious about not
interfering with cultural norms and
being sensitive to how you impact on
indigenous cultures the other thing I
want to point out is it you know when we
talk about Fisher women they’re not just
they’re not just fishing women are also
actively involved in processing as well
as you can see in these images as we
looked a lot into this sort of data and
the information we we found other
interesting things that I want to share
with you first of all that when we were
looking at what the income and what
people were making we just found us that
in general in many instances women
earning less than their male
counterparts women were also involved in
a wider diversity of Fisheries there
were be cuts because involved in both
the subsistence and the commercial
fisheries and not just one or the other
and then also because his women was so
invested in these fisheries they’re also
spending a lot of time you know in
addition to their normal work activities
as well you also find that women when
they take their catch a greater
proportion of it will actually go
towards the wanting to split it between
their subsistence fisheries and their
commercial and commercial fishing begin
income for the family
so men if you look at the catch that
they’re catching most of it of the
majority of it is tending to more go
towards bringing income for the family
and what this does is really emphasizes
the really different but very
complementary roles that men and women
are playing in fisheries in Fiji so what
I’ve described so far isn’t actually not
unique to Fiji and actually plays out in
communities all over the world a 2012
study by the Wildlife Conservation
Society actually documented that yes all
over the world men and women have this
very different but complementary role
when it comes to fisheries if you look
at the fishery sector at about almost
50% of that sector is actually made up
of women however when you start to delve
into the data look at the projects on
the ground you start to see a really
common and disturbing pattern and this
is there seems to be this consistent
failure to engage Fisher women in
fisheries management if there are
involved it often is some token small
amount and then if there are projects
being developed they are largely
targeted at fishermen rather than the
actual fish that you Fisher women and
this makes the women particularly
vulnerable to what is called
displacement so let me give you an
example because I think it’s really
important to understand this concept of
displacement I’m going to give you an
example from Tanzania
in the kilowatt district in Tanzania the
women have traditionally caught octopus
for sale and also for putting food on
their table when companies started to
come in the prices of octopus actually
started to increase and as a result men
started entering into this fishery the
men would would go on their boats out
onto the reef flats and collect octopus
an activity that’s actually prohibited
for women they would also ignore the
traditional practice that these women
had of owning fishing and harvesting at
very particular times of the year and
this helped to protect the reef stock
stock of the octopus as a result we
found that the women were very quickly
displaced from this fishery the stocks
declined profits declined due to
overfishing and the pressure that was
coming in and the interference from
middlemen what this example that had
given you also highlights something else
that’s really important I really want to
share with you that because the majority
of the poor or the rural poor are women
because their goods and services because
they sorry so reliant on goods and
services provided by nature they are
often disproportionately impacted if you
have a fisheries collapse or if there’s
some kind of degradation of a natural
resource so why does any favor a does
any of this actually matter why is it
important well globally we are losing
our fisheries at an alarming rate in
developed countries at least 60% of
stocks are depleted and in need of
urgent rebuilding so I’m going to repeat
that I did not say the stocks were
declining about to decline or going to
decline in some distant future
I said 60% of stocks in developed
countries are depleted to the point that
they need rebuilding paradoxically some
of the mo areas that are the most
productive in terms of fisheries
actually have the highest rates of
malnutrition and poverty
what this means is that we really need a
drastic rethinking globally on how we do
fisheries management and one of the
areas that I would like to see real
transformative change in is how we
include gender in fisheries management
so when I talk about including gender
and fisheries management I’m not talking
about promoting women over men or even
promoting practices that are
disrespectful or impactful to men or 12
culture when I’m talking about gender
I’m talking about recognizing the very
different and complementary roles that
men and women play in fisheries and how
these roles define who has the power
who has the influence and who ultimately
is making decisions about how natural
resources are used and allocated I’m not
asking us so now to take all those
resources and shift them and just focus
on Fisher women what I’m saying is that
we’re now when we do fisheries
management if you if you take a gender
based approach to fisheries management
you need to be inclusive you need to
understand and recognize that men and
women both have important roles you need
to include both if you address work from
a gender perspective what you’re doing
is actually just recognizing that there
are these inequalities out there between
the genders and then you’re slowly
starting to build the possibilities
towards more equitable and more
participatory relationships but as I
leave you today I don’t want you to
leave feeling very disparaged or down or
depressed about the state of the
fisheries even though it is there is we
need to be alarmed about what’s
happening out there
and I want to give some kind of
practical examples of what I mean about
being better at including gender and
fisheries management so first of all
let’s take the time when we start doing
some work on fisheries take the time
that’s really try and understand the
role that men and women are playing in
different fisheries don’t jump in and
make assumptions if we actually took the
time to actually understand the
different roles that men and women play
and how complementary to they are to
each other
then we can start to understand where
the inequalities lie and then we can
start to put in the right fisheries
management action the right strategy to
again address that imbalance we also
need to become so so so much better at
including women in workshops and in in
decisions around fisheries management
this is probably going to differ for
different parts of the world in Fiji
we’re going to have to maybe think about
holding those workshops when the women
are more available yeah we’re going to
have to think about if they’re not
comfortable at first voicing what they
want to say in front of the men is
creating us different a safe space for
them to have their discussions and to be
heard the other thing we’ve got to stop
doing is we’ve got to stop under valuing
our subsistence fisheries it’s not just
about the money if we actually took the
time to actually value our subsistence
fisheries the way we do our commercial
fisheries we would then stop and of
valuing the role that women play because
women play such a huge role in terms of
food security in our local communities
the other thing we could do is build if
need be build support networks for women
and I feel incredibly proud to be part
of the women of Fisheries network here
in Fiji and the women of Fisheries
network is actually bringing together
conservation practitioners and NGOs
government private sector anybody who
cares about this issue to try and
provide better support to Fisher women
to make their voice stronger and heard
and then lastly please don’t exclude the
men please continue to include them they
are still vitally important don’t make
assumptions that the men will not be
supportive of their women when we were
doing our work on mud crabs we were
actually overwhelmed by the level of
support and enthusiasm the men had for
us working with their women trying to
address fisheries management issues on
the ground we found if you approach them
in the respectful way you’ll get their
full support
and then as you leave here today I hope
you leave with a greater sense of how
much women like this are this amazing
untapped resource a knowledge base for
us to draw on if there’s just one thing
I can ask you all to do which would be
to actually go out find these women
spend time with them in their habitats
that they work in listen and learn
because if you do I guarantee it is
going to be the best marine biology
lesson that you could ever have
thank you
[Applause]
[Music]
you
left to largely entertain ourselves and
I would inevitably find myself drawn to
the seashore some of my earliest and
fondest memories are actually of my
auntie Ava featured in this photo here
taking me to her village on the island
of moto Rica in the loma VT group there
I would spend my time following the
older women around in the village
watching them as I went out onto the
reef flats to glean for sea urchins for
sea cucumbers and for numer a type of
edible seaweed I would follow them into
the mangroves and watch in absolute awe
as these women would wrestle mud crabs
with their bare hands I also have a very
vivid memory of mine to tether making me
to crawl up through these River Rapids
to find these quiet pools behind there
she very slowly and carefully made me
lift up these these through grass reeds
growing along the edge of the river to
find a myriad a very small shrimp hidden
within it she explained to me how her
aunt’s had taught her how to catch those
shrimps and she in turn was passing on
that knowledge to me you have to
remember this is a time in the 1980s
when marine biology of any sort was not
taught at school so everything that we
learnt about our oceans actually came
from our elders around us and whatever
they were willing to share with us and I
found myself this sponge just hungry for
knowledge about the marine life on our
doorstep and in my plane ground as an
adult I started working on coastal
fisheries
and I started to spend a lot of time in
rural villages and Fiji and I sort of
realized very early on in my career that
I was really spending a lot of time with
the Chiefs in the village and the men in
the village and this is because the way
this way at the village and the culture
is structured a lot of the decisions
around natural resource management have
been made historically by men and
continue to do so in in our modern day
times if we held workshops
I found that was still spending time
with the men the women were actually too
busy cooking for those workshops that
they actually couldn’t participate in
fact rural women in Fiji I think are
some of the busiest people that I know
because if they’re not cooking or
they’re looking after their children or
their homes they’re tending to their
gardens or they’re out fishing on their
for food for their families so about two
years ago we started to do a lot of work
to look at seafood supply chains in Fiji
and in particular the sea cucumber and
the mud crab fisheries and what this
involves is developing these very
detailed questionnaires in which you go
around and you interview everywhere
every player that’s involved in the
fishery from the Fisher and from when I
say the word Fisher I mean both
fishermen and Fisher women to the
processor to the exporter to the
middleman to the seller
and if you using structured
questionnaires you can actually start to
find out who is involved in the fishery
what they’re investing what are they
doing and also you get to really
document and really draw out how all
these different complicated
relationships that they have with each
other as we started to do this work
looking at seafood supply chains we
started to quantify the role that men
and women were playing in these
fisheries for example with the sea
cucumber fishery we found that 35% of
the fishers were interviewed were
actually women and these are women they
were harvesting actively harvesting and
selling for the Asian export market when
we started looking at the mud crab
fishery we actually were even more
surprised the figure was even higher in
Fiji at least 80 percent of fishers are
actually women again actively harvesting
mud crabs and selling mostly to our
domestic market here in Fiji
so given this role the women are playing
that I’ve just described they’re very
active in these fisheries then it makes
me ask a number of questions why women
are so involved in fisheries
are they so poorly recognized nationally
if women are so involved in our
fisheries then why are they not afforded
the same opportunities for training and
capacity as fishermen and then if women
are involved in both subsistence and
commercial fisheries why are they not
equally represented of why they’re so
poorly represented when there’s
decisions that need to be made around
Fisheries Planning and fisheries
management so I think there are many
reasons but what I’m going to do is just
really share and focus on three firstly
I think because of the way we do our
national summaries when we do national
statistics we tend to only focus on
commercial fisheries the things that
bring in money so this means we tend to
undervalue of subsistence fisheries by
undervaluing our subsistence fisheries
we then undervalue then the role that
women are playing in these fisheries
secondly if we are dealing with data we
tend to just aggregate the data we tend
to aggregate them into one group and
just lump them together as fishes as a
result when most of us sort of see the
word fishes then we we tend to just
think oh they were just talking about
the fishermen and not the not the fisher
women and then I think also because our
cultural norms are so ingrained in us I
think that often when we go out into
these communities we just accept the way
things are we’ve known there
historically this is how they’ve been
done if you work for an international
organization like myself you’re going to
be even more cautious about not
interfering with cultural norms and
being sensitive to how you impact on
indigenous cultures the other thing I
want to point out is it you know when we
talk about Fisher women they’re not just
they’re not just fishing women are also
actively involved in processing as well
as you can see in these images as we
looked a lot into this sort of data and
the information we we found other
interesting things that I want to share
with you first of all that when we were
looking at what the income and what
people were making we just found us that
in general in many instances women
earning less than their male
counterparts women were also involved in
a wider diversity of Fisheries there
were be cuts because involved in both
the subsistence and the commercial
fisheries and not just one or the other
and then also because his women was so
invested in these fisheries they’re also
spending a lot of time you know in
addition to their normal work activities
as well you also find that women when
they take their catch a greater
proportion of it will actually go
towards the wanting to split it between
their subsistence fisheries and their
commercial and commercial fishing begin
income for the family
so men if you look at the catch that
they’re catching most of it of the
majority of it is tending to more go
towards bringing income for the family
and what this does is really emphasizes
the really different but very
complementary roles that men and women
are playing in fisheries in Fiji so what
I’ve described so far isn’t actually not
unique to Fiji and actually plays out in
communities all over the world a 2012
study by the Wildlife Conservation
Society actually documented that yes all
over the world men and women have this
very different but complementary role
when it comes to fisheries if you look
at the fishery sector at about almost
50% of that sector is actually made up
of women however when you start to delve
into the data look at the projects on
the ground you start to see a really
common and disturbing pattern and this
is there seems to be this consistent
failure to engage Fisher women in
fisheries management if there are
involved it often is some token small
amount and then if there are projects
being developed they are largely
targeted at fishermen rather than the
actual fish that you Fisher women and
this makes the women particularly
vulnerable to what is called
displacement so let me give you an
example because I think it’s really
important to understand this concept of
displacement I’m going to give you an
example from Tanzania
in the kilowatt district in Tanzania the
women have traditionally caught octopus
for sale and also for putting food on
their table when companies started to
come in the prices of octopus actually
started to increase and as a result men
started entering into this fishery the
men would would go on their boats out
onto the reef flats and collect octopus
an activity that’s actually prohibited
for women they would also ignore the
traditional practice that these women
had of owning fishing and harvesting at
very particular times of the year and
this helped to protect the reef stock
stock of the octopus as a result we
found that the women were very quickly
displaced from this fishery the stocks
declined profits declined due to
overfishing and the pressure that was
coming in and the interference from
middlemen what this example that had
given you also highlights something else
that’s really important I really want to
share with you that because the majority
of the poor or the rural poor are women
because their goods and services because
they sorry so reliant on goods and
services provided by nature they are
often disproportionately impacted if you
have a fisheries collapse or if there’s
some kind of degradation of a natural
resource so why does any favor a does
any of this actually matter why is it
important well globally we are losing
our fisheries at an alarming rate in
developed countries at least 60% of
stocks are depleted and in need of
urgent rebuilding so I’m going to repeat
that I did not say the stocks were
declining about to decline or going to
decline in some distant future
I said 60% of stocks in developed
countries are depleted to the point that
they need rebuilding paradoxically some
of the mo areas that are the most
productive in terms of fisheries
actually have the highest rates of
malnutrition and poverty
what this means is that we really need a
drastic rethinking globally on how we do
fisheries management and one of the
areas that I would like to see real
transformative change in is how we
include gender in fisheries management
so when I talk about including gender
and fisheries management I’m not talking
about promoting women over men or even
promoting practices that are
disrespectful or impactful to men or 12
culture when I’m talking about gender
I’m talking about recognizing the very
different and complementary roles that
men and women play in fisheries and how
these roles define who has the power
who has the influence and who ultimately
is making decisions about how natural
resources are used and allocated I’m not
asking us so now to take all those
resources and shift them and just focus
on Fisher women what I’m saying is that
we’re now when we do fisheries
management if you if you take a gender
based approach to fisheries management
you need to be inclusive you need to
understand and recognize that men and
women both have important roles you need
to include both if you address work from
a gender perspective what you’re doing
is actually just recognizing that there
are these inequalities out there between
the genders and then you’re slowly
starting to build the possibilities
towards more equitable and more
participatory relationships but as I
leave you today I don’t want you to
leave feeling very disparaged or down or
depressed about the state of the
fisheries even though it is there is we
need to be alarmed about what’s
happening out there
and I want to give some kind of
practical examples of what I mean about
being better at including gender and
fisheries management so first of all
let’s take the time when we start doing
some work on fisheries take the time
that’s really try and understand the
role that men and women are playing in
different fisheries don’t jump in and
make assumptions if we actually took the
time to actually understand the
different roles that men and women play
and how complementary to they are to
each other
then we can start to understand where
the inequalities lie and then we can
start to put in the right fisheries
management action the right strategy to
again address that imbalance we also
need to become so so so much better at
including women in workshops and in in
decisions around fisheries management
this is probably going to differ for
different parts of the world in Fiji
we’re going to have to maybe think about
holding those workshops when the women
are more available yeah we’re going to
have to think about if they’re not
comfortable at first voicing what they
want to say in front of the men is
creating us different a safe space for
them to have their discussions and to be
heard the other thing we’ve got to stop
doing is we’ve got to stop under valuing
our subsistence fisheries it’s not just
about the money if we actually took the
time to actually value our subsistence
fisheries the way we do our commercial
fisheries we would then stop and of
valuing the role that women play because
women play such a huge role in terms of
food security in our local communities
the other thing we could do is build if
need be build support networks for women
and I feel incredibly proud to be part
of the women of Fisheries network here
in Fiji and the women of Fisheries
network is actually bringing together
conservation practitioners and NGOs
government private sector anybody who
cares about this issue to try and
provide better support to Fisher women
to make their voice stronger and heard
and then lastly please don’t exclude the
men please continue to include them they
are still vitally important don’t make
assumptions that the men will not be
supportive of their women when we were
doing our work on mud crabs we were
actually overwhelmed by the level of
support and enthusiasm the men had for
us working with their women trying to
address fisheries management issues on
the ground we found if you approach them
in the respectful way you’ll get their
full support
and then as you leave here today I hope
you leave with a greater sense of how
much women like this are this amazing
untapped resource a knowledge base for
us to draw on if there’s just one thing
I can ask you all to do which would be
to actually go out find these women
spend time with them in their habitats
that they work in listen and learn
because if you do I guarantee it is
going to be the best marine biology
lesson that you could ever have
thank you
[Applause]
[Music]
you
Please follow and like us: