
Translator: Laura Cirasola Reviewer: Michele Gianella
Rosetta is a crazy mission!
Believe me.
Telling the story of its journey is like experiencing a Sci-Fi movie.
But it is also about learning about real people,
coming from all parts of Europe
who get together
and work as a group to build an incredible dream.
I have been lucky enough to live a great part of this journey
together with many friends at the Mission’s Control Centre,
and I’d like to share some episodes with you.
My personal contribution to Rosetta started in the year 2000.
I came to work to Darmstadt,
that is a twin town of Brescia, for those who don’t know,
so it’s a kind of a lucky coincidence.
On the first day at work
I was given the Software Requirements,
and all the papers for Rosetta satellite’s Mission Control System.
First thing: let’s learn about Rosetta.
Rosetta is a mission to study a comet.
This comet is very far away.
The journey will take ten years.
Seven billion Km.
Once reached the comet, it will deploy a lander on its surface.
I started looking around me, convinced that this was a joke
from my new colleagues.
“They want to see how I react to this incredible story!”
There was no hidden camera,
it was no joke.
This was really the goal of the mission!
And the great thing,
is that now, after so many years,
I’m here to tell you about a mission that has produced some fantastic science.
From an initial science fiction idea,
we now have incredible results.
Year 2000 has been fundamental for me, as many things have changed.
But one thing has changed above all, which is my definition of Rosetta.
For all my life up to that moment,
and maybe also for some of you,
A Rosetta has always been only this.
(Laughter)
This is a rosetta. (Applause)
From that year instead, and I suppose for the rest of my life,
Rosetta has been a different thing.
Rosetta is a beautiful satellite.
It has enormous solar panels,
sixty-four square metres of surface.
With a giant antenna,
to communicate with Earth at those incredible distances
in deep space.
On one of its sides
there is Philae, the lander that will get down to touch the comet.
Let’s start our journey,
and Rosetta is at the top of this rocket you can see.
This is an Ariane 5, the most powerful of the ESA rockets.
The launch takes place in Kourou, in the French Guyana,
and in that moment, in ESOC, in Darmstadt,
we are sitting in the Main Control Room, and we are just powerless,
since all depends on the launcher.
If it all goes well, the satellite will be left in its initial orbit
and start an automatic sequence,
to deploy the solar panels, and start communicating with Earth,
then we can start operating.
But in such moments,
imagine the tension for people who have worked for years and years,
and everything depends on this moment.
So, we are simply concentrated
on the launch, and hope that everything goes well
and that we can start our job soon.
This is the start of an incredible journey.
I want to show you
an animation that brings us
through the phases of this 10-year long flight.
Look at the Earth.
Every time the Earth makes a circle around the Sun
a year has passed, obviously.
Rosetta followed this white trajectory,
around the solar system.
The journey has covered billions of Km, over a period of 10 years.
We would have never managed to reach the comet
without a trick
to increase the energy of Rosetta.
This trick consists of flying very close to planets
and exploiting their gravitational pull,
then steal some of their energy
to be thrown into ever bigger orbits.
We did this three times with the Earth,
and once with Mars.
You can see in the animation
how the solar orbit of Rosetta becomes bigger after events.
To reach the final orbit without these fly-by manoeuvres,
we’d probably never make it.
We would have needed tens of tons of propellant,
which is obviously not feasible.
Look at the last fly-by around the Earth.
This has shooted Rosetta in a new huge orbit,
that converges
with the orbit of the comet.
Now Rosetta is so far away from the Sun,
that even its huge solar panels
are not sufficient to generate enough energy
to keep all instruments going.
So the so called hibernation phase begins.
Think about it, now everything is turned off.
All instruments, the communication systems, all off.
The only systems that remain active are
a heater, to prevent the propellant freezing,
and an alarm.
This alarm is set to ring two and a half years later.
So, we now jump forward in time
and into the ESOC control room.
This is where Rosetta is controlled from.
Two and a half years have passed, and we have heard nothing from Rosetta.
We were using huge deep space antennas,
one of 70 m diameter, in America and one of 35 m diameter, in Australia
so one from NASA and one from ESA,
pointed in space,
at the location in which we believed Rosetta would have been,
after all this time.
Imagine, we had to predict this orbit after two and a half years.
These are the signals that come from the two antennas.
What we were waiting for was a peak in this oscilloscope,
showing the reception of a signal,
from one, and probably from both ground stations.
The problem is that the signal did not arrive
when we were waiting for it.
Nor did it arrive 15 minutes later.
And after half an hour, still no signal.
At that point, honestly,
many of us started feeling so bad.
Imagine all these years of work, years of flight.
If Rosetta doesn’t wake up now, it’s all over.
We no longer have a job, nor a goal in life.
Years of effort thrown away for nothing.
And we were already thinking what to tell the international press.
We were thinking about us the day after.
And when it really looked like all was lost,
the signal arrived!
You see this peak coming up in the two oscilloscope’s graphs,
and when we were certain,
look at the explosion of relief.
It is like going from hell to heaven,
it is a…
(Hooray!)
…right, it happened this time again,
I got goose bumps.
I have watched this movie one hundred, two hundred times,
and yet every time I get shivers,
because this is the expression of the feelings of a group,
that has lived together for so long time.
It does not only take mathematicians, physicists, and engineers
for this to happen.
It takes people that can work together.
For me, the human factor in a group is a fundamental component.
It is what has brought these people, along the years,
to understand each other, to overcome difficult moments,
to put aside personal problems and personal ambitions,
for the intention of bringing this project ahead.
A very complex project,
which only by chunking it down in pieces,
assigning precise responsibilities and communicating with each other.
could be accomplished.
I am really honored
to have been part of this group, in the first part of the mission.
But let’s not forget that the mission is not over yet.
It’s just begun!
What happens now
is that Rosetta has to brake energetically,
and start to “see” the comet.
And what we can see
is more or less what we expected to see.
Insofar, the comet has always been represented
essentially as a spherical, convoluted object.
What we discovered instead diverges from this common representation.
The first close-up pictures were a shock for us.
This is a totally unexpected structure.
We were expecting
a potato shaped comet, that turns around itself (laughs).
But this has created incredible reactions.
The scientists were ecstatic, they were saying:
“This is fantastic, the best thing we could expect!”.
And the flight dynamics engineers had their hands in:
“We need to enter orbit, around this object,
and land Philae on it.
This is going to be incredibly tough!”
Hefty discussions and heavy choices followed,
but the most important thing was to get closer to the comet.
Imagine that the comet has a gravitational pull
100.000 times smaller than that of the Earth.
So, we can’t really talk
about a proper orbit around the comet,
until we are very close to it.
And we don’t know much about the comet yet,
about its mass, and its distribution.
So, the flight dynamics engineers from ESOC in Darmstadt
have invented these pyramidal trajectories,
with 100 Km long edges,
going down towards the comet.
Observing Rosetta’s trajectory
and its modification due to the small gravitational pull,
helped us to better understand both structure,
and mass of the comet,
and calculate how to refine the trajectory,
in order to get closer and closer to it.
This step was very important.
We studied the comet
and we tried to get closer and closer to it.
We reached a closer distance, of about 30 Km.
Remember, we’re far as hundreds million Km from the Earth,
the comet is about 3 Km,
and we enter circular orbits of around 30 Km of radius around the comet.
At this point, it becomes possible to obtain Keplerian orbits,
like those of satellites around the Earth.
So if we don’t touch it, it stays there
and, with very large approximations, obviously,
it makes circular orbits.
The orbit lowered to 10 Km radius,
in order to take many pictures, and map the comet’s surface really well,
so to map the place where our friend Philae will land.
This phase was very critical,
since we had to match opposite instances.
The scientists wanted Philae to land in some special points,
typically the hardest to reach,
and typically those
where illumination and radio contact with Rosetta
would have been complicated.
Philae can’t communicate directly with Earth,
thus uses Rosetta as relay while it’s orbiting the comet.
Then Rosetta sends them to Earth.
We are now, in my opinion. in the most exciting phase.
A fantastic moment.
In November 2016, the landing phase starts.
Rosetta gets into collision route with the comet,
and releases the lander.
This is a picture taken from the lander Philae, upwards.
You can see Rosetta, the mothership up there,
with its huge solar panels.
The next picture is even nicer.
We can see the lander
with the three landing legs deployed
descending towards the comet.
The next pictures show the lander
getting far away towards the comet.
And this is the last photo, I hope you can see the white dot
of the approaching lander.
It took around seven hours for Philae to cover the 22 Km distance
from the release point to ground contact,
at a speed of about 50 cm per second,
like a person walking.
Here we have pictures taken directly from Philae.
This is one of the three landing legs,
and you see the comet approaching.
You can see its head,
we are almost there.
Here we are at 40 meters from the surface.
Note this stone, on the top right of the picture,
we’ll use it later to identify the landing point precisely.
And now get ready to the story:
this is the first picture of the surface of a comet,
directly from an object we landed on it.
It had never happened before,
and this is an image that will stay forever
in all Space History books.
It’s an achievement we all are very proud of.
It has been one of the biggest successes in our work.
Here, in my view, you see the apotheosis of mathematics, of human genius.
The distance between the calculated landing point
and the real point where Philae touched the comet
was less than 120 meters!
We are talking about 500 milion Km distance,
on a three Km diameter comet,
rotating around itself, with a period of 12 hours.
This is an achievement that still amazes me,
and my respect for my colleagues and friends in flight dynamics is immense.
I’ll carry it with me forever.
(Applause)
What happened?
Philae touched down exactly where we wanted,
but didn’t stop!
In the blue circle is the footprint of Philaes’ landing legs,
which bounced and flew away, unfortunately.
Look in the red circle on the right, that is Philae!
Its last image, while flying away.
The systems for grounding it didn’t work properly.
Have we been unlucky?
No! We have been extremely lucky,
because Philae bounced once more,
and landed again on a point
inside this red ellipse you see in the picture.
We really had it good,
because with that minuscule gravity
Philae may have bounced back into space,
and its mission would have ended then.
Throughout, Rosetta has continued looking for the lander on the comet’s surface.
We wanted to localise Philae,
and just a few weeks before the end of the mission
we were able to find it.
In the bottom right of the picture,
you can see Philae stuck in that rift,
from where it accomplished all its scientific tasks.
Rosetta continued its mission
for two more years around the comet,
collecting a huge amount of spectacular scientific data.
Some incredible pictures.
Once at the end of its mission, it has been decided to let Rosetta
land on the comet too.
These are the latest pictures of the comet from Rosetta,
slowly descending to the surface.
We have collected scientific data until the last moment.
And so, you can see the shadow getting closer,
until we get to the contact.
All instruments have been switched off, Rosetta won’t send any signal any more.
It is a moment in which we should have cried our joy,
but I confess that most people at the control center
had a sort of lump in their throat.
After all these years,
seeing the signal going down and becoming flat
was a really strong emotion.
And this brings me
to the second fundamental point of my speech,
and I wanted to point out that
no individual nation has sent Rosetta to the comet,
neither France, nor Italy, nor Spain.
It has been a cooperation between all these nations
that created the system that did that.
ESA, the European Space Agency, brings together 22 member states,
and through the joint effort,
as well as through the best personalities in space science and engineering,
succeeded in this great mission.
Think about that:
only a few decades ago, in the middle of Europe,
French, German, Italian, English people
killed each other by the millions.
I believe that change is beautiful.
Today the same people collaborate
on ambitious and marvelous common space projects.
Two things, the human factor and the cooperation,
in my opinion,
are what you should take away from this presentation.
And to better stick them into your heads,
I have a very personal example that sums up these two things.
This is the garden of our house.
My wife is Spanish, I’m Italian and our children were born in Germany,
So they have three nationalities,
and fluently speak three languages; Italian, Spanish, and German.
When people ask them:
“Do you feel more Italian, or Spanish…”
They just shrug their shoulders and say, boh! [“Whatever”, in Italian]
They speak all three languages as their mothertongues.
Even I, after 20 years in Germany,
can’t say I feel 100% Italian.
And yet, I’ll never feel 100% German.
So, I have the great opportunity to say that “I’m European!”.
For me, this is just marvelous.
I wish my children, and yours,
to have the chance to live, work, and learn
in a Europe where all nations understand,
and keep taking advantage of their diversities,
to create something exceptional and incredible
as the Rosetta mission,
because I really believe that we all need
this kind of cooperation.
Thanks.
(Applause)
Rosetta is a crazy mission!
Believe me.
Telling the story of its journey is like experiencing a Sci-Fi movie.
But it is also about learning about real people,
coming from all parts of Europe
who get together
and work as a group to build an incredible dream.
I have been lucky enough to live a great part of this journey
together with many friends at the Mission’s Control Centre,
and I’d like to share some episodes with you.
My personal contribution to Rosetta started in the year 2000.
I came to work to Darmstadt,
that is a twin town of Brescia, for those who don’t know,
so it’s a kind of a lucky coincidence.
On the first day at work
I was given the Software Requirements,
and all the papers for Rosetta satellite’s Mission Control System.
First thing: let’s learn about Rosetta.
Rosetta is a mission to study a comet.
This comet is very far away.
The journey will take ten years.
Seven billion Km.
Once reached the comet, it will deploy a lander on its surface.
I started looking around me, convinced that this was a joke
from my new colleagues.
“They want to see how I react to this incredible story!”
There was no hidden camera,
it was no joke.
This was really the goal of the mission!
And the great thing,
is that now, after so many years,
I’m here to tell you about a mission that has produced some fantastic science.
From an initial science fiction idea,
we now have incredible results.
Year 2000 has been fundamental for me, as many things have changed.
But one thing has changed above all, which is my definition of Rosetta.
For all my life up to that moment,
and maybe also for some of you,
A Rosetta has always been only this.
(Laughter)
This is a rosetta. (Applause)
From that year instead, and I suppose for the rest of my life,
Rosetta has been a different thing.
Rosetta is a beautiful satellite.
It has enormous solar panels,
sixty-four square metres of surface.
With a giant antenna,
to communicate with Earth at those incredible distances
in deep space.
On one of its sides
there is Philae, the lander that will get down to touch the comet.
Let’s start our journey,
and Rosetta is at the top of this rocket you can see.
This is an Ariane 5, the most powerful of the ESA rockets.
The launch takes place in Kourou, in the French Guyana,
and in that moment, in ESOC, in Darmstadt,
we are sitting in the Main Control Room, and we are just powerless,
since all depends on the launcher.
If it all goes well, the satellite will be left in its initial orbit
and start an automatic sequence,
to deploy the solar panels, and start communicating with Earth,
then we can start operating.
But in such moments,
imagine the tension for people who have worked for years and years,
and everything depends on this moment.
So, we are simply concentrated
on the launch, and hope that everything goes well
and that we can start our job soon.
This is the start of an incredible journey.
I want to show you
an animation that brings us
through the phases of this 10-year long flight.
Look at the Earth.
Every time the Earth makes a circle around the Sun
a year has passed, obviously.
Rosetta followed this white trajectory,
around the solar system.
The journey has covered billions of Km, over a period of 10 years.
We would have never managed to reach the comet
without a trick
to increase the energy of Rosetta.
This trick consists of flying very close to planets
and exploiting their gravitational pull,
then steal some of their energy
to be thrown into ever bigger orbits.
We did this three times with the Earth,
and once with Mars.
You can see in the animation
how the solar orbit of Rosetta becomes bigger after events.
To reach the final orbit without these fly-by manoeuvres,
we’d probably never make it.
We would have needed tens of tons of propellant,
which is obviously not feasible.
Look at the last fly-by around the Earth.
This has shooted Rosetta in a new huge orbit,
that converges
with the orbit of the comet.
Now Rosetta is so far away from the Sun,
that even its huge solar panels
are not sufficient to generate enough energy
to keep all instruments going.
So the so called hibernation phase begins.
Think about it, now everything is turned off.
All instruments, the communication systems, all off.
The only systems that remain active are
a heater, to prevent the propellant freezing,
and an alarm.
This alarm is set to ring two and a half years later.
So, we now jump forward in time
and into the ESOC control room.
This is where Rosetta is controlled from.
Two and a half years have passed, and we have heard nothing from Rosetta.
We were using huge deep space antennas,
one of 70 m diameter, in America and one of 35 m diameter, in Australia
so one from NASA and one from ESA,
pointed in space,
at the location in which we believed Rosetta would have been,
after all this time.
Imagine, we had to predict this orbit after two and a half years.
These are the signals that come from the two antennas.
What we were waiting for was a peak in this oscilloscope,
showing the reception of a signal,
from one, and probably from both ground stations.
The problem is that the signal did not arrive
when we were waiting for it.
Nor did it arrive 15 minutes later.
And after half an hour, still no signal.
At that point, honestly,
many of us started feeling so bad.
Imagine all these years of work, years of flight.
If Rosetta doesn’t wake up now, it’s all over.
We no longer have a job, nor a goal in life.
Years of effort thrown away for nothing.
And we were already thinking what to tell the international press.
We were thinking about us the day after.
And when it really looked like all was lost,
the signal arrived!
You see this peak coming up in the two oscilloscope’s graphs,
and when we were certain,
look at the explosion of relief.
It is like going from hell to heaven,
it is a…
(Hooray!)
…right, it happened this time again,
I got goose bumps.
I have watched this movie one hundred, two hundred times,
and yet every time I get shivers,
because this is the expression of the feelings of a group,
that has lived together for so long time.
It does not only take mathematicians, physicists, and engineers
for this to happen.
It takes people that can work together.
For me, the human factor in a group is a fundamental component.
It is what has brought these people, along the years,
to understand each other, to overcome difficult moments,
to put aside personal problems and personal ambitions,
for the intention of bringing this project ahead.
A very complex project,
which only by chunking it down in pieces,
assigning precise responsibilities and communicating with each other.
could be accomplished.
I am really honored
to have been part of this group, in the first part of the mission.
But let’s not forget that the mission is not over yet.
It’s just begun!
What happens now
is that Rosetta has to brake energetically,
and start to “see” the comet.
And what we can see
is more or less what we expected to see.
Insofar, the comet has always been represented
essentially as a spherical, convoluted object.
What we discovered instead diverges from this common representation.
The first close-up pictures were a shock for us.
This is a totally unexpected structure.
We were expecting
a potato shaped comet, that turns around itself (laughs).
But this has created incredible reactions.
The scientists were ecstatic, they were saying:
“This is fantastic, the best thing we could expect!”.
And the flight dynamics engineers had their hands in:
“We need to enter orbit, around this object,
and land Philae on it.
This is going to be incredibly tough!”
Hefty discussions and heavy choices followed,
but the most important thing was to get closer to the comet.
Imagine that the comet has a gravitational pull
100.000 times smaller than that of the Earth.
So, we can’t really talk
about a proper orbit around the comet,
until we are very close to it.
And we don’t know much about the comet yet,
about its mass, and its distribution.
So, the flight dynamics engineers from ESOC in Darmstadt
have invented these pyramidal trajectories,
with 100 Km long edges,
going down towards the comet.
Observing Rosetta’s trajectory
and its modification due to the small gravitational pull,
helped us to better understand both structure,
and mass of the comet,
and calculate how to refine the trajectory,
in order to get closer and closer to it.
This step was very important.
We studied the comet
and we tried to get closer and closer to it.
We reached a closer distance, of about 30 Km.
Remember, we’re far as hundreds million Km from the Earth,
the comet is about 3 Km,
and we enter circular orbits of around 30 Km of radius around the comet.
At this point, it becomes possible to obtain Keplerian orbits,
like those of satellites around the Earth.
So if we don’t touch it, it stays there
and, with very large approximations, obviously,
it makes circular orbits.
The orbit lowered to 10 Km radius,
in order to take many pictures, and map the comet’s surface really well,
so to map the place where our friend Philae will land.
This phase was very critical,
since we had to match opposite instances.
The scientists wanted Philae to land in some special points,
typically the hardest to reach,
and typically those
where illumination and radio contact with Rosetta
would have been complicated.
Philae can’t communicate directly with Earth,
thus uses Rosetta as relay while it’s orbiting the comet.
Then Rosetta sends them to Earth.
We are now, in my opinion. in the most exciting phase.
A fantastic moment.
In November 2016, the landing phase starts.
Rosetta gets into collision route with the comet,
and releases the lander.
This is a picture taken from the lander Philae, upwards.
You can see Rosetta, the mothership up there,
with its huge solar panels.
The next picture is even nicer.
We can see the lander
with the three landing legs deployed
descending towards the comet.
The next pictures show the lander
getting far away towards the comet.
And this is the last photo, I hope you can see the white dot
of the approaching lander.
It took around seven hours for Philae to cover the 22 Km distance
from the release point to ground contact,
at a speed of about 50 cm per second,
like a person walking.
Here we have pictures taken directly from Philae.
This is one of the three landing legs,
and you see the comet approaching.
You can see its head,
we are almost there.
Here we are at 40 meters from the surface.
Note this stone, on the top right of the picture,
we’ll use it later to identify the landing point precisely.
And now get ready to the story:
this is the first picture of the surface of a comet,
directly from an object we landed on it.
It had never happened before,
and this is an image that will stay forever
in all Space History books.
It’s an achievement we all are very proud of.
It has been one of the biggest successes in our work.
Here, in my view, you see the apotheosis of mathematics, of human genius.
The distance between the calculated landing point
and the real point where Philae touched the comet
was less than 120 meters!
We are talking about 500 milion Km distance,
on a three Km diameter comet,
rotating around itself, with a period of 12 hours.
This is an achievement that still amazes me,
and my respect for my colleagues and friends in flight dynamics is immense.
I’ll carry it with me forever.
(Applause)
What happened?
Philae touched down exactly where we wanted,
but didn’t stop!
In the blue circle is the footprint of Philaes’ landing legs,
which bounced and flew away, unfortunately.
Look in the red circle on the right, that is Philae!
Its last image, while flying away.
The systems for grounding it didn’t work properly.
Have we been unlucky?
No! We have been extremely lucky,
because Philae bounced once more,
and landed again on a point
inside this red ellipse you see in the picture.
We really had it good,
because with that minuscule gravity
Philae may have bounced back into space,
and its mission would have ended then.
Throughout, Rosetta has continued looking for the lander on the comet’s surface.
We wanted to localise Philae,
and just a few weeks before the end of the mission
we were able to find it.
In the bottom right of the picture,
you can see Philae stuck in that rift,
from where it accomplished all its scientific tasks.
Rosetta continued its mission
for two more years around the comet,
collecting a huge amount of spectacular scientific data.
Some incredible pictures.
Once at the end of its mission, it has been decided to let Rosetta
land on the comet too.
These are the latest pictures of the comet from Rosetta,
slowly descending to the surface.
We have collected scientific data until the last moment.
And so, you can see the shadow getting closer,
until we get to the contact.
All instruments have been switched off, Rosetta won’t send any signal any more.
It is a moment in which we should have cried our joy,
but I confess that most people at the control center
had a sort of lump in their throat.
After all these years,
seeing the signal going down and becoming flat
was a really strong emotion.
And this brings me
to the second fundamental point of my speech,
and I wanted to point out that
no individual nation has sent Rosetta to the comet,
neither France, nor Italy, nor Spain.
It has been a cooperation between all these nations
that created the system that did that.
ESA, the European Space Agency, brings together 22 member states,
and through the joint effort,
as well as through the best personalities in space science and engineering,
succeeded in this great mission.
Think about that:
only a few decades ago, in the middle of Europe,
French, German, Italian, English people
killed each other by the millions.
I believe that change is beautiful.
Today the same people collaborate
on ambitious and marvelous common space projects.
Two things, the human factor and the cooperation,
in my opinion,
are what you should take away from this presentation.
And to better stick them into your heads,
I have a very personal example that sums up these two things.
This is the garden of our house.
My wife is Spanish, I’m Italian and our children were born in Germany,
So they have three nationalities,
and fluently speak three languages; Italian, Spanish, and German.
When people ask them:
“Do you feel more Italian, or Spanish…”
They just shrug their shoulders and say, boh! [“Whatever”, in Italian]
They speak all three languages as their mothertongues.
Even I, after 20 years in Germany,
can’t say I feel 100% Italian.
And yet, I’ll never feel 100% German.
So, I have the great opportunity to say that “I’m European!”.
For me, this is just marvelous.
I wish my children, and yours,
to have the chance to live, work, and learn
in a Europe where all nations understand,
and keep taking advantage of their diversities,
to create something exceptional and incredible
as the Rosetta mission,
because I really believe that we all need
this kind of cooperation.
Thanks.
(Applause)
Please follow and like us: