Press "Enter" to skip to content

Bipartisanship and Pluralism in Times of Heightened Polarization | Nicole Fintel | TEDxYouth@Lincoln


recently I required a new nickname miss
Constitution it’s not the most
conventional nickname but it has gained
popularity among my friends and even a
few of my teachers so you may be
wondering how does somebody acquire a
nickname such as in this constitution
well I can’t quite pinpoint the origin
but I do have some theories perhaps it
was given to me because I once seriously
tried to memorize the entire document it
could have been the time I ranted about
the Constitution on c-span or maybe it
was because I quoted it on every single
AP US history test last year multiple
times personally I like to attribute it
to the time I saw the original
Constitution at the National Archives
and quite literally cried
needless to say I’m quite a fan of our
governing document the ratification of
the Constitution in 1788 signaled unity
and a willingness to compromise
throughout the 13 colonies after years
of relentless debate this however was
not the first step toward unity in 1782
six years prior to the ratification of
the Constitution our nation’s motto e
pluribus unum Latin four out of many one
was adopted in one of the most
contentious times in our nation’s
history
when the very fabric of our new
democracy was vehemently debated and
disagreed upon the concept of a pluribus
unum overshadowed political animosity
and endured as the unconscious base upon
which our new nation needed to be built
in order to prosper America would need
to be comprised of people with unique
and diverse perspectives backgrounds and
viewpoints however in recent years we’ve
begun to stray from that original
message through a dangerous combination
of hyper-partisanship culture of
confirmation bias and disdain for
discussion we begun to lose sight of an
imperative pillar of American democracy
as a people as a nation as citizens and
as politicians we must be willing to
discuss opposing viewpoints we must
teach under
and and embrace the concept of a
pluribus unum and work to create a
climate of pluralism in both our
legislative bodies and in our daily
lives as private citizens the desire for
a pluralistic society was revered by the
likes of George Washington and James
Madison central to the founding of our
government was the idea that we will
either rise united or fall divided but
if you felt like in recent years our
political climate has become more
divided you’re not imagining it a 2017
study found that the rate of party line
voting in Congress has steadily risen
from around 60% in the 1970s to nearly
90% today
objectively our politics have become
more partisan but why does this matter
though it’s still early to understand
the long-term consequences another
startling congressional trend has
followed the same timeline during the
93rd Congress which was in session from
1973 to 1974 over 26,000 pieces of
legislation were enacted or introduced
to Congress however during the 114th
Congress spanning from 2015 to 2017 that
number fell to just above 12,000 pieces
of legislation simply put we’re placing
partisanship above progress
unfortunately the effects of party line
voting are not left on the Congress
floor on a civilian level we have seen a
stark increase in hyper partisanship and
a culture where obsequious ly siding
with one political party has become the
norm this can be largely attributed to
citizens surrounding themselves only
with people ideas and new sources that
do nothing beyond reaffirm what they
already believe we are too quick to seek
out information and perspectives that
are exactly like our own and disregard
anything that might challenge our
thinking effectively resulting in a
state of partisan gridlock in order to
move forward we must better we must
learn to better communicate with one
another
as cliche as it may sound a simple
remedy to gridlock partisanship is
engagement in conversation with those
with whom we disagree in the end we all
do want the same things safer schools
better health care a stronger economy
but due to variance and things like
environment culture and upbringing
different people are led down different
paths
however these paths should lead toward
converging solutions too often we
mistakenly believe these dichotomies
arise from malice what in actuality
they’re indicative of the strength of
our democracy we’ve begun to take
bipartisanship and civil discourse these
really great and important things and
equate them with dignifying what we
believe to be irreconcilably evil it’s
become all too easy to fall into a
vicious feedback loop of lack of
understanding lack of discussion lack of
progress and ultimately rendering those
on the other side of the aisle as
somehow having less humanity than us I
discovered first hand the importance of
effective discourse last March when I
served as a delegate to the United
States Senate youth program a program
that brings together two high school
students from every state to DC for a
week to speak with some of the most
influential people in our federal
government early in the week five other
delegates and I sat together at lunch
and initiated a candid discussion on a
hotly debated issue we all came from
very different states and very different
backgrounds but took the time to
actually listen and consider each
person’s perspectives so we talked for
about 30 minutes and halfway through our
discussion a delegate from Idaho stopped
us and asked so what are your guys’s
political beliefs because it seems like
for the most part we all want the same
things and kind of agree it turned out
three were Democrats and three
Republicans so what can we take from
this if six high schoolers with vastly
different political views are able to
listen learn from one another’s
experiences and understand that none of
us have a monopoly on wisdom why isn’t
Congress doing the same we need to quit
treating political opponents as enemies
and rather recognize
we are all co-authoring the story of
America in order to understand the
extent to which opposing viewpoints and
if constructive debate are necessary for
democracy let’s take a stroll back to
the year 1780 eight our new nation was
split between two prominent political
factions the Federalists and the
anti-federalists the Federalists wanted
to ratify the Constitution without a
bill of rights as they believed listing
rights was a way of limiting rights on
the other hand the anti-federalists
opposed the ratification of the
Constitution as they believed without a
bill of rights it would be far too easy
for our federal government to shift back
into a monarchy though the history books
tend to paint the Federalists in a more
favorable light without the
anti-federalist opposition and a
willingness of both sides to compromise
we would not have the Constitution and
Bill of Rights duo that we so highly
value today now imagine if the two sides
had treated each other as enemies and
refused to debate and compromise imagine
if they hadn’t taken the time to
actually listen to you and understand
each other’s ideas and perspectives
where would our country be today now I’m
not here to tell you the solution as
easy as this issue is far more complex
than any ten minute speech but there are
all things we can do to improve the
level of political discourse in this
country to start we must redefine
winning we go into political debates
with the intent to win to ensure our own
ideals and interests come out on top
though this mindset is great in soccer
and chess tournaments it translates
horribly to politics and public service
when it comes to governing winning
should not be about convincing everyone
to agree with you through any and all
means necessary
winning should be about working with
public servants on all sides of the
aisle to craft the most robust
legislation to help the most people now
before I go any further I want to make
it abundantly clear that I’m not asking
anybody to abandon their own political
beliefs for the sake of getting along
with
one I have my own political views and
they’re very important to me but I’m
challenging all of you to take the time
to talk to somebody that you think you
strongly disagree with and you’ll
probably be surprised by how much you
actually agree but before we get to that
point we have to stop treating those on
the other side of the aisle as enemies
nobody has ever altered their political
beliefs or even considered the other
side after being attacked insulted or
humiliated we need to we need to
remember that we are all co-creating a
better country rather than trying to
tear each other apart more division
won’t heal our wounds and all admit
keeping ourselves closed off from the
other party’s views and values is much
easier than opening ourselves up but I’m
willing to do it and I hope you are too
because upholding democracy is not easy
it was never meant to be easy but it is
always worth the challenges it presents
throughout the course of human history
very few democratic societies have
existed and fewer have lasted the
success and longevity of America’s
democracy is by no means an accident or
a fluke unique to the founding of our
country was the unanimous support from
citizens of every political background
of the concept of a pluribus unum and
the steadfast recognition of the
vitality of pluralism in maintaining a
free society as arguably one of the most
important pillars of democracy if we
once again subscribe to the idea of a
pluribus unum our nation has and will continue to survive trying times
Please follow and like us: