Press "Enter" to skip to content

You should also consider… | Joe Panepinto | TEDxHamiltonCollege


I’m going to start out with a little

story that I hope that you’re going to

recognize some of your own experiences

in so we recently bought a new house and

being a do-it-yourselfer went through

the house and realize there are some

things that we want to change in one of

the first things we want to change is

want to replace some of the carpeting

with hardwood floors so I turn for

advice where we all turn for advice

these days I checked with Google alright

so I went to Google looked into hardwood

flooring then I started poking around

look for some inspiration on this old

house and went to flip or flop see if I

could get some design ideas went to how

to install hardwood floor on YouTube and

then of course i looked at amazon Lowe’s

Home Depot started looking for some

tools some of the things that I might

need after about an hour decided to take

oil now when it came back I was checking

the news on a squire Washington Post and

mother Jones and this is what I got

targeted ads for flooring from a vendor

that I never searched for and I never

visited now I want you to imagine what

it’s like for someone like me and my

strategy team we do client research on

everything from air sanitizers the

condoms to adult diapers so when more

targeted with ads it can be quite

embarrassing but I’m going to take a few

minutes today to talk a little bit about

how those little ads that follow you

around are emblematic of something it’s

a lot worse than a little embarrassment

those little ads are retargeting you

based on a virtual profile of you being

built by nearly every site you visit

every app you use every email you send

and that’s a profile that you never get

to see and it’s a profile that

increasingly determines everything that

you experience and that you ultimately

see online and that I’ll argue

determines lots

about everything that you believe you

can and maybe can’t become so there’s no

question that we’re at assist an

important historical moment for those of

us obsessed with the process of

communication when an outgoing president

in his farewell address talks about the

profound impact of living in our own

little communication bubbles you know

that it’s part of the cultural agenda

but while Obama focused on the choices

that we make to live in our own

homogenous filter bubbles and echo

chambers I want to direct our attention

for the next 10 minutes or so on the

choices that we don’t make the choices

that are made on our behalf by

algorithms bots that target us with the

kind of information that they assume

that we’re going to like okay so why

even bother talking about this today

well it’s not a new topic actually the

relationship between our online lives

and our offline lives has been a concern

for a very long time you go all the way

back to nineteen ninety six in Wired

magazine when sherry turkle said without

a deep understanding of the many selves

that we express in the virtual we can’t

use our experiences there to enrich the

real so as you can probably already tell

I’ve been fascinated by this old digital

communication thing for a very very long

time and in the early 90s a dope head

first into the emerging world of online

services some of the professors in the

crowd will recognize some of the logos

none of the students will recognize many

Delphi forums copy sir e world Apple’s

own online world prodigy Juno genie in

America Online all of these were online

options in the early 1990s that predate

the popularity of the graphical open

world wide web right around the time

right around that time I joined a

start-up and became an editor and a

columnist with the magazine launched by

disney and ziff-davis that ultimately

had a million readers a month and it was

called family PC our mission at the time

to explore the newly discovered consumer

appeal of computer technologies in the

burgeoning world of online services and

yes as you can see from some of the

covers we were writing about wired teens

and how online services are impacting

your life in the early in mid 1990s from

there I’ve continued studying in

participating in the emerging in

evolving digital revolution eventually

earning a PhD in communication with a

concentration on the social impact of

new communication technologies and like

a good hamilton college grad can’t help

but see the world in terms of

communication in the process of

storytelling some of you are going to

recognize what that’s from I’m a true

believer in the idea that our entire

cultural world is socially constructed

with communication and stories is a

primary driver of what we experience

what we expect and ultimately what we

become process of communication may not

tell us exactly what to think but

there’s plenty of evidence that tells us

it impacts what we should be thinking

about by setting the agenda cultivating

our outlook on the world and

coordinating meaning meaning between

each other meaning between groups our

own process of self actualization

becoming the people we are to become is

in large measure a process of

communication and storytelling as well

in a very real sense to me we are the

stories that we tell ourselves so we

quite literally speak ourselves into

being we tell ourselves all the time

people like me do this people like me

where this people like me say this and

then we act and dress and speak

accordingly so it’s incredibly

interesting to live in a time where so

many algorithms are being developed in

so much artificial intelligence and

brain powers focused on telling each and

every one of us a single pervading thing

no matter where we go online you may

also like in the ten hours and 39

minutes a day that America spend with

their various screens we’re

constantly being served without any

effort of our own what people like us by

what they read what they share I mean

what you know what can be wrong with

that I remember the excitement of the

early internet that came across this

monochrome 9 inch screen on a Mac plus

brick there was a there was a whole

bunch of them that I remember back in

1985 it the first mac lab was in the

basement of the of the library and so

much access is so many things an idea is

that you didn’t have access to before

and that was a promise of the early

internet in online services to give us

more access more choice more insight

into a wider range of ideas and stories

and cultures and as we grew more and

more custom to getting us to getting our

information from the web we wondered why

doesn’t why doesn’t it know me better

why is it why isn’t it filtering things

out for me why isn’t just highlighting

for me the things that I like so when

Amazon gave us the pervasive you may

also like feature or people who bought

this item also bought it was like the

gods had given us a wonderful

personalized gift recommendations and

suggestions about what others just like

us bought in other tech giants have had

followed suit in the year since then

most notably most notably news sites and

social sites that we increasingly rely

on for all of our daily information they

built their own recommendation engines

that help to show us not just what

people like us by but what people like

us read and what they share and what

they think and who they date so I pulled

this down directly off of a website that

does online matching online dating

there’s any problems with with this I

mean look at Paul and John and Dan and

Mark and John and look at Emily and

Cassie Patricia Suzanne Isabel Sofia

paid ad soon followed this is a chart of

all the technologies dozens and dozens

of programmatic buying services buying

services that marketers like me are able

to use so that we can buy audience is

based on those secret profiles and these

have all cropped up and they’re all

building their own little secret profile

of you so that I can target you with a

message all that targeting all that

channeling all that sameness it’s not

helping anyone of us to become an

individual or discover something new

it’s just mainstreaming us into a narrow

set of stories so I want you to imagine

with me for a second what it would be

like that instead of a screen invisibly

filtering what we read in here for 10

hours and 39 minutes a day that it’s a

person standing next to you or me or a

teenager or a preteen and saying to them

hey this is what people like us by this

is what people like us where is what

people like us say and as I mentioned

briefly much has been made about the

filter bubbles and echo chambers that we

all live in online and that has had so

much impact this past election in that

has contributed so much to the growing

polarization of the country a growing

consensus among communication scholars

is that we liberals and conservatives

alike are much more likely to have our

prior biases and prejudices and

worldview reinforced online rather than

to have it challenged and so by giving

us such tailored access the stories

about people like me preferred by people

like us shared by people like us and

light by people like us it’s narrowed

our focus it made it more difficult to

go against the grain and remember to a

communication obsessed person like me

stories aren’t simply an interesting way

of conveying information or conveying

meaning

are passing the time their constitutive

of who we are if we never find or have

access to stories that go against the

grain our well-established grain and our

habits of mind how are we ever going to

live lives that do the way I see it the

fewer stories we have access to the

fewer possibilities we have for the

lives we believe we can live and the

people we tell ourselves we quite

literally tell ourselves we can become

so I have a modest proposal for all the

algorithm writers and the news and

shopping sites that employ them to

create features helping you to discover

things like you might also like take

those recommendation algorithms right

don’t have to change the technology flip

them and change you might also like to

you should also consider or more

pointedly you might not like but you

should read anyways now what would such

a feature do it would introduce you to

the kinds of things people like that the

people like you rarely even consider or

what people who are not like you read

and buy and we’re in say it would

fulfill the early promise of the

internet to broaden our points of

reference by exposing us to the widest

range of stories the world has to offer

stories that we can individually use to

create new stories individual stories

unconventional stories original stories

and through those stories see new

unconventional in original possibilities

for creating a unique life story for

ourselves one that we can own and

possibly more possibly cut against the grain

Please follow and like us: