Press "Enter" to skip to content

Wizards, Wolves and Women in the Great Game of Global Development | Audrey Selian | TEDxYerevanSalon


so the year after I started my graduate

studies at the Fletcher School a film

came out called the Lord of the Rings

waistband on the book by talking and I

went to see this film with a close

friend of mine and it started a bit of a

running silly joke after that every time

I would try to say anything with any

amount of gravitas or intelligence my

friend would call me Gandalf the wise

old wizard – the beard of course and I

would call her Frodo the child hero and

the Explorer and I got to thinking about

the role that Gandalf the wizard plays

as an archetype that sort of guides and

governs the kind of perception that

people have of a development sector

ganda and archetypes I thought would be

a useful tool and that these are things

that we essentially all understand

intuitively from Carl Jung’s collective

unconscious and I thought that this

archetype actually fits in almost

subliminally with the development world

the wise old man is mythic he’s

all-knowing he’s a source of guidance

the sage the son acts of ancient Rome in

some ways this archetype manifests in

the form of well branded institutions

banners that we all recognize experts

that are innovating and creating the

best silver bullets creating the

solutions that will chart the course of

human progress for the bottom billions

at the base of the pyramid and by the

way I think the the presence of a long

silvery beard as well probably helps

with you know the credibility at the

project tables I’ve often been told the

next archetype that I’ll mention is the

alpha male

the alpha male often manifests as sort

of an investment banker the wolf of Wall

Street a world leader in some cases I

might shift the image to something a

little easier on the eyes the the alpha

male is the fittest survivor the

ultimate destination of the alpha males

behavior is power and essentially this

archetype is one that has traits that we

all also recognize there’s a certain

amount of arrogance domination

aggressiveness it’s all about classic

zero-sum for the alpha male and in some

sense this manifests in nature in fact I

heard a story that recently

a troop of chimpanzees that brutally

deposed a former alpha leader that had

dominated them in years past and when

the Alpha tried to reenter their

community the younger male monkeys not

only remembered him but they tortured

him before they killed him and they had

to put a viewer discretion on the video

so I mean before I continue down the

very slippery slope of being a woman

talking about alpha males I should

probably make an admission I am a

graduate of a women’s college called

Wellesley which is sort of a bastion of

American feminism but I’m not here to

mail bash in fact some of the most

interesting examples of cooperation have

emerged from patriarchal communities and

with a colleague of mine we were

actually trying to implement an impact

investing network in the context of

Atlantic Canada and I picked up a book

that was written by Daniel Paul called

we were not the savages explaining the

experience of the Aboriginal indigenous

communities of the McMansion in Atlantic

Canada and what was so interesting was

that this community achieved and lived

with a value system that was

fundamentally sustainable collaborative

and harmonious they were able to harness

the better sides of the competitive size

of human nature while still retaining a

deep spirituality and a deep respect for

other living things in fact their

civility far out shadowed that of those

who tried to strip them of their lands

and destroy their culture and there’s

basically in nature I think a natural

response to being subjugated by a

dominant as we saw in the case of the

monkeys there is no magical vacuum into

which repression and injustice just

magically disappear and similarly social

justice sensibilities don’t emerge from

a vacuum either we’re all part of a

functioning system and in some sense I

think this is why a capitalist system

that functions on the basis of alpha

male survival of the fittest behavior is

inevitably going to result in some sort

of violence or inequality unless we find

ways to better harness the better sides

of this archetype now unsurprisingly the

next archetype I’ll refer to is the

Divine Feminine and again I’m not

talking here

men or women I’m talking about what we

typically understand to be the role the

female gender role and its ability to

establish sort of a dynamic of

collaboration the likelihood of

empowering marginalized voices achieving

win-win outcomes and better managing

risk in investment portfolios is one

that’s well proven by those who are

intentionally more collaborative and I

think that if we shift for a moment to

sort of the the collaboration models

will find that the behavior of this this

archetype is something that will govern

what we see ahead I think that there’s a

fundamental shift and I saw this

delightful image in the news a couple of

weeks ago some of you may have seen it

set up on International Women’s Day by a

hedge fund manager that I thought

captured sort of the clash of the

archetypes brilliantly this little girl

defiant standing in the face of the

representation of the capitalist system

so there’s a purple elephant in the room

and it took a lot of self-restraint not

to put an image of a purple elephant

behind me the purple elephant in the

room is that the wise old wizard of

development is challenged not because

his knowledge is not brilliant but

perhaps because of how it’s imparted and

maybe a little bit because of how its

funded now it’s not news that the

development arena and international

institutions are not known to be the

most agile and transparent we know that

there’s a certain level of bureaucratic

heaviness that comes with a lot of these

institutions and in fact there’s a body

of literature one of the first books I

read was the Lords of poverty given to

me by my officemate when I was at the

ITU at the United Nations describing

some of the miscalculations and the

problems sort of inherent to how the the

arena works and so examples like UN aids

administer aids programs administered

with you know condoms staple –

information brochures or energy

solutions in a box deployed to villages

or play pumps to draw water from the

ground without thinking about how things

need to be transferred for local

ownership without thinking about

maintenance

and certainly the issue of fiefdom

parallel events that take place within

the umbrella of a single organization or

even parallel platforms within a single

organization all trying to solve the

same problem and sort of leveraging the

intelligence of different teams that

don’t actually talk to each other so in

some sense this is kind of a well-known

narrative covering in lots and lots of

books of course there are I guess

moments sort of examples of light in

Gandalf Stan as well we have the United

Nations principles for responsible

investment now with some of the

governance issues that they’ve had that

have been worked out over time this has

been an incredible large success in the

sense that they’ve been able to gather

over 1600 signatories the world’s

largest institutional investors signing

on to an agreement about certain

principles and really who else could

have pulled that off that was set off by

former UN Secretary General Kofi Annan

we also have sort of examples of

organizations like the World Bank and

going back to the aid organizations and

just global aid for a moment apparently

about 2.3 trillion dollars has moved

from the global north to the global

south and it’s important to note that

you know this this money runs through

institutions and organizations and

departments and divisions and it also

fundamentally runs through you and

through me all of us who are personally

complicit in the development arena now

apparently to in order to reach the

sustainable development goals in 2030

another 2.5 trillion dollars needs to be

spent that’s an estimate that I read so

if we think for a moment not just about

the cost of capital but about the

transaction costs of getting that to

where it should be I think it’s

interesting I mentioned for a moment

because we’re here in Armenia I had a

chance to do my PhD research here in

Armenia in 2004 and I was researching

the role of information and

communication technologies and political

development and it was an amazing place

to do research in some ways because it’s

a it’s an excellent development

laboratory it’s a small country at some

ingenious and everybody everybody’s

about one degree of separation away

Armenia receives about three billion

dollars in overseas development

assistance and I did a bit of back of

the envelope and honest analysis and I

was figuring out that so for every $1 of

Oda that comes into

the country about $3 comes into this

country in the form of romances as

compared to just under $2 in the case of

other low or middle income countries for

every $1 of Oda

we see about $1 of FDI foreign direct

investment coming to this country which

as compared to a little over $3 for

other lower middle income countries and

there are stories in every one of these

comparisons for every $1 of Oda and this

is a major lowball figure just because I

tried to calculate it on the back of the

philanthropist that I know of but at

least 25 to 50 cents on the dollar comes

in in the form of philanthropy from the

Diaspora so for every $1 of Oda coming

into Armenia at least four more dollars

is coming into this country in the form

of external capital in real terms that

amounts to about 36 billion dollars

since independence that’s not even

counting state budgets so and that’s

also in light of a population that has

decreased a little bit over the years as

people have thought economic

opportunities abroad and is stabilized

and it’s stabilized now around I think

about three million people so the net

result is that one in three Armenians

today apparently live under the poverty

line with all of that money coming in so

either what’s happening is that the

capital flowing in is slipping through

the margins slipping through the cracks

and not reaching its intended purposes

and or there is a massive what I’ll call

a collaboration margin for every $1 of

Oda that’s coming into this country

that’s remaining underutilized or under

leveraged in some way I think that’s the

opportunity that we address today when I

was doing my research I found evidence

of what one of my favorite authors

called William easterly talks about as

the technocratic approach to development

the conventional development paradigm

the idea that poverty is essentially a

technical problem for which we require

technical solutions antibiotics pumps or

in my case when I was researching them

websites and fiber optic cables easterly

also talks about in his book the tyranny

of experts the idea that the real cause

of poverty is actually the unchecked

power of the state against its people

who have no voice no rights and no

feedback loop and I’ll come back to that

feedback loop in a moment

essentially when I was looking at some

of the ministries and agencies that were

admitting that we’re administering and

using technology to deliver services

citizens I discovered that there was not

a lot of coordination amongst donors who

were trying to address these projects in

fact with the help of those that you

know I interviewed we discovered that

there were at that time and I’m sure

this is a much improved margin now but

there were a hundred and six projects in

parallel all utilizing ICTs for public

sector reform at that time and a lot of

these projects were basically ending as

soon as the money ran out in the case of

most of these donors basically they come

in again in easterly’s terminology as

planners they have top-down sort of

perspectives they have tick boxes in

jargon they already have in mind and the

searchers are essentially those who

would come in co-create sort of listen

to the market and come in with no plan

so there’s sort of two or two different

perspectives – to the development sort

of task searchers if they are good at

what they do we’ll also leverage the

passions of a diaspora and I’ll take a

liberty to talk about a diaspora because

I consider myself as part of one here in

Armenia and as most of the aspera to

date I mean historically have not been

the best searchers now this has changed

in the last maybe ten years and actually

where we’re standing today is a perfect

example of the new innovative approaches

that are being taken that are much more

sort of search oriented most planner

type approaches taken by diasporas have

often treated symptoms as opposed to

thinking about sort of addressing

underlying political economic illnesses

now what does an investment approach to

development mean there’s no debate that

competition and business acumen and sort

of the rigor of a business lens are a

good thing of course they are the thing

is my 10 million dollars in the foremost

of a silver bullet or another person’s

50 million dollars in the former’s –

over Silver Bullet are not going to

achieve their goals

they’re not actually coordinated

especially if we’re out to try to you

know solve a major development problem

in terms of the debate around the

approach of investors I think there are

certain characteristics to sort of the

the business lens there’s a sort of an

art it comes back to the archetype of

the wolf of wallstreet flag-waving

territoriality brandishing tools and

weapons the sort of traditional alpha

investor will basically shrug his

shoulders and sort of talks you know

talk to an impact investor and say you

know in the traditional financial

markets in the real world in terms of

how things work we don’t share diligence

we don’t share information about

pipelines we don’t share information

about our portfolios because that’s just

not how it’s done and I would argue and

I and I don’t suggest for a moment that

we should be sharing information

indiscriminately holding hands around a

campfire singing songs I actually think

that we have to bear in mind that the

ability of our solutions that we’re

investing in to scale our function of

our network the ability of our solutions

it’s a benefit from liquidity are a

function of our network and to that

extent I think that type of

collaborative approach is useful in

capitalism 2.0 or in what we’re talking

about is post capitalism what’s

interesting I think there’s this big

debate about the trade-offs of impact

investment and I think what Spurs that

is that there’s kind of a clashing of

the archetypes and certainly the impact

investors are using sort of the tools

from the traditional financial arena and

the tools and the tools of the

development arena but the thing is

what’s the net result if the venture

capitalists beat the development wizards

at their own game

the evidence base for impact investing

is grown there’s not a lot of question

there’s a lot of different sort of

foundations clubs and traditional

consulting organizations that are

providing ample evidence of the

performance of impact portfolios when

companies are able to embed impact into

the DNA of companies they outperform

market benchmarks so that’s not new

all Olson is a social monster Olson was

a social scientist and an economist who

basically talked about the logic that

drives this he talked about enlightened

self-interest and the logic of

collective action

it turns out that this logic holds and

there’s been recent experiments to prove

this when there are cases of social

transparency on the contributions of

people to those public goods so what

that means to me is that today in a

Twitter meets blockchain world where

everything that we do can be tracked

where our respective contributions are

visible we can actually establish the

fabric of cooperation for better

outcomes technology is a key driver for

some of the best nonzero-sum

interactions out there and that includes

things like surfing the World Wide Web

flying in airplanes you know raising

crowd campaigns and that kind of thing I

would argue that this technology is

actually a key to an sort of reinventing

the fabric of human trust we set up the

artha platform the artha platform is

actually a tool that we set up to enable

sharing of deal flow on a systematic

basis and also to enable the ability for

people to conduct due diligence with

access to people on the ground so we

don’t actually have to fly a green guy

in from Geneva to go and do a due

diligence if we’re actually able to

leverage the user-generated feedback

loop on people’s profiles if we know

that people trust the service provider

they can actually be brought in to

respond on on a basis that makes sense

this enhances the efficiency of the

impact investor in a given region in

this case of the artha platform

functions in India and we’ve actually

had a great example of the

inter-american Development Bank as a

pioneering development institution that

has decided to adopt and adapt this type

of architecture to be able to allow for

the smaller tickets beyond is sort of

far far sort of to the left of on their

curve of ticket sizes so that everything

below two or three million dollars could

be addressed by those more agile funders

who can actually leverage this type of a

tool to to manage efficiencies what

we’ve discovered over the years after

having built this platform is that

actually there are a number of other

platforms there are a number of other

user

and founders and innovators that have

had the same thought

approximately if this is just off the

top of my head in terms of the peer

networks and improve information

infrastructure that’s been set up

probably 60 to 70 million dollars at a

minimum has been spent on building the

kind of information architecture that

we’re talking about here all of these

are essentially aggregating information

and trying to adopt and adapt sort of an

open architecture approach to creating a

coherent social capital market we have a

long way to go and a lot of the

discussion the connective tissue that

needs to be built I believe actually

will reside and come back to the

leadership of development organizations

I would argue that essentially we have

to adopt sort of the opposite of an

alpha approach to be able to achieve

these types of collaborations we need to

be radically collaborative with one

another to be able to minimize and

manage the costs of getting some of this

capital to where it needs to get there’s

no point in having different

organizations building solutions over

and over and yet we see this every

single day we have the technology to do

better to enable the types of

interactions that will support outcomes

based models and essentially Trust is

not only possible it is the preferable

approach to achieving the kind of STG

outcomes were all aiming for so what

will be the some behavior of our work

here today but what will define the

essence of what you and me and what all

of us are here to achieve will it be the

approach taken by the Wolves of Wall

Street will it be all about the council

of elders or will we actually be open

and resonant to the quantum level

evidence that the winners and losers in

our system today are all one we are all

connected in some ways I think it’s a

perfect time to be rethinking incentives

it’s a perfect time to be rethinking

sort of collaboration margins and it’s

time to sort of make it a taboo to make

people to see people an individual

organization

working alone saw in solving problems

that are not our own so if we’re going

to actually sharp shoot those silver

bullets that we’ve crafted and developed

so carefully into the regions that we

want to get them to I think it’s time

that we start thinking about the

slingshots we’re using and in real and

in reality the the wise wizards of

development the High Priestesses of

collective action and the alpha males

and the wolves have never been better

poised and positioned to collaborate for

the greater good thank you

[Applause] [Music]

Please follow and like us: