Press "Enter" to skip to content

Why we need to offer group trauma treatments to (ordinary) males | Ilana Berman | TEDxDicksonStreet


[Music]
in order to convince you that grip
trauma treatments is important and
effective for men ordinary men more than
just veterans I wanted to tell you a
story about a man who sought through
treatment to deal with symptoms of
unprocessed trauma and got better as a
result but I don’t have that story not
because group treatment is effective but
because men aren’t signing up for it or
even acknowledging their struggle
nowadays everyone talks about male
privilege and the advantages given to
men in a lot of areas of our society but
when it comes to mental health men are
in a striking disadvantage to receive
mental health services and even talk
about their struggles in men substance
use disorders are three times more
common and men account for it means 75%
of people who conceive suicide but
they’re half as likely to seek mental
health services as a disclaimer this
talk generally refers to gender as a
binary concept I recognize that it isn’t
however research on transgender gender
queer and non-conforming individuals is
in its infancy there are important and
distinct mental health needs for those
populations but that’s not the focus of
today’s talk also it might seem strange
that I a white woman and talking to you
today about treatment for men so allow
me to introduce myself
my name is Alana Berman and for the last
nine years I’ve been doing trauma
related work in a variety of settings
I’m passionate about working with trauma
survivors because I don’t think it’s
fair that people have to suffer with
everyday living just because something
bad happened to them and as a
fourth-year student in a ph.d program
for clinical psychology I know there are
treatments out there so that they can
help reclaim their lives okay so what is
trauma and yes that’s trauma with a TR
not drama in psychology when we talk
about trauma it’s not necessarily
physical or blunt force trauma
it’s an emotional wound historically
prime examples of trauma have included
going to war or having a car crash or
experiencing a rape those can definitely
be traumatic but there’s more
tides are beginning to turn in the
understanding that trauma is subjective
and that means that we each experience
situations differently so you’re the
only one who knows if an incident was
traumatic for you
essentially trauma is an emotional wound
and so it overwhelms us it overwhelms
our body’s capacities our resources in
the moment when our biological instincts
to fight to flight or freeze kick in and
long after the event has passed so
statistically men are more likely to be
exposed to trauma but they’re less
likely to receive help and seek it
really in our recent community
recruitment for trauma treatment groups
at the psychological clinic on campus we
actually received zero inquiries from
men okay so if men are saying they’re
not affected by trauma they’re fine
they’re over it we should just believe
them and let them get on with their
lives right well not so fast in my
experience as supported by research a
lot of men have not only experienced but
been affected by these traumatic events
and so given these experiences we’d like
to help them right and so this doesn’t
turn into a traumatic event for me I’m
gonna reference my notecards a lot of
men are hesitant to identify these
traumas as traumas they just consider
these events as part of life life with
bad luck nevertheless natural disasters
happen people die parents aren’t as
supportive as we’d hoped and so you
don’t have to identify these events as a
trauma in order to be traumatized you
might not even recognize the aftermath
of trauma even if you’re experiencing it
but sometimes other people notice the
signs we’ve all seen the symptoms
whether we notice it in someone we love
or maybe even ourself but maybe we
haven’t exactly had the label for it so
some of these symptoms come up pretty
often actually we can see the symptoms
and sometimes we notice a facial
reaction a wince or a far-off look as
someone is experiencing a flashback
feeling like they’re reliving that event
sometimes these flashbacks come in the
form of nightmares
making it difficult to fall asleep or
staying asleep making us tired from
restless nights sometimes we see someone
who’s jumpy or always on edge we all
know someone who’s too scared to sit
with their back to the door at a
restaurant and then sometimes in men
we might even view that as an honorable
or protective act when really it can be
a sign of trauma sometimes this hyper
vigilance comes in the form of being the
fear of being abandoned so maybe we
cling a little too tight or don’t get
too close to anybody in the first place
for fear that everyone will eventually
hurt us or leave us anyway and so there
are ways that trauma can change the way
that we look at the world the way we
look at ourselves and others sometimes
these symptoms come and we’re alone
without anyone there to witness maybe
it’s that nagging feeling that we could
have saved our friend or when we make a
mistake at work we hear our mothers
voice telling us how useless we are
trauma really can change everything and
so we’ve got to do something about that
right because in men trauma can look a
little differently in general men are
more likely to react externally or act
out experience expressing their fear is
in the form of anger or irritability in
America men are more likely to kill and
are responsible for over 90% of all
murders these stresses can also express
themselves in different ways so we can
project the stress onto our
relationships romantic or otherwise have
difficulty connecting or communicating
with others and really just impact the
way that we function so there’s a lot
going on here
the point is men are exhibiting symptoms
of trauma without realizing that their
symptoms of trauma symptoms are really
hiding in plain sight and so we know
that everyone is affected everyone can
be affected
additionally alcohol and drugs can be a
common outcome of experiencing trauma we
sometimes don’t turn to substances as a
form of avoidance a coping mechanism so
yes
avoidance to make things worse as humans
we have this tendency to avoid we don’t
want to
talk about things we don’t even want to
think about them and sometimes that can
work great for us for a little bit right
but some then we experience these we
want to avoid the anxiety so we exit the
situation when we’re faced with a
trigger like authority figures or the
scent of Cologne that are abusive father
war or maybe the white car like the one
from the accident so that strategy works
for a bit but it fails this overtime it
actually makes things worse for us those
thoughts come into our mind more often
and we it seems even more unmanageable
so furthermore there’s a study called
the adverse childhood experiences and of
these 10 types of traumas studies have
shown that the more types of trauma
experienced the more severe the symptoms
are in fact individuals who’ve
experienced at least four of these types
of traumas are way more likely to
experience mental and physical problems
like stroke heart disease and even die
up to twenty years sooner so we know
that not addressing the underlying
trauma that is fueling these symptoms
can be a big problem the good news is we
have treatments and a lot of evidence
that they work one of these treatments
is a group trauma treatment that uses
exposure to the thoughts and the
memories of the trauma by telling your
story in a specific way and cognitive
processing which is learning to
understand to be aware of how you form
these beliefs and challenge the
unhelpful ones like maybe no one can be
trusted ever and learning some more
helpful coping patterns and ways of
thinking so taking these things together
we’re teaching people that not to avoid
the trauma but to actually approach it
because yes these things are absolutely
uncomfortable to talk about but they’re
not dangerous and doing so we can learn
a way to get through those emotions that
come up and lead more successful lives
without these symptoms interfering so
experience going through these trauma
treatment can certainly be done in an
individual setting especially because
it’s just you and the therapist that
would know what’s going on right but it
can actually be even more useful to
provide this in a group setting
the additional benefits like support and
validation can come not just from a paid
therapist but also your peers people
often fear reactions that they get from
others that they might have actually
received before when talking about
trauma you’ve got shame blame social
rejection invalidation all of that is
terrible trauma can make us feel
isolated and alone and so when we come
together in a group it’s different so
now imagine experiencing the exact
opposite of everything you’ve feared in
this safe confidential and
non-judgmental environment participants
have the opportunity to learn that
they’re not alone other people have gone
through similar things and so they can
support each other because they’re all
in their own stage in a journey of
recovery to getting better they can
provide that encouragement that support
that compassion and really work together
learning new strategies of how to move
forward okay so it sounds pretty great
right so why aren’t men signing up for
group treatment
well stigma has former NFL player Joe
ermine once said the three most
destructive words that every boy hear
that every man hears when he’s a boy is
when he’s told to be a man societally
and culturally men are raised to think
that emotions are a signs of weakness
and vulnerability they’re told to be
strong and tough and picked themselves
up by their bootstraps and so that’s
really hard to do and kind of sets us up
for failure and they’re also taught that
other men don’t have these emotional
experiences it’s not like we see a lot
of examples in mainstream media of men
discussing their mental health problems
most male characters I can think of that
even discuss mental health are portrayed
as gay or socially rejected even women
are featured in the advertisements for
depression commercials or seen in films
reaching out for support these
stereotyped and gendered portrayals only
further instigate the reluctance of men
to seek help
so expressing and experiencing these
emotions is somehow even is counter to
the concept of masculinity but emotions
are important they give us information
they communicate with other
and they help us process the world
around us so we kind of need those as
children boys and girls begin equally
emotional and expressive but even well
intending adults start to interpret
behavior through gendered lenses even as
young as infants adults will interpret
behavior the same facial response and as
fear if they’re told the infant is a
girl and anger if they’re told the
infant is a boy so by the age of three
to five years old boys are actually
starting to show signs of hiding their
emotions three to five years old so take
this history this culture and combine
that with this tendency to avoid and now
it makes sense why men aren’t eager to
sign up for group treatment talk about
their past experiences and current
difficulties with the group of other men
I get it it’s tough so let me illustrate
this point for you with two examples of
people I’ve met in real life in
recruiting for trauma treatment groups
in the community so in the first session
of a trauma treatment group at a local
women’s prison I met a woman at the
first session who said well you know I
had this trauma
well she had actually heard the
recruitment story several times before
she even got to sit in that room she
said I was hesitant to sign up and I
still don’t know if this group is right
for me and she said she experienced
something bad and she was younger but it
was so long ago that you know she
doesn’t think it affects her anymore
and she was quiet for the first few
weeks as other people expressed their
symptoms of having difficulty trusting
people and sort of missing out on
opportunities because they were too
scared they had this anxiety but
eventually she started to share too and
it was affecting her by these intrusive
nightmares and she was having
promiscuous sex and discussed that she
actually had started using drugs to numb
out those feelings – so these symptoms
were really intruding in her life she
didn’t want to give up recreation time
to come and be there and talk about that
but she shared her story of child sexual
abuse in that fourth session of group by
the end of the eight-week treatment this
woman had reported decrease in
of PTSD anxiety and depression and all
of these gains were maintained at least
three months after treatment when we
followed up so it was the supportiveness
of the encouragement of the prison staff
as well as the supportiveness of the
clinicians that engaged her in treatment
but really it was the examples of the
other women the other women sharing
their stories and encouraging her to
stay so in contrast I met a man at a
local drug court facility when
recruiting in the community there and he
said he had a hard life but he didn’t
experience trauma
I was never raped or anything he said
and so he said some he basically was
like okay you know so this happened to
me when I was young but you know he so
what happened to him is he said his
father used to hit him his siblings and
especially his mom and he said well that
doesn’t really bother me now and you
want me to go to treatment just because
my dad hit me everybody I know has a
story like this why would I do that
besides he was too busy for group with
everything going on with drug court and
he had bills to pay he was working all
the time and he said he was trying to
pay child support for these kids he
didn’t even get to visit and that was
the moment where I saw the sadness in
his eyes so he says he’s over it but his
drug court counselor tells us that he’s
actually missing appointments a lot of
the time he’s getting angry and group
settings and he’s sort of joking about
everything that’s happened to him and
not taking it seriously
which is another form of avoidance so
these symptoms these seemingly normal
behaviors are actually symptoms of
trauma and they’re interfering with his
life at this point but he said no thank
you
he and I respected that autonomy so we
told each other to have a good day and
that was the end of our interaction see
I wanted to tell you a story that was
successful but I don’t have that because
this kept happening man after man sounds
frustrating huh
actually it’s more disappointing to me
in that as you could see these women
were really benefiting from group they
loved the experience they loved
connecting
other women and they really like being
bothered by those symptoms a little bit
less but these men denied themselves
that opportunity they didn’t want to
participate and so we didn’t get a group
going for males at that time so what are
we get to do about that act one place
where we look as an example is the
Department of Veteran Affairs the VA
actually has men engaged in trauma
treatment groups how did they do that
it’s so popular there they sometimes
even have a wait list well it wasn’t an
overnight achievement for them either
it took about 20 years from the time
that they decided to hire a clinical
psychologist to develop and improve
treatments to serve male populations and
then encourage men to sign up and
increase recruitment so what it took
there was this huge culture shift within
the organization from the top down from
the management to staff and permeating
throughout the ranks of veterans that
not only was help available but that
they could utilize it to go to help
recover from what they’ve been through
in their service in order to utilize
those services men had to recognize two
things one they were affected by their
experiences and two treatment could help
they had to be encouraged to do that so
similar to what happened at the VA
society at large could really benefit
from a culture shift this here is my
top-down approach I’m coming to you as a
clinical psychologist in training
talking to you engaged in interested
people about what I’ve seen men
struggling and not realizing that they
don’t have to and that they can still
keep their man card if they ask for help
so what are we supposed to do we’ve got
to figure it out at this point we’ve got
to tackle the barriers and I’m not
saying I’m the first one to do this
don’t get me wrong there have been
attempts from within the field before to
do that for example there’s a website
called man therapy org and it utilizes
the existing stereotypes of strong men
with facial hair and uses colloquial
language like when where he grabs you by
the balls or it’s okay to cry even if
it’s not about sports
that’s a great start right but we need
more and it’s going to take all of us to
make that shift we’re working to create
safe places but they have to be utilized
to be effective we’re changing the
language that we use in recruitment
we’re also trying to increase awareness
in the public of everything that’s gone
on so that we know about the impact of
trauma so here I am today and yet it’s
still going to take a community of
people to support men and help them
realize that some of the difficulties
they’re going through might be an
expected result of what’s happened to
them so let’s do this together let’s
teach children and we’ve got to teach
children and adults to be aware of their
emotions to recognize them and to
respond to them with compassion we
recognize that it’s unfair and you don’t
have to feel this way anymore we’re
ready to reward the strength that it
takes because it takes more strength to
ask for help than it does to suffer
alone so when we’re ready to step up
we’re here for you more help is on the
way when you’re ready to fight for it
thank you
[Applause]
you
Please follow and like us: