Press "Enter" to skip to content

Why we fail and how we stand up afterwards | Katherine Milkman | TEDxPenn


[Music]
[Music]
[Music]
I’m not a doctor and I’m not cut out to
be I’m a data loving social scientist
and I try to solve problems that hit me
hard it turns out that 40% of premature
deaths in the u.s. are the result of
behaviors that can be changed let me
break that down if we could convince
everyone to exercise regularly eat a
healthy diet quit smoking and get
recommended cancer screenings we could
prevent 850,000 unnecessary premature
deaths in the u.s. each year so how do
we do that well that’s what I’m going to
talk about today that’s what I study but
I don’t want this to be a dry research
talk so let’s have a little fun I want
to start out by telling you about an
idea for helping people like Liz Lemon
the lead character on NBC’s former hit
show 30 rock in case you aren’t familiar
with Liz Lemon’s persona let me give you
a quick profile
she’s a 30-something exec who works too
much exercise is too little and is
generally a disaster when it comes to
self-control I’d like to make two
plausible assumptions about Liz first
assume she wishes she exercised more but
lacks the willpower and second assumes
she has a thing for trashy novels but
feels guilty wasting her time reading
junk I’m gonna tell you about an idea
for solving both of Liz’s problems that
I call temptation bundling the idea is
simple what if Liz only allowed herself
to read trashy novels while exercising
at the gym she’d stop wasting time at
home on literary garbage and start
craving trips to the gym to find out
what happens next in her latest thriller
not only that she’d enjoy her novel and
her work out more combined she wouldn’t
feel guilty reading the novel and time
would fly at the gym now as important as
it is to reduce waste of time and
increase exercise temptation bundling
can solve lots of other dual
self-control problems as well for
instance imagine you crave juicy
hamburgers but you’re also watching your
waistline and imagine you also have a
difficult on Tilly who you know you
should spend more time with but you
don’t really want to what if you only
allowed yourself to go to your favorite
burger restaurant with aunt Tilly
you’d eat fewer burgers when you should
be dieting and you’d see more of aunt
Tilly there are a few other examples I
can give you of this for all the men in
the audience
you’ll particularly like this one
imagine only allowing yourself to get a
pedicure while catching up on old work
emails or imagine only allowing yourself
for everyone to listen your favorite
podcast while catching up on household
chores these are all examples of the
ways that temptation bundling can help
but of course a key question is the
slide previews does it work to find out
my collaborators and I ran an experiment
we recruited participants from the
university gym across the street Patrick
Jim who owned iPods and wanted to
exercise more and we randomly assign
them to one of two experimental
conditions partition participants who
are assigned to our temptation bundling
Group were given a loaned iPod preloaded
with for tempting audio novels of their
choice these are books that it’s really
hard to put down once you get hooked
like The Da Vinci The DaVinci Code in
The Hunger Games we invited them to come
to the gym and workout for 30 minutes
while listening to the start of one of
their novels and then we told them if
they wanted to hear what happened next
in their novel they’d have to come back
to the gym where we would be holding
their iPod in a locked monitored Locker
participants in our control group also
completed a 30-minute workout at the
start of our study they also were
encouraged to exercise more but instead
of receiving a loaned iPod we gave him
an equally valued gift certificate to
Barnes & Noble so the question is what
happened well for the first 7 weeks of
our study the temptation bundling group
exercise significantly more than the
control group which was great then Along
Came Thanksgiving break the gym closed
participants went home probably ate a
lot of Turkey apparently forgot about
novels and when they came back the
effect was gone on the one hand this is
neat because it means that wanting to
find out what happens next in your novel
is driving our effects because we know
that forced cravings excuse me that
cravings are best assists suppressed by
for separation but it also means we have
more work to do to make this behavior
change stick alright we had one more
question and that was a question that
Liz Lemon’s profit-hungry boss Jack
Donaghy depicted here would very likely
ask and that was does anyone value
temptation bundling or in other words
would anyone pay for it to find out at
the end of our study we invited
participants to pay us for a new service
we told them we’d be happy to lock their
own iPods containing tempting content at
the gym for a month so they could only
access them when exercising in other
words would people pay us to take away a
possession they could otherwise use as
they please so they could only access it
under strict supervision amazingly more
than 60 percent of participants eagerly
signed up for this program suggesting
there might be a real market for
companies like Netflix let’s call it Jim
flicks that let you set aside certain TV
shows for Jim only access this could be
helpful not only for people’s waste
lines but also for Public Health much
more broadly okay so I’ve told you about
an insight we can use to promote
physical activity and temptation
bundling but I’ve also highlighted that
a key challenge is figuring out how to
change behavior for good I’ve done some
other research on how to create habits
that really stick and to describe that
to you I want to ask you to imagine two
people who both want to exercise more
let’s say Liz Lemon and her eccentric
colleague Jenna imagine that they both
sign up for a month of sessions with a
personal trainer at the gym in the hopes
that after this month both created a
lasting exercise habit
imagine that arbitrarily they end up
with trainers who have different
philosophies gymnast trainer is all
about routinization Jenna’s trainer
asked Jenna when do you prefer to
exercise in Genesis 7 a.m. her trainer
says great we’ll meet at the gym three
times a week at 7:00 a.m. for the next
month and by the end of our sessions you
will have a lasting exercise habit
Liz’s trainer on the other hand thinks
flexibility is key to habit formation
she also asks Liz when she prefers to
work out and Liz says 7:00 a.m. but
Liz’s trainer says we’re gonna meet at
different times on different days three
times a week sometimes 7 a.m. but
sometimes life will get in the way
we’ll be flexible by the end of the
month you will have built a lasting
habit so the key question is this who is
right which person will have a more
lasting habit at the end of the month of
sessions with a personal trainer will it
be routine Jenna or flexible Liz I’ll
let you noodle on that for a minute but
let me tell you about why I thought that
maybe routines would be effective I done
some other research showing that when
people make concrete plans it can help
them with follow-through we studied this
in one context where we are trying to
get people to get flu shots we sent out
different reminder mailings inviting
people to come to a free on-site flu
shot clinic at their workplace and some
mailings were just that a reminder and
others included a simple planning prompt
a prompt to write down the date and time
when you intended to get your flu shot
now note that these were not appointment
cards they’re just a prompt to write
down the date and time the privacy of
your own home but we thought that they
might increase follow-through by getting
people to think concretely about their
plans embedding them more firmly in
memory and associating a time cue with
that call to action we found that they
costlessly increased follow through on
flu shots by four percentage points and
in another study using a very similar
design of reminders with thousands of
patients who were overdue for
colonoscopies we found that we could
costlessly increase colonoscopy follow
through rates significantly with these
planning prompts okay so can we use
these kinds of planning prompts to help
people form lasting habits that’s the
question I posed earlier when we were
thinking about Liz Lemon and her
eccentric colleague Jenna to find out
the answer to this question we ran
another study and this time we ran it at
a fortune 500 company
we recruited 2,500 employees who wanted
to exercise more to join a four-week
program everyone who signed up told us
the two hour workout window when they
prefer to go to the gym and we started
sending them reminders 15 minutes before
the start of that workout window here
comes the science we randomly assigned
these people to one of three
experimental conditions participants in
the first group the control group just
got our reminders that was it
participants in the second group got an
experience that was based on Liz’s
trainers flexible philosophy they were
paid either three or seven dollars for
exercising regardless of when they did
it finally participants in our routine
condition modeled on Jenna’s trainers
philosophy were only paid three or seven
dollars if they exercise at that planned
time that they had told us at the start
of the study so had this worked out well
for the four weeks of the intervention
period we found that the more we paid
people to work out and the easier we
made it to collect payments the more
they exercised but that’s not
interesting what we wanted to know was
if we convinced two people to exercise
about the same amount one always at the
same time and the other at different
times that varied who would form a more
lasting habit after our four-week
intervention and we can see that by
zooming in on two groups in our study
the group that we paid seven dollars to
go to the gym always at the same time
and the group we paid three dollars to
go to the gym whenever they want it when
we look to see who exercised more after
our intervention period we were really
surprised to find it was the flexible
group you might be surprised to and you
might be wondering why is that so were
we so we looked at our data and here’s
what we found it turns out that the
routine folks like Jenna did in fact
form a more robust habit around
exercising at their planned time that
lasted after the intervention but if
they didn’t make it at their planned
time they didn’t make it at all whereas
the flexible folks like Liz they figured
out what to do if something got in the
way of their plans and they still went
to the gym so what’s the takeaway
well planning can help us with
follow through but it seems to be really
important to learn with to roll with the
punches and be flexible when life gets
in the way of your plans if you want to
build a lasting habit okay at this point
I’ve told you about a few strategies
that we can use to improve health
behaviors we’ve talked about temptation
bundling we’ve talked about planning
prompts for follow-through and we’ve
talked about how we can help people form
habits by encouraging them to engage in
physical activity at routine times but
rewarding them even if they do it out of
out of sync with their schedules okay so
I shared some of these ideas a few years
ago at a large company and I got a great
question from a manager who looked a lot
like Liz Lemon’s boss Jack Donaghy he
asked a great question that Jack might
have asked to and he said alright I’m
sold we should be using these strategies
to get our employees to make healthier
decisions but when should we use these
strategies when is the right time well
first answer that might have popped into
your head might be the one that’s on the
slide behind me maybe you thought of new
years that’s what I thought of we all
know that people redouble their efforts
to achieve their goals at the start of a
new year and in fact 40% of Americans
including Liz Lemon make new year’s
resolutions there are many reasons for
this including a herd mentality my
collaborators and I though have shown
that at least part of what’s going on is
that at the start of a new year we feel
like we have a clean slate
last year’s failings feel far behind us
and we feel new improved and more
capable than before it turns out that
it’s not just at the start of a new year
when we have those fresh start feelings
we feel those fresh start feelings at
the start of lots of new cycles like the
beginning of a new week or a new month
following holidays or following
birthdays in one study we show that the
very same undergraduates are much more
likely to visit the gym at the beginning
of a new week month year following
holidays at the start of a new semester
and following birthdays with the notable
exception of 21st birthdays and I’ll let
you speculate as to why that might be
the case we see the very same patterns
around fresh starts when we look at when
it is that people search for the term
diet
on Google and we also see these patterns
when we look at when it is that people
create goals on a popular goal-setting
website stick comm where you can put
money on the line that you’ll forfeit if
you fail to achieve your goals and these
starts at fresh start these spikes at
fresh start moments don’t just occur for
health-related goals we see them when we
look at goals around anything savings
education and so on so this suggests
that maybe we could use fresh starts to
encourage good behavior to figure this
out we actually moved outside of the
domain of health and ran an experiment
in savings to explain let’s imagine Liz
turns thirty five and two months and
isn’t saving for retirement it’s not
such a large leap to take all right so
would it be more effective to encourage
her to start saving by inviting her to
start saving now or after her next
birthday or now or in two months we
thought the first might be more
effective because it highlights this
upcoming Fresh Start and we tested this
with about 2,000 employees who weren’t
saving for retirement and had birthday’s
coming up at all different points in
time what we found is that that fresh
start mailing increased savings rates
significantly for the nine months of our
follow-up period which was really
exciting so this may be due to fresh
starts or maybe it’s because of the
salience of aging induced by reminding
people about their birthdays but either
way it suggests there’s real opportunity
here to use fresh starts for good okay
where does this all leave us well first
of all we’re clearly inching closer to
solving a problem of behavior change for
good and now that you know about fresh
starts you can look for the next one in
your life and use it to motivate
yourself to pursue whatever goal has
been eluding you coupled with the other
strategies I’ve told you about today you
should feel well-prepared to get
wherever it is you want to be but what I
find really exciting about all of this
work is that with ideas like these and
there are many more where these come
from if we can just disseminate them
widely we actually have a shot at making
a dent in the 40% of premature deaths
each year that are a result of behaviors
that can be changed and if we can do
that then there will be fewer and fewer
families like mine
that face catastrophic losses and there
will be more and more families like mine
too that have happy endings more parents
who live to become grandparents for me
really that’s what this is all about
thank you
[Applause]
Please follow and like us: