Press "Enter" to skip to content

Go your own way: on originality in fiction | Laura Barnett | TEDxCambridgeUniversity


today I’d like to talk to you about fear
the kind of fear that looks like this
the kind of fear that grips you slides
into your throat and keeps you awake at
night the kind of fear that makes you
want to run away and hide this fear
isn’t actually the monster it appears to
be it looks like a monster and it feels
like a monster but to the writer and to
any and every kind of artist this fear
is actually a friend this fear is what
we need to be feeling in order to create
or paint or write anything of worth this
fear is the measure of our originality
of our drive to reach deep inside
ourselves and draw out an idea that is
honest original and true an idea that
doesn’t just retread the same old part
an idea that tries to break new ground
to fit our understanding of the world
around us to a shape that we and only we
can see I know this because I’ve felt
that fear and I still feel it pretty
much every day pretty much every time I
sit down to write it’s there peeking out
from behind every paragraph it’s there
lurking behind every sentence it’s there
and the slow tentative movements I make
towards trying to understand my
characters their motivations their
states of mind and it’s there above all
in the moment in which an idea is born
that crazy intoxicating moment when a
loose series of thoughts or images seems
to coalesce into something some
distillation of a feeling or a question
that might just become the beginning of
a book what a stupid idea
the fear says then I actually imagine
him with a sort of slithering sibilant
voice a bit like this
in the film of the jungle book but I was
very my acting skills what a loser you
are even to think of it okay so this has
never been written before but what makes
you think that it’s worth writing now if
I were you I’d give this up straight
away you’re bound to fail I first met
the fear about four years ago when I
reached something of a crossroads in my
life as a novelist or an aspiring
novelist I should say because I hadn’t
actually yet published a book over the
last 10 years I’d written two whole
novels while working full-time as a
journalist it hadn’t been easy I’d given
up evenings weekends holidays when
friends and family were out having fun
and I was sat in the dark room talking
to imagining people staring at my laptop
screen but obviously it was something I
needed to do it was I was driven to do
it and I had been for as long as I could
remember all I had ever wanted to do was
write fiction and as I wrote those two
novels I had high hopes for each of them
I believed I poured in my blood sweat
and tears and I believed that each of
these books might just be the novel that
would launch me into the world that
would connect me with readers that would
that would see me a published author but
unfortunately that wasn’t what happened
you seen either of those novels was
working they looked like real books but
they didn’t smell like them something
was missing some key ingredient
they just weren’t lifting off the page
they were standing in the shadow of
other far greater novels rather than
trying to break new ground
of their own as you can probably imagine
the moment I came to that realization
was pretty depressing I’d recently
turned 30 which I appreciate is not old
by any stretch of the imagination but it
was old enough to meet already feel like
I was failing as a young child loving
books dreaming of writing them and later
as a student here in Cambridge I’d never
have imagined not having published my
first novel by the time I was 30 it was
all I wanted to do it was the sum total
of my hopes and ambitions and so for a
while
I let myself be depressed I’m each
Tyrone
I ate an awful lot of cake some of it I
think suspiciously like this I indulged
in self-pity I told myself it was
pointless that I’d never make a writer
never find anything original to say how
could I when everything worth saying had
already been said I looked at all those
novels lined up on my shelves all those
amazing published authors whose work I
so loved and admired how could I
seriously ever dream of joining them how
could I ever come up with anything as
interesting or necessary or original as
they had and then one morning the fear
entered my life he and I will point out
of this at this point that I do picture
the fear as a man in fact he looks
slightly like Richard he grant in my
head some somewhere between Richard he
grant and that wall Russ I showed you
earlier
so like Richard Lee grant with fangs
probably don’t have time to go into the
psychological implications of that right
now but you can picture whatever you
like for me it was Richard Lee Grahn in
my head with fangs appearing in my head
one morning dragging on the coattails of
an idea for a novel a fragile concept
that also appeared that morning and just
refused to leave the idea was this to
tell the story of one couples
relationship in three different versions
so weaving together into one novel three
separate trajectories of how this
couples life together or apart might
turn out this idea felt exciting to me
immediately in a way that no other idea
ever really had neither of those two
novels I’d finished nor any of the
countless other books and stories that
I’d started and set aside this idea felt
different it felt important it was
founded on something I was absolutely
fascinated about which are these tiny
fulcrum points that draw our lives down
one path rather than another it didn’t
feel like any book I’d read before it
felt like the story I had to tell and
that was where the fear slipped in with
his slithering sibilant voice he
whispered in my hair he said Laura I
don’t know what you’re thinking now but
this is just crazy you really need to
give us up now because no one’s ever
written three versions
the same characters into one book and
you just need to give up it’s just never
gonna happen well for a while I listened
to the fear I did dismiss the idea as
crazy impossible stupid
I set it aside I ate some more cake I
just wondered what on earth I was going
to do next but then over the next few
day the next few weeks something seemed
to change in me the fear seemed to shift
his shape in my mind I started to wonder
whether the presence of the fear
actually indicated that I was on to
something that this idea was worth
pursuing I started to question myself I
started to think that perhaps if I
wasn’t feeling the fear as I hadn’t been
not really with either of those other
two novels I’d been doing something
wrong perhaps I’d simply been standing
in the shadow of the Giants all those
writers I most admired and loved and
simply trying to reframe their ideas
their ways of seeing as my own if I was
feeling the fear perhaps I was being
given a chance to step out from the
shadow of those giants and write
something innovative something new I
decided that the fear wasn’t actually so
terrifying after all
he wasn’t exactly cuddly those fangs and
that scary Richard II brought face were
a bit too scary for that but he didn’t
terrify me as he had before I took that
idea the idea of the one couple told in
three different ways and I started to
write and over the next 10 months or so
I wrote that idea into a novel they gave
it the title the versions of us and a
couple years after I finished that first
draft
it became my first published novel and
changed my life in ways I couldn’t even
have imagined the most amazing thing
about it has been to my absolute
amazement and delight it seems to have
connected with readers all over the
world and it’s been translated into 23
languages this is a selection of the
different editions of myself in my study
and most importantly of all it’s given
me the opportunity to realize my dream
without meaning to sound to pollyannaish
that is really what happened I get to
now spend my time thinking about talking
about and of course writing fiction but
I will emphasize that even with that
degree of success even with my dreams
coming to you left right and center the
fear has not gone away in fact he came
straight back as soon as I started
working on my second novel greater Pitt
I had in mind an idea of my next book
which the fear deemed absolutely crazy
in fact crazier than the one I’ve
written before this time I wanted to
write the whole life story of a musician
a women a singer-songwriter British who
in my head was somewhere between Joni
Mitchell and Kate Bush but what was
really mad about this idea and what
really got the feel of furious was that
I wanted to work with a
singer-songwriter a live real life one
not a fictional one to create the songs
that were reflected in the book so to
release an album they would they would
come out alongside the book this really
felt exciting to me it felt like an
opportunity to truly break new ground
because as far as I was aware that had
never been done before well as they say
the fear had an absolute field day with
that he thought I’d finally lost the
plot he just stood there he folded his
arms he told me forget it Laura this is
ridiculous no one’s ever going to agree
to do this with you
how are you gonna get your publisher to
talk to her a record label it’s complete
madness just stop now before you
embarrass yourself but this time I was
ready for the fear this time I invited
him in over offered him a cup of tea
I said hey good to see you again welcome
back because this time I was sure that
his presence meant I was on to something
but this idea was worth pursuing I did
pursue it and as you can see the book
exists and will be coming out this
summer and I’ve been working on an album
with an amazing singer/songwriter called
Catherine Williams that will release
alongside it and the whole experience
has been so much more exciting so much
more life-changing than I could even
have imagined I’m telling you all this
because in the end I do think that idea
was worth pursuing and that the fear in
the end can be our friend
today we are thinking about giants about
whether we as artists song writers poets
must stand on the shoulders of the
Giants if those who came before us in
order to see our
towards creating something innovative
something of worth the point I’d like to
leave you with is that it isn’t enough
simply to stand on those shoulders
taking in the view from up there what we
must do instead is do that look out from
where the Giants have looked look
through their eyes but then direct our
gaze inwards at our own thoughts our own
experiences
it’s not about disregarding the world
around us or ignoring what other writers
have to say but about trusting in the
uniqueness of our own perspective as an
amazing series of documentary films by
the musician Dave Grohl and his band Foo
Fighters relating to an album they may
called sonic highways each track on the
record is inspired by different American
city and in the film we see the band
touring that city and then recording a
track in a studio in one of these films
inside one of those studios there’s a
poster on the wall and you guessed it
says this don’t follow in the footsteps
of the Masters seek what they saw now
I’ve researched as it turns out this
isn’t actually Dave Grohl’s own
philosophy which I found slightly
disappointing but it’s that over 17th
century Japanese poet named Matsuo Basho
what I find so striking about this quote
and its relevance today is that it
reminds us that we as artists or writers
or scientists or researchers or anyone
trying to do anything of worth in any
field
we can’t ever hope to repeat the
triumphs of those who’ve come before
what we must do instead is try to do
what they did to look inside themselves
and find out what they and only they
really wanted to write or paint or
research when we do that we can be sure
that the fear will come crawling
wretchedly grant or The Walrus or
whoever hears for you he’ll come with
his claws out and his teeth bared but
it’s been as we stare back at him that
we can be certain we’re in with the
chance of creating something honest
original and true
you
Please follow and like us: