Press "Enter" to skip to content

What’s the Value of Education? | Seshu Iyengar | TEDxUNB


fellow students are probably familiar

with the vague sense of dread that I

think everyone’s kind of felt when

someone asks you a question like what

are you gonna do with that degree anyway

and this isn’t something that’s isolated

to one major or one faculty I mean ask

someone whether your degree is useful

and they’re probably going to tell you

about how high your earning potential is

later or what type of career you can

expect with that and that can leave

someone feeling a little empty inside

because surely there’s more to what

we’re doing here than cold-hard

economics so what’s the value of getting

an education at university well people

often ask me how I can study philosophy

and physics at the same time and that

question seems to imply that you know

these subjects are so different they’re

somehow incompatible and that’s not true

in fact I would go so far to say that

what I get out of studying philosophy is

exactly what everyone gets out of

studying all of their degrees now

someone might stop me here and say an

electrical engineering student and a

philosophy student they take different

courses that have different information

in them and that’s true but my point is

that the result of earning both degrees

is the same you get this insight into

the world and how to interpret and

reapply its many patterns for example

it’s hard not to be impressed by physics

a fun guy at a party might start

throwing a hacky sack around and be

struck at how it traces on your perfect

parabola I mean look at that who knew

that the quadratic formula actually

could tell you something useful it

didn’t have to be that way and at the

same time we have to realize the way a

refrigerator works is also incredible

but you don’t see us sitting down in awe

every time we go looking for a snack

it’s education that lets us do that

however sit in awe at the patterns that

appear in nature society and people and

then learn how to manipulate those

patterns ourselves

now unfortunately the often segmented

way education occurs particularly at the

grade school level causes us to believe

that once we get knowledge in a subject

our knowledge is applicable to that

subject alone aren’t we told that there

are arts people and there are math

people or that there are physics people

and biology people or we’re told that

engineering students were those students

who were good at math but just couldn’t

do essays there’s this idea that any

given human brain can do one thing but

not another not just because of how that

brain was trained or what that brain is

interested in we’re told that there are

different types of human brain this is

an idea I completely disagree with I

think that the insight education brings

and the insight into the patterns that

we see from education means no matter

what subject you get trained in you

bring valuable perspective into others

now maybe I can grant that specific

skills need to be trained like essay

writing or calculus but you have to

realize writing an essay or taking a

derivative these don’t require any

special cognitive faculty they’re

practiced mechanical skills in contrast

the insight a psychology student gets

into how the human mind works can be

used over and over again to analyze how

economies work or how entire societies

work this cognitive faculty isn’t

practiced into existence the way we

practice into existence our ability to

use long division it’s a paradigm or a

way of thinking and this isn’t something

I’m making up on the spot actually major

movements in the arts and sciences

relied on thinkers who could take

patterns from one context and reapply

them somewhere completely different I’d

say that the entire enlightenment and

scientific revolution was based on this

exchange of paradigms and here’s my

personal favorite example many of you

have probably heard of Isaac Newton

those of you who took a chemistry course

would be familiar with Robert Boyle and

if you took some fizzy

robert hooke’s name was mentioned

although you definitely didn’t see him

these three were physicists who are

among the first to pursue the theory

that the stuff around us was made out of

particles or atoms and these physicists

also happened to be close colleagues

with the famous thinker john locke at

oxford in the 17th century but john

locke is noted for his social contract

theory and is considered the father of

Western political science so it isn’t a

coincidence then that Locke’s political

theories were based around these human

atoms is it here you see an example of a

philosopher or a social scientist

looking at a pattern that natural

scientists were seeing in the world and

reapplying them in a completely

different place and it led to some

pretty amazing results I mean Locke’s

political atavisms is still considered

the dominant force in political

philosophy today and is hailed as the

founding philosophy of the United States

that’s not bad

in the other direction you had

physicists like Verner Heisenberg who

you can see on my right Albert Einstein

in the center and Erwin Schrodinger on

my left these were physicists who

developed quantum theory and general

relativity in part because philosophers

gave them the confidence to think that

they could when great names like

Einstein Schrodinger and Heisenberg

grappled with issues like quantum

indeterminacy like is that cat dead or

alive or the fact that time was no

longer standard it’s this relative thing

they didn’t fight their equations which

I’ve displayed in their full beautiful

glory here they didn’t cite these

equations as justification they in fact

cited philosophers like Immanuel Kant of

Prussia in the 1700s and this seems

weird to us now because why should a

self-respecting scientist like Einstein

listen to someone who 200 years earlier

talked about subjective experience or

the phenomenal world but therein lies

the key

their confidence in their own work came

because they had read enough beyond

physics to redefine what is possible

within physics it is important to

realize what I’m not saying I’m not

saying for example that I should be

allowed to change someone’s plumbing

actually I shouldn’t be allowed near

anything that could affect your quality

of life that dramatically clearly you

need a broad range of education Ziff you

want to bring this paradigm into a new

field after all we’re at a university

right like I don’t have to look far to

find someone here with a story about how

someone else came and dismissed their

degree or their courses that’s easy a

joke not important and that’s a bad

attitude that’s an attitude that goes

against the idea of insight because it’s

an attitude where someone says oh look

this answer that I’ve found to one

question it must be the answer to every

question instead of using their training

to find places to find new solutions

they’ve learned to say I already have

all the solutions and instead of using

their education to bring insight and

perspective into their work they’ve

learned to shut it out because life

isn’t that certain there’s no magic

bullet which will get you all the

knowledge and anyone who tells you they

know the degree that will make you money

or get you a job or explain the universe

has fallen into a trap the truth is in

the scheme of interpreting the world

around you your degree isn’t the answer

it’s part of a broader solution so we

have to learn and respect and value

education because in education no matter

where it happens or what that education

is in it brings training discipline and

as I said before a unique insight this

is difficult because we have to remember

when someone has training or an

education and something different from

your own we have to stop and remember

unusual isn’t bad it’s good and we also

have to respect ourselves just because

our major doesn’t

is intimidating or scary as someone

else’s doesn’t mean the work we have put

into it is any less valuable and with

this mutual respect and understanding we

will have the ability to engage in that

cross-disciplinary mentality that lock

and Heisenberg did so what’s the value

of getting an education well as I’ll say

as I said before I’ll probably say again

it’s insight when you get an education

you get this insight into the world and

how you can shape it in turn and

universities are particularly good

because of the diversity of insight

you’ll be exposed to for example UNB has

concurrent programs in science arts

computer science and education and of

course you have access to courses in

many completely different faculties at a

university so when you walk out with a

piece of paper yes it will be nice to

put on your resume or show to a med

school or whatever but it signifies so

much more because it signifies that

you’ve interacted with the world in a

way that goes beyond living in it you’ve

learned something about it and when a

politician gets up and tells you how

many jobs they’re gonna make or how good

the health care is gonna be or how high

the wall they’ll build will be or when a

celebrity tells you what’s okay to eat

what you’re allowed to put in your home

you’ll have perspective the perspective

to ask how does what they’re talking

about even work does that make sense to

me because after all you’ve listened to

many authorities on subjects but you

know better than to take what they say

for granted because you’ve become educated and that’s something valuable

Please follow and like us: