
mathematics that makes it such an
effective tool for learning about the
universe with so many applications in
such diverse fields even the advanced
the objects that advanced mathematics
studies can be very abstract and very
weird and these two have surprising
relevance in the world around us what is
that and what is it about mathematics
the logical some might take hold study
of abstractions that can inspire such
intense emotions in people profound love
deep passion or maybe intense anxiety
what is it about math that see so many
people putting it behind them saying I
was never very good at math for that
matter although in completely different
ways what is it about music what is it
about music that makes it such a
powerful tool for approaching problems
in our social lives our emotional lives
are political and our civic lives what
is it about music that inspires such
intense emotions in people music – can
leave people while still enjoying it
saying I’m not a very musical person
there’s lots of connections between math
and music I’d like to talk about one
that I perceive as underlying how we
listen to and appreciate music and how
we approach and solve mathematical
problems and that’s the idea of tension
and release concerning tension we as
humans are remarkably good at feeling
tense and anxious and afraid and that’s
a wonderful thing the recognition of
threats in the fear of danger has
enabled us to survive throughout the
millennia but of course fear can get the
better of us it can cause us to make
poor decisions and we need to find ways
of managing and releasing ourselves from
fear too much fear and because it
pertains to both math and music I’ll
mention that we’re also remarkably good
at recognizing patterns were fascinated
by them we love finding patterns and
this is a wonderful thing – it’s enabled
us to grow crops to treat illness to
create and modify political and civic
structures but here – our love of
patterns and our search for them can
sometimes get the better
and cause us to make poor decisions we
can miss identify patterns miss
attribute them extrapolate them an
unhelpful or sometimes even harmful ways
mathematical thinking can give us a
really really powerful way of gaining
some control over our innate love of
patterns and we need mathematical
thinking if we’re gonna grapple with
complicated problems like climate change
economic disparity the management of
limited resources the spread of illness
we need mathematical thinking we need to
cultivate and grow and nurture our
mathematical thinking skills now more
than ever but it’s hard to cultivate
mathematical thinking skills and to
nurture them when all too often
mathematics can inspire some really
intense anxiety I know what it is to
feel anxious when doing mathematics
early on in my undergrad I didn’t know
whether I wanted to study math or music
in part because I found music soothing
mathematics was not always soothing for
me but as I took more mathematics
courses I was really surprised to hear
my math profs speak about mathematics
with such warmth in such affectionate
tones they spoke about math not as
though they found it fun and interesting
or even profoundly important they spoke
about math as though they really loved
it and saw true beauty there and I
didn’t get that and I wanted to know
more about it in short my math profs
spoke about math the way I was expecting
my musics profs to speak about music of
course
my music profs did say some did they did
speak about music and really
affectionate tones and one of my music
profs said something other people have
said the same idea that to him music was
nothing more and nothing less than
patterns of tension and release I don’t
want to turn this into a music theory
class but I just want to give some very
simple examples of this if I play a
and then play it again we’re consciously
or subconsciously waiting for that final
note and if I modify it and if I hang
there
I’m very subtly creating some kind of
tension that our ears are perceiving and
it gets released or resolved when I play
that note there which you might call the
home note or the root node and that’s a
very simple example of what you might
call melodic tension and release we can
do more with this you can create
harmonic tension and release through the
use of chords so if I establish that as
the home chord or the root chord that’s
where things start out if I move away
from that chord I can create varying
degrees of tension and if I play this
chord in particular
that resolves or releases very nicely
back to the home cord in part that’s
because this cord contains an interval
called the tritone which by itself is
kind of dissonant but it resolves very
nicely to that interval which is in the
home cord and so you can hear how this
cord pulls the tension is created and it
pulls back towards home and jazz harmony
kind of takes this to an extreme even in
a very simple the most basic jazz
progression a two five one you can hear
some kind of tension and release
happening there even if you’re not aware
of the music theory if I change that a
little bit I can create tension within a
release if I play this chord that sounds
a bit like the home chord but there’s a
couple of extra notes there that create
some kind of tension you’re wondering
what happened maybe what’s gonna happen
next though that’s just some very simple
examples of harmonic tension and release
there’s other kinds of as well a very
kind of raw example of tension and
release in music is that which occurs
often in electronic dance music the
build-up and the drop this occurs in
other forms of music as well what you’ll
have is maybe just a the music quiets
down a little bit and then you’ll have
this rising crescendo things are getting
a little bit louder since their synths
are building you have these rising
frequencies and you can sense that
something is about to happen but you
don’t know quite what and you don’t know
quite win and that tension builds and
builds and builds and then finally the
bass kicks in and the kick drum kicks in
and the beat takes off then you go away
now that’s another example there’s all
sorts though there’s all sorts sometimes
repetition itself creates a form of
tension if I were to just play this
chord
[Music]
for two minutes straight you would start
to wonder when is something gonna happen
sometimes
funk music exploits this really really
in really interesting ways
the familiar can itself lead to some
kind of tension and when something
different does happen you feel that
released there’s all sorts of ways to
create tension or perform tension and
release in mathematics a couple other
examples just since I’m on the topic
rhythmic tension and release this is
particularly common in in in modern
hip-hop music where you’ll hear drum
patterns just in a slightly offbeat and
really creative and interesting ways
lyrics can add a whole other dimension
of tension and release to listening to
music even the social or political
context of a song can create tensions
and releases that affect how we listen
to and perceive that song now while
tension and release is related to the
familiar and the unfamiliar it they
don’t quite correspond that nicely
sometimes the familiar is is what causes
the tension and the unfamiliar releases
it there can be tensions within releases
releases with intentions and they can
occur in really really interesting in
complicated ways and our ears perceive
them and our brains perceive them even
if we’re not consciously aware of the
music theory this is part of what makes
music so rich and rewarding for us and I
would argue that the more we can
appreciate and understand and develop a
capacity for these kinds of tensions and
releases the deeper our appreciation for
music is but here’s the thing with music
these tensions aren’t genuine tensions
we don’t take them personally they just
happen they pass through us they wash
over us and then we’re ready for the
next tension even if we’re not aware of
it now let’s move to math picture
sitting down to solve a math problem or
maybe a set of math problems maybe
there’s some tension there right at the
start do we know what the problem is
asking are we going to be able to solve
it
maybe you that tension gets released and
you start to make some progress on the
problem but then you
encounter some obstacle maybe you’re
able to think of some technique that
might be helpful here but you can’t
quite remember the formula so you look
up the formula
maybe the jargon is a little bit
different maybe the notation is a little
bit different maybe there’s some tension
between how you’ve learned this in the
past how you’ve been taught in the past
and how you’re being asked to apply that
knowledge now maybe you made some
judgment at the start about how
difficult this was or wasn’t going to be
and now that assumption is being
challenged
maybe you subconsciously made a judgment
at the start about how long this should
take you and now it’s taking way longer
or it took way less time than you
thought and that’s surprising and you’re
not quite sure what’s happening you can
have a tension within a release okay I
got that I don’t fully know if I’ll be
able to do it the next time but I got it
now
or you can have a release with an
attention I’m not quite sure why that
worked but I got the answer these
patterns of tension and release can
happen in very complex layered ways and
here too just like with music I would
argue that the more we can develop a
capacity to work through these tensions
and appreciate them the richer our
relationship with mathematics can be but
here’s the difference compared with
music now the tensions can be real they
can be personal and they can get
emotional a tension that starts out as
I’m not quite sure if I remember how to
apply this formula can very quickly turn
into I’m not quite sure I’m smart enough
to solve this problem and that can turn
into I’m not quite sure I’m smart enough
to learn this kind of mathematics and
that can turn into I’m not quite sure
I’m smart enough to do more mathematics
maybe I’ve reached my limit maybe this
is where math ends for me and I’m okay
with that
now sometimes mathematics can make you
question your intelligence and to some
extent that’s natural but for some
people in a competitive academic
environment
questioning your intelligence is a
slippery slope to questioning your value
that hurts
now it doesn’t always play out that
dramatically when we encounter some
difficulty in mathematics of course
sometimes it’s just fine but there can
creep in these subtle patterns of not
just tension and release but self
judgment and wondering whether we’re
good enough to do this anymore
and that can hurt but I don’t think it
has to be that way what if what if we
were able to learn mathematics in a way
where the tensions that happened weren’t
emotional if we just welcomed them the
way we welcome them with music without
letting the without letting them lead us
to a path of I’m wondering whether this
is good enough what if we just let the
tensions happen pass through us wash
over us they won’t just disappear but
they’re there and we welcome them and we
acknowledge them and that’s part of
learning mathematics it’s just part of
it just like tensions and music that’s
just part of listening music I think
that can happen I think that people
individuals are at the same time more
musical than we give ourselves credit
for and also more mathematical than we
give ourselves credit for we have a deep
as a species we have a deep love for
music that’s very safe statement to make
we as a species have a very deep love of
mathematics that’s maybe a bit of a
stretch but what if I tweaked it a
little bit what if I said we as a
species have a deep fascination with
mathematical thinking with problem
solving with finding patterns with
working with patterns with breaking hard
problems down into simpler problems and
exploring the space around us and
exploring the quantities that we
encounter I think that’s true I think we
can cultivate slowly very gradually a
more productive psychological
relationship with mathematics I won’t
say more positive because it’s too much
to hope for that a subject is vast and
interesting and complex and difficult as
mathematics that when we learn that that
it can always be fun and pleasant and
enjoyable it won’t be that’s too much to
hope for but we can call
a more productive relationship where we
welcome the struggle that’s part of it
we embrace it learning math is tough I
don’t love math because I find it easy I
love math in part because I find it hard
and I think that we can achieve this
kind of relationship with mathematics
but only if we can embrace the Heron the
inherent tension in mathematics it is a
difficult subject for us to learn and it
will be but only if we can release
ourselves from the paralyzing self judgment