Press "Enter" to skip to content

What hidden patterns tell us about the spread of diseases | Margaret Cullather | TEDxVCU


and everyone all right I am going to

start today by telling you a little bit

about myself I am a bio nerd and an

emergency medicine enthusiast at heart

but above all I’ve been in love with

public health since my very first high

school science fair project this is

actually me at the Virginia state

science fair back in 2010 where I was

researching the connection between

playing musical instrument and asthma

and I was so in awe at how I could take

biology and statistics and make it

relatable and impactful and so when I

was in my senior year of college and I

had to come up with an undergraduate

thesis I knew immediately what it would

be on and that’s public health and while

I was on that journey I discovered

something critical and that is that

disease is racist disease takes the path

of least resistance so imagine with me

for a moment that you have OOP just

gotten home from a long day at work or a

long day of classes and you have two

options in front of you you can a

workout or B crash face-first into your

couch so if you’re anything like me

you’re going to choose the option that

involves curling up with your cats in

front of Netflix disease works very much

in the same way it’s going to take the

path of least resistance and that is to

take the easiest victim so here I was in

my senior year of college I was studying

microbiology volunteering full time and

attempting to balance being an athlete

as well and I on top of all of that

needed to find both a research project

and an undergraduate thesis and maybe

sleep maybe and so I decided to take the

path of least resistance and combine my

interest in public health with my

research that I was working on at the

time along with my other assignments in

school at that time I was working in a

lab studying the effects of a number of

disinfectants on Staphylococcus aureus

which is a very very common

hospital-acquired infection so I decided

to use this basis for my thesis and kind

of

roll it all into one every year more

than 100,000 people will die from a

hospital-acquired infection that is more

than will die in a year from Alzheimer’s

or from diabetes or from even the flu if

every single person in this audience

today were to spend a night in the

hospital

chances are 24 of you would end up with

a secondary infection three of you would

likely die from that infection so every

time we go to see a doctor we go to see

them with the anticipation that we’re

going to get better right we don’t go

into a hospital knowing that we might

die from an infection that we get in

that hospital ward so I decided to use

this project to find a solution to this

problem to battle this horrible issue so

I randomly selected 20 hospitals from a

Medicare and Medicaid database and ran

an analysis on community attributes I

wanted to see if hospital acquired

infections had an impact outside of the

hospital so I looked at community

attributes that included income level

education supplemental nutrition veteran

status and race and when I found was

particularly interesting hospitals with

higher infection rates trended towards

communities that had high minority

populations and very low median income

for whatever reason minorities were much

more likely to get a hospital-acquired

infection but just because there’s a

correlation doesn’t mean there’s a

causation right for example we have seen

a correlation between per capita sales

of margarine and divorce rates in Maine

this doesn’t mean that because you buy

more butter you’re less likely to get

divorced in Maine right in epidemiology

we there we go in epidemiology we use

what’s called the Bradford Hill criteria

it’s a set of nine loose guidelines that

help us determine if a relationship is

real or fake

it was the term determined by the

this man Bradford Hill in 1965 to

determine the cause between smoking

cigarettes and lung cancer so I had this

very very interesting results and I

wasn’t quite sure what to do with it so

I went back to the basics of

Epidemiology I dug through literature

research

I spoke with medical professionals and

slowly I began to put the pieces

together and I was checking items off of

this causation list in the end more than

half of the criteria were a match but I

had spent weeks working in hospitals and

in fact years if you count my emergency

medicine experience and never once had I

gotten hospital-acquired infection so I

needed to know why specific people and

why specific communities were much

higher risk for these infections I ended

up with a list of three criteria and

that is the inability to develop

acquired immunity presence of secondary

conditions and lack of resources how

many of you here today traveled to get

here anybody yeah all right so I did – I

actually came in from st. Louis it took

me two airplanes to get here and I

actually have been traveling quite a bit

for work lately so I’ve been on ten

airplanes and in seven airports in the

past two weeks and for me I hate

traveling there’s never enough room

there’s a baby screaming two seats over

a kid kicking you in the back and your

neighbor is inevitably breathing down

your neck it’s just it’s such a hassle

but I am privileged I had the

opportunity to travel to expose myself

to a number of environmental factors

including bacteria and viruses that in

the end boosted my immune system this is

what we call acquired immunity acquired

immunity is not something you’re born

with you develop it over a lifetime

through exposure to the environment

around you every time that your body has

to fight an infection to mount an immune

defense your body and your immune system

gets stronger so if you don’t travel if

you don’t move if you don’t have those

experiences you never build that

immunity that

scenes play into this as well and as the

research has shown minority groups and

low-income families are much less likely

to have received the flu vaccine HPV

pneumococcal or shingles or tetanus

vaccinations each of wist which will

boost your overall immunity this is then

compounded when families will live in

one city block for an entire lifetime

for generations on generations never

getting exposure to new environmental

factors secondary conditions also play a

part as I was speaking to one nurse she

explained to me that the patients that

they see with the most hospital-acquired

infections are those being treated with

chemotherapy or dialysis as a matter of

fact Hispanics and African Americans are

significantly more likely to experience

cancer or diabetes that would need to be

treated with these methods now not just

hospital acquired infections but many

diseases will continue to

disproportionately affect underserved

and underprivileged communities this

pattern is a type of social injustice

that we refer to as structural violence

structural violence is a systematic way

in which social structures harm and

disadvantaged particular communities in

particular populations it is very very

subtle almost invisible even and has

multiple responsible parties and this

brings me to my final point that

communities lack the resources to

improve their health outcomes now I am a

happy healthy person most of you in this

audience are but we are not a healthy

community and unhealthy communities lack

economic opportunities access to

adequate health care vaccination

programs and often display a high

prevalence of drug use so minority and

low-income communities and neighborhoods

continue to be the victim of structural

but we you know we continue we try with

our medicine to treat these infections

to treat hospital-acquired infections in

particular but it becomes a struggle

because antimicrobial resistance is

evolving at a rapid pace we need to

understand that community health

requires an effort from all of us that

we are only as strong as our weakest

member so I want you to take for

consideration the Hippocratic oath the

Hippocratic oath is the vow taken by all

new medical school graduates that says

first do no harm

where does first do no harm end does it

end when that patient leaves the exam

room does it end when they leave the

hospital diseases are evolving at an

increasingly rapid pace and in order to

respond to that we also need to evolve

the way in which we implement medicine

if we recognize this pattern we can then

extend that Hippocratic oath to the

community to take it on as an effort

from all of us so why should we care why

does it matter structural violence in in

its most simplest term we often think of

it as occurring in developing nations in

developing nations it’s far away it’s

hard to recognize that we could help or

intervene it’s not our home it’s our

town it’s not your neighbor but if

disease is racist then it’s coming for

you too

this could very easily be your own town

your own city block that will soon be

impacted by health disparities so then

what’s the solution is there one my

solution is that we need a healthcare

system that fights for community health

that boosts herd immunity because the

more people in a community that are

capable of fighting an infection then

the hell

the community is as a whole we need to

push for health care that emphasizes

Public Health and values diversity over

the mono culture because a diverse community is a healthy one thank you

Please follow and like us: