Press "Enter" to skip to content

The welcoming museum | Caroline Meyers | TEDxVCU


in 2001 Los Angeles teenager Howard Wang

published the article why museum suck in

LA youth publication based out of

California and the article is exactly

what it sounds like he belittle six

California art institutions frustrated

with the overall museum experience the

hyped up price of food the monotone

voice of a tour guide the chilly

temperatures even the ubiquity of naked

people and paintings but more than

anything he’s confused by the art he

views now the entire article is pretty

pessimistic but Hong does get a little

introspective near the end and the

article ends on a speculative note I

used to ask my history teacher why art

was important she told me that it helps

us understand how people express

themselves in ancient times I asked why

we’d want to know that she told me to

stop asking stupid questions so then I’d

be like how is that a stupid question

then I would get detention but it’s not

a stupid question is it now this article

meant little until almost ten years

later when suddenly the museum

blogosphere seized hold of it it

prompted a dozen responses some people

sympathizing with Wong’s complaints

others putting forward examples of new

and innovative programs that museums are

using to engage their audiences but

obviously the reason that this article

written by a teenager was able to catch

the attention of art world professionals

ten years after it was published is that

visitor engagement is a constant concern

of museums especially in this age of

digital technology now Huang isn’t the

only one to feel this way about museums

I have cause to believe it’s a pretty

common experience to not know what to do

with yourself in a museum setting how

long to stand in front of each piece or

how to pose your body or whether you

really have to look at every label in

the room or every piece in a world where

we are so constantly and easily

entertained by video or social media or

music museum going can surprise us as a

more austere experi

Ariane’s that involves looking and

reading and can be easy to become

disengaged from and this is especially

true with conceptual or what is known as

modern art paintings composed of a

single line or sculptures made out of

abstract forms I think people look at

these types of art sometimes and I think

to themselves how is this considered art

in the first place I like to think back

to a Skype call I had with a couple of

my friends when I was probably 16 years

old we got to talking about Edward

Shay’s painting which is in the Museum

of Modern Art in New York City and one

of my friends said something to the

effect of well I could have done that

and me wanting to impress her said guys

it’s all about the intent and we all

paused and then nodded even though I had

no idea what I was talking about at the

time another piece of typically modern

art is this Giant Steps a piece by

artist Enrico Riley that’s currently on

display in the Virginia Museum of Fine

Arts 21st century collection now at

first glance it appears to be a series

of little white abstract panels so let’s

say I’m in the museum I’ve been there

for a while it’s been a long day I’m

tired probably hungry I get to this

piece and I just have no idea what to

make of it so I decide to consult the

label that’s posted next to it to see if

I can gain some more information about

it and maybe appreciate this piece a

little bit more so I read the label and

what the label tells me is that the 61

panels that make up giant steps are a

simplified version of the musical score

for a song of the same name by famous

saxophonist John Coltrane so now I

understand a little bit more of why this

piece looks the way it does but I’ve

never heard the song giant steps before

and I don’t know anything about John

Coltrane or jazz history besides what

the label has just told me so it’s still

not particularly interesting for me and

I want to go back to that Wong quote

because he too expresses to his teacher

that he isn’t really engaged by the

contextual supplementary text that the

museum’s provides the museum provides

for him

and she essentially puts him down for

this which is too bad because not every

museum visitor that passes through a

museum is going to have enough

experience with art history so that this

information is enough to truly interest

them in a piece of art art history is

the lens through it the lens through

which most museum curators and other

museum professionals primarily

appreciate an examine art and this makes

sense because this is the way that they

studied at their entire lives but what

it also leads to is a bit of an over

representation of this type of

historical or contextual information in

supplementary texts and museums and also

creates a bit of an attitude that the

best correct way to learn about art no

museum is to appreciate it from an

academic or historical standpoint which

simply not every museum visitor is

capable of George Hine a leading museum

researcher for decades turned the type

of museum I’ve been talking about so far

the systematic museum what the

systematic museum does is asserts the

museum’s authority over the meaning of

museum objects by providing mostly if

not exclusively historical and

contextual information in the supporting

text and in this way of shutting out the

perspectives of the visitors that pass

through but Heim proposed another model

for a museum the constructivist museum

and this model is based in the learning

theory constructivism which posits that

knowledge is not something that exists

outside the learner to be pulled in but

rather something that is continuously

created within the mind of the learner a

process and the way that this philosophy

figures into the museum model is that in

the constructivist Museum the role of

the visitor in creating meaning from the

objects they view is prioritized and

visitors are encouraged to make personal

connections I believe that the

implementation of constructivist

elements in modern art museums can help

take visitors from a passing passive

experience with the art they view to a

more true and active interest and the

main way I’m proposing that museums do

this is by harnessing the power of

exactly the thing that Huang’s teacher

put him down for in the first place

stupid questions

going back to giant steps let’s say that

the museum under the means under the

main text for this piece of art let’s

say that the museum were to pose me a

question how many colors can you

decipher in this piece now at first

glance Giant Steps appears to be made

out of completely white panels but when

you look closer you realize they’re not

white at all they’re actually very light

a light pink a light yellow or a light

green and now this is a phenomenon that

the current label for this piece of art

informs visitors of but if they were

encouraged if visitors were encouraged

to scrutinize this piece of art and find

this information for themselves it would

create a much more active and

constructive experience with this piece

of art can you make out any animals in

this piece and can you make out any

faces in this piece both of these

questions ask the visitor to create a

totally new image from a piece of

abstract art and the great thing is that

everyone that enters a museum is going

to have different experiences biases

memories and these are all going to

result from people creating different

images from the art they view finally if

you had to install this piece in your

living space where would you put it this

question is literally an exercise in

taking the art outside of museum context

which can be intimidating in its

authority and grandeur and placing it in

a familiar space and in this way the

visitor is encouraged to see art as

something that can personally relate to

them now all of these questions are a

little silly and stupid in the sense

that they’re basic or simple but they’re

not really meant to provide a deeper

inquiry into the self or an immersive

museum experience at all instead they’re

so basic that visitors almost can’t help

respond to them in their minds and

immediately make a connection the hope

with these questions is that they would

provide a jumping-off point something to

pique visitors interest who might not

otherwise care and main lead them to go

look up that artist on the internet

later or finish reading that long label

text that’s posted next to the

piece of art this is a cartoon by Linda

berry famous American cartoonist and I

think it tells us a really important

truth about not just the way that people

relate to art but anything that exists

outside of them the two characters in

this comic don’t really get the piece of

art they’re looking at until they see

themselves reflected in it perfectly we

as humans are at the absolute center of

every experience we have by default and

that’s what makes it so easy for us to

relate things outside of us back to us

and so why not take advantage of this

impulse within art museums and encourage

making personal connections to art in

this way is a lot like looking up at the

clouds to find different images in them

because when you do this the sky is

literally the limit you can see anything

you can imagine and everyone sees

different things but if looking at the

clouds were like looking at art museums

can be like some of the time now it

would go something like this

you would look up into the sky and a

booming voice would come down saying

this is a straight-on emulous cloud it

is fluffy it is low to the ground it is

generally associated with rain and now

this information is correct and

important but it’s not pertinent within

the context of cloud gazing because

you’re not looking up at the clouds to

gain information you’re doing it for

leisure and again this is true of a lot

of people who go to art museums

especially for example someone who has

never been to an art museum before these

people are not attending museums for

some higher goal of learning they’re

going to enjoy the art that they see and

I do want to make clear though that I’m

not advocating museums rid themselves of

texts with historical or text contextual

information because this information is

important and it is engaging to people

that do go to museums with a higher goal

of learning all I’m saying is that the

addition of constructivist elements

might make the museum experience more

accessible

another method that museums use another

way that museums implement

constructivism into their spaces that

I’ve actually already seen a few modern

art museums do is by avoiding organizing

their objects out of any defined order

often museums will place the objects in

an exhibition in a chronological or

thematic order because they have a

specific point that they want to

communicate to visitors but besides

being systematic at base this

organization makes it so that if a

visitor is to cut out of an exhibition

early or to go in an order outside of

what the museum intends them they may

end up feeling confused or unsatisfied

with their experience because they’ve

missed the point that the museum has

laid out for them however when objects

are placed out of any hierarchical order

when equal weight is placed on every

object visitors are free to move from

the space however they wish visiting as

few or as many objects as they want and

also spending as little or as much time

as they want and in this way creating a

personalised and fulfilling museum

experience the Virginia Museum of Fine

Arts 21st century collection where Giant

Steps is located implements this type of

organization and so does the Renwick

gallery this gallery is a Smithsonian

Museum it reopened from a two-year

renovation in 2015 and immediately

became an Instagram phenomenon you may

have heard of it you may be seeing

pictures of the giant rainbow strings or

giant tree trunks within the museum the

museum is very open about encouraging

its visitors to take and post pictures

of the art within the collections these

photos are from the Museum’s second

exhibition entitled connections and the

coop the collection comprises a variety

of crafted objects as you can see and

it’s somatically concerned with

hyperlinks specifically the ways that

hyperlinks can take us from website to

website idea to idea without us knowing

where we’re going or where we’re going

to end up and so the pieces in this

exhibition or organize out of any

defined order so that visitors might

treat them like hyperlinks and bounce

between them however they want but

isn’t even the most clearly defined

constructivist element of this exhibit

in my opinion the Renwick has provided

paths on the floor of the gallery in the

form of colored dotted lines they

connect different objects in the

collection together and suggest

similarities between them now at first

it might seem like these paths are

reinforcing the systematic museum

because they are literally they’re

defined in the most literal sense they

are color they are printed on the floor

they are obvious but I believe that

these paths aren’t meant to be followed

in the first place for one there are far

too many of them for anyone to

realistically do this sometimes two or

three can sprout off of one object and

they don’t link up in a linear fashion

you can’t start at the beginning of this

exhibition and follow a path all the way

to the end

of the three times that I visited this

exhibition I didn’t notice anyone paying

particular attention to these paths

either nor did I feel the need to

instead what these paths are doing is

suggesting to visitors that connections

can be neat can be made between

virtually any piece in this collection

and encouraging them to move from the

space however they move throughout the

space however they wish I want to end by

imploring everyone here to take whatever

actions to make your to make your museum

experience fun for you and whatever way

that is regardless of what programs for

visitor engagement exists constructivist

or not take silly selfies in front of

artworks and spam them to Instagram make

fun of the funny faces that people in

sculptures and paintings pull if you’re

in an exhibition that isn’t interesting

you leave it but I do hope you’ll go on

to find one that you do generally like

all these actions might seem silly or

stupid but they are all constructivist

in the end because they all originate

with you and your interests ultimately

the most necessary part of the

constructivist museum is you thank you

you [Applause]

Please follow and like us: