Press "Enter" to skip to content

What global trade deals are really about (hint: it’s not trade) | Haley Edwards | TEDxMidAtlantic


I want you all to come away from the

next ten minutes with a single

counterintuitive idea and that is that

trade deals aren’t really about trade

not in any conventional sense of the

word they’re not about tariffs they’re

not about quotas they’re not about GDP

growth they’re not even really about

jobs that’s how we tend to talk about it

job loss and job gain and that’s what’s

in the news and that’s what’s at the DNC

but that’s not what they’re really about

not really and we’ll get to that but for

now I want to start at the very

beginning the modern era of free trade

as we think of it today started in about

1944 when all the great lights of

liberal economics got together in a

little place called Bretton Woods New

Hampshire and at the time the world was

in a pretty dark place it was you know

all the people they are remembered World

War one they lived through the

depression World War two was still

raging across the Atlantic and at the

top of everyone’s mind at the time was

world peace how do we create an economy

that fosters and necessitates world

peace that was the entire idea and they

seized on this idea of economic

interdependence

the idea was that if nation-states were

dependent on each other for their supply

chains then they couldn’t go to war with

each other if Germany needed France for

its coal and France needed Germany for

its steel then they couldn’t go to war

with each other so that was the idea

behind what became about four years

later the GATT the general agreement on

tariffs and trade and this little

document created the world as we know it

today

it created globalization it created

outsourcing it created multinational

corporations as we think of it it’s hard

to imagine a world in which there

weren’t you know McDonald’s isn’t global

corporations and the and the sort of

structure that we have now but the

general agreement on trade on tariffs

and trade is what did it we created this

and it brought on this period of

extraordinary disruption in convulsion

and prosperity from about 1948 when the

GATT was first signed to late 70s the

global GDP grew by about 7% per year

just explosive growth and for a while

people thought that wouldn’t end that

was just it we had cracked the code but

then it began to wane in the late 70s

and early 80s you had the great lights

of a new generation of liberal economics

get together for a second time a new

Bretton Woods only this time it was the

uruguay round and it lasted for eight

years and the scenario there was a

little different instead of world peace

and economic independent interdependence

they were really motivated by this idea

of global efficiency it’s basically how

do we continue to boost the global

economy as it has been boosted over the

last thirty years what do we do and the

scenario was different so in the 1940s

there was just really really high

tariffs and quotas and really high or

really protectionist policies at all the

borders and so lowering those could have

this profound influence but by the 80s a

lot of those quotas were pretty low a

lot of those tariffs were already pretty

low so they began to think outside the

box and they seized on this idea of

non-tariff barriers and now this this

leads into the modern era of trade I’m

talking about now now non-tariff

barriers are the idea that it doesn’t

really matter how low a tariff is around

a country’s border if once a product

gets inside it has to compete on an

uneven playing field so once you have

you know Jim Beam for example if it’s it

doesn’t matter if Japan doesn’t have a

tariff on liquor if once it’s inside

Japan it has to compete on the same

shelf next to a Japanese liquor that’s

subsidized by the Japanese government

so the idea now was

you know we need to strip away all that

other stuff and make the world economy

as efficient as possible and that is the

philosophy that governed trade beginning

in the 1990s in 1995 we got rid of the

GATT and we replaced it with something

you probably have heard of the World

Trade Organization and around that time

before and after we had these

extraordinarily enormous ly powerful

trade agreements the NAFTA the CAFTA and

literally thousands of bilateral

investment treaties all of which were

governed by the same philosophy

non-tariff barriers how do you create or

you got nation-states to sign on to this

idea that their domestic industrial

policies their domestic laws their

domestic regulations needed to align

with this global sense of efficiency

it’s the whole idea and that just take a

moment appreciate that because it’s

totally different than anything that the

granddaddy’s of trade would would

consider it would have considered trade

in the late 19th century you know David

Ricardo and Adam Smith and all these

people you learn about in the textbooks

when they were talking about trade they

were not talking about someone’s

domestic policy on environmental law

they were not talking about you know how

long a pharmaceutical company’s data

exclusivity should should last at last

for 12 years or 7 years or five years

and under what circumstances all of a

sudden that became what we were talking

about when we talked about trade and

that changed everything so to give you

two examples one of the biggest

discussions about trade that we’ve been

having since the late 90s involves or

fights really involves the Europeans and

the Americans and the Americans want to

export their genetically modified beef

to Europe and Europe in the Europeans

for a variety of sort of cultural and

social mores don’t want that don’t want

GMO beef and so you have this fight

because the Europeans say that they are

allowed for local rule and national

sovereignty and

democratic nations reflecting the

Preferences of their constituencies they

should be allowed to have those rules in

the US it’s backed by the WTO says nope

that’s your domestic policies are not

aligning with the sense of global

efficiency and that is actually a much

more interesting discussion to be having

then is trade good or is trade bad

suddenly we’re discussing national

sovereignty we’re discussing local rule

we’re discussing what do we mean by

environmental regulations and are we

okay with with them being trumped under

what circumstances so here’s a second

example and this happened this year in

the u.s. in the US it used to be or it

is that if you wanted to put your tuna

on the shelf and say dolphin free tuna

on it it actually you had to use methods

that actually excluded dolphins and the

Mexican government got wind of that and

said you know that doesn’t that’s not

fair that discriminates against Mexican

fishermen because Mexican fishermen fish

in waters that are dolphin heavy and

they use methods that don’t exclude

dolphins so by having this law where

we’re actually discriminating against

Mexican fishermen and the WTO agreed so

we have you know these efficiency

problems you know what do we how do we

how do we think about global efficiency

how do we promote the free movement of

as much Goods and as much services

across as many borders as possible while

at the same time preserving the laws and

regulations that prize things that

aren’t about global efficiency that are

maybe about you know racial equality or

about protecting the environment or laws

the prize public health issues things

like that that gets us up to where we

are today you may have noticed that the

conversation that we’re having about

trade on the national stage right now is

very confused we’ve got both of our

presidential candidates you appear to be

in favor of free trade but are against

the trans-pacific partner

that’s that massive trade deal that

would connect the United States and 11

other Pacific Rim countries and then you

have other organizations like the AARP

and the Sierra Club and Doctors Without

Borders that are opposed to elements of

it and people are telling us you know oh

you’re either for treat free trade or

you’re against it or you’re for

globalization or you’re against it you

know what kind of world do you want to

live in well we’re not talking about

trade we’re talking about rules we’re

talking about global rules global

standards and what kind of world we want

that to be and as soon as you sort of

change your mind and you and you realize

that that’s what we’re talking about it

all starts to make a lot more sense so I

want to leave you guys with that idea we

created the world that we live in now

our forefathers got together at Bretton

Woods and they created this global

economy that we have now and they and we

remade it in the late 80s and the 90s

with the World Trade Organization the

rules that we that we pass and we

embrace are the rules of the game that

we live in so let’s think about that

let’s think about trade in that context

let’s think about what rules we want to

embrace what we want them to serve you

know do we want global efficiency to be

the paradigm that we that we think of or

do we want it to be something else maybe

like global prosperity global prosperity

for for normal people for farmers and

ranchers and you know everyday Americans

it’s because the rules that we pass are

the rules of the game and when we talk

about trade we’re talking about rules

thank you so much [Applause]

Please follow and like us: