Press "Enter" to skip to content

We need to talk about Physics | Helen Czerski | TEDxManchester


as you heard I’m a physicist and I think

that the way we talk about physics needs

a little bit of modification

I am from just down the road here I

don’t live here anymore

but uh coming from around here means

that I have a northern Nana my mum’s ma

and Nana is very bright she hasn’t had

much formal education but she’s sharp

and when I was a second year

undergraduate studying physics at

Cambridge I remember spending an

afternoon at Nana’s house in instan

studying quantum mechanics and I had

these folders open in front of me with

this

you know hieroglyphics let’s be honest

and now that came along and she looked

at this folder and she said what’s that

and I said it’s quantum mechanics Nana

and I tried to explain something about

this these what was on the page ships to

do with the nucleus an Einstein a and B

coefficients and and now that looked

very impressed and then she said or what

can you do when you know that don’t know

no no and I think I said something about

computers but and because it was all I

could think of at the time but you can

broaden that question out because it’s a

very good question what can you do and

you know that it when that is physics

and I’ve come to realize that when we

talk about physics and society or in our

sort of image of it we don’t include

the things that we can do when we know

that our perception of what physics is

needs a bit of a shift and not only does

it need a bit of a shift but this

perspective sharing this different

perspective matters for our society and

I’m not just saying that because I’m a

physicist and I’m biased and I think

we’re the most important people in the

world honest so the image of physics

right we’ve got an image problem let’s

be honest and it hasn’t moved on much

from this this is a very famous

photograph it’s from the Solvay

conference in 1927 and this is when the

great minds of physics were grappling

with what it you know

the nature of determinism and what it

means only to have a probability that a

particle might be somewhere and whether

any of it was real and it was all very

difficult and you’ll notice that they’re

all very stern looking men in suits I’m

Marie Curie I keep nearly saying Marie

Antoinette marry which would be a turn

up for the books and Marie Curie third

from the left on the bottom there she

was allowed in but she had to dress like

everybody else so this was the this

resistive this is the you know this is

what physics is like there’s all this

kind of hieroglyphics these are to do

with waves and particles that is an

artist’s impression of two black holes

colliding which makes it look worth

watching to be honest I’m glad I didn’t

have to write the risk assessment for

whatever was going on there the point is

this is the image of physics right it’s

weird and difficult it’s done by

slightly strange people dressed in a

slightly strange way it’s inaccessible

it’s somewhere else and fundamentally

why should I care

hmm and the problem with that is that

I’m a physicist and I studied this come

on this this this is my job right I

study the interface between the

atmosphere and the ocean the atmosphere

is massive the ocean is massive the thin

layer that joins them together is really

important because that’s where things go

from one huge reservoir to the other you

can see that the sea surface I was that

was me took this video the average

height of those waves by the way was 10

meters so this is definitely it’s

definitely physics happening here

there’s lots of things this is

definitely physics and you know it’s not

included in our cultural perception of

physics and that bothers me so what is

included in our cultural perception of

physics well so because I’m a physicist

there has to be a graph right that’s

allowed and so we’ve got time along the

bottom here from very small very fast

things there’s very long things that

take a long time over here small things

at the bottom big things up there so our

current cultural image of physics looks

like this

there’s quantum mechanics down in that

corner it’s very small it’s very weird

it happens very quickly

and it’s a long way down in the general

you know on the scale events in the

matters for everyday life and then

there’s cosmology which is up there very

large very far away also very weird

if you go to some places like black

holes in the beginning of the universe

those who join up around the back and we

know that these are frontiers in physics

right there’s lots of work being done to

discover new physics in these places but

the thing is you will notice there’s a

very large gap in the middle and in that

gap there are many things there are

planets and toasts and volcanoes and

clouds and clarinets and bubbles and

dolphins and toast and all sorts of

things that make up our everyday life

and these are also run by physics u-visa

but there is physics in the middle it’s

just that nobody talks about it

and the thing about all of these is that

they all run on some a relatively small

number of physical laws things like

Newton’s laws of motion thermodynamics

some rotational dynamics the physics in

the middle applies over a huge range

from very very small things to very very

big things you have to try very hard to

get outside of this and there is also a

frontier in research physics here it’s

just that nobody talks about it and this

is the world of the complex when these

laws work together they bring they bring

about the beautiful messy complex world

we live in and fundamentally this is the

bit that really matters to me on an

everyday basis and this is the bit that

we don’t talk about there’s plenty of

physics research going on here but

because it isn’t doesn’t involve

pointing at stars people somehow some

reason think it’s not there now the cool

thing about this is that there’s so many

things in this middle pit that this

middle bit all following the same

physical laws that we can see those laws

at work almost all the time around us so

I’ve got the video here oh here we go

yes right so the game is one of these

eggs is raw and one of them has been

boiled and I want you to tell me which

ones which it’s good that in it which

ones raw the one on the left

yes and even though you might not have

tried that you all knew and the reason

for it is that you set the spinning

that’s all right and then when you stop

the cooked egg the one that’s completely

solid you stop the entire egg when you

stop the other one you only stop the

shell the liquid inside is still

rotating because nothing’s made it stop

and then it pushes the shell around

again so that the egg starts to rotate

again and this is brilliant right

it’s a demonstration of something in

physics that we call the law of

conservation of angular momentum which

basically says that you set something

spinning about a fixed axis it will keep

spinning unless you do something to stop

it and that’s really fundamental in how

the universe works and it’s not just

eggs that there applies to although it’s

really useful if you’re the sort of

person and apparently these people do

exist who boil eggs and then put them

back in the fridge

who does that don’t admit to it it’s

okay we won’t judge you um so but it’s

also got much broader applicability so

this is the Hubble Space Telescope the

Hubble Ultra Deep Field which is a very

tiny part of the sky and Hubble has been

floating in free space for 25 years not

touching in the thing and yet it can

point at a tiny region of sky forever

there are half days it did it in

sections accurately enough to take

amazing images like this so the question

is how does something that is not

touching anything how does it know where

it is and the answer is that in the

middle of it it has something that to my

great disappointment isn’t a raw egg but

basically does the same job it’s got

gyroscopes which are spinning and

because of the law of conservation of

angular momentum

they keep spinning with the same axis

indefinitely and Hubble kind of rotates

around them and so it can orient itself

so the same little physical law that we

can play with in the kitchen and use

also explains some of what makes

possible some of the most advanced

technology of our time and so you sort

so this is the fun bit of physics for me

it’s that you learn these patterns and

then you can apply them again and again

and again and it’s really rewarding when

you spot them in new places this is the

fun of physics I have shown that egg

video to a an audience full of business

people once and they’re all very sort of

dressed up very smartly and trying to

employ that they’re trying to impress

their bosses and I ran it was running

out of time so I showed the egg video

and then so the way you can work it out

you can ask me afterwards to check and I

left the stage and then I had literally

middle-aged grown men tugging on my

sleeve afterwards saying is it this is

it this and then I said yes to it yes

right the joy that you get from like

these are spotting these patterns

doesn’t go away when you’re an adult and

that’s really important because physics

is all about patterns and the small

of patents give you access to all almost

all of the physics in our everyday world

and the thing that’s best about this is

it evolves playing with toys things like

the egg shouldn’t be dismissed as the

mundane little things that we just give

the kids to play with on a Saturday

afternoon to keep them quiet this is the

stuff that actually really matters

because this is the laws of the universe

and it applies to eggs and toast of all

you butter side down and all sorts of

other things just as much as it applies

to modern technology and anything else

that’s going on in the world so I think

we should play with these patterns so

there are basically there are a small

number of concepts that you can become

familiar with using things in your

kitchen that are really useful for life

in the outside world so if you want to

learn about thermodynamics a duck is a

good place to start for example why is

that feet don’t get cold and once you’ve

got a bit of thermodynamics with the

duck you can also explain fridges and

magnets that you can play with in your

kitchen get you two wind turbines and

modern energy generation raisins in them

neighed which is always a good thing to

play with if you’re at a boring party

fish some raisins out of the bar snacks

put them in some lemonade it’s got three

consequences first thing is it’s quite

good to watch try it

secondly it sends the boring people away

thirdly it brings the interesting people

to you you win on all fronts and and

then there’s those things you know spin

and gas laws and viscosity but these

little patterns and they’ll write around

us everywhere and it’s fundamentally

democratic right everybody has access to

the same physics you don’t need a big

posh lab when I am when I wrote the book

and I have it the chapter on spin and

I’d written a bit about toast falling

butter side down and I gave the chapter

to a friend of mine who’s not a

scientist and for him to read tell me

what he thought and he took the chapter

away and he was working overseas and I

got this text message back from him a

couple of weeks later and it said um I’m

an emic breakfast in a posh hotel in

Switzerland and I really want to push

toast off the table because I don’t

believe what you wrote and that was the

good bit he doesn’t have to do he can

push the toast off the table and try it

for himself and so these laws teachers

too important there’s two important

things to know about science right

there’s the fundamental laws that we

have explained through experience and

experimentation work right the day we

drop an apple and it goes up then we’ll

have a debate about gravity up to that

point we basically know how gravity

works and we can learn the framework and

then it’s the process of experimentation

having confidence in things trying

things out critical thinking how we move

science forward and you can learn both

of those things by playing with toys in

the everyday world

um and it’s it’s really important

because you know is that there’s all

this talk about technology with her

talks about quantum computing and all

these sort of mysterious far-off things

but fundamentally we still live in

bodies that are about this size we still

walk about so on chairs that are about

this size we still live in the physical

world and knowing being familiar with

these concepts means we’re not helpless

and I think it’s really important that

we’re not helpless that society feels it

can look at things because this isn’t

about knowing all the answers it’s about

having the framework so you can ask the

right questions and by playing with

these fundamental little things in

everyday life we gain the confidence to

ask the right questions so there’s a

bigger thing in answer to Nana’s

question about what you can do when you

know that because there’s lots of stuff

in the everyday world that you can do

when you know that especially if you’ve

got eggs in the fridge and and there’s a

much deeper answer ah

and the stuff is all the fun in the

curiosity that you could have playing

with toys because we shouldn’t by the

way toys why should kids have all the

fun right all of us can have fun playing

with toys and we shouldn’t be

embarrassed about it you can blame me

it’s fine

so when it comes to reasons for studying

physics for example here is the best

reason I can think of I think that each

of us has three life support systems

we’ve got our own body we’ve got a

planet and we’ve got our civilization

each of those is an independent life

support system keeping us alive in its

own way and they all run on this

fundamental physical laws that you can

learn in the kitchen with eggs and

teacups and lemonade and everything else

you can play with go back doesn’t like

me this may be a

okay never mind and so but this is some

fundamental physical laws are playing

about it and so but this is the reason

for example that something like climate

change is such a serious problem it’s

because it’s two of these life support

systems our planet and our civilization

kind of butting up against each other

they’re in conflict and we need to

negotiate that boundary and the

fundamental physical laws that we can

learn that are the way the world around

us works are the tools at the basis of

everything they’re the foundation

there’s lots of things to know about in

life but knowing the foundations is

gonna get you a long long way and I

think this if you’re not interested in

having fun with physics or anything like

that

strange but anyway apparently these

people exist and you can you surely are

interested in keeping yourself alive

right in how our life-support systems

work because the framework for physics

is remarkably constant right it’s the

same in lots and lots of things that we

measure it’s not going to change anytime

soon they might discover some new

quantum mechanics but apples right here

are still gonna fall down so the

question is how I’ve got asked you know

I get asked sometimes how do you start

what’s the place to start if you’re

interested in the physical world in not

being helpless and in finding some toys

to play with so here is my suggestion to

you so some things to start with so it

starts right the place that starts is

that moment and adults do this right you

you’re drifting along somewhere and you

spot something and your brain goes oh

that’s weird and then your conscious

nose goes oh you and I don’t keep going

and I like that’s the point right hold

that thought that bit where you’re going

oh that’s a bit odd because there’s

something there to play with and it’s

worth you playing with it so that’s the

place to start but if you don’t have any

of those little moments on your way home

from from this event here are some

things to start with like I said put

raisins in lemonade it’s highly

entertaining

watch your coffee spill dry I know that

sounds a little bit like watching paint

dry but it does do quite weird things

it’s worth watching um get I am you know

what I’m an acquired taste at dinner

parties if there are tea cups around

there are so many things you can do to

play with tea cups it’s brilliant the

most obvious one is to get a tea cup get

a spoon

tap the teacup around the rim and listen

and you will hear something strange and

the other thing is put your toast off

the table push some toast on the table

because you can write and you’ll learn

stuff from it and if you’re feeling

really ambitious try and push it off in

such a way that it doesn’t fall butter

side down which is possible so the point

of all of this is that first of all we

should all play with toys right we

shouldn’t be afraid to investigate the

physical world for ourselves with the

tools around us because we all have

access to them it matters because if we

want to understand society if we want to

be good citizens we need to understand

the framework on which everything else

must be based so playing with toys is

great understanding how to keep our

life-support systems going is great but

fundamentally the thing that we need to

change in the way that we talk about

physics is that we need to understand

that physics isn’t out there with weird

people and strange hieroglyphics for

somebody else in a posh lab physics is

right here it’s for us and we can all

play with it thank you very much [Music]

Please follow and like us: