Press "Enter" to skip to content

Unchanging Man: Relationships, Behaviours & Brains in The Digital Age | Dan Machen | TEDxManchester


good morning everyone can I just do a

little experiment before I start because

this being Ted everyone should have

their phones away and on silent

obviously but anyone who’s got a phone

in their hand and this is not like a

teacher spotting people chewing gum can

you just put it in the air it’s a pretty

good

you’re obviously massively advanced

security ed audience but I think that

that’s what I want to talk about so it’s

just the intimacy of our relationship

with technology and what that actually

does to us and I think most importantly

what it does to our brains so literally

what is going on with our heads when we

pick up a smartphone and I think this

came out some research that we did and

what’s fascinating is when you talk to

people about their smart everything we

do a lot of behavioral research at a

human which is marketing communications

agency and it’s normally normal except

when you start speaking to people about

smart phones and you say to them do you

think you use it too much do you think

could I just take it off you so we can

happen they’re like no no it’s fine it’s

absolutely fine I don’t need to cut down

on it at all it’s it’s called it is

called just leave it with me

and I just thought this isn’t normal

this is a really strange thing and so we

had to start to look at this and what um

what also provoked me which is a tough

tough visa to fight was this guy who was

the god of advertising Bilbo back and he

famously said and bear in mind he said

this in the 50s it’s taking millions of

years for our behaviors to evolve it

take millions more for them to even vary

and so although it’s fashionable to talk

about unchanging man sorry talk about

changing man we must focus on unchanging

man and I just had a real issue with

this in that I thought it was bollocks

and so I set up and it’s really it’s

really tough to take this guy on because

all the big thinkers and advertising are

informed by this guy and they just say

well it’s not there’s no such thing as

new behavior it’s just the same

behaviour especially technology and I

think bearing in mind he said this in

the 50s when all we had to worry about

was TVs radios and

this wacky thing called a record player

you know I just thought he can’t have

anticipated what was gonna come and I

think you know Volkers taught was

fantastic in terms of just how fast this

stuff is accelerating and so I thought

let’s look at the neuroscience on this

and I kind of this is not my day job so

I’m not a neuroscientist I kind of work

in work in marketing but I thought we’ve

got to get into it and what I found was

was incredible so I think you know this

sort of headlines are we all think of

this as multitask

multitasking and that’s kind of our

cultural narrative in terms of what we

think we’re doing with these machines

but actually we’re fragmenting our

attention and we have a very finite

precious human attention I think the

important thing is spending more of that

in the world I think then there’s also

this sense of responsibility we

absolutely have a personal

responsibility to control the amount we

use our devices and how we use them but

we forget about the thousands of people

on the other side of the screen in

Silicon Valley whose job it is to make

you come back to that screen as often as

possible

and what’s fascinating about them is

some of the modules that a study in

terms of behavioral design is based on

clicker training for dogs so it’s kind

of you know probably offends you as much

as it offended me but it’s kind of it’s

just that sense off they want that

Pavlovian response and my wife’s here

today thank you and apologies for

looking at my phone so much but I think

that’s the thing you know and we see

this all the time when my phone will

ping and I can’t I can’t resist I try to

but you sort of have to have a look I

have to have a look and so that’s really

you know that’s really what’s going on

so that was kind of my day job and then

I thought well actually this stuff’s

really fascinating how can I actually

make that how can I make work allow me

to study this more so this is an amazing

visualization of my gasoline labs called

the glass brain fly-through and this is

a real visualization of thoughts flying

around the brain in real-time so these

these thoughts go 268 miles per hour

which is faster than a Formula One car

and this you know the brain has about a

hundred trillion interconnections so

it’s actually the most complex structure

that we know of in the universe

and I you know they’re the way that

memories encoded is thought to be a

quantum process in your neurons and yet

we so with this amazing you know the

most advanced structure we know of in

the universe

what are we feeling it with cats pee

cucumbers Facebook Twitter all the time

and I just thought you know this has to

this has to be having a serious impact

on our attention and the amount of

energy we’ve got and I think you know

just looking at how that kind of how

that sort of racks up I’m really

grateful for the Moore’s Law

introduction music saves me time but

it’s kind of I think Moore’s Law is just

this sense that we’ve got this ever

advancing march of machines and you know

that this that’s becoming increasingly

vertical line and that’s happened over

scale of 40 years you know and Gordon

Moore thought it would last for ten

years but it’s carried on going and I

think you know if in Bruce Lee terms if

we’re higher or lower in terms of the

brain and this is a time scale of 20,000

years how’s the brain doing how are we

getting on in terms of our little

noggins

there we are flatlining at the bottom

I personally blame Jeremy Kyle I’m not

sure specifically what the reasoning is

for this but over 20,000 years we’ve

actually lost a tennis ball size of grey

matter

maybe a glass debris I don’t know but a

tennis ball size a brain matter and I

mean the good news is that doesn’t mean

we’re entering an era see Donald Trump

aside but I think it just it’s just this

sense of you know our brains are

optimizing to cope with digital lives so

but I think that the biggest thing is

that the demand for our attention is

massively up stripping our finite human

capabilities so that’s kind of the main

point I think if we just look at what

that makes us this feels very true to me

you know the rich of rich of form and

the playwright describers as pancake

people all right and I just think that’s

kind of that’s how it feels and it’s you

know it’s really exhilarating though so

why do we do it then and I don’t know

about you guys but that constantly been

connected to the to the digital world is

a really exhilarating thing

I’m if you get me in an eBay auction I

can’t I can’t come away from it you know

and I think that’s what’s what’s unique

to the brain is it’s driven by this sort

of cocktail of hormones and dopamine is

probably the principle player in this in

this space and its really to do with

task operations every time we win that

eBay auction send an email send a tweet

we get a little hit of dopamine and it’s

disposing the brain to a kind of reward

system so I think it’s difficult to talk

about it in terms of addiction because I

think that’s an exaggeration but it’s

definitely habituation and what would be

interesting as well is just a little

show of hands if you would how many of

you have ever felt your phone vibrating

your pocket I need to take it out and

then there’s nothing on the phone right

so pretty much everyone the good news is

you’re not nutters this has actually

looked at medically and it’s called

phantom vibration syndrome it’s true

thing I’m not making Google this I’m not

making out and it’s because your brain

is so disposed to the reward that sits

at the end of your phone either you

getting your phone out and getting that

message or whatever it might be that it

taps you you know you might get a muscle

twitch and it taps you on the shoulder

and says hey you have a look at that it

could be something rewarding in that for

us so that’s that’s what’s kind of going

on so I think you know it’s really we

are digital dopes but it’s what can we

start to do about that and I think the

you know as I talk you through our

research you’ll start to see what people

actually frame it as in their minds

that’s fundamentally wrong I think the

biggest thing we found and we did

research with old people young people

male and female and everyone says it’s

just multitasking it just helps me

control my life I love it you know I

can’t be without my phone I can’t live

without my phone but what we actually

found and I’ll show you what happens in

the brain in just a second is that

people are actually not multitasking

their task switching so this describes

flitting attention between screens

constantly and normally the screen

that’s closest to us will demand our

attention but as you do that it actually

depletes energy you lower your actual

attention and we found from sort of

single tasks which is about 90 percent

recall

to giving people a smartphone or a

laptop they drop their attention to

about a third and so all the time

although we think we’re just

multitasking in a bit like the phantom

vibration syndrome actually something

much deeper is going on at a

physiological level so let’s let’s jump

into the brain and actually see what

happens

so I think you know primarily when we

gave people a single task always quite

rosy in the garden so you’ll see kind of

activity the front of the brain in the

cortex which is kind of a thinking part

and then it was cycling back to the

hippocampus which is the mem the memory

center of the brain we think most others

but and I think that was you know that

was kind of fine and in that sort of

quite quite passive but focused state we

got really good recall what gets

interesting and you’ve heard the term

brainstorm before is what happens when

they start the task switch so what as

you give people a laptop or a mobile

phone it activates an area of the brain

called the striatum which is much more

to do with doing things that engage in

the hands and recall just drops off the

cliff and not only that but emotional

engagement and also you know just in

terms of energy they reach such a stage

called cognitive collapse which is

probably what explains reality TV you

know we kind of get home in a night out

and we want to watch stuff that allows

us to veg out and so I think you know if

you think about the strands in our

program it’s kind of deck decorating

stuff cooking stuff or watching people

watching telly you know don’t be right I

love gogglebox but I think it’s quite

interesting to think of the reasons

behind why some of the programs we love

are so popular so space that’s where we

got to the big things now what do we do

about it so I think that I just wanted

to give you a few practical steps I

think as you know it’s Volker alluded to

this train is running we can’t get off

it it’s chairlift to say my kids aren’t

gonna touch texting technology they have

to to live in the world that we have but

I think there are things we can start to

do so a lot of people now have fitbit’s

so we’re starting to get into quantified

behavior from point of view of our

physical activity I think the big

opportunity now is to look at how can we

actually monitor our digital activity

better

so there’s a couple of apps here one

called moment for Apple and one called

break free for Android that will

actually look at how long you spend on

your phone so I started using this

recently and I found out that I spend

about three hours a day on my phone and

and that that basically you know adds up

to six weeks across the year so when you

start to think of it in those terms and

the other things you could be doing it

actually makes you start to want to

actually change things a little bit I

think the other part that’s really

really reassuring is to focus on people

not platforms and yet a lot of you will

have got notifications recently saying

so-so is now live on Facebook that you

just couldn’t give two hoots about right

and that’s the platform trying to push

their new functionality and I think

what’s really interesting given I think

we have a clouded view of how we use

technology and what it does to our brain

is the guy in Silicon Valley that

designs all this stuff is called doctor

fog there’s no word of a light sounds

like a Bond villain in his lair right

and so he runs the behavioral design

laboratory that trains people around

things like the dog clicker and he also

uses this module where he leads to it a

never-ending suit ball so there was a

experiment they did where they fed soup

from the bottom of a soup bowl to see

how much people would carry on eating

and on average people eat 78 percent

more soup and so this is you know this

is these are the kind of conversations

that’s going on in terms of how they

want us to just keep the need for feed

the whole time now the good news is

there’s a fifth column within dr. Fox

laboratory so guy called Tristan Harris

who’s described as the conscience of

Silicon Valley sir suddenly had a Jerry

Maguire moment so he kind of left and

set up a movement called time well-spent

and he’s actually I think you know the

vanguard of something that’s incredibly

important which is the realization that

Silicon Valley needs to take

responsibility for helping us change our

behaviors as well so he talks about

moving your social apps off your front

screen charging outside the bedroom a

lot of people charge in the bedroom

that’s hard

my alarm clock now you don’t buy an

alarm clock so 87% of people touch their

phone between midnight and 5:00 a.m.

which is such a terrible impact on what

we do but I think importantly empower

people to contact you in terms of your

notifications but it shut down any

platform notification so that was kind

of the advice from from Tristan Harris

and I think finally and I thought about

bringing this as a physical property

would have been a very uncomfortable

start for you just think about presence

and purpose so if technology is a tool I

think there’s some social norming around

what we do with phones that we wouldn’t

do with other tools so if we just you

know replace that for a second with a

hammer which is also a tall you wouldn’t

take a hammer out in a meeting and put

it on the table even if it was on silent

right you wouldn’t you wouldn’t go to

the toilet and go off a wasted trip and

got my hammer and you certainly wouldn’t

take your hammer out in the pub you know

unless you wanted Swift the rest so I

think it’s just really thinking about we

do have this finite attention it’s so

precious and we have such fleeting lives

we’ve got to spend more of it in the

world and so just coming full circle

back to Bill he was right you know I did

all this research and weirdly I expected

kind of a digitized brain in the middle

of it all but actually I found human

beings whose frailties and need for

connection has been amplified hugely by

technology but I think you know we need

to be concerned about the fact that way

unchanging in the midst of this

Maelstrom so the trainer is running

absolutely and I think it’s how we direct it this the next stage that’s me

Please follow and like us: