Press "Enter" to skip to content

Warning! Graphic Content: Using humor for social change | Dwayne “Mr. Fish” Booth | TEDxPenn


[Music]
[Music]
[Music]
tell me what’s really good how has
nobody taken advantage of the fact that
you have a silhouette you’ve got this
dramatic music you have to strike a pose
and so yes
send your pescado to my spanish-speaking
friends as well and one more note –
there is documentary about me and the
filmmaker is desperately needing a
dramatic ending so if there’s an
assassin here tonight and and I am your
target please have the courtesy to wait
until the end of the talk so it has the
dramatic punch that I think the film
could use so thank you so let’s begin
with a question what is an artist this
is an artist what qualifies an artist to
make him or her a unique commentator
when it comes to political ideas and
cultural ideas it’s not a question that
you’re used to hearing because generally
speaking artists are no longer included
in the public debate about what we are
as citizens and where we should be going
and that is a problem and I’m going to
explain to you why how many people have
ever had an itch you can raise your hand
looks like everybody has had an itch
okay
second part of that question is how many
of you had have had an itch while you’re
in public that decorum prevents you from
scratching
everybody has right there’s a number of
of techniques that you can use you know
my favorite perhaps being is now wait
where did I put those lottery tickets
but everybody has a method to cope with
it okay so the second part of that
question is if you are in a private
space and you get that same itch what do
you do then you scratch it you
immediately scratch it there is never a
moment when you do what you do in public
which is try to pretend that you don’t
have the itch you attack it you go
straight for the itch depending on your
commitment it’s either with this or it’s
with this but you acknowledge it and you
take care of it it’s an irritant that
you satisfy your itch you scratch and
the angels did sing right so why is this
significant let’s think about where an
artist does the majority of his or her
work they do it in private right so in
this space that we’ve already
established as being a place where you
can actually be very honest and you can
address irritants and things that bother
you let’s expand the definition of what
a niche is because I was talking about
corporeal edges right there are
cognitive itches there are ideas that
you share with your friends you have
personally inside of you that you don’t
feel safe because of this decorum to
bring out into the public square there
are historical examples of that at one
time it was impolite and considered
politically incorrect actually to engage
with notions such as African Americans
are not inferior women are not the
lesser sex gays lesbians and transgender
people are not moral degenerates at one
time you could not paw at the
it is in the public square because they
were considered too crude but luckily
there were artists thinkers outlaws
deviants who are willing to go against
decorum and what is polite and as a
result as a society we are considerably
less itchy and that is a very good thing
so what I do as a political cartoonist
and as an artist one of the best
vehicles let’s remind you I am this is
what an artist is it’s can I have a
grant so I can finish my art
yes we’re just going to keep bringing it
back to sort of like deep deep
significant ideas with some of these
images so I would argue that you need a
technique to bring controversial ideas
into the public square what is perhaps
the greatest delivery system I would
argue traditionally has been jokes
because jokes they you have to actually
be a little bit of a bad boy or a bad
girl you have to step out of this
straight and narrow you have to consider
alternatives you have to embrace
diversity in many ways right so these
little excuses where I’ll just say it
permit you to scratch your ass in public
just for a moment
right so let’s look at some of these
jokes and as a Helen said at the
beginning of the day you may be offended
by some of these things or you may not
but pay attention to whether this
inspires you to have an itch that you
need to scratch or it scratches an itch
for you and you go ah the point is is
that these are ideas that are presented
in art these are not bayonets these are
pencils so they are non-lethal so they
are safe to consider inside your mind
and inside my mouth when I speak them so
stretching extra exercises so let’s just
have a little fun with some of these
this is Jesus as a young man learning
carpentry
this one for you who can’t people can’t
read it in the back this is people this
is Bert talking people are so worried
about what gay marriage will do to the
community and the irony is that they
probably learned all about what a
community is from me and I’ve had a
guy’s hand up my ass for the last 40
years this is great news we just found
out that justice isn’t really blind and
that she’s into rich white guys this is
the stairway to democracy and also the
stairway to fascism this is before we
throw a ton of money into constructing a
tomb for the unknown finger we should
first determine if it’s saying you
or we’re number one and of course for
the kids we have fly creationism which
is in the beginning God made a whole lot
of while we’re operating at such a
sort of sophisticated level actually
it’s not as great as it sounds it’s the
only position she’ll try
and this of course is Cupid afraid that
his parents are starting to suspect that
he’s discovered masturbation and since
we’re close to Easter let’s end with a
big bang sorry baby not tonight I got to
rise up early tomorrow okay so what have
we learned I love having that phrase
after images like that at a TED event
now what have we learned that we made a
mistake in booking Senor pescado so what
we’ve learned is that there are two
really when you think about it basically
there there are two realities that we
typically navigate in a day
there’s your private self which you
where you can be yourself and you can
you can address irritants and you can be
honest about what is happening with you
and how you interact with the world and
then there is the your public self where
you’re much more conservative and you’re
much less likely to voice your opinion
and do something about it and engage the
world in such a way that is positive and
and meaningful so when you when you
consider two realities what does that do
to the concept of truth you can’t have
two realities and then have a consistent
truth right so something’s happening and
what I would propose since I don’t have
that long I could talk for hours on this
is that what we’re doing is we’re
inventing a substitute reality and
imaginary reality that we’re conflating
with real-life objects and people and
situations and making them the same
thing when they’re not okay so to put
this in a way that is very easy for
everybody to engage with we do with our
money every single debt take for
instance a penny which I know I have a
penny in here somewhere
I do so if you consider the penning it’s
a scent right it’s both of those things
but let’s break it down
you have the physicality of the penny it
has mass it’s a statement of fact it’s
undeniable
you can touch it you can really can
actually see it but it is also a cent
which is the imaginary value of the
penny and we’ve conflated them to be the
same thing and so what that does is it
creates a situation where you think that
you are actually perceiving your
imagination when you look at a penny and
that’s problematic because you’re seeing
a fantasy and that is that that’s a lie
and we do it with also with words we do
it with words that turn into concepts
they don’t have intrinsic value until
they are labeled as such for you for
example does anybody know what this is
did somebody say something oh well since
I have the microphone and I am
all-powerful I will say what this is
this is the Sanskrit word for inner
peace is it inner peace no it is not
inner peace it is a label that is used
to represent inner peace and if you
don’t have the ability to read this word
then it is absolutely meaningless so
therefore it has no intrinsic value
until one is imagined on it if you
consider a menu the words on a menu are
drastically different than what you
receive when you order from a menu only
one of those things you can taste you
can savor and is nourishing and the
other is not if you don’t want to take
my word for it let’s look at somebody
who has more credibility than may Flo
bear somebody heard it Flo bear human
speech is like a cracked kettle on which
we tap crude rhythms for bears to dance
– while we long to make music they will
melt the stars so it’s been going on for
a long time this recognition of the the
incongruity between what we think about
something the concept of reality and the
intrinsic experience of reality to give
you one more analogy no matter how good
the writing is reading about a roller
coaster ride is never going to compare
to the actual experience of riding a
roller coaster okay we are speechless
when we are riding a roller coaster and
that’s the experience it’s not this
right there are different things
whoever says yippee anyway when you’re
actually on a roller coaster now that I
think about it I’m going to start doing
that and there are other examples too
you look at something like this this is
green everybody understands what green
is but it’s because you understand you
know how to read this language this is
the label this is the experience so they
are two different things and sometimes
as a cartoonist it’s my job to figure
out what happens when you have these two
conflated realities as they move along
and then when they separate right
because sometimes when you’re looking at
a political cartoon or engaging in
political conversation particularly
currently it all starts to happen in
here it starts to become this it’s
either it’s it’s intellectualized hate
you’re not feeling it here so I try to
create cartoons that acknowledge this
conflation between imaginary reality and
real reality and then what happens when
those two things separate what can we
learn where do we go what resonates as
truth for us so consider this we have a
murder
we have massacre
we have genocide and then we have
investment opportunities okay so it’s
the same it’s the concept and it’s the
experience it’s the concept and then
it’s the experience and there’s that
difference so then the question becomes
how do we devise a way of recognizing
those differences between the intrinsic
reality and the conceptual reality okay
because when you’re looking at a penny
going back to the penny analogy a penny
only has value to me because it has
value to you right if you didn’t
recognize the value of a cent it would
just be meaningless and so what do we do
what are what are we doing to perpetuate
this idea that our imaginations have
credibility as reality how does that get
perpetuated it gets perpetuated by
creating narrow mythologies that
everybody or the majority can agree is a
viable truth that we should all abide by
and so when that happens you end up with
a very over simplistic notion about what
your responsibilities are in a society
you create ideas about us and then you
vilify people you turn yourself into a
hero so there is a way to recognize how
to separate these two things at least I
think so
and what that thing is is empathy
because you do not require empathy to
recognize the value of ascent but you do
require empathy to recognize the value
of another human being and even of
yourself or of the environment and you
can tell the difference it’s not a
decision it’s an experience and you know
what is true and what is so
my job often as a political cartoonist
is to avoid the left side of the aisle
and the right side of the aisle and look
for what makes us all human it’s finding
this MP this empathy so I’m going to
show a couple more images that rather
than blab and say this is this and this
is that none of them have gag lines just
see if there’s something that resonates
inside these images for you that
provides a truth or an experience or
creates an itch or scratches in it
and this is one that I will actually say
a few words about just Eve context this
last summer I was tasked with the job by
TruthDig comm who I often work for to
cover the National the Democratic
National Convention here in the city and
the idea was that I would go and I would
attend and I would be a snarky political
cartoonist and create really funny
images about the circus that was
happening in this town I had every
intention of doing that but putting
yourself into a situation and seeing
other human beings around you changes
your responsibility we start to
recognize the humanity so I found myself
at Dilworth Park just outside of City
Hall which have you ever seen it in the
summer time it’s turned the plaza is
turned into interactive fountains and
you children come and they play many
inner-city kids just that’s their entire
day it’s just playing
among these fountains so I found myself
focusing on these two boys and they were
brothers and they were completely
engaged in play and it was precious and
it demonstrated a vulnerability that we
all need to be reminded about it was
beautiful what I didn’t have in this
image other than the other children I
pulled out and the convention goers and
protestors off to the side maybe by 15
feet was a chapter of the Westboro
Baptist Church if you don’t know who
they are they enjoy screaming through
megaphones about how God hates
Muslims Catholics Jews screaming and
what was meaningful and precious about
this seemed to me was this deep
significance of this human activity and
that this is what is going to sustain us
it’s not about figuring out the right
way to play our politics it’s
recognition of the human heart and
recognition of
the empathy that is the only thing
that’s going to give us cohesion as a
species start thinking about us as a
species so that’s what I wanted to
capture with that image because until we
figure out the preciousness and the
vulnerability of what we are just as
beings we’re always going to be at risk
from people who want to cheapen us into
something else
so if there’s nothing else that you
leave with from me this afternoon leave
with this never recognize this as music
don’t trick yourself into seeing this
and saying it is music your literacy
will tell you that you’re looking at
music because if this is music to you
and you accept this as the definition of
music you will miss the opportunity to
sing and you will miss the opportunity
to hear other people saying and if you
do that the great tragedy is you miss
the opportunity to dance and if you miss
the opportunity to dance then you miss
what it really truly means to be
speechless
[Music]
[Applause]
Please follow and like us: