Press "Enter" to skip to content

Transforming History Education through Virtual Reality | Tony Ford | TEDxTucson


[Applause]

how many of you were enthralled by your

history textbooks a few you stayed up

late at night under the blanket with a

flashlight reading history right how

many of you are history majors let’s see

your hands I’m going to take more than

five history classes in college or high

school okay for most of us though

history is a class we have to take to

graduate it is something that requires

us to memorize some dates and some

places and some names take a test and

get a degree or a diploma and most of us

know that history is an important part

of a well-rounded education and we may

have heard a quote some of the effect of

those who do not know history are doomed

to repeat it

but the actual quote is from a man named

George Santayana and in 1905 in a book

entitled a life of Reason he wrote those

who do not remember the past are

condemned to repeat it

two critically important words the first

remembering remembering is memory it is

a recollection of experience and the

second condemned condemnation implies

our guilt we are willing participants in

our own demise if we fail to remember

the past because history even what we

teach is our memory as a society it is

how we pass on the context of what we

learned the actions we took what led us

to that path and the results the real

human impact of those decisions and

actions it is that context that is

important that memory allows us to share

our greatest triumphs as a species and

it also allows us to recall and remember

our most shameful and horrible failures

so that as we

what took us to that place we can avoid

going there again as we look around our

country today and we see the rise of

fascism and ethnocentrism and hate it is

not a coincidence it happens at the same

moment that the very people who fought

those things in Europe in the 1930s and

40s are dying with them they take our

memory and without the memory of the

past we are condemned to repeat it

I want to take you further back though

there’s another echo in our history

right now in this country we are very

divided we all know that sitting here

today in fact pure research just

released a study that showed that we are

more divided now as a country than any

point in our history since the American

Civil War think about that for a second

the last time we were this divided as a

people we were literally killing each

other over it and at that point in that

war there was a leader who stood on a

stage and tried to make sense of it all

and tried to express why the price we

were paying was worth it for the promise

that is America that leader was Abraham

Lincoln and you know the speech he gave

was the Gettysburg Address many of you

learned this in school it was only ten

sentences long far shorter than what I’m

doing here on this stage if you know the

Gettysburg Address say the first line of

it with me four score and seven years

ago our fathers brought forth on this

continent a new nation conceived in

Liberty and dedicated to the proposition

that all men are created equal you

learned it you memorized it when you

learned it you probably didn’t

understand it with age and experience

you may have gained some context if you

studied history you may have understood

the historical facts and events that led

up to it but it wasn’t the true

experience of humanity you see we have a

tradition of teaching these things from

teacher to student to teacher in an oral

history that goes back before the

ancient Greeks

and somewhere in the 20th century

because of industrialization of the

requirements of a modern society we

realized we had to be more efficient and

so we distilled down the context and the

meaning of history into those things

that could be easily measured on a

scantron sheet and we lost the

experience of history it’s funny George

Santayana was a bit of a visionary he

said the great difficulty in education

is to get experience out of ideas ideas

are wonderful and we’re here to share

them today but experience is what

changes your behavior in the future it

is the recollections of your past that

changes your trajectory so how do we

give history students in modern

education experience the easiest method

would be time travel and I can’t do that

yet but I can trick port your mind you

see virtual reality is very interested

as a psychoactive technology research at

Stanford in their laboratory for virtual

reality and human behavior demonstrates

that your mind cannot tell the

difference between virtual reality and

reality and so we could put you on a

field in Gettysburg Pennsylvania

standing in the crowd and that

experience would become your memory you

would experience it as a personal

narrative you would understand better

context and emotion and human impact and

it would cease to be words on a page and

become real this is exciting for me as a

storyteller because there are kind of

three layers of narrative that we work

with the first is dictated narrative

most of you who tell stories understand

this one we have two events and a

cause-and-effect

the king died the Queen died of grief

that’s a story and that’s the kind of

story we tell very often and the brain

loves that story and it’s very

interested in it one layer deeper is

something called self-assembled

narrative and this if you watch Game of

Thrones or lost or West world as we feed

you little bits of information and

scenes and frames of reference in your

mind assembles the story

you build the story on the fly and every

time a new reveal or a new piece of

information reaches you you have to

rebuild the story and one layer deeper

this participatory narrative this is

where you are in the story everything

that happens to you is important to you

because it happens to you it’s the most

important thing right here on this edge

of self-assembled narrative and

participatory narrative this very

powerful point of immersion I only need

to make you the witness in history to

immerse you in it most of the people in

history we’re not actors they were

witnesses and so I can use it to change

your behavior because we know it works

already we use it to train medical

personnel to engage in complex

procedures that risk human life because

using virtual reality they build the

neural pathways and the muscle memory to

perform those operations when it really

counts based on their experience in

virtual reality

we used to Train first responders so

they are faced with difficult and

complex life-threatening situations they

can make mistakes where it does not cost

lives the brain doesn’t care that that

was virtual reality it remembers those

experiences and those outputs when it is

actually faced with a situation and so

those first responders remember their

past and are therefore not condemned to

repeat it

now I can’t just drop you on a

battlefield in the middle of a war

your brain can’t tell the difference we

would traumatize our high school

students they would all have PTSD and

while we’re using virtual reality to

treat PTSD I don’t think we want to fill

that pipeline just yet so I’m not going

to put you on Omaha Beach on d-day in

Normandy but I could put you on a glider

on the night before and you could sit

with men who are about to jump out of

that plane and listen to their stories

and hear why they care about what’s at

home and understand their fear and their

courage and why they are willing to make

the ultimate sacrifice to ensure fascism

never rises again on this planet and

that would become your memory you would

I know many of you are thinking this is

kind of high-tech stuff it’s probably

very expensive there’s a lot of hardware

and a lot of cost and you might be

thinking Virtual Reality involves

something like this but in fact with $1

worth of plastic lenses and the old

cardboard from a pizza box we can build

virtual reality headsets for the phone

you already have in your pocket your

phone is a virtual reality engine 85% of

American high school students have

access to smart phones today the other

15% would have them tomorrow if we

donated our phones instead of throwing

them out of recycling them for $30 we

can outfit an entire classroom with the

capability to view virtual reality

that’s the cost and it is difficult to

create virtual reality production in the

sense that what you know about movie and

TV and film the jump cut the pan shot

the close-up those things cease to exist

because in virtual reality the viewer is

the camera they choose what to see and

where to look however we have history on

how to tell those stories because on the

stage you use lighting and sound cues

and blocking to drive the narrative and

it may seem like it’s expensive to

produce this kind of content but I can

tell you that using off-the-shelf

components two years ago a small team

and I produced a four-minute spaceflight

experience based on Carl Sagan’s pale

blue dot we built the solar system at

scale and we wrapped each planet with

the scans from the public domain

available NASA files of those planets

and we built all of that in four months

for less than $20,000 the planet you see

in front of you this picture of Earth is

not a picture this is a CGI generated 3d

model that we built that’s the quality

that can be built with off-the-shelf

components so now what does that

experience like does it look like I

can’t put headsets on all of you right

now but I’m going to ask you to imagine

with me what that experience is so for a

second imagine putting a headset on and

when you open your eyes

you’re on a field in Gettysburg

Pennsylvania it is November late

November it’s cold won’t be above 60

today you’re standing in a crowd of

7,000 people who have come here to watch

behind us is a wall of cavalry horses

with mounted soldiers a complete line at

the back of the crowd they push forward

nudging us towards the dais and we can

hear the rustle of saddle leather and

the jingle of Spurs often the distance

in the middle distance we see the field

that for months prior held the Battle of

Gettysburg and while there are no

casualties remaining the flotsam and

jetsam of that terrible battle still

exists there are pieces of broken rifle

and pieces of wagon wheel and bandages

and strips of cloth and old canteens

still littered about standing the very

front row of the crowd right in front of

the dais is a line of men in bandages

missing limbs and eyes on crutches and

in chairs and they hold in front of them

a homemade banner on it is painted first

Army of the Potomac invalid division

these are the men who fought and were

wounded at Gettysburg and they stand and

look up at a president who sent them

into battle

Lincoln rises and walks to the center of

the stage he is a tall man he is a gaunt

man he has already lost one child and

another is sick he is not a very popular

president and he looks into the faces of

people asking why this division is here

what do we do next

why did we pay this terrible price then

he begins to speak the address that you

learned Lincoln had a high voice it

wasn’t low and resonant and he didn’t

use his hands to gesticulate he held

tightly a single piece of paper on which

the Gettysburg Address was written

although he did not look at it because

he had it memorized and he spoke to

Americans about how

promise of liberty and equality was why

we had to pay this terrible price he

spoke about how that promise is the very

thing that this war is being fought

about he spit the ground that we’re

standing on could not be consecrated or

made hallowed in any way further than

the sacrifices of those who fought and

died here and poured out their last full

measure of devotion and that by making

that sacrifice it demands the

responsibility in us as a country to

come together to heal divided to move

forward to build on the promise of

equality and Liberty that that sacrifice

cannot be in vain and to ensure together

that government by the people of the

people and for the people shall never

perish from this earth that moment that

experience that resonating truth of who

we are and where we need to go that is

the memory we can give your students

that is the experience they can carry

with them so that they remember the past

and we are never ever condemned to

repeat it thank you very much [Applause]

Please follow and like us: