Press "Enter" to skip to content

This is what inequality looks like | Johnny Miller | TEDxJohannesburg


I want you all to imagine something with
me for a minute imagine standing
somewhere far away from yourself outside
your own body looking back at yourself
imagine you’re on top of a mountain
imagine you’re looking at the sunset
you’re a small little silhouette you
can’t see what color clothes you have on
can’t even see your face would it make
you feel small and insignificant or
would it make you feel more connected to
everything around you I actually had
this opportunity earlier this year I had
my new toy with me I just bought a drone
and I took it up to the top of Table
Mountain because I live in Cape Town now
and I shot this video that this is a
still from I put it together it was an
awesome video everyone really liked it I
edited the video together I put it on
the internet and my friend watched it
and my friend watched it and he said to
me you wrote me an email and he said
I’ve never seen Table Mountain look like
it looks in this video and that might
seem like kind of a throwaway comment
but to me it was really really profound
I thought this is the most iconic
landmark in South Africa it’s definitely
the most iconic landmark in Cape Town
and this new perspective this what I
call a toy is actually an extremely
powerful piece of technology it totally
changed how he saw Table Mountain and I
started to think well what else could I
apply this really strong perspective
shift to this is important to me because
I’m a photographer and I always thought
that if I wanted to tell someone’s story
the best way to do that was to look into
their eyes it was to take photos show
people’s faces and try to create a sense
of empathy by looking into someone’s
eyes but I realized maybe I need to
start thinking outside the box I live in
a city where there’s tons of barriers
everywhere I live in a city where
there’s fences where there’s walls where
there’s highways
and specifically what interested me as
you can see in this photo there’s big
open green areas where people have
designed the city to be separate from
one another it’s very difficult to see
over these fences especially if you’re
living in an area like this that’s flat
because we live at ground level we don’t
get to see this perspective very often
we surround ourselves with people that
look like us we surround ourselves with
communities that seem like we should be
a part of them we drive the same cars as
our friends we have the same jobs as our
friends our kids to go to the same
schools as our friends kids go to their
schools but right next door to us
there’s this community of people who
live in red colored houses and those
people in the red colored houses they
have better cars and they have better
schools and they have parks in their
neighborhood and oh by the way their
houses are colored red and that two-lane
road that acts as a barrier to us
physically it also acts as a barrier to
us mentally it acts as a barrier to our
imagination we do this for a variety of
reasons I think we tell ourselves that
it’s natural to bond together to band
together into tribes we tell ourselves
that it’s necessary for defense that
were defending against an enemy that
were protecting our families there’s a
whole bunch of reasons that we tried to
use to justify why we like to live with
other people who look like us but my
question was always who are we defending
against and who are these enemies when I
went to University of Capetown I was
really interested in these topics like I
said and I found this map right before I
did this project I was thinking about it
it was inside my head this is a map
based on census data and this is
particularly Cape Town but there’s maps
for all the major urban metros in South
Africa and it really struck me this is
another way to look at the topic that
I’m talking about tonight with data it
really struck me how by and large people
still live in those same areas that they
were placed decades ago and they’re
bounded by this infrastructure you can
see on this map behind
you can see that blue square right in
the middle it’s surrounded by roads an
industrial area a power plant and a big
Greenbelt it’s incredible how people
can’t seem to get out of these
environments that we’ve placed them into
and that’s important because the next
slide that I’m going to show you is
income level also based on census data
from 2011 there’s a very close
correlation between people’s income
level and where they’ve been placed
throughout the last five six decades at
least in the city of Cape Town so after
seeing that video and after having my
friend comment on it and after having
all these things percolate around in my
head I decided to take this toy drone
and take it down to an area near Cape
Town where I live an area called Nord
Hook and I’d often pass by there and I
thought it was interesting because
there’s a sort of a very low-income
township area called masa boom la la
right in the middle of relatively
affluent housing estates and I thought
this would be a really interesting
perspective shift to go down there and
actually see what this looked like from
the drone and actually this is the
cul-de-sac that I flew from I found this
image on Google Streetview
yesterday the housing estates in this
area aren’t atypical of South Africa
they’re walled in with two meter high
fences it’s very difficult to see on the
other side of those fences it’s also a
flat area so it’s really difficult to
see very far or to get a perspective to
see what’s very far away from you
because everything’s flat so I decided
to try it out I hooked up my phone to my
remote controller
I put the drone in the middle of that
cul-de-sac and I took off and this is
the video that I saw when I took off
[Music]
okay so that’s the photo that I posted
on my Facebook page later that night I
only had 300 likes on my Facebook page
at the time so I wasn’t a very famous
photographer and I put it up there and I
went to bed and when I woke up in the
morning there was 40,000 people that had
viewed that photo thousands of likes
hundreds of comments hundreds of shares
I touched a nerve somehow and people
were sharing this image like crazy and
what I thought was really interesting
were the comments that people were
leaving on my facebook profile some of
them were super passionate some of them
were less passionate but they were all
invested in what I was trying to portray
here they’d all been taken by this new
perspective looking at something that
they thought they knew what it looked
like the number one comment that stuck
out to me was I didn’t know that it
looked this bad I heard that from a lot
of people and I decided right then in
there that even though I hadn’t really
even thought of continuing this project
after this first photo it was just sort
of a personal project I decided there
that it was going to be my mission to
actually show what my city actually
looked like from the air as I like to
say the beauty of how things really are
becomes apparent when you fly above them
so I went to help bay next if you guys
have ever been to Cape Town help Bay is
about 15 kilometres south of the city
bowl and it’s right next to a Township
area called a Mazama yeah – and by this
time and this was only the second day
these videos I’m sorry these photos had
80,000 a hundred thousand views people
were contacting me from all over the
world and definitely from all over South
Africa journalists other people I
realized right away that this was a much
bigger project than just Cape Town than
just local and I wanted to go to the
rest of South Africa so I very quickly
within the next couple weeks bought
myself a ticket to come to Durban and I
took a road trip throughout the big
metro areas in this area of the country
so I went from Durban to
Pietermaritzburg to the hotel
area and the last photo I took which is
the top left photo in this image that
was just a few kilometers from where
we’re sitting right now the research
that I put into all of these like I said
I used the maps earlier I also
researched on Google Earth what the
actual terrain looks like and then I
finally drove around and actually went
to these areas because I had to fly at
these areas so in my research I’m pretty
confident that I found the most unequal
areas in South Africa but I didn’t want
to just focus on wealthy versus poor I
wanted to make the project broad enough
to incorporate sort of my artistic
vision to incorporate visual metaphors
and other types of imagery that would
inspire people to want to look above
fences and to want to look at the other
side what was going on in their
neighbors yards what was going on over
the fences that they couldn’t see over
so I incorporated it too to have images
like this which is a informal settlement
right next to a cemetery in Tim bisa
which is also not too far from here
and a lot of people asked me and I think
probably some people still think well
what’s in it for me why does this matter
to me I don’t live in those places I
don’t really care about those things
what’s the big deal and my answer would
just be you’re wrong
it does matter to you and you should
care about it this little girl’s name is
Cephas Elia I met her about two months
ago in a continuation of this project
working with Thomson Reuters
she lives in Mantua BC Park which is in
Khayelitsha in Cape Town she’s 12 years
old she lives in a tin shack but she’s
your neighbor she goes to a South
African public school she’s gonna grow
up and she’s gonna have kids and she’s
gonna work and she’s going to become
your neighbor your coworker the
compatriot that you live with in your
city she’s a South Africa and this is
her neighborhood this is mano a BC Park
just as an example of the power of
shifting your perspective going from
that view that we just saw the slide
before to where she lives now and how
effective it is at getting across
certain points I want you guys to spend
the next minute and try to find where
the toilets are in this photo does
anyone see the toilets there’s not very
many of them I can tell you that there’s
25,000 people that live in mono lbc Park
you can see right here along this road
right in the middle of that road there’s
a small little block of ten toilets and
the day that I was there eight of them
were locked and two of them were broken
those are the only toilets in this
entire photograph everyone in this
photograph has to use those ten toilets
if they want to go to the bathroom if
they don’t want to use those toilets
they have to use the bush and the bush
is filled with dangers like sea Fasil a
his friend who five years ago went to
the bush to go to the bathroom and never
came back these sorts of issues these
sorts of problems that your neighbors
are dealing with that’s exactly why I
wanted to start this project and that’s
what I’m hoping that I’m starting to get
across when people want to use aerial
imagery in their storytelling in their
journalism in their policymaking people
ask me what’s my plan with the project
and I really really hope that people are
using my images and I know they are to
plan conferences to communicate ideas to
work on planning out how to better
deliver services how to better construct
houses how to make us all more equal but
really deep down what I really want out
of the project is to change people’s
mindsets is to get people to tap into
that compassion that I know we all have
that we feel for our neighbors that
neighborly love that want to better our
neighbors who live on the other side of
the fences and to do that we need to
understand what it is they’re living in
and what it is they’re living like
defining the problem is the first step
towards solving it so as I finish up
here I really invite all of you guys
after you’ve listened to me when you go
home tonight when you go to your big
houses
behind the fences imagine what it felt
like to be on this mountain and to float
away from yourself and look back in and
try to do that in your own community try
to float above your own house and try to
see yourself as part of a holistic whole
in your own City if you can visualize
that then I think our neighbors are
going to thank you very much and we’re
going to move very quickly towards
solving these problems that affect our
cities thanks very much
[Applause]
[Music]
you
[Music]
Please follow and like us: