
we are standing at a crossroads in human
history it’s not the usual kind of
crossroads that we talk about this one
has nothing to do with the catastrophe
of climate change with a wondrous
promise of artificial intelligence this
is the kind of crossroads after which we
understand our world really differently
like in 1900 that was the year we
rediscovered the works of Gregor Mendel
if you don’t remember Mendel was a 19th
century monk who painstakingly bred pea
plants and lay the foundation for
today’s genetic science it was the year
that Sigmund Freud published the
interpretation of dreams he introduced
us to the subconscious and lay the
foundation for modern psychology Mendel
and Freud radically reoriented the way
we understood our world we understood it
one way in 1899 and really differently
just a year later that is the kind of
crossroads right now here’s why many
scientists now believe that most of our
behavior is dictated by social cues they
believe that nearly everything you and I
say and do is grounded not in our
biology in our own particular histories
but in hundreds or thousands of social
cues that we’re picking up and
processing every day we are finely tuned
satellite dishes processing signals from
everyone around us and then making
decisions largely unconscious decisions
about what to do in response I know this
is disempowering but we’re social
animals
and this is what social animals do we’re
like ants that form colonies or birds
that fly in formation except more so for
us it’s about unwritten rules unwritten
rules dictate how we behave tell us how
to behave at home at school at work and
everywhere in between sure they’re
written rules there are millions of them
their constitutions and laws and
ordinances and regulations and policies
but that ain’t nothing we’re juggling
many many more unwritten rules in fact
any time we’re around other people it’s
unwritten rules not written rules that
dictate how we behave you’re driving
down a freeway the posted speed limit a
pretty simple straightforward written
rule 65 miles an hour so how fast are
you allowed to drive 65 no you’re
supposed to drive about the same speed
as everybody else
if the speed limit is 65 and everybody
around you is driving 75 you can drive
75 it’s okay the unwritten rule wins or
let’s say you’re in an office building
you’re on the fourth floor and you want
to go down to the lobby you push the
button for the elevator the elevator
comes the doors open inside is a handful
of other people you step inside you push
L for Lobby and then you turn around and
face the doors except today you don’t
today you face everybody else on the
elevator and you smile you smile your
biggest friendliest smile and you smile
at them all the way down from 4 to 3 to
2 to the lobby uncomfortable right you
hated it and I promise you they wanted
to kill you
and that’s because you violated an
unwritten rule about how to behave with
other people on an elevator it’s not
written anywhere and yet it’s followed
everywhere that kind of calculus about
how to behave on a freeway or how to
behave in an elevator we’re doing all
day every day now we’ve known about
unwritten rules for at least 2,500 years
the ancient Romans called them lex
non-scripted
and scientists have been studying them
since the 1930s so they’re not a party
trick in fact they’re critical to how we
function so there are a few things you
ought to know about how they work
one unwritten rules have been the tool
of choice for managing societies for two
hundred thousand years think about it
from the very earliest humans until 1754
BC all rules were unwritten rules
it wasn’t until 1754 BC that somebody
namely king Hammurabi of Mesopotamia
bothered to write any rules down there
were two hundred and eighty two of them
and they included some classics like an
eye for an eye or tooth for a tooth and
about eleven hundred years later in 600
BC somebody wrote down all the rules in
the Book of Leviticus from the Jewish
Torah the Christian Old Testament now
Leviticus has 613 rules some of them are
serious like no line and others are less
serious like one all of us are violating
right now no mixing fabrics and your
clothing to unwritten rules help us
figure out how to juggle written rules
as I said before we are subject to a
ridiculous number of written rules more
than we could ever remember much less
follow but unwritten rules helped us
figure out which ones we should care
about for example Deloitte did a stud
and found that 91% of Americans sign
user agreements without ever reading
them and that number is even higher 97%
for Americans ages 18 to 34 now this
doesn’t bother us very much and we’re
not all that surprised because even
though user agreements or legally
binding documents we’ve decided that
they’re not that important unwritten
rules to the rescue 3 we learn unwritten
rules by watching other people whether
you’re aware of it or not you’re
constantly scanning other people’s
behavior and adapting your instincts
about how to behave how to talk how to
dress or whether to take your shoes off
on an airplane which is now apparently a
thing this turns out to be a huge
evolutionary advantage other animals
have to depend on biological evolution
which takes hundreds of years in order
to make big changes we with all of our
scanning and adapting can take advantage
of sociological evolution which moves
much faster this is why we and not
answer birds keep up with the
Kardashians for unwritten rules our
cheat codes every unwritten rule begins
life as a workaround there’s a problem
several people try to solve it in
various ways one of the ways sticks and
it spreads from person to person group
to group in society to society now if
you want to find these cheat codes there
are two good places to look the first is
in a place that has too many written
rules as we’ve discussed and the second
is where there are no written rules at
all remember Lord of the Flies the 1950s
British novel about a group of boys
stranded on an island with no adult
supervision now if you haven’t read it
spoiler alert things do not go well
everybody freaks out there’s some
torture and a bit of killing but my
larger point is that we human beings do
not tolerate
an absence of rules inevitably will just
hack some together and hold each other
accountable and finally five we
reinforce unwritten rules with subtle
cues we don’t need police to enforce
unwritten rules we just have to leverage
the fact that we’re social animals we
think we’re individualist particularly
in the West especially in the United
States but in the event you have not
noticed we all dress about the same and
we all wear our hair about the same and
we all talk about the same and we all
eat about the same foods and follow
about the same customs now this isn’t a
problem it’s not even a lack of
imagination it’s an adaptation remember
for most of the past 200,000 years human
beings were small slow and puny and we
were doing everything we could not to be
eaten by animals that were bigger faster
and stronger and what we did our
competitive advantage was that we could
coordinate our behaviors and so fast
forward
that’s what now allows us to build
cities and do science but because we are
social animals we do not like to be
alone and when we’re with other people
we do not like to be ostracized so it
does not take much to keep us in line a
look a glare a half smile is usually
enough to reward us when we do something
right like turn around and face the
doors in an elevator or punish us when
we do something wrong like talk about
ourselves too much at a party so at this
juncture I’m always asked the same
question Jeff how do I change unwritten
rules this is a great question and we do
not have time to get into it
however I will tell you what you cannot
do you cannot change an unwritten rule
by adding a written rule as a former
colleague of mine used to say if you
have to put up a sign to tell employees
to wash their hands you have already
lost the war
no you change unwritten rules by
replacing them with new better unwritten
rules yes this is hard but it’s
critically important to my work and it
might be tears I take on social problems
for a living public education and health
care and homelessness genocide lots and
lots of problems and in my work I have
found that unwritten rules are always
where things go wrong
take hunger you’ve no doubt noticed that
we throw away more than enough food to
feed every hungry person heck the people
in this room right now have probably
thrown away enough food in the past week
at home in restaurants and the cafeteria
to feed every hungry person in this
community so what’s that about
it’s about unwritten rules unwritten
rules like don’t reward people who don’t
work don’t donate half eat meals don’t
invite hungry people into your home’s
these are not laws these are just
unwritten rules that over decades have
morphed into common sense and that we
reinforced with social cues consider the
gender wage gap in 2017 a woman in the
United States working full time made
about 20% less than a man this has been
a problem for a very long time and we
haven’t been able to solve it and the
reason is unwritten rules social
traditions like encouraging girls to be
nurses and teachers instead of doctors
and administrators we’re labeling girls
is lousy at math
discouraging women from promoting
themselves again these are not laws
these are just social cues that we
consistently reinforce so to change
these conditions to solve these problems
we have to find and replace these faulty
triggers this is why we’re at a
crossroads because for the very first
time we know precisely how we are the
problem sure we need smarter technology
and better algorithms sure we need more
laws but mostly we need to find and
replace the unwritten rules that hold
these conditions locked in place and
then finally we’ll be able to solve the
most important problems in the world
thank you [Applause]
history it’s not the usual kind of
crossroads that we talk about this one
has nothing to do with the catastrophe
of climate change with a wondrous
promise of artificial intelligence this
is the kind of crossroads after which we
understand our world really differently
like in 1900 that was the year we
rediscovered the works of Gregor Mendel
if you don’t remember Mendel was a 19th
century monk who painstakingly bred pea
plants and lay the foundation for
today’s genetic science it was the year
that Sigmund Freud published the
interpretation of dreams he introduced
us to the subconscious and lay the
foundation for modern psychology Mendel
and Freud radically reoriented the way
we understood our world we understood it
one way in 1899 and really differently
just a year later that is the kind of
crossroads right now here’s why many
scientists now believe that most of our
behavior is dictated by social cues they
believe that nearly everything you and I
say and do is grounded not in our
biology in our own particular histories
but in hundreds or thousands of social
cues that we’re picking up and
processing every day we are finely tuned
satellite dishes processing signals from
everyone around us and then making
decisions largely unconscious decisions
about what to do in response I know this
is disempowering but we’re social
animals
and this is what social animals do we’re
like ants that form colonies or birds
that fly in formation except more so for
us it’s about unwritten rules unwritten
rules dictate how we behave tell us how
to behave at home at school at work and
everywhere in between sure they’re
written rules there are millions of them
their constitutions and laws and
ordinances and regulations and policies
but that ain’t nothing we’re juggling
many many more unwritten rules in fact
any time we’re around other people it’s
unwritten rules not written rules that
dictate how we behave you’re driving
down a freeway the posted speed limit a
pretty simple straightforward written
rule 65 miles an hour so how fast are
you allowed to drive 65 no you’re
supposed to drive about the same speed
as everybody else
if the speed limit is 65 and everybody
around you is driving 75 you can drive
75 it’s okay the unwritten rule wins or
let’s say you’re in an office building
you’re on the fourth floor and you want
to go down to the lobby you push the
button for the elevator the elevator
comes the doors open inside is a handful
of other people you step inside you push
L for Lobby and then you turn around and
face the doors except today you don’t
today you face everybody else on the
elevator and you smile you smile your
biggest friendliest smile and you smile
at them all the way down from 4 to 3 to
2 to the lobby uncomfortable right you
hated it and I promise you they wanted
to kill you
and that’s because you violated an
unwritten rule about how to behave with
other people on an elevator it’s not
written anywhere and yet it’s followed
everywhere that kind of calculus about
how to behave on a freeway or how to
behave in an elevator we’re doing all
day every day now we’ve known about
unwritten rules for at least 2,500 years
the ancient Romans called them lex
non-scripted
and scientists have been studying them
since the 1930s so they’re not a party
trick in fact they’re critical to how we
function so there are a few things you
ought to know about how they work
one unwritten rules have been the tool
of choice for managing societies for two
hundred thousand years think about it
from the very earliest humans until 1754
BC all rules were unwritten rules
it wasn’t until 1754 BC that somebody
namely king Hammurabi of Mesopotamia
bothered to write any rules down there
were two hundred and eighty two of them
and they included some classics like an
eye for an eye or tooth for a tooth and
about eleven hundred years later in 600
BC somebody wrote down all the rules in
the Book of Leviticus from the Jewish
Torah the Christian Old Testament now
Leviticus has 613 rules some of them are
serious like no line and others are less
serious like one all of us are violating
right now no mixing fabrics and your
clothing to unwritten rules help us
figure out how to juggle written rules
as I said before we are subject to a
ridiculous number of written rules more
than we could ever remember much less
follow but unwritten rules helped us
figure out which ones we should care
about for example Deloitte did a stud
and found that 91% of Americans sign
user agreements without ever reading
them and that number is even higher 97%
for Americans ages 18 to 34 now this
doesn’t bother us very much and we’re
not all that surprised because even
though user agreements or legally
binding documents we’ve decided that
they’re not that important unwritten
rules to the rescue 3 we learn unwritten
rules by watching other people whether
you’re aware of it or not you’re
constantly scanning other people’s
behavior and adapting your instincts
about how to behave how to talk how to
dress or whether to take your shoes off
on an airplane which is now apparently a
thing this turns out to be a huge
evolutionary advantage other animals
have to depend on biological evolution
which takes hundreds of years in order
to make big changes we with all of our
scanning and adapting can take advantage
of sociological evolution which moves
much faster this is why we and not
answer birds keep up with the
Kardashians for unwritten rules our
cheat codes every unwritten rule begins
life as a workaround there’s a problem
several people try to solve it in
various ways one of the ways sticks and
it spreads from person to person group
to group in society to society now if
you want to find these cheat codes there
are two good places to look the first is
in a place that has too many written
rules as we’ve discussed and the second
is where there are no written rules at
all remember Lord of the Flies the 1950s
British novel about a group of boys
stranded on an island with no adult
supervision now if you haven’t read it
spoiler alert things do not go well
everybody freaks out there’s some
torture and a bit of killing but my
larger point is that we human beings do
not tolerate
an absence of rules inevitably will just
hack some together and hold each other
accountable and finally five we
reinforce unwritten rules with subtle
cues we don’t need police to enforce
unwritten rules we just have to leverage
the fact that we’re social animals we
think we’re individualist particularly
in the West especially in the United
States but in the event you have not
noticed we all dress about the same and
we all wear our hair about the same and
we all talk about the same and we all
eat about the same foods and follow
about the same customs now this isn’t a
problem it’s not even a lack of
imagination it’s an adaptation remember
for most of the past 200,000 years human
beings were small slow and puny and we
were doing everything we could not to be
eaten by animals that were bigger faster
and stronger and what we did our
competitive advantage was that we could
coordinate our behaviors and so fast
forward
that’s what now allows us to build
cities and do science but because we are
social animals we do not like to be
alone and when we’re with other people
we do not like to be ostracized so it
does not take much to keep us in line a
look a glare a half smile is usually
enough to reward us when we do something
right like turn around and face the
doors in an elevator or punish us when
we do something wrong like talk about
ourselves too much at a party so at this
juncture I’m always asked the same
question Jeff how do I change unwritten
rules this is a great question and we do
not have time to get into it
however I will tell you what you cannot
do you cannot change an unwritten rule
by adding a written rule as a former
colleague of mine used to say if you
have to put up a sign to tell employees
to wash their hands you have already
lost the war
no you change unwritten rules by
replacing them with new better unwritten
rules yes this is hard but it’s
critically important to my work and it
might be tears I take on social problems
for a living public education and health
care and homelessness genocide lots and
lots of problems and in my work I have
found that unwritten rules are always
where things go wrong
take hunger you’ve no doubt noticed that
we throw away more than enough food to
feed every hungry person heck the people
in this room right now have probably
thrown away enough food in the past week
at home in restaurants and the cafeteria
to feed every hungry person in this
community so what’s that about
it’s about unwritten rules unwritten
rules like don’t reward people who don’t
work don’t donate half eat meals don’t
invite hungry people into your home’s
these are not laws these are just
unwritten rules that over decades have
morphed into common sense and that we
reinforced with social cues consider the
gender wage gap in 2017 a woman in the
United States working full time made
about 20% less than a man this has been
a problem for a very long time and we
haven’t been able to solve it and the
reason is unwritten rules social
traditions like encouraging girls to be
nurses and teachers instead of doctors
and administrators we’re labeling girls
is lousy at math
discouraging women from promoting
themselves again these are not laws
these are just social cues that we
consistently reinforce so to change
these conditions to solve these problems
we have to find and replace these faulty
triggers this is why we’re at a
crossroads because for the very first
time we know precisely how we are the
problem sure we need smarter technology
and better algorithms sure we need more
laws but mostly we need to find and
replace the unwritten rules that hold
these conditions locked in place and
then finally we’ll be able to solve the
most important problems in the world
thank you [Applause]
Please follow and like us: