Press "Enter" to skip to content

The Uncomfortable Truth About Underlying Anger | Peter Knoope | TEDxAUCollege


fifteen million dollars per hour fifteen

years has been spent on counterterrorism

15 million dollar per hour in 15 years

since 9/11 the problem is not getting

smaller

the problem is increasing something is

not right

I work on come to tears because I feel

for the victims because of the impact on

our daily routines our freedoms our

freedoms are at stake because of some of

the measures that are taken I’ll talk

about that later what I do is try to

understand the anger and I’m going to

share some of that information with you

mind you what I do is not talk to those

people I don’t talk to the people at the

top love the else over here is Osama bin

Laden’s the cows know I talk to the

people that enter the foot soldiers

those who feel attracted in the

outskirts of Nairobi the cities like

Karachi people that feel left out people

that feel excluded that once heads

ambitions human feelings dreams fears

and then at one stage gets recruited and

then kill because of their religion

I talked to that mother in Nairobi who

told me about her son and they said I’m

preaching him non-violence not militant

moderates interpretation of Islam but he

says mother you know what happens

outside you know about the corrupted

police force that is abusive I must make

a fist murder I talked last week to that

commander of this Celica Central African

Republic who said listen we the Muslims

we’ve always been marginalized they

don’t even listen to us in Bali they

don’t share their resources with us and

then one day the Christians come and

kill us

I needed to defend myself I took up arms

Peter he says I talked to that two weeks

ago to that young boy in Maiduguri

who said listen I’m in Nigeria that

earrings is rich we’ve got all that oil

all those resources you think any of

that will ever come to us in the Lord no

it doesn’t happen Peter we are not part

of those who are in power and take the

wealth of my country as patterns in what

I see and the patterns are visible from

all the way from Indonesia by a party

into the Middle East into Africa there’s

a hopelessness people that sit and wait

for the day to go by and know that they

will never ever get an education let

alone a job before they have no access

to power political leadership and they

see that their leaders are corrupt this

patterns

so there’s exclusion this test sense the

people are not part of the in-group

they’re part of an out-group basically

for one reason only because there are a

collective they are excluded for who

they are often on a religious basis what

I see happening is that these

individuals start to reconnect from

exclusion they now go now go to

inclusiveness but they go to a

reconnection in groups like in Palestine

like in China the Eagles who oppose

their government because they feel

excluded from the Chinese reality in

political environment I see that

happening in Nigeria Boko Haram I see it

in Kenya al-shabaab individuals that

feel excluded on the basis of a common

characteristic and then now reconnect

and find friendship comradeship in a

group from excluded to include it and

then recognize each other’s pain they

recognize each other’s position from

Baghdad to Saudi Arabia from Tunisia to

our schools of Rotterdam from Kazakhstan

all the way down to Latin America where

what strikes me in all my discussions

with these people is that a lot of the

anger that I find is not about what

happens today but it’s about what

happened yesterday at first this thing

puzzled me I didn’t get it I couldn’t

understand why they won’t live for the

future why they won’t take today as the

first day of the rest of their lives why

I always referred back to what happened

to understand this we really need to

understand the way people think we think

that time is something in front of us

time is there we live we have an agenda

we have a plan for next year we plan our

careers we live the less time we have I

live longer

less time that’s exceptional the

majority of the people seven billion

people in this world look at time in a

very different manner time is something

behind them the more you live the more

you have you live longer you have more

time you build up you assemble it’s

something that you grow time it’s clever

now if that is true if time is something

that you build up the traditional roots

ancestors your parents all that becomes

important as a daily today’s reality

people feel solidarity with their

parents their grandparents and

unfinished business of the past now this

has a major impact we fail to realize

that because if they look at the past

and they look at their luggage they look

at what they have assembled and what

their parents have assemble that the

unfinished business of the past then

this is what they see don’t think that

people out there don’t know about

Western domination colonialism but the

fact that we came to Christendom to a

decade to bring them our way of life our

governance systems our national borders

the way we decided that and how we

brought culture and most of all how we

brought development because they were

obviously underdeveloped try to imagine

that tomorrow a Plane full of Chinese

will come to develop you try to imagine

how would you react that’s what we’ve

done of the last couple of hundreds of

years we’ve developed so they’re

struggling with those national borders

that we determined there are national

they struggle with the question Who am I

in terms of history self-esteem identity

why am i underdeveloped don’t think they

don’t know that when we came to Nigeria

Tanzania the Philippines that we did

accept the Muslims we didn’t you brought

Christian missionaries we brought our

education today we talked about

unlearning

we talked about a different approach to

education they already had that but we

the message is clear there you look you

act you behave like a westerner you will

be accepted

you don’t look behave or act like us and

you want at this export of our culture

our way of life our thinking our

religion our development is still

continuing today we export modernity

now the interesting thing about

modernity it’s interesting concept

it focuses on individualism market we’ve

OSD if you live with tradition in your

ancestors in the past and modernity is

about change individualism competition

opposition that that modernity doesn’t

really fit in your own perception of

your own identity

it doesn’t fit so there’s a new conflict

and the worst thing about modernity is

that it opposes both religion and

tradition it denies the value of them by

the way hundreds of years ago

we good we were there to tell them they

should be Christians missionaries today

we tell them

Corie mistake be men’s you need to be

modern not religious we try to confuse

people it works and all this confusion

and all this search for identity and all

this problem of self-esteem leads to the

attraction of religion as a new solution

to that search of identity and that

search for self-esteem religion offers a

new venue for people to find solidarity

guidance rules regulations a solid house

where people can live and that religion

might you is exported the militant

interpretation of religions is being

exported from the Gulf to all these

communities but not only from the Gulf

it’s not only develop ISM and salafism

that is exported as

solution to this problem no it comes

from the other side as well it’s called

Pentecostal charismatic backed by big

money from the United States and it

completes with Salafism and Wahhabism

remember the anti-balaka and the silica

maybe what happens in the Central

African Republic is the precursor of us

to come to happen globally in the time

to come so religion offers everything

that modernity doesn’t it offer

solidarity it so offers a house where

you can live in and it offers security

certainty rules regulation and God

now the attraction of religion is even

bigger where the corrupt regimes do not

offer the moral standards

it’s bigger where there’s no political

alternative it’s bigger for the market

competent competitive methodologies are

dominant it’s bigger since the fall of

the Berlin Wall and the bankruptcy of

the only alternative political system

that offered social responsibility it

was bankrupt it didn’t work

but there’s no more alternative to the

market system and it’s even more

attractive where conflict resolution

systems like the Jews

police are corrupt and art is functional

my taxi driver in Bunge the day before

yesterday I said listen they gave me

money to vote was this politician he

came to give me money

I voted anything from democracy that is

what democracy looks like

in many places in this world you get

so where do we find the solution I’m

going I’m not going to leave you tonight

depressed and loaded with problems

there’s a solution to this I’m going to

give you three elements of the solution

first of all this is issues trust I’m

not going to tell you a lot of news when

I tell you that there’s a trust issue

between governments and citizens not

only in Pakistan and Nigeria it’s in

many places distrust has become the

governments don’t trust their own

citizens they go through my emails they

go through my luggage they follow my

financial transactions there’s cameras

surveillance all over this trust is the

guiding principle between in the

relationship between the government and

a citizen they don’t trust me they don’t

if distrust is the guiding principle of

that relationship that that relationship

will go sour everybody who’s ever been

married knows that you discuss your

partner oops something is going wrong so

there’s an urgent need to reintroduce

trust between governments and citizens

not just in the United States but also

in Nigeria in Kenya and China secondly

and maybe even more importantly religion

offers moral compare it gives you values

if politicians want to compete they will

have to live to give moral values moral

standards in its ultimate consequence

the market modernity has no values I’m

not the first one to know that tonight

but change is in the air it was noticed

by somebody changes in the air banks are

now offering services with values you go

to a shop you find green and fair trades

apparently there’s also non fair trade

there’s a lot of non fair trade and the

consumers want products that are not

produced with child labor that do not

have components that drive conflicts

consumers want values not just in the

Netherlands all over and that change

what 911 did is in many places in the

world reduce the political landscape the

political space in which citizens can

organize themselves because

organizations are scary governments

don’t know what organizations to so they

reduce that space even the Netherlands

the subsidies for civil society have

been reduced if you reduce that space

that means the citizens find other ways

in which they organize themselves civil

society must come back on the agenda

because the majority of people do not

want humiliation the majority of people

do not want polarization do not want the

violence those voices must be

facilitators to organize themselves and

be heard urgently because only if we

allow ourselves that discomfort talking

to the angry engaging and connecting to

them only then can we solve terrorism thank you very much

Please follow and like us: