Press "Enter" to skip to content

The stigmas of cultural appropriation | Thanika (Annika) Sirikulthada | TEDxShrewsburyIntlSchool


a teacher might set culture does not
make people people make culture and so
before i’ma give my speech today I would
just like to highlight that many of the
themes and categories I will be
exploring such as race religion and
culture they are all social
constructions meaning that we as society
were the ones who put labels and
categories on them this is linked to
cultural appropriation because in many
other cases you will see today one idea
that will begin to arise is how one
group is enforcing these labels on
another and so in the same way we
created this I also believe that we have
the power to eliminate them
and this is an idea getting back to at
the end of my talk for those of you who
can keep up with fashion I’m sure you
would have heard of the 2017 Marc Jacobs
spring collection runway show where he
had a high-end models such as Gigi Hadid
walking down his runway of adored with
fake dreadlocks
this the course stimulated many angry
calls of cultural appropriation as
dreadlocks are symbolic of the language
of Judah and were historically ignored
by many African Americans this was
particularly problematic because Jacobs
did not credit the original source of
the hair and instead he tried to present
it as his own idea the result of this
was chaos as we want to see
missions between some African Americans
as well as many people from the rest of
the world and Jacobs if I were to give
you an example but every time a phrase
misstatement or an action was somehow
linked to the idea of cultural
appropriation then we can honestly be
here for the rest of time the truth is
as our most technological systems are
advancing and our access to the rest of
the world via social media expands we
begin to see more and more posts
comments that all has something to do
with cultural appropriation but how many
of you know exactly what this is
according to the Oxford Dictionary
definition cultural appropriation is the
unappropriate is the inappropriate or
unacknowledged adoption of customs
practices and ideas by one group of
people directed towards another and
typically less dominant however
according to the ambiguity within this
definition we can argue that even our
most domestic and everyday activities
can be accused of culture or patient
drinking tea for example because how
many of you are aware of the significant
use of tea as medicine during the Shang
Dynasty
thus I’d like to begin my talk by
exploring the arguments against cultural
preparation and how cultural
appropriation
can be terminal in the 21st century
cultural appropriation is often viewed
as very problematic because it causes
divisions within society this is because
when one social group feels that their
cultural history is not being respected
by another they psychologically distance
themselves for the purpose of cultural
preservation
an example of this
the adoption of the Native American name
and mascot for the end of our Washington
Redskins team the word Redskins comes
from a historical period when the
government was courted to persecute and
kill these Native Americans so the
adoption of this word for sports for
education purposes demonstrates a lack
of regard and arguably respect for their
cultural history here division is our
divisions is arguably men between the
Native Americans who feel attacked and
felt this act as a validation of their
cultural history and the white Americans
who felt they had the authority and the
power to implement this however I’m
going to also like to explore a less
explicit form of cultural appropriation
such as that within a themed party when
parents choose a theme for their son or
daughter’s birthday party we can argue
that they are indirectly endorsing
cultural appropriation through props and
costumes however I would also like to
argue that this is not necessarily a bad
thing
because instead of closing admissions I
would like to argue that this causes the
bridges of culture for example the use
of the LaRhonda jelly bag of our
brotherhood themed party can increase
awareness on Moroccan culture and thus
bridge cultures together so the
important question I would like to
answer today is what is the middle
ground because as you already seen not
all examples of cultural appropriation
are harmful and we should begin to step
away from the stigma that all are from
reading the ethnics of cultural
appropriation by the hotrod trunk and
James Young one of the key ideas I was
able to get was that the intention per
scale this simply compares
those who are appropriating to the size
of the appropriation so life’s easy an
appalling example for this the end of
our would have been considered a
large-scale problem as this volumes
consisted of many millions of people
that’s the scale plays thus the
intention plays the lesser ratio when
we’re assessing is harmfulness so in
order to find the harmfulness of this
action we would have to look at your
feedback from those who’ve been affected
by this large-scale action the party
however would have been considered a
much smaller scale problem
I just thought yes would have consisted
of a lot less people so when we’re
assessing its harmfulness we have looked
more towards the intention and was
likely parents who have not had the
intention to offend where they’re
setting up the theme party another
simple way of finding the middle ground
is through the overall feedback of those
whose culture has been appropriated if
they feel that their culture has been
disrespected to the point where they no
longer want to engage with the party
who’s responsible then we can argue that
this form of cultural and preventive
side of my speech has all of these
groups as inertial constructions and you
believe that we have the power to
eliminate them as well as just my own
methods however the key point I hope
that everybody takes away today is that
cultural appropriation it’s not a bad
thing and it should not be completely
avoided that Bradley losers
thank you [Applause]
Please follow and like us: