Press "Enter" to skip to content

The Search for Planet 9 | Dr. Renu Malhotra | TEDxPortland


[Applause]
thank you David thank you everybody for
being here thank you to everybody who’s
tuned in so let me get started I have a
limited amount of time the clocks
running the solar system is old we have
little time here so I’m a planetary
dynamicists that’s a mouthful and a
pretty esoteric profession but as a
planetary dynamicists I’m especially
tuned to two mathematical things about
planets the shapes of their orbits and
their period ratios so I like numbers so
about two years ago when astronomers
started noticing some peculiar patterns
in the Kuiper belt there’s belt or small
planets beyond Neptune we call them
minor planets or Kuiper belt objects I
tuned into their orbit shapes and their
period ratios and I stumbled onto a new
a new idea that may help us discover a
new planet in the distant solar system
searching for a distant planet in the
solar system is a story about human
imagination and curiosity and increasing
intellectual and technological
sophistication it’s also about being
human about our curiosity about the
universe about seeking knowledge of our
place in the cosmos so I’m gonna start
with a brief history of our this this
very human enterprise ancient
civilizations had a very simple concept
of the cosmos
okay so we live on earth the Sun and the
moon ruled the sky and our daily lives
and the afterlife is in heaven above or
hell below very simple with more data of
the long time cycles in the sky humans
developed a more sophisticated model of
the universe a more sophisticated
conceptual model of the universe there
were the distant fixed stars the seven
wandering stars all gods and demons that
ruled over our lives and all and over
the cosmos in time with even more data
and even more mathematics a more precise
model came to be accepted
that’s the Ptolemaic model that you see
up there this was a combination of
circular paths everything in the
universe was perfect circles are perfect
spheres are perfect and this was a
highly successful model it was really
accurate in predicting the cycles in the
sky and it was accepted for more than a
thousand years predicted the seasons
everything that we needed for human life
agriculture and so on then in the dawn
of the 17th century
Galileo upset the elders with a new
technology he pointed a little telescope
to the sky and he discovered not that
not everything in the heavens turns
around Earth there are worlds turning
around Jupiter the Sun was not perfect
it was blotchy the moon ball mountains
and valleys like earth and the evening
star Venus ran phases right the moon so
seeding the center to the Sun the
heliocentric cosmos grew in acceptance a
mechanical model of the cosmos emerged
beginning with Kepler’s laws of
planetary motion and leading to Newton’s
law of gravitation the cosmos it was
finally realized was ruled by natural
laws shortly after that with a bigger
better telescope Sir William Herschel in
England discovered a new planet in the
solar system Uranus
a planet that was unknown to the
ancients and this discovery truly opened
human imagination to the possibility of
more planets and more objects in the
cosmos more than we could see with the
eyes before meticulous analysis of the
slow movement of Uranus just a few
Ernest to seek the tell-tale
fingerprints of gravity of the gravity
of planets now of even more planets led
a French mathematician Urbain le Verrier
to predict the exact location of the
unseen 8th planet on the night of the
24th 23rd of September 1846 ok on that
night
one German astronomer turned his
telescope to the sky and actually found
that planet at the location that was
predicted on that same night and this
was a triumph of 19th century
mathematics applied to the cosmos now
the most famous search for planet 9 so
I’m here to talk about planet 9 the most
famous search for planet 9 was that of
Percival Lowell the sources Observatory
he he was convinced that the movements
of Uranus and Neptune were sufficiently
aberrant that there was a large planet
beyond Neptune and he started a
systematic search in in 1906 and his
Observatory in Flagstaff Arizona
that’s my adopted home state and this
was the first Observatory located
remotely to to do the best astronomical
photography ever now Lowell died in 1916
the research continued the source for
planet was found in 1930 and was named
Pluto a shout out for Pluto too no files
here
[Applause]
well the more than 2 decades of
searching for this planet is truly a
story of persistence a man’s life and
generations of astronomers have been
persistently looking for objects in the
sky the size and mass of Pluto however
took even longer to settle not until
1978 when its moon Charon was discovered
and alas then it became very clear that
Pluto is smaller than the map than our
own moon than Earth’s moon and hence
only a distant cousin of this planet
that Lowell was searching well the hard
work of following Pluto’s movements over
many decades revealed many surprises
about this little planet the shape of
its orbit and its ratio with Neptune’s
either thinks that I tune into that my
mind Tunes in to Pluto’s orbit is very
elliptical ok it overlaps Neptune’s
orbit but these two never collide these
two planets are in a celestial
partnership known as orbital resonance
so Pluto makes it to revolutions around
the Sun in the same time that Neptune
makes three and in such a way that the
two are never in the same place when
Pluto is at perihelion ok so that makes
them never collide they they kind of
dance around each other so calculations
of the three-dimensional geometry
revealed this is oh look at this
beautiful picture of Pluto this is the
symmetric grand gasp that Pluto makes if
you’re on a carousel rotating around the
Sun with Neptune’s orbital period watch
this the symmetry of Pluto’s orbit this
is this resonant orbit and we’ll run
into resonance is constantly again so
the three-dimensional geometry of
Pluto’s orbit is also really fascinating
there is actually an additional
resonance more subtle Pluto reaches
perihelion when its farthest away from
Neptune’s orbit claim him so Pluto’s
orbit is tilted it reaches perihelion
when it’s far up away from the plane of
the solar system and over time it only
wobbles slightly around this geometry so
altogether Pluto is in what’s called the
periodic orbit of the Third Kind one of
a class of orbits identified by the 19th
century
mathematician on reef on curry such
always have a resonant period and a
specific tilt to the planet the
gravitational force so the reason this
these are really fascinating orbits the
gravitational forces of the planets on
each other have a special respect for
these resonance patterns and we’ll run
into this again with planet 9 these
peculiarities of Pluto’s orbit kept
celestial mechanisms really busy for
many decades and as a graduate student I
learned about these puzzles of Pluto and
I wondered how the Pluto get to be so
this peculiar planet and I proposed an
answer I proposed this answer that
you’re seeing in this animation here a
giant planet migration that the giant
planets Jupiter Saturn Uranus and
Neptune formed in a very narrow annulus
around the Sun and then later spread
apart I calculated that as Neptune
slowly spiraled outward and originally
circular coplanar Pluto was shepherded
into this resonance and transformed into
this elliptical tilted orbit now lucky
for me for an astronomer it’s really
lucky that subsequent discoveries over
the net over the few years after I
proposed this idea discoveries of the
Kuiper belt many small planets beyond
Neptune that are in resonance with the
witness tune have bolstered this
hypothesis of giant planets migrating so
the our planets didn’t form where we see
them today computer simulations suggest
that Uranus and Neptune and possibly
additional giant planets were shaken up
scattered for a long time for millions
of years before settling into the orbits
we observe today now more recently hints
of a massive planet in the very distant
solar system have been noticed the
orbits of the most distant Kuiper belt
objects are kind of clustered they are
not randomly oriented as we might expect
so if a distant planet the true planet 9
not the little Pluto if a distant planet
9 is Shep
these Kuiper belt objects we would like
to know how massive is it where is it
orbiting now computer simulations tell
us that the planet is up to 10 times or
its mass at somewhere between 300 to 900
times or it’s distance key but these
simulations tell us nothing about its
position in the sky where it is in its
orbit at the current time where would we
go look for it now when I look carefully
at the data I noticed an another
intriguing pattern the numbers again
you didn’t expect to see tables here did
you so what I noticed was that the
ratios of the orbital periods of the
most distant objects are close to small
whole numbers now this could be mere
numerology or it could be a real clue it
could be a real clue if a massive planet
and it could be a real and valuable clue
else I’ll show you were indeed
shepherding these Kuiper belt objects
and orbital resonances if a planet were
indeed shepherding these Kuiper belt
objects and resonances then we have some
clue as to where the planet is just like
Pluto’s resonance with Neptune we know
if we know Pluto where Pluto is we know
where Neptune is not it’s not near
Pluto’s perihelion so I searched for an
orbit of planet 9 that would be resonant
with the distant Kuiper belt these
Kuiper belt objects there are only a
small number of possibilities of likely
possibilities the choice most consistent
with the orbital clustering that we’ve
seen is an orbit theory of period near
17,000 years very long period so this
planet is moving really slowly in the
sky this singular choice of planet lines
orbit period leads to simple resonant
geometries of the distant Kuiper belt
objects relative to Planet 9 like the
shapes that you see on the screen now
these shapes of the resonant orbits show
us the portions of the orbital path
where the hypothetical planet cannot be
at the current time in addition there
are only two choices
of or to approximate choices of the tilt
of this planet’s orbit one is that it’s
either close to the plains of these
distant Kuiper belt objects or it
follows the spa
Curry’s periodic orbits of the Third
Kind that I mentioned before so it has a
specific tilt and those two choices turn
out to be one that’s about 18 just 18
degrees tilted to the plane of Earth’s
orbit
the other one is tilted 48 degrees to to
our to our planet’s orbit it remains now
to refine our mathematical predictions
and test them with telescopes to prove
that this planet really exists or if
perhaps the apparent patterns in the
distant Kuiper belt are a fluke a
statistical fluke of small of a small
sample you only have about a dozen
objects giving us leading these clues so
it should refine Planet 9 it will be a
triumph of both mathematics and advanced
astronomical technology again yet again
what will it mean to discover a distance
large planet well we will have a more
complete inventory and a new self image
of the solar system it may make
horoscopes more accurate finally
[Applause]
well for scientists it will stimulate
new research on the origin of comets
this planet nine rooms in this reservoir
of frozen in of bodies the remnants of
our solar system far out in the distant
solar system how does it affect the
frequency of comets that come to us so
we can see them in the sky
it’s gonna change our ideas about how
comets arrive in the inner solar system
it will also stimulate new research on
the formation of the solar system how
did the solar system manage to look like
this clockwork mechanism that Newton and
Kepler believed in despite having this
history of scattering of planets almost
surely this planet was scattered from El
Strom closer in are there even more
planets roaming in the distance how did
the scattering of this planet affect the
course of our own planet it almost
surely did so Planet 9 will provide a
new challenge and a new destination for
future exploration and I thank you
[Applause]
Please follow and like us: