
myself I can remember two moments
clearly one lying in bed next to your
tiny always needing body exhausted
sleep-deprived for months
seeing no way out there was no way out
two sitting on the edge of the bed as
her father walked out of the room out of
my life
a disembowelment my dreams of love and
partnership family spilling out onto the
floor from somewhere in my middle
I still have flashes moments when I
imagine slicing my wrist the acute burn
of the cut the relief of not feeling
anymore you have always kept me here
resentfully so at first and now a life
preserver
an anchor a mission this thing called
life is no joke the world is
built on our backs our wombs are tears
but it was not made for us and yet I
claim it for us auntie Eliza writes the
Asian model minority is not doing well I
am not doing well I’m writing you this
letter because I need you to see the
crisis that is Asian American life the
civilizing chair that is model minority
zation the neoliberal American dream
madness as the psychic life of living
under siege I’m writing you to tell you
the lie of the thing called wellness my
child the world makes us sick and then
tells us it is our fault sickness as
individual pathology a lack of ability
our will to achieve wellness the world
tells us what wellness looks like marks
it as normal moral like whiteness
wellness is an ideal to strive for a
state of being in constant performance
invisible eyes structures holding up
bodies and persons certain bodies
certain persons invisible eye structures
tearing apart other bodies other
person’s your worth is not tied to how
well you can perform racialized
capitalist productivity or gendered
constructions of the self-made martyring
sacrificing woman mother or what aunty
Aaron calls the debt bound daughter
parental sacrifice exchanged for
daughter Lea personhood people are not
to be measured by their usefulness their
ability to perform health their
proximity to racialized gendered ideals
I need you to understand that we are all
differentially unwell that people are
vulnerable made vulnerable kept
vulnerable that our vulnerabilities are
both our death and our life that are
vulnerabilities link us connect us in a
web of death and survival this thing
called life is no joke my sweet child it
is okay to hurt we must allow ourselves
to hurt to trace the losses the
heartbreak of the death we must allow
ourselves to be whole people in all our
brokenness our lives as always
negotiating violence trauma crises of
meaning our lives as always finding new
ways of making meaning making community
I tell you this to free you but to also
show you how to allow others to be free
in your hands is a project I dreamed for
me and for you for the brokenness we all
share so different and so similar I
dream this project to save my own life
to help others save their own lives to
help you save yours open an emergency my
darling child it’s an emergency right
now so this letter opens a project I
curated titled open an emergency and the
project is on Asian American mental
health
is an attempt to think and feel our way
out of circuits that are killing us I
find it necessary to extend this letter
to help you understand exactly what it
is I’m trying to pass on to you
let me try here I used to think that we
could simply think our way out of
problems that plague our communities
that the mine was the most important
tool the most important site of
cultivation learn more sharpen
analytical skills see more find new
critiques generate new ways of thinking
this would be what leads to freedom to
revolution it’s why I went to graduate
school why I trained as a scholar it’s
what I learned in graduate school as I
trained to be a scholar for instance
learn what racism is and what it isn’t
learn how to analyze what people think
racism is learn to trace how people’s
ideas about racism affect actions
dialogues policies see what opens up
when we shift how we understand racism
from individual acts of prejudice to
systems of devaluing and exploiting
certain lives systems that find
themselves embedded in expressed through
laws social norms cultural practices
ethnic studies as a field as a set of
fields was born out of a desire to hold
up and make visible the lies of those
who bear the brunt of these systems of
violence and to understand the complex
workings of those systems so learn what
racism is and perhaps we can defeat it
learn what racism is and in the process
unlearn old ways of thinking many
educators I know talk about teaching as
a process of helping students unlearn
identify and address our assumptions
things we learn from our social
environments from cultural narratives
from educational systems things that are
inaccurate untrue or harmful
see the scripts for what they are
inheritances that say more about our
communities investments that actually
about capturing realities but this goes
for feeling too because we don’t just
think and learn ways we feel in them too
we learn emotional scripts what we’re
supposed to feel in particular moments
about particular things we police
ourselves with our emotional scripts and
so I found myself feeling my way into
motherhood five years ago leading up to
the birth feelings of excitement anxiety
about the birth anticipation feeling
ready than feeling not ready enjoying
being celebrated by my family and larger
community most would consider these
normal feelings but what are normal
feelings feelings that occur often or
feelings that fit norms feelings that
fit our expectations the stories we are
told what we tell ourselves of how we’re
supposed to feel what are abnormal
feelings who gets to say what feelings
are abnormal and then what happens when
we have so called abnormal feelings we
tell ourselves something is wrong with
me other people tell us something is
wrong with you sometimes this makes
people jump off bridges sometimes we get
put in hospitals or prisons the World
Health Organization defines mental
health as a state of well-being in which
every individual realizes his or her own
potential can cope with the normal
stresses of life can work productively
and fruitfully and is able to make a
contribution to his or her community it
opened an emergency writer and therapist
chi-ching Tom wonders why the definition
emphasizes an ability to work is our
health and value really determined by an
ability to be productive to participate
in capitalism what if
in fact capitalism causes unwellness as
cultural studies scholar and tsvetkova
CH suggests what if depression isn’t an
individual state of maladjustment
expressed through the inability to work
but actually the shared emotional state
of life of working under neoliberal
capitalism and then I wonder about
another part of the definition can cope
with the normal stresses of life
what are normal stresses of life for
whom are they normal who gets to deem
certain stresses as acceptable and other
kinds as too much beyond some imagined
threshold who gets to tell you what you
should be asked to bear and who gets to
tell us how we must bear our burdens
what kinds of coping our healthy
picture this you have a new baby the one
you’ve been so excitedly waiting for the
one you began loving from the time you
felt her kicks like butterflies in your
middle she is here and now you feel
trapped you do nothing but care for her
around the clock nurse change rock hold
maybe put down for a few minutes but
then she’s crying again so pick up and
repeat through the night you sleep in
one-hour increments day and night your
life a non-stop routine of exhaustion
and frustration and resentment and
despair despair that this will never
change that you will never sleep again
never have a break and never have a life
outside of her needs where is the joy
that motherhood supposedly brings where
is the meaningfulness the satisfaction
and so you think something is wrong with
me but not something is wrong with me as
in my feelings or indicators of needs
not being met but as in something is
wrong with me
you think maybe I’m not cut out for
motherhood
maybe I’ve made a terrible mistake maybe
I am a failure of a mother of a person
because everywhere everyone told you
that mothers are supposed to be happy
mothers are supposed to do everything
and be happy while doing it mothers are
supposed to find meaning in all their
sacrifices martyrdom as ideal motherhood
you find that you can’t get other
parents to admit even to themselves that
we sometimes don’t feel like it’s worth
it that sometimes there is little or no
reward that sometimes we even have
regret resentment and a desire for
something else you can’t even get most
new parents to admit that joy might not
be their predominant feeling that is
where I found myself feeling motherhood
through these narratives earlier I
described open an emergency as an
attempt to think and feel our way out of
circuits that are killing us so what are
those circuits and how can thinking and
feeling get us out of them so when one
such circuit idealize motherhood of
contemporary American culture another
asian-american model minority zation it
was especially difficult to get my
Vietnamese American family and larger
Asian American community to think and
feel outside of these usual narratives
of motherhood because in a world in
which we are always trying to become
American striving for an elusive
belonging through faith in the American
Dream in which we work hard work harder
climb the ladder of upward mobility to
find a kind of belonging that might keep
us safe that might bring us security and
accumulation which we often confuse with
happiness in this world there is no room
for motherhood being hard for anything
being hard Excel achieved be normal at
all costs the life of racism its shape
and its reach not simply in our thoughts
but in our feelings our anxieties our
insecurities our low
wev Dubois famously asked about race and
being black in the u.s. how does it feel
to be a problem a century later the J
Prashad would ask of the South Asian
American community how does it feel to
be a solution in open and emergency
literary scholar Aaron Ning says that
all of her work excavating the dynamics
of asian-american life has really been
about answering the question of what it
feels like to be the model minority so
how do we feel our way out of these
circuits these structures that bear down
upon us giving us effective maps that
are killing us I’m not suggesting that
we simply need to feel better or create
better feelings this is not about
overcoming anger or other supposedly
negative feelings and finding some kind
of tranquility I have a deep suspicion
of people telling me how I should feel
or that a way of feeling about something
is better or healthier again what are
normal feelings and who gets to say
instead I want to think of feeling as a
site of critique a site where we
investigate the relationship between
feeling and structure I’m not an effect
theorist there are many doing incredible
work in this area but as a cultural
studies scholar as a scholar and writer
around issues of mental health I can
observe the cultural scripts in my own
life and the lives of those around me
and trace the ghostly presence of power
to find pathways to resist it to survive
it so questions I asked you to consider
how can we identify where and how we’ve
been conditioned to feel and not feel
how can we trace how that conditioning
is shaped by systems of power such as
racism misogyny homophobia
via ableism xenophobia how can we
disinvest in those conditioned feelings
and how can we cultivate deeper feeling
different feeling outside of norms how
can we cultivate feelings for things
we’re not supposed to in ways were not
supposed to many will tell you that
empathy is the answer compassion as a
salv
for our era of vitriol and hate but I
write you this letter to tell you that
that is not enough empathy and
compassion cannot be general or generic
they must be specific in response to
what we have already been conditioned to
feel empathy for and what we have not to
cultivate deeper and possibly
revolutionary feeling we must first
identify the scripts we inherit and then
feel our way out of them this means
evaluating what you are feeling weighing
its ethical ethical possibilities
choosing to reject it if necessary and
cultivating new feelings that perhaps
didn’t come naturally easily to you at
first feeling as a life practice a
political ethical spiritual method open
the possibilities of feeling and we open
the possibilities of living of being
able to live this is both my charge and
my hope for you thank you [Applause]