Press "Enter" to skip to content

The Necessary Paradigm Shift For Women To Collectively Thrive | Cyndie Spiegel | TEDxIthacaCollege


we are changing the narrative around two

important terms one is feminism the

other is women’s empowerment so I stand

here as we near 2018 or 2018 and many

things are changing every single day

women are vulnerably standing up

standing out sharing our stories and

being heard so yes though the narrative

is changing and women are finally being

heard some narratives are not so though

we know the old adage that collectively

we all rise and rising tides lifts all

boats

still we are unconsciously disempowering

one another every single day and when I

say we I mean us I mean women women are

not always supportive of one another

that is not a new narrative I’ll share

with you a story

I was just two weeks ago in New York

City at an event that was put on by a

major fashion magazine and in that event

there were all women leaders that were

being highlighted I had the honor of

being in the second row and watching two

women on stage one was a veteran of the

film industry and the other was a

veteran of the fashion industry and they

were having an interview with one

another which was again super excited I

was in the audience all of these women

were surrounding me and we were so

anticipating what they were going to

share what wisdom was going to be

imparted upon us so the woman in the

film industry started to share her story

we were all held so closely like just

hanging on every word and then finally

they had a Q&A this is our time this is

the time the audience gets to stand up

and ask the important questions so mind

you this is a Women’s Leadership

Conference we are here to lead and to

learn the tools to lead better brighter

more boldly so the woman in the audience

stands up cinch and she says please can

you tell us clearly you’re so successful

you’ve spent 50 years in film tell us

how

your female friendships have empowered

you to grow to get to where you are

today I thought that was a pretty made

sense to ask that question I see a lot

of nods right seems like a good question

so here’s what happened next she looked

directly at this woman in the eye and

she went they haven’t in fact I have

just as many if not more frenemies than

I do friends hey guys I will I for a

living work with women this broke my

heart

so then what precedes to happen as the

woman in fashion looks over at her

friend who she’s interviewing and she

said you know I got to tell you men are

better at this than women men just

bombed better women it’s not our thing

and I get it I mean you know it’s been

hard one for us we can’t just go giving

it away mortified because this is the

narrative that we are constantly sharing

this is the narrative that the world

hears about women we are catty

we are unkind we are not helpful and we

don’t support one another we are

constantly asking of other women that we

stay in our own lanes and it’s not

something that any of us want to admit

to no of course not because we’re

ashamed of that so a little bit about

what I do is build communities for a

living to in particular one is

empowering women to build bold

businesses and the other empowering

women to build bold conversations

because they truly believe that if we

are not able to be vulnerable and share

our truths we will never get to the

other side of where we are so clearly

hearing this conversation and sharing

this narrative that by the way is not an

untrue narrative was mortifying because

it’s continuing to share this out this

video has since gone viral of this

interview that is the story that we are

telling about women and partially it’s

true but it’s not the whole story the

whole story starts with a before and

moves forward into how we shift from

here so I’ll talk a little bit about how

we got to this magical space of where

paradigm in the narrative has really

shifted to women not caring about other

women because if we don’t know this we

can’t move forward one culturally this

is how we were raised in this country

women or boys rather and girls are

raised differently so think about when

little boys are young we teach our sons

to play sports whether it be basketball

or football they know that there will be

a winner and there will be a loser and

no matter what you will shake hands at

the end of that game so we are teaching

our sons competence and confidence and

the ability to compete with somebody

else and hopefully lose or win and still

feel okay about yourself

we’re teaching them to lead at very

young ages also we take our sons to the

beach and we put them in their tiny

little speedos or perhaps it’s their

short shorts what are the kids wear to

the beaches these days

but little boys are able to show up

whether it be at a pool or at a beach

and they show up and they show out and

they are confident and happy and they

run and they roam and they are allowed

to experience childhood and all of their

self in their full self in contrast our

little girls we teach our daughters to

be nice we teach them to be kind we

teach them that somebody doesn’t have to

lose or win it’s okay it’s all good just

be nice and so what happens is that our

daughters grow up and they can see that

there is a difference between the

qualities that are expected or the

traits rather that are expected of them

versus their little brothers there let

little brothers are allowed to compete

their big brothers are allowed to lead

because no one’s telling them to be nice

no one’s acknowledging those traits for

them so our little girls are being

raised to understand that there is a

difference in expectation and that same

exact situation at the beach from I

don’t know maybe three months or so we

put our babies in bikinis or one-piece

bathing

and it all seems very cute when they’re

this big but again here’s what we’re

teaching little girls your brother he

can show up he doesn’t have to cover up

but you you should and so what that

message is sharing with our little girls

is shame because what’s appropriate for

their brothers their cousins their

friends is not appropriate for them and

that shame manifests and adult women so

how many of you for example have ever

seen an adult woman breastfeeding I mean

obviously an adult woman breastfeeding

yeah a lot of us how many of you have

experienced a woman breastfeeding her

baby that has her babies smothered under

a blanket yeah

because here’s what happens we’d rather

cover our baby up than to have you see a

boob because we’ve grown up in a culture

where that is not acceptable that is the

shame that goes from childhood into

adulthood and that’s what I’m referring

to and I say this is how we’re raised so

boys and girls are not raised the same

in this country

second unconscious gender bias is real

and all that means is that we have

expectations of someone based on their

bias so we are for example expecting

girls or women to be nice and we’re

expecting men to be direct and to lead

us to show us the way there was an

incredible interview that I watched with

Sheryl Sandberg and Oprah Winfrey and

Sheryl Sandberg said you know women are

still referred to or women are still

expecting other women to be to rather be

nice we expect women to be nice even now

I stand on this stage as a feminist and

I still expect a woman to be nice here’s

what could happen here’s a great example

if a man walked into a room and said hey

I’ll need this by four o’clock we might

go okay yeah sure at 4 o’clock if a

woman walked into the room and did the

exact same thing

she’s assertive she’s aggressive she’s

bitchy and she’s too direct because she

didn’t have small talk first she didn’t

ask me how my kids were doing she didn’t

ask how my husband

do you ever expect a man to walk into a

room and ask you how your kids are doing

no but even as women we expect that

behavior of other women so it’s no

surprise that we are in the place that

we’re in today and then there’s the tall

poppy syndrome the tall poppy syndrome

is envy based the tall poppy syndrome is

not something that we refer to a lot in

the US but it’s talked about a lot more

in Australia and it’s the idea that tall

poppies or poppies that are in a field

are meant to grow at about the same

height and when one grows too high it

gets chopped down so this is I love the

audience going yeah yeah so this is what

we do to women and women we do this to

other women when women get a little bit

too successful it makes us uncomfortable

when they ask for a little bit too much

and actually get it we don’t like that

either so again these are not qualities

or traits that we want to show off for

the world because there’s a lot of shame

behind them this tall poppy syndrome

stems from envy it stems from jealousy

remember we’re nice nice people aren’t

jealous nice people aren’t envious so no

we don’t want to admit to this and then

there’s the imposter complex so we’re

the tall poppy syndrome was envy based

the imposter complex is fear-based

the imposter complex as Tanya Geisler

refers to it where we are unable to

internalize our own successes so if any

of you question whether or not you’ve

experienced it it may sound something

like this hey you did a great job out

there and then you respond to go ah you

know it really could have been better

because I forgot this i forgot this and

i forgot that sound familiar

yeah here’s here’s a super example my

mom for thanksgiving made a six-course

meal six people six-course meal everyone

proceeded to tell her how amazing the

meal was she made 13 pies there’s only

four kids she made 13 pies as everyone

proceeded to tell her how amazing the

meal was do you know what her response

was

it wasn’t thank you it was this that

roast beef was dry kinda sounds silly

but it’s the truth that is the impostor

complex we are unable to internalize our

own successes and it stems from one

overwhelming feeling and that feeling is

fear fear that we are not enough we are

not good enough we are not as good as

someone else maybe and so that shows up

for us so we’ve talked about several

ways in which we’ve gotten here and none

of them are exceptionally beautiful but

they are in fact our truth so you see

women didn’t just wake up one day and

decide not to be nice to other women no

that’s not what happened

we were culturally in many ways taught

to show up the way we do today so this

we are in fact in our culture taught to

shun women I’ll share with you a story

as I said I sent her on the stage a

feminist with hot pink hair and pink

lipstick and high heels who works

specifically with women I attend a lot

of women’s events and I would like to

think that I know better I mean I know

how we got here so why would I show up

in the world in this way except I do and

I have and I’ve been guilty of every

single one of those last month I was at

one of those events that I swear I don’t

know how I get invited to these things

but I did and there was a line wrapped

around the block and I was on the VIP

list so I was inside and I was having

champagne with a girlfriend I don’t even

like champagne but I was having

champagne with a girlfriend and I I kid

you not I just turned to the left for a

second and I swear it looked like the

crowds parted ways PS there were 1500

women at this event the crowds parted

ways and this stunning woman walked

through she had on a one-piece outfit

and her thing was hanging out so I said

everything yeah so but here’s what

happened next I stood there I put my

champagne down on the table I put my

hands on

hips and I went mm-hmm now why would she

show up like that with everything

hanging out I run a business to empower

women but that was the thought that came

to mind for me and I caught myself and I

said Cindy this is not about that woman

so here’s what I did next I kept my

champagne down on the table for about

1.5 more seconds I picked it up and I

sauntered over to a floor mentioned

beautiful woman and I said hey beautiful

woman how did you get the courage to

show up in a room of 1,500 powerful

women dressed like that

we spent I love this it feels like

church thank you for that we spent the

next half an hour in a conversation that

ended in laughter and in tears and what

that taught me was this there’s an

amazing quote by brené Brown in her

newest book and she says we cannot hate

people close up she was right

because the second I walked over to this

woman and had a conversation she was me

and we can laugh and we can cry and we

can share one another’s truths and so

we’ve got to be willing to move in to

lean in and to have those conversations

more honestly so you may be wondering

where do we go from here how do we go

from sharing the narrative where we all

hate each other and we’re only

pretending to uplift each other to one

in which we actually do it’s not that

hard and there are four R’s to remember

first recognize and acknowledge how you

feel and that these feelings are not

about the other woman so the next time a

beautiful woman walks into the room just

honor that recognize like oh yeah I

checked her out definitely checked her

out

and I and I’m thinking the things that

I’m thinking definitely thinking those

things but equally acknowledge that it’s

not about her because she didn’t

actually do anything she just showed up

being awesome the way we all should

second redirect those feelings towards

empathy toward grace and curiosity and

what I mean when I say that is redirect

those feelings toward ourselves so

rather than feeling shame around the way

that we feel when a beautiful woman or a

successful woman walks in the room show

ourselves grace show ourselves empathy

be curious have the conversation and

explore however do take responsibility

and accountability for your fears

because when we acknowledge what is true

for us it gives the power back because

fear can no longer take hold of us the

third are reach out and build conscious

community as long as we as women

continue to see ourselves as other we

will never come together we can never

truly empower other women so we must

change this narrative because when we do

come together we change history

insert women’s March history-making

January 21st 2017 yeah give a high five

to the women’s March I am not mad at

them we were there fourth are actually

this is a great quote it says there’s a

quiet transformation happening that is

moving us from turning on each other

instead turning toward each other

Piper nee Brown and that’s what I mean

by build conscious community finally

reflect and live your deepest values in

your why because when you give yourself

permission to show up in the world for

everything that you are and boldly stand

up and tell your truth you are

empowering one another to do the same as

women we are permission givers for one

another and we have got to take that

role seriously so recognize redirect

reach out and reflect

we must first get to know ourselves and

hold a mirror up to our relationships

with other women before we can move

forward your courage your empathy and

your grace our permission giving and

more so they are visionary for everyone

around you and it is only via these

behaviors that we can truly and collectively rise thank you

Please follow and like us: