Press "Enter" to skip to content

“The Backstage of Motivation” | Paul McCarthy | TEDxUniversityofGlasgow


the title of my talk today is if at

first you don’t succeed I think most

people can finish this often-quoted line

so when I was in primary school one of

our teachers had two quotations over the

blackboard the first one was do what you

do do well and the second was if at

first you don’t succeed try try again

and it was a picture of Dennis Taylor

who had won the 1985 World Snooker

Championships was interesting about

these two quotes is that they’ve served

me well over the years but more recently

I’ve come to enjoy a new interpretation

of if at first you don’t succeed try try

again it’s the one by David Brent from

the office if at first you don’t succeed

hide all evidence you ever tried in the

so if it doesn’t work out today

okay I’m snow Gert the notion of trying

and failing and continuing is a really

interesting one and it’s kind of the

theme of my talk here today but to

introduce myself properly my name is dr.

Paul McCarthy and I’m saying that with

emphasis not because I’ve earned that

PhD but more for the notion that I carry

a level of competence or at least I’m

supposed to have when I work with people

and I work a lot in sport and this

notion of working in sport is really

important because the people who are

seeing a psychologist often feel that

there is some stigma attached to it if

you’re working with a psychologist you

must have problems but once you come to

see a psychologist we do a very clever

thing we turn your problems into issues

no more problems but that notion that

psychologists are working with problems

and dealing with issues it’s a really

narrow view and we’re really looking at

enlightened self-interest how do I get

the best out of myself in every possible

way and getting the best out of

ourselves often means that we are trying

to understand who we are now and where

we want to go to in the future that

process of enlightened self-interest is

really about seeing the whole picture

and there’s a lovely quote ever tried

ever field no matter try again fail

again feel better and support by Samuel

Beckett but the notion of that trying

and failing doesn’t work well for

everybody so when we work with athletes

we’re looking at different components

physical mental technical tactical and

lifestyle we’re trying to present an

entire view of the athletes life and why

the psychologist has a unique role

because he or she is set is usually

stepping a little bit further away than

the code

strength and conditioning coach

nutritionist and so on there there is a

sounding board and they’re there to give

a perspective that most athletes might

not ordinarily get from the team around

them and in sports just as in life we

have a lot of compare and despair you

look at yourself you see somebody else

and you come up short and we do this all

the time what we wear what we achieve

the car we drive the holidays we go on

so what we tend to do is poison the

present with this compare and despair

we’re sad about what happened in the

past worried about what might happen in

the future and the present doesn’t get

any better so most of the work are the

psychologists and especially in sport is

trying to look at psychological fitness

how do we manage ourselves better seeing

the challenges that we experience every

day and this notion and the thread of

today’s talk is about that resilience

that we have a notion of motivation now

I’m going to do with the service to all

the motivational fear result here by

next analogy I’m going to use a bulk or

evasion but if we conceptualize

motivation as energy and direction I’ll

explain it like this

imagine you are a car in a car park

filled with petrol but you keep going

around the car park you’re lots of

energy with no direction alternatively

you could be a car on the motorway

knowing where you’re going but no petrol

and no energy to drive you where you’re

going so that notion of energy and

direction is it’s interesting because

sometimes we read out energy sometimes

we read out Direction sometimes we’re

without both and many people seek the

help of a psychologist to be able to

deal with these issues but the

psychologists can only work with these

issues if the person coming to see us is

willing to work on these things him or

herself so we need the client to be

engaged and that’s the really hard part

because most people who come to see us

would like us to take away

all the issues that seem to surround

them and then we tell them we can’t

until they start to help themselves but

this notion of motivation then when we

think about it how you might have been

motivated in the past especially if you

have been involved in sport much of it

is shouting screaming swearing demeaning

running you down running other people

down and we’ve all had a lot of that

does it make you feel good doesn’t seem

to but somehow we think this must be the

way forward to threaten people put them

under pressure so what we often tend to

do is we end up attacking somebody’s

personality their attributes and their

character so we are attacking them

personally and the interesting thing

about is is that it doesn’t tend to work

so well because words are knives so

here’s my problem I’m not going to work

to anybody here today but just to

illustrate what I mean if I say words or

knives I said this to my little boy and

he said you had that of course they’re

words heart

or it’s heart if I use this knife in my

interactions with other people I could

hand them as we are safely asked to do

the handle or I could hand them the

blade now we all know the right thing to

do but here our interactions with others

often mean that we are handing them to

bleed and our interactions with ourself

we’re often handy ourselves to bleed

we’re heartful totters hurtful to

ourselves some people think this works

and I guess a little bit of it does but

we’re trying to move away from that

notion towards a more enlightened view

that we have alternatives we could

listen to somebody to motivate them we

could ask them what they enjoy we could

ask them what it is they need and how

they need at under way in which they

need it we could provide a supportive

environment no that’s not be for me to

stand up here and say this but in the

world of professional sport or in

education or in business it doesn’t go

down so well because it takes a lot of

time it takes a lot of endeavor

and that notion of hard work seems like

too much it’s much easier to shout at

somebody or scream but the difficulty

with that is that the emotional bomb

we’re all looking for we rarely get that

we might be able to get in other ways to

maybe tranquilizing our emotions to

maybe alcohol or food or whatever we can

but we never really get to the root of

what’s going on and recently a golf

coach asks me well I suppose a few years

ago now asked me if I would see one of

his players and he said he’s a great guy

but he’s so negative in fact he’s so

negative the court said that he loses

mobile phone reception and he’s working

with him this is interesting so he said

I’d like you to see what you could do so

when I met him things weren’t going so

well and he said that he had made so

little on tour this year that money

thought he was dead and he was really

looking for a helping hand here so I

said well let’s see where we can go when

we started talking it became clear that

his interpretation of the world his way

of making sense of it was that he was a

victim fair enough but more than that

the way he treated himself was a bit

like that knife the blade went in a lot

so what he did to the ball he stopped he

thought was the coach’s domain but what

the ball did to him was my domain

how was I going to help him feel better

about what was going on on off the golf

course but after speaking for a little

while we said the best way to begin here

it’s a little bit of self-awareness

getting to know yourself and because he

was going back out into her I just

suggested he might read a book for a

little bit of enlightenment which he did

and a notion within this book is trying

to help us to see ourselves and nobody

really wants to see ourselves because if

anyone has read in Scott pecks book the

road less traveled you might understand

the very first line of this book says

life is difficult and it’s a line all on

its own a sentence all on its own and

what it goes on to see is that if you

accept that life is difficult

life becomes easy because you never

expect anything to be easy because you

already accepted that life was difficult

nice and easy so we’re trying to hold

this notion in mind that if we accept

that Golf is difficult or sport is

difficult we very little to complain

about and that’s wonderful for me within

this book M Scott Peck spoke about this

dilemma that he had he was working

really hard working late and his

colleagues were leaving early even

though they had the same caseload but he

was working because he was working down

reproduce he was putting in a little bit

more effort into the process so he went

to see his line manager as line manager

said to him you have a problem with your

time and he goes I know I have I just

told you

I’m having to work much later can you

alter my load for me so he he just left

him he approached him again and asked

him you know I told you about the

problem I was having can you do

something about it to which the reply

came you have a problem with your time

now impact left very angry with this and

he was angry for about three months

until he realized the lesson that his

lying manager was trying to teach him he

was trying to tell them that the way you

live your life the way you set your

standards they become the cause of your

disappointment and anger later he chose

to put in all the effort extra effort

more than his colleagues yet he was

angry at somebody else not himself it’s

a strange situation but one which when

we look at our own lives we realize that

we have a sense of responsibility and

accountability to be able to look after

ourselves in the right way and once we

have that sense of accountability and

responsibility we start to drive our

motivation in a direction in which we

are willing to travel now if I said to

you can you write a book object pop

might you say I often ask my students

and they say no and then I tell them

about the diving bell and the butterfly

a story about Jean Dominique Bobby who

had locked-in syndrome and only had the

use of his left eyelid and he brought a

book I read it it’s a lovely book now if

I provide that perspective you might say

to yourself well

he was able to write a book with his

left eyelid how did he do it well

there’s a specific way of doing that

right most frequently-used that letters

in the alphabet are presented first then

you get somebody to help you and

obviously that’s how the book but it’s a

lot of blinking to say yes that’s the

letter I’m looking for it was a

difficult process the difficult process

meant a lot of time but the principle

behind it was that somebody could do

something that ordinarily you might

think was not possible not just because

they’re spending time but because

they’re investing in a process with

values they believe in so being

motivators really is following the

values you hold for yourself I like

books I like to read but this is a

lovely one that you might read maybe

sometime in the future it’s about a

seagull called Jonathan Livingston

Seagull he was no ordinary seagull he

wanted to find out how fast he could fly

how low he could fly but he wasn’t like

other seagulls who just looked for food

and and flow out after trawlers and then

back to the shore he wanted to become

faster and faster and faster and as you

read and book the story shows him

getting very very good at something

DubLi as thought he could do but the

flock didn’t like that he was really

good at this they wanted him to be just

like them but he wanted to be different

he was motivated to change the maximize

his potential and it saw him being

excluded from the flock he went away and

came back but he wasn’t allowed to join

the flock but others within the flock

thought I’d like to be able to do what

he’s doing

so they went to seek his help and they

tried to learn from him and after a

while they thought that everything he

possessed was something extraordinary

nothing that the seagulls themselves

could have but what he was trying to

explain to them was he got better at

flying simply by investing time and

effort and learning and fundamentally

that’s all we’re ever trying to do we

get better at what we do by investing

time so we could solve most problems we

have true effort strategy and health

modders if you think about that that’s

pretty good

there’s a little bit more to it than

that but that’s pretty helpful

effort strategy and helpful mothers you

can always put in effort you can always

change your strategy and you can always

get help from others lots of people come

to see me and they say I’ve tried

everything and I say everything ok maybe

not everything

ten things really ten ok maybe not 10

two things and Portland don’t work and

usually that notion that they’ve tried

everything isn’t true and even the

everyday protein might be true either

so as psychologists we’re trying to help

people to value themselves first to make

the change possible and then figure out

what’s the right strategy working with

the client towards their ends now when

we look at ourselves we see ourselves as

we were born and was we grew up there

was you know a rarely childhood was the

authentic self we just went around as we

did our lives our youngest is two and

she will happily run around with no

nappy on happy happy happy

and when she’s sad she cries and when

she’s angry she throws things but as she

gets older that authentic self changes a

little bit because people tell her that

you can’t do that and you need to do

things that are well are the right

things

so she becomes an adapted child and she

learns to do things that mommy and daddy

think are the right things to do and

after a while she realizes that as I am

I’m unacceptable but if I do the right

things I become acceptable and that

works for us for most of her lives but

at this stage of our lives we often

think about what would I be like if I

had the best parts of myself so if I was

going to change my diet go to the gym

eat fruit for breakfast drink water all

day get up in the morning air early hit

the gym all of these things that we

promised ourselves and reluctantly can’t

keep can’t follow through a bit like the

new year’s resolution we want something

but somehow either the effort or the

strategy goes awry and part of the

reason why the effort or strategy goes

awry is because we’re looking for

something but in the wrong place if I

said just like we had spoken with the

golfer that we were going to look for

something that we are choosing not that

what somebody else wants but something

of our own choosing

we would be much closer to finding what

we are looking for so when somebody

comes to see a psychologist

we’re firstly working on their awareness

getting to know themselves and all they

want really is the opportunity to get to

know themselves they’re scared by it but

the in the end value of the opportunity

and there’s a lovely quote by TS Eliot

that says footfalls echo in the memory

down the passage we did not take towards

the door we never opened and it is about

regrets of all regrets of tongue and pen

the saddest are DS what might have been

and that quote helps us to see a world

of future a future if we travel down a

particular route we don’t know what

other rolls are going to be like but

we’re going down there in an enlightened

way we’ve taken a look at ourselves we

said change is possible and we’re

seeking to go forward so before I go

this notion of psychological fitness is

available for everybody change is

difficult but possible and we can always

step lightly into the future for everything we need thank you very much

Please follow and like us: