
science of networks now if you’ve heard
about networks there’s a pretty good
chance of what you’ll think about is
maybe the movie the social network you
might think about Facebook you might
think about Twitter or Instagram if
you’re a little bit older you might
think about another movie and play
called six degrees of separation
when Will Smith was younger and did
funny or more interesting movies my
comment networks from another
perspective okay so I look at infectious
diseases now I did my my undergrad in my
graduate work in physics but I soon got
really interested in how you could use
some of the techniques in physics to
understand how diseases pass through
populations okay a lot of you look
pretty young to remember this but in
2001 there was a big epidemic of
something called foot-and-mouth disease
now foot mouth disease is probably the
most infectious disease we know of and
when it came into the country it would
result in over six million livestock
being slaughtered cost us over 8 billion
pounds to control farmers today are
still traumatized by what happened to
them now one of the things about the
epidemic is it was spread initially by
sheep moving all around the country ok
so that’s what all those arrows and that
map behind me are and you can ask the
question well what does sheep moving
around Britain have to do with things
like Facebook or Twitter okay the thing
is if you view a population as a series
of individuals with connections between
them and information flowing between
them then it doesn’t matter what that
information is in a way if it’s diseases
it’s a bacteria or a virus it could be
pandemic flu or a bola virus
transmitting around the world if it’s
something like Facebook or Twitter
it’s information of another sort it
could be news it could be gossip it
could be fake news now there’s a few
commonalities to these things which help
us to understand what it is about making
a disease spread from place to place in
the same way it helps us understand when
does a piece of gossip sort of go like
wildfire also that everybody knows about
it one of those things is some
we call super spreaders so there’s some
individuals who are just really really
active if you think about gossip it’s
the individual always has their ears
grunted always know what everybody’s
doing and once they know it once they
know it then they tell everybody if it’s
disease over here for this system that
I’m talking about its markets because
markets bring in lots of animals and
then they spread them out again now
because they’re more important books for
transmitting information and forgetting
that information that makes them really
really important out of proportion to
their actual activity two times is
active four times as important now the
other thing is that what you can see on
this map is that there are different
areas the country which are infected and
that infection in different parts of the
country are cars bug the jumps by
individual groups of animals and these
are what we call small world links okay
and they refer to the that what often
happens when you talk to somebody a
party say oh isn’t it a small world we
both know the same person now later on
you’re going to be introduced to Steve
Backshall he’s not here at the moment
I’ve never met him however it just so
happens I used to live in a village
called Claire north of Glasgow some
friends who kids go to school with my
kids or news – Nigel Pope and Jackie
savoury happened to bring us wildlife
documentaries including the highlands
documentary which some of you wildlife
documentary which some of you would have
seen and they know Steve and so they
represent in a social sense those small
world links now what do those networks
look like that I actually deal with so
what you see here is what looks like a
big mess what it is is a bunch of farms
it’s all the farms that own sheep in
Scotland and all the movements of sheep
between them in one month June of 2014
and what that represents is a population
of over two thousand in individual farms
which over 3,000 individual events among
them so this information is recorded
from day to day now to a person like me
who loves looking at data because I sort
of almost voyeuristic interesting and
seeing what people do this is like candy
okay you can look at this for ages just
to try to figure out what people are
doing and the really big datasets that
we have
things like moving of capital around
Britain we know where every single cow
is for every single day of its life over
its entire lifespan so that’s 25 million
animals over roughly speaking 50 years
we’re talking terabytes of data and all
this information produces what appears
to be enormous complexity now I’m going
to thin this Knepper out a bit by saying
okay well let’s not take a look let’s
take a week and what you should be able
to see by comparing the two things is
that you got broadly those same
properties which I showed you before
with foot-and-mouth stuff so you get
these these groups these clusters of
nodes so those are the big groups of
circles those represents farms moving
things in and out of markets and then
you’ve got these things that join them
up those are those small world links and
so what you can see is the pattern of
the disease as it transmits in 2001 is
replicated in the pattern of movements
and that pattern is consistent so
underlying the complexity there are
often simple rules and to try to
convince you that those rules apply to
more than just sheep in Britain this is
my rather pathetic Twitter network these
are my Twitter followers all 50 out of
them they’re grouped as a network is
people who I follow and people who
follow me there actually are more of
them but a lot of them are junk where
people just sort of well anyway there’s
there’s a lot of spam out there in the
Twitter world they’re grouped in four
groove but you can still see that same
pattern the groups which represent
different interest areas that I have are
all connected by bridging follows okay
so the same kind of structure you see
saw before look at the same thing
another way so this represents a series
of tweets retweets and mentions all
around the term bovine TB and the reason
being is because one of the disease’s I
look at is bovine tuberculosis in cattle
and badgers now some of you only know
this is a very controversial disease so
there actually is quite a bit of Twitter
traffic about it so in this short time
frame you can see that same pattern
individuals who are super spreaders lots
of things going back and forth with them
and bridging between different groups
the different groups who represent
things like government officials farmers
badger welfare groups okay and so what
you should be able to see from this is
that a network is a network but what
travels over the network largely depends
on the behavior different bits of
information are interesting to different
people for different reasons and one of
the really interesting things for me is
what happens when things like behavior
and disease operate over the same
network in other words what happens when
two networks collide so I did a study
with a friend of mine Jess Enright who
works in computer science where we
simulated a population of supposed
farmers so every individual that you see
there is a farmer and there are linked
to their next-door neighbors so these
are like farms spreading disease to each
other and in this simple simulation that
we ran we had four properties and that’s
it that’s the entire simulation we have
an infection risk so these farmers can
infect each other but they can also be
infected by some external factor and
let’s imagine that they’re say Badgers
infecting the farms without the farmers
doing anything themselves the farmers
have memory so they know what happened
to them before did they get disease
yesterday did they get the disease two
days ago etc etc and they applied some
sort of value system to it
so the question is how much do I value
having a disease-free farm and the last
thing they have is on the basis of that
combination of memory and value is they
make choices and the choices do I do
something to stop disease or do I not
and so what this graph represents is the
outcome of some of those simulations so
if you look across the bottom axis
glowing to the right what we say is well
what happens as you increase the amount
of risk that a farm is experiencing okay
so more and more badgers infected for
example well what you could see at the
beginning as you move from left to right
is that as that risk increases what you
would expect to happen is the amount of
disease increases but you reach a
critical point
okay what’s called a phase transition
where all of a sudden the disease risk
drops the reason being that farmers
start to change their behavior
and so you get kind of the
counterintuitive result that increasing
risk actually results in decreasing
disease now that’s a really good thing
right people reacting to circumstance
doing things for the good of everybody
and everybody benefits
but the really curious thing about it is
this now in that last simulation that I
was mentioning everybody more or less
have the same value system okay they
value Disease Control about the same
amount some randomness in it but we’re
pretty much the same now what this says
if we now look at the red line if only
one percent of individuals one percent
don’t care about disease at all what
happens is there is actually no benefit
at all to people being hearing about
biosecurity okay so one percent of
individuals can make all the difference
between controlling a disease and not
now the thing to keep in mind about this
is that these individuals actually don’t
disease spread very far they can only
spread it to their next-door neighbors
okay so that my friend just would put it
what they’re responsible for is not so
much the spreading of disease but what
they’re responsible is for the spreading
of despair okay farmers deciding that
just isn’t worth it to do some kind of
action because there it does no good now
that that contrast okay between
individuals doing what they very
rationally perceive as being the right
thing and an outcome that is worse for
everybody is actually something that’s
known not from social networks so much
but from something called game theory
and you may have heard from about game
theory in for example the movie A
Beautiful Mind which is about John Nash
who was one of the originators of the
whole field what the networks add to it
is they said that a small number of
influential individuals can change
everything even though most people don’t
even know that they exist now that’s an
example of where networks and small
number of individuals can cause
something bad to happen what I’m going
to argue about now is to say that
sometimes those few individuals can do
something good
now when I talk about difficult friends
I’m pretty sure most of you know what I
mean effectively they are that person
who you least want to see at your door
at the end of a long day either at uni
or at work asking to go up for a drink
okay but you’d go out anyway because
they’re your friends and those friends
could be your classmates those friends
could be people you’ll work with
it could be friends from your childhood
they could be your parents okay this is
simulated my daughter actually is pretty
good about having things anyway and the
thing is in today’s world where a lot of
our interactions are through social
media okay where we do things virtually
it is very easy to unfriend somebody to
make sure that you only follow the
people on Twitter you agree with to only
read the newspapers online that say the
things that you like to hear and that is
true whether you read breitbart news or
or listen to Fox News or a Guardian
reader it’s true about everybody we can
do that same thing about isolating
ourselves from individuals who do not
think like us and the reason why those
individuals are important I’m going to
try to show over here now this is my
Twitter network again now remember I
said these four groups are broadly
speaking groups of people who tend to
follow each other all right and broadly
speaking as well they refer to different
disciplines that are involved in the
work I do so I work in infectious
diseases population policy so I need to
talk to people or evolutionary
biologists statisticians mathematicians
people do networks veterinarians etc etc
etc but scientists often do not speak
the same language they speak different
languages mathematicians in particular
there were some I met upstairs are
completely different from everybody else
okay and unless you make the effort to
break through those language barriers
then you lose an awful lot in the
science especially in these areas where
all of them are important now the thing
about these links is because there are a
few a number they’re actually very
fragile lose them and again you lose
the communication the cooperation in the
network and I’m going to show you
another example or this has actually
been really really important okay so now
this graph over here this represents
American Senate voting patterns from the
time of dwight d eisenhower being
present which is in the early 50s
through de barackobama so there’s no
data yet on donald trump and i don’t
want to know what that looks like
so these US Senate voting patterns
represent the proportion of all votes
per year where Democrats although one
way and Republicans all vote the other
and so what you can see is all the way
pretty much until the first George Bush
that proportion of these polarized votes
actually stays fairly constant obviously
his fluctuations from the year to year
but we’re talking about a time when all
sorts of major incredibly controversial
events occurred we’re talking about
civil rights movements in the 60s we’re
talking about the Vietnam War we’re
talking about the oil crisis we’re
talking about all sorts of things which
should have been divisive and yet
because the American parties believe
that consensus and the good of the
countries is more important in the party
they tended to agree as much as they
could that has all changed over the last
few years and in fact by the time
Obama’s president the polarization is
absolutely incredible
now I haven’t looked at these data
myself but other people have and the
pattern is being driven by a relatively
few number of senators who are willing
to cross the floor okay they’re not many
of them there never have been but they
were always there but they have
virtually disappeared over the last
eight years now the net result of that
is an American government that became
largely dysfunctional over the last few
years the disillusionment of the
American people with the traditional
directions of power and the rise of
populist like Donald Trump now the thing
about Donald Trump is he’s actually not
that special I mean there have been
people like him all the time there
always will be Donald Trump’s in the
world okay what has changed is our
attitudes all right now some of you may
have heard of something
the Doomsday Clock okay the Doomsday
Clock was started in 1947 by a bunch of
nuclear scientists we wanted to have
some sort of graphical representation of
how closely were to an apocalypse
initially nuclear but now including
things like climate change for example
and just this past January they decided
that we were actually now closer to some
major disaster than we have been since
the 1950s now when things are bad okay
when when we have tough times this is a
time when we most want to retreat into
our comfort zone it’s a time when it’s
very easy to blame others Outsiders for
what our problems are and that’s true in
the American election but we certainly
cannot point fingers here can we with
results after the bread’s vote for
example so I remember people blaming
older people for why we were in this
problem saying why are they allowed to
vote because they’re not going to live
very long okay I mean this goes
completely against the principles of
democracy it’s precisely these times
where we need to reach out where we need
to reach out to those difficult friends
people who don’t necessarily agree with
not because they’re going to change
their minds but so we can understand the
way they think
now I’m gonna end this talk a slightly
different way from I originally intended
to I just found out last night that my
sister my older sister is in hospital
and she’s not doing very well and so
this is sort of a tribute to her she’s
one of those difficult people she does
not agree with me in any way politically
personally the way we raise our kids etc
etc we don’t talk that much but I know
she cares and I know that she always
tries to understand my point of view she
almost never succeeds okay and I almost
never succeed with her but the truth of
the matter is sometimes we do and in
that course of doing that I think I’ve
actually become a much better person so
the reason why I like networks the
reason I enjoy studying them because I
like the way they tell us about how the
disease is transmitted but also I like
the way they tell us about ourselves
they tell us about how we interact not
just as individuals there’s populations
how we interact as a group
and I hope you think so a little bit
more now yourself thank you very much [Applause]