Press "Enter" to skip to content

Space Might be Our Last Frontier, but Diversity is Our Last Horizon | Svitlana Ramer | TEDxTAMU


howdy

I’m so excited to be with you here today

and talk a little bit about diversity

but before I tell you anything about

myself I actually have a question that I

want to ask you about myself if you had

to guess where do you think I come from

Italy Germany oh good

Argentina I love it thank you

Russia those are all really really

wonderful guesses but I think the

interesting part is that there was not

actually a consensus there was so many

there were so many different opinions

right and there wasn’t an obvious

response an easy way to pin me down and

my admits ethnicity for somebody who is

fairly generically white and doesn’t

have much of an accent and also has less

name that’s not really reflective of

their ethnicity mine is my current last

name is a courtesy of my wonderful

husband it’s really hard to pin down

where they come from I am actually

Ukrainian not as in born in America to

Ukrainian parents Ukrainian I mean born

and raised fresh of the boat Ukrainian I

came here only about eight years ago to

pursue my graduate education at ECU from

a master’s and then at Penn State for my

PhD when I came here my experiences with

cultural shock adjustment to the new

environment and trying to figure out who

I was in this new country were so

profound that I did what any other

academic would do I made these questions

the topic of my dissertation I spent the

next four years researching immigration

immigrant adjustment and cross-cultural

identity issues and what I found was

actually pretty traumatizing

according to dr. Celia Fowler cough who

is a scholar as well as a practicing

therapist immigrants are about four

times more likely to experience social

anxiety depression substance abuse

and suicidal thoughts and actions all

because of their struggles and

adjustment and their struggles with

identity why does it get so bad other

pair of pair of scholars iron jet and

they try to offer us a little bit of an

understanding by suggesting a concept of

identity continuity which is basically a

connection between who we were in the

past to who we are now they showed that

identity continuity is an integral part

of our psychological well-being and the

physical act of relocation to another

country massively ruptures identity

continuity to understand why that

happens we need to understand a little

bit more about identity Jean Feeney who

is a leading scholar in the area of

identity and ethnicity says that

identity actually has two different

components an internal component and an

external component an internal component

basically is who I think I am an

external component is who you think I am

but since there’s really no way of

getting into somebody else’s head it’s

really about what I think you think I am

that makes sense right and so for me for

example that would be thinking of myself

as a Ukrainian through and through but

also realizing that people around me

don’t see me that way I’m pretty sure my

own husband thinks that I’m fairly

well-adjusted American and expects me to

behave and think accordingly but I’m not

American and I never will be because I

came here so late in life and so the

closeted Ukrainian within me suffers

from continuous non recognition and when

so much of our external identity becomes

misplaced this is when our internal

identity starts suffering and we start

experiencing all these psychological

issues just how much of the external

identity can be misplaced I’m going to

give you an example I’m going to show

you an image and I want you to just

think to yourself about what you see in

this image this picture was shared at a

graduate research seminar on critical

thinking here at Texas A&M and the

speaker asked the exact same question

what do you see in this Victor

I think I said something along the lines

of well there is a man on the side of

the road fixing a trunk something very

obvious like that and then other

responses started coming in and somebody

said well this is a third-world country

like why would you say that and they say

well we’ll look at the colored color

colorfully painted walls I was like that

looks like pretty much every other

Street I saw in Hawaii or in Palm Beach

somebody else mentioned we’ll look at

how dilapidated the truck is that he’s

fixing I think you’re trying to tell me

their own dilapidated trucks in Texas

because I get stuck behind one every

single day in Houston and so play the

devil’s advocate like that for a little

while until one comment came in well

this can be in America because Americans

are not creative and they’re wasteful

and they wouldn’t try to fix this truck

and they would just throw it away and

buy a new one I really didn’t have much

just after that because when you have so

much assumption and judgment flying in

the air there’s really no appropriate

way to respond to that so would like you

to return back to the things you thought

when you first saw this picture and see

if you made any of the assumptions about

this situation they were not readily

present in the image and now knowing how

much psychological distress it can bring

to people when you place those

assumptions of external identity on them

is it even ethical to do so let’s go

through some brief statistics just in

the United States the number of

immigrants increased from 77 million to

244 million between 1960s in early 2000s

at this point about 15 percent of the

population here is foreign-born but if

you really think about it deeper if

you’re not Native American that means

your family came here from somewhere and

that means that with different lengths

of time all of us in here are immigrants

so how is a nation form then

how do we bring together all of this

diversity to create this beautiful

tapestry that is the American Society

the process through which immigrants or

any people adjust to another culture is

called acculturation John berry created

a theory of acculturation and he

suggested that there are four different

paths to acculturation depending on how

much somebody is willing to acquire the

host society so societies culture and

how much they’re willing to maintain

their own home culture so for example if

somebody comes to the US and believes

that their success depends on becoming

as American as quickly as possible they

would pursue the path of assimilation if

on the other hand somebody comes in and

they completely reject the host culture

they only talk to people from their own

culture they consume their own media

they live in ethnic enclaves like

Chinatown and Little Italy and Brighton

Beach they are pursuing the path of

separation the most psychologically

stressful scenario is rejection of both

cultures called marginalization it’s

similar to a feeling of I don’t yet

belong here but I no longer belong there

it’s a very psychologically difficult

place to be according to Barry the most

labor-intensive but also the most

successfully adaptive path is

integration where an immigrant literally

picks and chooses the best qualities

from different cultures to become the

most successful unique individual that

they can be I decided that pursuing US

education would make me successful here

but there will not come a day when I’m

going to give up Ukrainian food so I

pick and choose things that make me

successful so this is already complex

right we have people that can default to

any of these four paths at any time what

brings another level of complexity to

the diversity that we face today is that

people come to us from countries who

have different levels of cultural

distance to this society

a Dutch sociologist Geert Hofstede a

created a model of cultural differences

and said that there are actually six

dimensions on which cultures differ from

one another

there’s individualism collectivism

masculinity femininity long-term versus

short-term orientation power distance

and uncertainty avoidance six different

dimensions with a scale from zero to

hundred that’s a little bit of diversity

if I’ve ever seen one

so to keep it close to home I’m going to

give you an example between Ukraine and

the United States

what Geert Hofstede they did is he took

on this massive project when he went and

surveyed countries all around the world

and developed scales and there was a

very nifty online tool where you can go

and plug in two countries and it will

show you just how different on each

dimension those countries are so for

example on power distance the u.s. is

very low this is a society where

equality freedom of speech speaking up

for yourself are very highly valued

right students get participation points

for speaking up challenging the

professor asking questions in Ukraine a

professor walks into the room the class

stands up and doesn’t sit back down

until the professor says it’s okay to do

so so the level of power distance is

very different

similar with individualism collectivism

drastically different scores Ukraine has

spent seventy years being part of the

USSR and the collectivist ideology is

still very much alive United States is a

textbook example of an individualistic

culture similar differences exist for

masculinity feminity

uncertainty avoidance Americans are risk

takers there are so many inventions that

have been done here because people are

willing to take risks we’re going to fly

and crash a bunch of planes but we’re

going to be the first people who’s going

to lift off in the outer banks

Ukrainians are much more cautious what

my husband thinks is a type-a

personality is really high cultural

level of uncertainty

avoidance I don’t just want to know

you’re going to take out the trash I

want to know when I don’t like

uncertainty right same with long-term

and short-term orientation we think

about things in sort of more longer

timeframes whereas Americans kind of go

day by day which is reflected also in

the indulgence level Ukrainians because

they’re collectivistic and because

they’re long-term oriented we’re willing

to forego instant gratification for some

goal in the far future whereas with a

lot of convenience and driving and

bigger portions and a lots of sweet

things Americans are known as one of the

most indulgent cultures in the world so

with so much cultural difference being

able to produce an immigrant that

doesn’t really look or sound very

different on the surface

how are we to identify ourselves anymore

if ethnicity voice of origin cultural

ties are no longer the defining pillars

of our identity then what is and here in

America where so much of this complexity

and diversity is present how do we how

do we know what it is to be American

anymore we are such a progressive

society we develop technologies we reach

out into space we call it our last

frontier we’re saying we’re going to be

on Mars by 2020 but I believe that it is

here on earth that we face our last

challenge our last horizon which is a

society of acceptance and non judgment a

society where we don’t build walls and

don’t pray separation a society where

diversity itself becomes the pillar of

our identity so on this Earth Day I want

to leave you with a challenge as you go

through your day try to be aware and

notice those moments when your mind

tries to jump to assumptions and

judgments about somebody else just based

on a cursory look about them and try to

actually get to know them a little bit

more because on the diversity horizon

all identities shine bright

thank you

[Applause]

[Music] [Applause]

Please follow and like us: