
educational background engineering
degree JD PhD some of you may be
wondering what does this kid want to be
when he grows up and I’ll let you know
when I get there I’m going to talk today
about copyright copyright attorney
copyright scholars what I am right now
and basically all of my training from
engineering to law to economics is about
problem solving and so for me when I
talk about copyright what I want to know
is does it work is it solving the
problem it’s meant to solve and while
this title is not very informative right
the point I want to drive home the idea
I want to convey is the copyright system
as we have it today is fundamentally
broken and the idea of copyright is that
we prohibit people from making copies so
that you have to buy an authorized copy
instead of getting one from your friend
and that makes the author or the artist
or the copyright owner earn a little
more any more money from each book or
song or whatever it is that they’ve
created and so we get more more works of
authorship more books more movies more
novels all that stuff we get more of it
and that’s good for society but what I
found is that Mol copyright it does give
them more money but less works of
authorship and in particular I’m going
to focus on the music industry over the
last 50 60 years so the purpose of
copyright is enshrined in the
Constitution in article 1 section 8
Clause 8 which authorizes Congress to
enact copyright to promote the progress
of science not to enrich authors or
copyright owners but to give us more
more music more movies more books and so
the idea here is that because some
people are going to freeride they’re not
going to pay for their copies we’re
going to get an under production
illustrated here by the shortfall in
production from Q to Q Prime instead of
having the actual demand we actually
have some people who are file-sharing I
know none of you file share but maybe
you have some friends that have done it
and so the author is not getting really
the full price for the novel they’ve
written or the song they’ve created and
so copyright fixes that problem by
prohibiting copying and their buys or it
makes everyone pay for the music for
example that they get access to and as a
result we push the production up to
where it’s supposed to be
and we get this public benefit the
progress of science we get more music
for example if that’s the work of
authorship we’re going to focus on as it
is here
the other thing copyright does though it
doesn’t just prohibiting copying for
those marginal works those additional
works that are not otherwise profitable
also prohibits copying for the whole
range of music we would have gotten even
without copyright or with somewhat
shorter or narrower copyright and that’s
what I call copyright success and the
traditional analysis of this is that
this success is not really a big problem
it means music may be a little more
expensive and so we’re balancing sort of
the higher price and the shortfall in
access against the incentives for
additional works but it’s really just an
assumption and so we assume that more
incentives is going to be more music and
we’ve assumed this for four hundred
years and over that four hundred years
copyright has gone from a very short
term fourteen years to a very long term
today life Plus 70 years of the author
it’s gone from a fairly narrow scope
against really mechanical copying to a
much broader scope including derivative
works such as making a film from a novel
as well as public performances on radio
stations or other forms Spotify or
Pandora but we really don’t haven’t
tested these assumptions now if we
wanted to do it ideally the economists
in me would say we take four different
worlds that are otherwise identical and
you say no copyright here some limited
copyright here much more copyright here
and really complete copyright here and
we’ll see how the four worlds do over
time but we don’t really have the
technology to do that so we have to look
for natural experiments that is
situations where technology or the law
changes and we get some variation and
copyright protection and so of course
the example we’ve all been focused on
here is file-sharing I’m sure again none
of you have done this but you may know
friends who have done it or heard of it
right but allows you to share your music
files with someone else who has the same
program whether it’s Napster or one of
the others and you see the list of the
files that are available you just click
on it suddenly you have a copy on your
computer now of course the copyright
owner is including the music industry
we’re not happy
about file-sharing and so they’ve
soothed all of these file-sharing
services out of existence they’ve even
sued private consumers for file-sharing
and of course that lawsuit campaigns
been very successful you can see maybe
not so the lawsuit campaign has been
going on since before 2000 started
really in 2000 itself against Napster
and this is file-sharing traffic in
North America in petabytes per month and
you can see we’re up about a thousand
petabytes per month last year 2016
that’s what Cisco estimates which is
about 1.25 billion CD quality albums of
music a year being file shared in North
America if it’s all music and CD quality
so there’s still a lot of file sharing
going on and if we put that in our
traditional balance of incentives versus
access right there’s good people are
getting a lot more music when I
testified to Congress about this issue I
said file-sharing has put more music in
the hands of more Americans than any
invention since the phonograph and you
can see from the blue here this is all
the file sharing if all that file
sharing traffic were music we’d be up
over 12 billion albums a year whereas
the most we ever got distributed in the
market was here in 1999 2000 about a
billion albums a year so file-sharing
radically increases exact access to
existing music our concern of course is
that it interferes with the incentives
for the creation of new music because
people are file-sharing to get their
music instead of going to Blockbuster or
your favorite record store record stores
don’t exist anymore right they’re all
gone and so far the the revenue from
music sales record sales has gone from
20 billion dollars in 1999 that’s in
current dollars these are all constant
dollars I’m using so we can compare them
all the way down to under 7 billion
dollars in 2013 that’s about that still
last year in 2016 as well so we’re
worried that this decline in revenue if
copyrights premise that more revenue
means more music if that’s right it’s
been right we’ve assumed it’s right for
400 years then we should see a sharp
downfall in music so then the question
well how do you measure music output and
there are a number of techniques you
might use so the simplest is go to see
on scan and ask him how many albums were
released in the United States each year
and they’ll give you something that
looks like this starting they only go
back to 1996 so we don’t have data back
for all the time we’d like to look at
but back to 1996 it was about 30 to
40,000 albums a year and then the late
90s it sort of drifted down for a little
bit but then it really took off and got
up over a hundred thousand albums in
2008 and then with the great recession
sort of tailed down but still 2012 and
today last year 80,000 albums twice what
we had at the peak revenue period of
1999 but maybe they’re all bad albums or
it’s hard to know what this really means
on its own maybe there’s new technology
maybe YouTube is letting us discover
more Justin Bieber’s and so we’re
getting more music out we just don’t
know so what if we took the whole music
revenue for the whole Rock era right all
the way back to 1960 and put it again in
constant dollars so it’s starting below
5 billion climbing to the peak in 1999
of 20 billion dollars and then falling
down now that’s a great test if
copyrights right and we’re going to get
more and better music because of this
money we’re giving them a bunch of money
how much money we’re giving them three
hundred thirty two billion dollars to
the record industry so they better give
us something in return
right even if we just took a line here
from the 90s right up through the 90s it
was about a hundred billion so in terms
of constant dollars what cost similar
well the Apollo 11 moon landing or the
Marshall Plan we could rebuild Europe
after World War two so what sort of
music are we getting for this well when
you think about so what sort of charts
or data do we have on music output over
the last 50 60 years well we have the
hot 100 chart
every week 52 weeks we get a hot 100
chart from billboard so we can go back
and that goes all the way back into the
50s and it turns out most of the songs
on the Billboard Hot 100 chart are
repeat same songs week to week over and
over again well you know we like to
listen to the same thing
but we can count the number of new or
unique songs on the chart you can see it
peaked here in the late 60s early 70s
out of the 5200 slot 743 was the peak we
reached and in his revenue went up right
so our revenue charts going up to 1999
and then falling down so as revenues
going up the number of unique songs that
are good enough to compete for a slot on
the hot 100 are falling and they fall
all the way down here to 2001 and then
they start kicking up again well that’s
right when the revenue started falling
so what’s going on there okay so that’s
one bit of data and of course just like
the albums
fell off in the Great Recession we see
the turnover fell over in the Great
Recession as well so that seems to be
real well we can look at reviewers of
music and so Rolling Stone magazine puts
out a list of the top 500 albums of all
time
we can group them by the year they were
released and it turns out just like the
turnover peaked in the late 60s early
70s turnover the best rock albums
courting Rolling Stone also early 70s
and then sort of steady fall again as
revenues going up we don’t seem to be
getting the best rock albums at least at
least not according to Rolling Stone
magazine a bunch old white guys though
what do they really know about music
have any other data well the young and
the hip are using Spotify so we could
ask them what good music is and look at
what they actually stream on Spotify so
this is worldwide streams again
organized by year for the top 1,000
songs from 1960 to 2005 the number of
times they were streamed worldwide in on
Spotify in 2014 now you can see there’s
a very clear Time Tran preference for
newer music maybe a younger skewing
population using Spotify so let’s take
that time trend out and see which years
were actually better than we would
expect and worse and this is what we get
once we do the econometrics work on that
so the good years or years where we got
more plays than expected so we get a
positive normalize play count so the
late seven late 60s early 70s
that’s three pieces of data that all
agree on that
as it turns out 83 was a very good year
and as it turned out that was one of the
low years on the revenue the 90s when
were pouring these hundreds of billions
of dollars into the music industry well
frankly they sucked at least in terms of
the music people want to listen to today
and we do see file-sharing and revenue
start to fall in all sudden they start
to pick up again and so we see this sort
of consistent pattern now the 60s some
of the data here’s what not quite sure
what’s going on there The Beatles were
not on Spotify in 2014 so that may be
yet all by itself now Taylor Swift was
not on Spotify in 2014 but her first hit
is 2006 so we don’t have to worry about
the Taylor effect which you always have
to consider when you’re doing analysis
of music I don’t want her to sing a song
about me it would undoubtedly be bad or
I would be bad okay so let’s go back to
the Billboard Hot 100 chart and see if
we can make any better sense of this so
we have two types of entries these
unique songs are either by a new artist
so their first hit on the Billboard Hot
100 and this is what it looks like
pretty steady we had the most new
artists in the 60s and this is one of
the troubles of doing this type of
natural experiment this mean we should
reinvade Vietnam and we’d get another
peace movement and more music and you
just can’t account for factors cultural
factors of that sort that may be causing
those problems but since there’s been
pretty much downhill now there does seem
to be a flattening right here in the 90s
and if we put it in terms of percentage
of unique songs by new artists you can
see part of what that 100 million
billion dollars was going to was
investing in new artists of course most
of them turned out to be busts right
they’d have one billboard hit on average
they’d have one billboard hit and then
they’d be done 50% of the time we’re
seeing an even steeper fall though in
existing artists so our existing artists
those the second or third hit on the
Billboard Hot 100 they’re not putting
out as many hits and so the question
really is why and of course what you
need to realize so if we take those same
Spotify top 1000 hits and we just put
them in order
the top song any guesses top song from
2005 and before mm lose yourself down to
the number 1000 song any guesses you’ll
never guess it the Goo Goo Dolls your
name right it’s very highly skewed so we
give that hundred billion dollars to the
music industry in the 90s most of it
goes 90% of it goes the to the top
artists right if we use a system like
copyright that’s uniform gives the same
protection to everybody to give $1 here
to the Goo Goo Dolls we have to give 12
to Eminem I’m sure you know given a lot
of money mm that’s part of my life goal
but it may not really be helpful in
terms of copyright and of course this is
only part of the data right this is only
the most popular song from 2005 if we
extended this chart up to the most
popular song that would be Drake one
dance over a billion streams and the Goo
Goo Dolls are not actually the worst
song on Spotify actually the 25 million
songs on Spotify 4 million have never
been streamed at all
no one’s ever listened to him not even
once so go out and listen to one of
those songs today but the average song
only gets listened to about 15,000 times
a year so to give one of those average
songs $1 we have to give Drake sixty six
thousand six hundred and sixty six
dollars and sixty six cents and I’m sure
it’s just a coincidence that happens to
be the number of the beast I don’t know
but what we end up doing is giving all
these money all this money to our very
top artists and so what do they do
so you’re 20 you’re extremely popular
with the opposite sex and I give you
twenty million dollars you’re going to
show up to work tomorrow are you going
to go to Miami maybe rent a Lamborghini
get a little drunk at a party get
arrested tell the cop don’t you know who
I am he says no get a petition started
at the White House to have you evicted
from the country because you’re from
Canada well that’s what Justin Bieber
did right and I think that’s what our
artists are doing and so we economists
talk about this as the backward bending
labor supply curve right sure if I pay
you ten dollars now your work 20 hours a
week pay you a hundred you work harder
pay you a thousand you work harder ten
thousand you say wait a minute I got
enough money in the bank I need to take
a little time off for myself and if I
was paying you a million dollars an hour
how many hours you’re going to work each
week maybe one half ten minutes I don’t
know
I wouldn’t work that much if I was
making a million dollars an hour so do
we have any data to back this up
this notion that we pay our top artists
copyright ensures a system that top
artists earn so much money it’s really
not worth showing up to work the next
day and so here’s the top 250 artists of
all time
and in terms of record sales and the
number of studio albums they released in
the first 10 years of their career on
the y-axis by the year of the first
album release and so we average about 14
albums per year for the best-selling
acts in the early 60s down to 8 and a
half down to 7 and a half down to 5 so
they’re getting better technology and
it’s taking them longer to release their
albums something weirds going on here
right we can look at the top artists of
each year from 1962 to the present well
2006 because we’ve got to have a 10-year
time frame for the releases the number
of billboard albums who’s number one way
up there that would be the Beatles
number two there’s Taylor Swift
if only she had had eight more breakups
she probably could have gotten up
to squeeze those in no didn’t work out
so here they are the top billboard ours
most hits in the first ten years of your
career and look they’re all either in
the early 60s or in the 2004 in
thereafter period they’re all in the low
revenue periods when they actually have
to work at least a little bit for the
money they’re getting so that’s pretty
much all I have and the basic point here
is copyright we have a problem you’re
not doing what you’re supposed to do
instead of encouraging more marginal
works in making sure we don’t have a
shortfall in copyright production you’re
enriching the people at the very top and
you’re enriching them so much that they
are not producing the works we would
like them to produce what if Mozart or
Shakespeare had been paid in this
fashion and only written half of the
works that we have from them what if the
Beatles had stopped after their six
album and whenever net got sergeant
pepper’s Lonely Hearts band so we
need to prevent further expansion of
copyright I talked about testifying
before Congress copyright owners always
they’re always try and get more
protection we need to reform the
copyright systems so that it does what
it’s supposed to do and if we can’t we
probably should abolish it but this is
all up to you right you are the people
who elect representatives who make these
decisions so be involved make a
difference and that’s my idea we’re
sharing thank you [Music]