Press "Enter" to skip to content

Secret agent training: why we need creativity in education | Karen Newman | TEDxAstonUniversity


[Music]
hi everyone I’m gonna tell you a story
about my little boy Stan and Stan is
nearly 7 he’s just gone through his
first set of SATs at school so SATs are
the government’s way of screening
children for their abilities in math and
English and that happens twice in school
it happens first of all like when it
stands out when they’re 6 and 7 and it
happens again as they’re about to leave
primary school when they’re 10 or 11
years old and the kids at school were
starting to get a little bit ruffled
about this they have an anticipation
that something was happening okay so the
teachers become aware that things are
hotting up pressures are hotting up and
to try and prepare them for what’s to
become they send home with the children
a practice SATs test paper it’s like an
8 page booklet and we have two weeks to
to work our way through these practice
papers and you know I always leave
everything to the last minute so I sit
down at a table with them the day before
and we start wading through and actually
the questions were like the pretty sort
of regular data visualization bar type
bar chart type questions there’s a
character called Ravi who has their
collection of pencils he often loses
them or swaps them all these different
colors and he goes to shop with Risa
quite a lot you know they have lots of
different coins and they’re pretty
unimaginative questions really on the
whole but the thing is that he’s really
struggling with is that they questions a
lot of the time have kinds of language
that he hasn’t come across before words
like in verse and he’s like my I don’t
know what any birthdays and I might okay
let’s talk about in verse I stole this
and this is a problem because he’s
supposed to be able to do this work
independently and I’m supposed to just
kind of sit back and watch and and
there’s more and more unfamiliar words
they come up words like equivalent an
estimate but just don’t feature in a six
year olds like everyday vocab right so
he’s getting a bit frustrated he’s
working through it and bless him you
know he’s doing alright we’re trying to
make the best out of a bad situation
and then we get to this question about a
tree so the question goes nowhere ever
like here’s a tree beside the tree is a
meter ruler right estimates the height
of the tree and circle the best estimate
and the answers that you’re given are
six meters six centimeters
six milliliters and six kilograms and
this is like a total shutdown this is
like one of these answers of why this
just this just doesn’t make sense it
doesn’t make sense at all and I’m like
okay let’s just take it easy so I just
tell me the right answer and I’m like
okay well the kilogram a million
milliliter yeah like waiting they quit
so it’s definitely not those and he’s
like well it’s got to be like one point
something it’s gotta be like it’s just
stay for me sir
clearly if that’s the meter well unlike
for that do we so it’s got to be six
centimeters or 6 meters right so I’m
like okay let’s just let’s just bear
with it and he’s getting more and more
worked up about this I said we start
trying to count the centimeters and the
ten centimeters at the ruler and try to
work it out from that but actually even
in the ruler there isn’t even a hundred
centimeters in the ruler so we are stuck
he’s going nuts he’s going bananas no
amount of chocolate bribery is going to
solve this problem we are just off
limits for the rest of the day it’s like
papers shot off you go to your bedroom
it’s fine that’s just like take the heat
out whatever he goes off a bit emotional
I’m like ok right so I’m fragility onto
the whatsapp because the whatsapp is my
only way of solving any of these
problems so we get on the phone to the
what’s up girls what’s that bad mums
what’s that bad mums I’m an awesome
bunch of women wait who happens health
kids at the same school as that so we
have we have a police officer we have a
mental health nurse we have a woman who
works in audiology we’ve got a woman who
works in engineering and we’ve got two
senior sale manager type women and
there’s me the RT one and you know I’m
thinking right like between us right
we’re going to be able to fix this quest
we are going to be able to work out the
true height of this trade like what is
the real answer to this because girls
I’m really struggling and they were like
oh this just does not make sense and
we’re all kind of sharing stories about
what we think could be the answer none
of us actually really know and we kind
of battle it out for about half an hour
over what’s up like different questions
going because of always lots of slicing
about Ravi going on and then we go with
Louisa who’s the science teacher who’s
like you know what there’s only one
logical answer here it has to be six
meters but the movement their meter wall
just has to be like wildly out of out of
scale
definitely not to scale so let’s just
forget the question we’ll just go with
them right yeah it’s fine it’s always
fun but then we carry on over a few more
giant ease and we talk about all of the
different meltdowns that all of the kids
have been having over the last two weeks
and it seems like if the kids haven’t
already switched off then they’re
incomplete like don’t want to do this
this is absolutely ridiculous it just
doesn’t make sense
and they’re all having exactly the same
problems and that’s really all this has
been going on for us two weeks I’ve just
been completely oblivious cuz I’m not
into that is I am a procrastinator so
over more gian teas we come up with wild
fantasies about Ravi and how potentially
he could be a superhero by night and
maybe maybe stories about Ravi as a
superhero could help Oscar to relate to
him because Oscar doesn’t really relate
to rubbing and his pencil collection
Oscar spends 90% of his life being a
soldier or a knight so we came up with
some stories to kind of help this and
some blatant lies and tricks – let’s
face it just be able to get our kids to
be able to answer their questions and we
do it we go through that we go through
the weekend finally get through it and
we get into the school playground on
Monday morning and I’m like how do you
hey wait it was like yeah I’m like what
day is it Monday who’s picking you up
you know I just look up great brilliant
we’re on track and we get close to the
front and then he notices down stops in
his tracks because all of his mates are
like zombies like six seven year old
zombies in the playgrounds with their
mouths open like this
it stands like Phoenix Phoenix Phoenix
what’s wrong he’s like and there at the
door is mrs. yeates but it’s not mrs.
Yeates
it’s mrs. Yates as a woman in black and
alongside her are all of the year two
teachers and teaching assistants stood
dressed as men and women in black
they’ve got it going on Will Smith eat
your heart out they’ve got the black
suits they’ve got the black ties white
shirts they’ve got the blacked-out
sunglasses they look like absolutely
real like spy secret agents for the
government like it’s totally going on in
school like something’s come down over
the weekend and what life is never gonna
be the same again so the kids are like
just siding past the teachers like this
looking like slightly scared like and
they go into school because today isn’t
Monday and it’s not that’s testing day
number one today is secret agent testing
day so over the weekend the teachers
realizing that some of the kids were
struggling a bit came up with the
ingenious idea of becoming secret agent
testers the school had been set a secret
mission by the government to test the
abilities of future potential secret
agents oh yeah this could be their
chance to be a future spy it doesn’t get
any better than this the excitement is
palpable they are all bouncing off the
classroom walls off the ceilings they’re
waiting for their name to be called and
they’re all given a secret code name
Stanley’s
sharks so they all wait for their name
to be called or the secret code name and
they go in in waves through the week but
in between they’re coming home and they
are literally like the most hype you’ve
ever seen them like some of them won’t
even go to sleep
Oscar being is demanding that his mom
tells him everything
is to know about what it takes to be a
spy he’s desperate to be a spy so Louise
is like on the Google were on the
whatsapp like mi5 and FBI are probably
kind of having strange suspicions about
what’s going on like why there’s all
these like secret spy investigations
like what what is going on but between
us we manage to get them the data that
they need like to feed their
imaginations to go back into school and
they go through the week and they have
like actually one of the best weeks ever
and they come out buzzing because they
all feel like they’ve got a chance at
being a spy in the future there’s no
emotional scars it’s amazing and
actually I’m never gonna blow that
bubble so Stan still thinks he’s in line
to be the next you know an ex-secret
agent which is awesome now I know that
I’m really fortunate that my kids go to
a really really creative school they
really do and that was a deliberate
choice you know you can see it’s evident
from the moment you walk through the
door they have artists design spaces and
learning spaces which are really themed
it’s a really really wonderful school
and not all schools are like that we
made a choice to move to that school
from another school which actually had
some really interesting kids in it
really lively really interesting kids
really mix demographic skills abilities
and an interest and it felt great like
perfectly creative like community school
but it went into special measures
because it wasn’t hitting its targets
and as it did that a lot of the kids
just started detaching they started just
switching off including Fred – my oldest
who then was five and we used to get
called literally every day from the
school saying you need to come in you
need have a meeting we just get emails
complaints like disruptive behavior
going on all over the place one day my
husband and I’m called at work and we
were told we had to come in as soon as
possible something really urgent had
happened and you know it was you know we
were like oh my god it’s all right and
they were like yeah it’s physically fine
but there’s a really serious behavior
situation that’s happened so my husband
and I left work we rushed onto the
school we got there were around this
table with the head teacher with the
class teacher
and the pastoral care lady and little
Fred and we say okay what’s happened and
the teacher says today Fred flicked a
pencil across the classroom to another
table I’m her husband and I relate and
then what happened and they were like
well this is the really bad bit because
we told him that was really unacceptable
and not to do it again and he did it
again I mean why would he do that again
I mean we just don’t understand like why
his head would do that so I’m like okay
everything cool that was like work so we
look at Fred and I’m like why did you do
that he’s like well we’d be learning
about calculations and distances and I
was trying to get the pencil in the pot
on the next table can you just leave
some help with his math reasoning skills
you know maybe he’s just not getting the
support with distance as they least I
don’t know but like really seriously and
we’re seeing more and more kids
switch off in school you know that
that’s one situation that we had control
over but we were recently asked to work
with a bunch of teenage boys who’d
hacked into their computer school
computer system and downloaded porn on
to their teachers computer we were like
amazing skills boys we’d love to work
with you and you are probably the secret
agents of the future that mi5 absolutely
come this way and actually they really
relate to a lot of the artists that we
work with who also come from similarly
disruptive backgrounds you know they
might have taken down a famous bookies
website trying to learn tricks of
betting or you know had free catalog
clothes deliveries for their families
for their entire teenage years for
example but they do not now leave really
legit creative careers developing
creative technologies that have never
existed before
like amazing amazing inventions
experimental games super super highly
intelligent people and if you look at
the history of innovation it’s littered
with examples of people that just didn’t
fit into the right kind of usual box
like the Industrial Revolution that
started right here in Birmingham and the
Lunar Society was a collective of really
radical thinkers philosophers
scientists artists engineers poets and
ceramicists you know who met they shared
a kind of similar kinship because they
thought really creatively and
out-of-the-box and that included James
Watt the guy that went on to invent the
steam engine James was a backward
scholar or so they called him he was
home-schooled because of ill health and
eventually when he was old enough to go
to school he didn’t fit in
he was socially awkward everyone else
had made their own friends by that point
and he was different
he’d learned to tinker in his dad’s
workshop he’d learned to tinker with
loads of different instruments and
materials and he became a brilliant
inventor of instrument before moving
here to Birmingham where he met Matthew
Boulton and they together remodeled the
the engine that created the steam engine
and so the Industrial Revolution was
born but how amazing you know he was he
was not able to take up a lot of
opportunities he was excluded from so
many apprenticeships and schools but he
found the opportunities right here
within a kind of kinship group of
creatives and people that also thought
outside of the box
in fact burnings coat of arms even
features an artist and an engineer it’s
only just recently their arse has
stopped being seen on an equal footing
with the sciences and the idea of steel
as well as the steam engine is really
really important you know the the the
combining of science technologies
engineering arts and math so putting art
into the STEM subjects is really really
great way of getting kids to learn
getting kids that are more disruptive
innovating young people to learn it
suits their brains that short circuit
when they’re going round that tiring
little box of how to answer a perfect
question
there are kids and people that can fix
problems that we can’t even imagine
there are really great systems fixes and
while the idea of steam has been really
easily picked up within the corporate
sector lots of businesses have got very
excited about it universities fab labs
and so forth education
it’s still really backwards and coming
forward with the idea of steam I don’t
know why that is and why we still
structure subjects in separation in
isolation and where we have this you
know drive towards creating a generation
of perfect english-speaking
mathematicians and that’s really really
important because if we’re creating
perfect systems fixes how are we ever
going to fix the very real-world
problems that were creating right now
right here for the future generation and
how will we ever dream up new inventions
new ideas new technologies and new
possibilities for things that can change
the world tomorrow we need to be working
with people that can think outside of
the box that don’t fit the usual system
and it’s really really important that we
create spaces and opportunities to
support the progression of those people
not exclude them we really need to
revalue the importance of the Arts in
society the arts isn’t something that
should only be seen as entertainment as
something extracurricular and accessible
to only a few privileged people the arts
is absolutely essential for learning
across subjects across cultures is
essential for innovation and it’s
essential to the very fabric of our
future society thank you
[Applause]
you
[Music]
Please follow and like us: