
my name is Christian Hernandez I’m a
venture capitalist my job my passion is
to fund technology and innovation
they’ll drive disruption and economic
value a couple of years ago I was at
Oxford University giving a speech that
lady a journalist at the back of the
stage racer Hannah asked me a question
she said if your job is to fund
disruption whose job is it actually to
fund the jobs you’re disrupting it’s the
questions that you sat with me ever
since
and the deeper I go into the advancement
technology around artificial
intelligence robotics and genomics the
more I really start thinking that we
need to start asking that question and
defining an answer but not only talking
about the jobs are being lost but
actually the impact that those
technologies are gonna have on our
society or economy and even our humanity
then the sural revolution was
transformational it changed our
definition of urban centers it changed
the population growth and it even has
some negative impacts on our planet we
know that in hindsight over the next
decades the acceleration of artificial
intelligence robotics and genomics will
change our planet and our humanity as
well we know that looking forward we
might not know is how quickly or how
deeply those changes will happen so
we’re sitting on this cusp
once-in-a-lifetime opportunity in
humanity to actually proactively think
and debate and discuss and act upon some
of the changes that will happen to us
and yet I fear that too few of us
actually understand what’s happening too
few of us are actually having the
conversation and too few of us are
actually acting upon it we need to start
talking about morals and ethics when we
talk about technology you might want to
know why would we want to discuss
something as fluffy and soft
as moral ethics we’re talking about
technology well the truth is technology
has no morals morals are placed upon
technology by its creators and by its
users as futurist GERD Leonard recently
wrote in his book technology versa
Manatee the fundamental challenge will
be that while technology knows no ethics
norms or beliefs the effective
functioning of every human and every
society is predicated upon them these
are the frameworks upon which our
societies are built and we as
technologists corporate corporations
governments and societies are pursuing
these amazing advancing technologies
without necessarily thinking about the
moral and ethical overlay we’re placing
upon them and as a technologist a
citizen a father and a human that
concerns me robert oppenheimer the
father of the nuclear bomb famously said
knowledge cannot be pursued without
morality and a fear that we are so let
me share some examples of some amazing
advance in technology and yet how not
necessarily overlaying a moral layer on
top of it might lead us down the wrong
path we’re living in an era of data and
algorithms the advance in artificial
intelligence will drive amazing
disruption today an artificial
intelligence algorithm can look at a
million x-rays and with that knowledge
identify that black spot in my own x-ray
to diagnose or help a doctor diagnose me
soon artificial intelligence algorithms
will help power self-driving cars which
will completely change or urban
landscape or notion of Transportation
and even reduce the fatalities caused by
car accidents today our official
intelligence robots are actually making
allocation decisions for investment from
my retirement pot therefore helping me
be better off financially but also have
the money for my retirement that might
be needed and these are just going to
continue to accelerate
but without actually thinking about
adding moral layers ethical layers to
these algorithms they could actually
lead us to the wrong decisions and the
wrong outcomes it’s an example in the
United States that Justice Department
create an algorithm that was meant to
help judges make the determination
whether to grant a prisoner parole or
not based on the likelihood that that
prisoner might commit another crime in
the future the algorithm ingested vast
amounts of data and was meant to predict
whether that individual versus another
individual was a risk for society the
issue is that that algorithm was
massively biased analysis by the
organization called Pro Publica proved
that the algorithm would forecast with
77% more likelihood that a black
prisoner was more risky to her society
than any other and the bias was built
into the algorithm by its creators the
bias came from the data that the
algorithm was using to make that
prediction the data included things such
as does the prisoner’s parents ever go
to jail does the prisoner live in an
area of all the high crime rate when it
might be influenced to commit a new
crime and these datasets statistically
influence the algorithm to predict that
blacks were more violent and risky to
society than others I’m pretty sure the
creators of the algorithm didn’t mean
for it to be biased and they were trying
to do something good by providing
technology tools to judges to better
protect our societies but by not
thinking about the morality of how their
algorithm had been built they biased it
in such a way that I would consider
reproachable the morals of Technology
are created by its users that they’re
also overlaid by us as consumers in
March of 2016
Microsoft Research released an
experiment onto the wild it was a chat
bot called Tay Tay was supposed to talk
with users across messaging platforms
including Twitter learn from you learn
about the language that you used and try
to have a human conversation
it sounded cute it was a way for
Microsoft to show off its artificial
intelligence research but it very
quickly went wrong users very quickly
discovered that they could teach tey to
say things that we might never say to
each other in a normal conversation in
24 hours Tay went from saying it loved
humans to becoming racist and bigoted
defending Hitler and the nine the
Holocaust and the PR department very
quickly took it down never to see the
light of day again and the problem with
Tay was that it was a great lab
experiment and it was meant to do some
pretty cool stuff but its creators never
provided Tay with the ethical framework
for it to determine what might be
appropriate in terms of social discourse
social conversation between normal
people and therefore as users realized
that that ethical framework was lacking
they started jokingly or maybe seriously
trying to game it to turn into something
that we would not feel appropriate in a
normal conversation so the morals of
technology can be impacted by the
creators and the data but also by the
users and how it gets applied let’s now
turn from genomics sorry from artificial
intelligence and talk about what I think
is gonna be one of most disruptive
technologies in the next hundred years
genomics and gene editing – labs in the
United States have recently developed a
technology called CRISPR which allows
you to very very efficiently identify
and a very very low-cost modified genes
simplest way of thinking about CRISPR is
the Microsoft Excel find and replace
function you give CRISPR a string of
text of DNA and if swims across your
body trying to find that specific string
of DNA and it has scissors which cuts
out that DNA and it pastes unused a new
string into that space in labs today
we’re erasing amazing amazing results
from this technology scientists have
been able to cure animals with liver
disease using CRISPR and very recently a
group of scientists announced that
they’ve been able to use it
to identify and destroy the HIV virus
CRISPR is going to have an amazing
impact on our health or wellness in
order longevity but I think it also
comes with some moral dilemmas the first
of those is who gets access to some
mazing technology will it be purely a
capitalistic decision in other words
those who pay the most get the access to
it or should it be democratized and
given to all it will have a
transformational effect on humanity and
therefore how broadly do we want to
benefit this benefit to spread the
second issue is how else it can be
applied what if you start using this
technology to modify the eyes and the
hair color of your unborn child could I
pay for a DNA treatment that gives me my
hair back or could it actually be
applied to make soldiers a hundred times
stronger or actually make their DNA not
susceptible to biological weapons and
this is where actually starts evolving
into how does gene editing and gene
modification start to influence how we
believe is appropriate use of it but
also how we begin to influence what we
define as humans and in preparing for
this talk I was going through this
conversation with my nine-year-old son
Sebastian and I said I explained to him
the notion of CRISPR and the notion of
impacting and changing genes and humans
he looked at me and said but Dad what is
a human well scientifically being human
means that we are part of a species Homo
sapiens that happens to share the
majority of his DNA with other Homo
sapiens some of us have slight
variations black hair blue eyes blond
darker skin but in general world fairly
similar from a DNA structure and that is
what encapsulate s– humanity but let me
put that in context humans share
ninety-nine point seven percent of their
DNA with Neanderthals or cousins who
were wiped off the face of the earth
that’s pretty similar and
we started modifying genes that have
started actually changing or internal
DNA at which point do we cross that
barrier form point 1 point 2 point 3 and
at which point do we go from humans to
whatever comes next and as we actually
evolve into whatever comes next how do
we actually treat each other if we’re
cohabitating as two different species
back to my earlier question about who
decides who gets that treatment or that
modification but the modifications will
not only be biological it won’t only be
necessarily gene modifications there’s
things like retinal implants that allow
you to actually see a hundred times
better
we’re actually exoskeletons being pried
out by a military that make you a
hundred times stronger and if you’re a
Chinese military general would you not
want to have soldiers are a hundred
times smarter a hundred times stronger
or you’re hiring somebody to work in
your factory would you not want to be a
hundred times more efficient a hundred
times stronger and we start thinking
about how we’ll make these decisions or
in framework of interaction and a
geopolitical level is defined by this
notion of human rights but what happens
we have humans and something else
cohabitating which rights will actually
drive or interactions and who will
protect who and these are the types of
conversations anyway I think we start
having now there’s some initial efforts
are driving these conversations for
example a number of investors and
founders in Silicon Valley have created
the open AI which is a non-for-profit
organization seeking to Duck Drive
dialogue and frameworks for the moral
application of artificial intelligence
Microsoft recently came out with a call
for what it called the new Geneva
Convention the Geneva Convention a set
of rules that determine how nations at
war treat civilian populations but the
notion of war has changed it’s no longer
soldiers shooting guns and dropping
bombs on each other now there’s non
nation-states attacking each other with
cyber technology and biological warfare
and there’s no legal framework for us to
actually govern how we should be
protected under that world the World
Economic Forum the famously meets in
Davos every year and brings together
government leaders academics and
business leaders is
to drive this conversation around what
it calls the fourth Industrial
Revolution trying to drive a
conversation about the job losses about
jobs of the future about artificial
intelligence and these are nice initial
attempts to have the discussion but I
feel they’re not enough because they’re
missing one key component and that’s us
the billions of people that will be
affected by its investment technology
and for whom society communities
countries and even humanity is likely
changed in decades to come and the
reason we’re part not part of the
conversation is because the average
person in this room average person in
this world does not really understand
what’s happening right we might have
ready a new story in Jakarta or Sao
Paolo about robots taking our jobs or
seem some TV special about gene cloning
and mice being copied in labs but it
still sounds very science fiction and
very far away and that argue it’s not
that far away governments play a role in
this as well governments should be
driving the discussion governments
should be thinking about higher applies
to their citizens but most recently the
US Secretary of Treasury steam and you
can said that he did not really get
bothered much by the changes in AI and
robotics because it was 50 or 100 years
away when they were actually started
placing jobs with all due respect sir I
actually think it’s gonna happen
much more quickly and much more deeply
and even if it is only 50 years away
that starts impacting children they’re
being bored today so I really think you
should care about it today there’s a
sole role for media to play in this
where the media should be educating
rather than scaring us helping us
understand these amazing advanced in
technology but also helping to drive the
discussion around what each individual
society thinks are the right moral
decisions or ethical layers on top of
this application we need to start
becoming part of the conversation
and so I’ll leave you with a final
thought go educate yourself on these
amazing advances go read about them go
be amazed by them but start having your
own internal conversation about how it
might impact you your job your community
your children your country your humanity
and after you had that internal
conversation questioned how you morally
or ethically feel about them and then go
have that conversation with your
neighbor and then have the conversation
with your kids and then have a
conversation with your boss and your
elected officials these advances are
going to accelerate extremely quickly
and we have this one in a lifetime
opportunity humanity to proactively
figure out where we’d lead or
communities or societies or countries
and our race technology has no morals
the users and the creators of Technology
lay those morals upon them I think we
need start having the conversation about
what sort of future we want and what
morality wonder well over lay on top of
it thank you very much
you
[Music]
venture capitalist my job my passion is
to fund technology and innovation
they’ll drive disruption and economic
value a couple of years ago I was at
Oxford University giving a speech that
lady a journalist at the back of the
stage racer Hannah asked me a question
she said if your job is to fund
disruption whose job is it actually to
fund the jobs you’re disrupting it’s the
questions that you sat with me ever
since
and the deeper I go into the advancement
technology around artificial
intelligence robotics and genomics the
more I really start thinking that we
need to start asking that question and
defining an answer but not only talking
about the jobs are being lost but
actually the impact that those
technologies are gonna have on our
society or economy and even our humanity
then the sural revolution was
transformational it changed our
definition of urban centers it changed
the population growth and it even has
some negative impacts on our planet we
know that in hindsight over the next
decades the acceleration of artificial
intelligence robotics and genomics will
change our planet and our humanity as
well we know that looking forward we
might not know is how quickly or how
deeply those changes will happen so
we’re sitting on this cusp
once-in-a-lifetime opportunity in
humanity to actually proactively think
and debate and discuss and act upon some
of the changes that will happen to us
and yet I fear that too few of us
actually understand what’s happening too
few of us are actually having the
conversation and too few of us are
actually acting upon it we need to start
talking about morals and ethics when we
talk about technology you might want to
know why would we want to discuss
something as fluffy and soft
as moral ethics we’re talking about
technology well the truth is technology
has no morals morals are placed upon
technology by its creators and by its
users as futurist GERD Leonard recently
wrote in his book technology versa
Manatee the fundamental challenge will
be that while technology knows no ethics
norms or beliefs the effective
functioning of every human and every
society is predicated upon them these
are the frameworks upon which our
societies are built and we as
technologists corporate corporations
governments and societies are pursuing
these amazing advancing technologies
without necessarily thinking about the
moral and ethical overlay we’re placing
upon them and as a technologist a
citizen a father and a human that
concerns me robert oppenheimer the
father of the nuclear bomb famously said
knowledge cannot be pursued without
morality and a fear that we are so let
me share some examples of some amazing
advance in technology and yet how not
necessarily overlaying a moral layer on
top of it might lead us down the wrong
path we’re living in an era of data and
algorithms the advance in artificial
intelligence will drive amazing
disruption today an artificial
intelligence algorithm can look at a
million x-rays and with that knowledge
identify that black spot in my own x-ray
to diagnose or help a doctor diagnose me
soon artificial intelligence algorithms
will help power self-driving cars which
will completely change or urban
landscape or notion of Transportation
and even reduce the fatalities caused by
car accidents today our official
intelligence robots are actually making
allocation decisions for investment from
my retirement pot therefore helping me
be better off financially but also have
the money for my retirement that might
be needed and these are just going to
continue to accelerate
but without actually thinking about
adding moral layers ethical layers to
these algorithms they could actually
lead us to the wrong decisions and the
wrong outcomes it’s an example in the
United States that Justice Department
create an algorithm that was meant to
help judges make the determination
whether to grant a prisoner parole or
not based on the likelihood that that
prisoner might commit another crime in
the future the algorithm ingested vast
amounts of data and was meant to predict
whether that individual versus another
individual was a risk for society the
issue is that that algorithm was
massively biased analysis by the
organization called Pro Publica proved
that the algorithm would forecast with
77% more likelihood that a black
prisoner was more risky to her society
than any other and the bias was built
into the algorithm by its creators the
bias came from the data that the
algorithm was using to make that
prediction the data included things such
as does the prisoner’s parents ever go
to jail does the prisoner live in an
area of all the high crime rate when it
might be influenced to commit a new
crime and these datasets statistically
influence the algorithm to predict that
blacks were more violent and risky to
society than others I’m pretty sure the
creators of the algorithm didn’t mean
for it to be biased and they were trying
to do something good by providing
technology tools to judges to better
protect our societies but by not
thinking about the morality of how their
algorithm had been built they biased it
in such a way that I would consider
reproachable the morals of Technology
are created by its users that they’re
also overlaid by us as consumers in
March of 2016
Microsoft Research released an
experiment onto the wild it was a chat
bot called Tay Tay was supposed to talk
with users across messaging platforms
including Twitter learn from you learn
about the language that you used and try
to have a human conversation
it sounded cute it was a way for
Microsoft to show off its artificial
intelligence research but it very
quickly went wrong users very quickly
discovered that they could teach tey to
say things that we might never say to
each other in a normal conversation in
24 hours Tay went from saying it loved
humans to becoming racist and bigoted
defending Hitler and the nine the
Holocaust and the PR department very
quickly took it down never to see the
light of day again and the problem with
Tay was that it was a great lab
experiment and it was meant to do some
pretty cool stuff but its creators never
provided Tay with the ethical framework
for it to determine what might be
appropriate in terms of social discourse
social conversation between normal
people and therefore as users realized
that that ethical framework was lacking
they started jokingly or maybe seriously
trying to game it to turn into something
that we would not feel appropriate in a
normal conversation so the morals of
technology can be impacted by the
creators and the data but also by the
users and how it gets applied let’s now
turn from genomics sorry from artificial
intelligence and talk about what I think
is gonna be one of most disruptive
technologies in the next hundred years
genomics and gene editing – labs in the
United States have recently developed a
technology called CRISPR which allows
you to very very efficiently identify
and a very very low-cost modified genes
simplest way of thinking about CRISPR is
the Microsoft Excel find and replace
function you give CRISPR a string of
text of DNA and if swims across your
body trying to find that specific string
of DNA and it has scissors which cuts
out that DNA and it pastes unused a new
string into that space in labs today
we’re erasing amazing amazing results
from this technology scientists have
been able to cure animals with liver
disease using CRISPR and very recently a
group of scientists announced that
they’ve been able to use it
to identify and destroy the HIV virus
CRISPR is going to have an amazing
impact on our health or wellness in
order longevity but I think it also
comes with some moral dilemmas the first
of those is who gets access to some
mazing technology will it be purely a
capitalistic decision in other words
those who pay the most get the access to
it or should it be democratized and
given to all it will have a
transformational effect on humanity and
therefore how broadly do we want to
benefit this benefit to spread the
second issue is how else it can be
applied what if you start using this
technology to modify the eyes and the
hair color of your unborn child could I
pay for a DNA treatment that gives me my
hair back or could it actually be
applied to make soldiers a hundred times
stronger or actually make their DNA not
susceptible to biological weapons and
this is where actually starts evolving
into how does gene editing and gene
modification start to influence how we
believe is appropriate use of it but
also how we begin to influence what we
define as humans and in preparing for
this talk I was going through this
conversation with my nine-year-old son
Sebastian and I said I explained to him
the notion of CRISPR and the notion of
impacting and changing genes and humans
he looked at me and said but Dad what is
a human well scientifically being human
means that we are part of a species Homo
sapiens that happens to share the
majority of his DNA with other Homo
sapiens some of us have slight
variations black hair blue eyes blond
darker skin but in general world fairly
similar from a DNA structure and that is
what encapsulate s– humanity but let me
put that in context humans share
ninety-nine point seven percent of their
DNA with Neanderthals or cousins who
were wiped off the face of the earth
that’s pretty similar and
we started modifying genes that have
started actually changing or internal
DNA at which point do we cross that
barrier form point 1 point 2 point 3 and
at which point do we go from humans to
whatever comes next and as we actually
evolve into whatever comes next how do
we actually treat each other if we’re
cohabitating as two different species
back to my earlier question about who
decides who gets that treatment or that
modification but the modifications will
not only be biological it won’t only be
necessarily gene modifications there’s
things like retinal implants that allow
you to actually see a hundred times
better
we’re actually exoskeletons being pried
out by a military that make you a
hundred times stronger and if you’re a
Chinese military general would you not
want to have soldiers are a hundred
times smarter a hundred times stronger
or you’re hiring somebody to work in
your factory would you not want to be a
hundred times more efficient a hundred
times stronger and we start thinking
about how we’ll make these decisions or
in framework of interaction and a
geopolitical level is defined by this
notion of human rights but what happens
we have humans and something else
cohabitating which rights will actually
drive or interactions and who will
protect who and these are the types of
conversations anyway I think we start
having now there’s some initial efforts
are driving these conversations for
example a number of investors and
founders in Silicon Valley have created
the open AI which is a non-for-profit
organization seeking to Duck Drive
dialogue and frameworks for the moral
application of artificial intelligence
Microsoft recently came out with a call
for what it called the new Geneva
Convention the Geneva Convention a set
of rules that determine how nations at
war treat civilian populations but the
notion of war has changed it’s no longer
soldiers shooting guns and dropping
bombs on each other now there’s non
nation-states attacking each other with
cyber technology and biological warfare
and there’s no legal framework for us to
actually govern how we should be
protected under that world the World
Economic Forum the famously meets in
Davos every year and brings together
government leaders academics and
business leaders is
to drive this conversation around what
it calls the fourth Industrial
Revolution trying to drive a
conversation about the job losses about
jobs of the future about artificial
intelligence and these are nice initial
attempts to have the discussion but I
feel they’re not enough because they’re
missing one key component and that’s us
the billions of people that will be
affected by its investment technology
and for whom society communities
countries and even humanity is likely
changed in decades to come and the
reason we’re part not part of the
conversation is because the average
person in this room average person in
this world does not really understand
what’s happening right we might have
ready a new story in Jakarta or Sao
Paolo about robots taking our jobs or
seem some TV special about gene cloning
and mice being copied in labs but it
still sounds very science fiction and
very far away and that argue it’s not
that far away governments play a role in
this as well governments should be
driving the discussion governments
should be thinking about higher applies
to their citizens but most recently the
US Secretary of Treasury steam and you
can said that he did not really get
bothered much by the changes in AI and
robotics because it was 50 or 100 years
away when they were actually started
placing jobs with all due respect sir I
actually think it’s gonna happen
much more quickly and much more deeply
and even if it is only 50 years away
that starts impacting children they’re
being bored today so I really think you
should care about it today there’s a
sole role for media to play in this
where the media should be educating
rather than scaring us helping us
understand these amazing advanced in
technology but also helping to drive the
discussion around what each individual
society thinks are the right moral
decisions or ethical layers on top of
this application we need to start
becoming part of the conversation
and so I’ll leave you with a final
thought go educate yourself on these
amazing advances go read about them go
be amazed by them but start having your
own internal conversation about how it
might impact you your job your community
your children your country your humanity
and after you had that internal
conversation questioned how you morally
or ethically feel about them and then go
have that conversation with your
neighbor and then have the conversation
with your kids and then have a
conversation with your boss and your
elected officials these advances are
going to accelerate extremely quickly
and we have this one in a lifetime
opportunity humanity to proactively
figure out where we’d lead or
communities or societies or countries
and our race technology has no morals
the users and the creators of Technology
lay those morals upon them I think we
need start having the conversation about
what sort of future we want and what
morality wonder well over lay on top of
it thank you very much
you
[Music]
Please follow and like us: