
[Applause]
today all over the world the
women are underrepresented in the
spaces of economic power and in
positions of responsibility in europe
only 5% of large companies
listed shares are headed by a
woman is only they do not
represent only a quarter of
members of the boards of directors of
these big groups to increase the
representation of women in
boards of directors
business
the European Commission proposed in
2012 a directive to oblige the
companies at a representation
balance of women and men in
their advice
among the objectives assigned to this
proposal
we find the best governance of
businesses and better performance
for her this justification
apparently innocuous of this proposal
endangers legality and I’m going
try to convince yourself of that so
my purpose is to show
that the justification of equality by the
economic performance endangers the
very principle of the equality
public policies are judged
the yardstick of their effectiveness that is heard
as their ability to reach
the goal we set them what is
the goal of a quota policy
the quotas are considered to be
fill this gap in the representation of
women in power instances
because this deficit is the result of a
malfunction of our societies
unequal process of discrimination
and as such it is contrary to
principles of justice that is equality
in this case the effectiveness of the policy
quota will be judged by the yardstick of its
ability to increase the presentation of
women in these tips
countries that have already
voted laws life
to force large companies to a
representation of 40% of
women in their councils
of administration like France or
italy are those in which one
observe a greater momentum of this
point of view there the quota policy
and therefore effective another perspective
is to say that among the
objectives of the quota policy there
improving governance and
business performance
so first question companies
in which women are more
represented in management positions
are they more efficient
there is an abundant literature on this
subject that does not lead to any consensus
some works show that the
positions of responsibility are more
feminized companies have a
best stock market performance
other works show that there is
no significant effect
finally some works show that
when there are more women in the
the administration’s advice
performance is degraded and
authors of these works to conclude this is
so certainly not on the basis of the
performance that must be justified
quotas then methodologically it is
very complicated to analyze the relationship
causal relationship between the place of women in
positions of responsibility and the
performance of these companies why
for example very businesses
dynamics can for other reasons
do more to make more room for
women in this case it’s not the
women where the presence of women who
produces this performance but that’s the
opposite
another case of companies in
difficulty may be less attractive
for men and actually feminizes
and in this case it’s not the presence
women who degrade their
performance but the opposite
you see it it is possible that
economists are not in capacity
to measure this possible performance
companies from a larger
representation of women in
positions of responsibility or in
boards of directors then
do we ask where can this
performance if it exists
there are two main channels the first
is the one I call the difference
gendered women and men do not
would not have the same risk face
facing the competition in the face of problems
to solve and therefore this complementarity
behaviors could allow
greater performance and diversity
of solutions
the second channel is the one that I
calls human capital women
today are more educated on average
that men does not have access
not to positions of responsibility
inefficiency and underutilization of
this human capital and its skills
so let’s go back to the first argument
of the difference of the sexes women and
men behave differently
this argument was rekindled at the time of
the financial crisis of 2008
outrageous risk taking
some banks have been analyzed
retrospectively as the fruit
of a masculine culture
if women had been more
present in decision-making
of these banks as they are
suppose more cautious at risk the
decisions and strategies of these
banks would have been less risky and
they would have made more decisions
balanced that’s what christine lagarde
funds when she says that if lehman
brothers had been lehman sisters the
bank would not have gone bankrupt
in other words, the complementarity of
behaviors between women and men
could draw a diversity of points
view of opinion analysis is therefore a
performance so what about it is this
that men and women behaves
differently
here again an abundant literature
experimental economy has developed
to try to watch to measure
this difference in behavior he in
actually shows that women
seem a little more chilly to
risks that men and I
competitors
these results are very sensitive to
the environment in which
individuals is besides these
differences in behavior remains pretty
low
and much less important than those
that can be observed between individuals
however, it is not surprising that
women and men and
different behaviors
after all women and men
girls and boys have experiences
different social
stereotypes gender norms
act from early childhood
we know it in the family at school
in society in general they these
behavioral injunctions of norms
of gender to women and men are
still very strong
they are the result of discrimination
against women who she is
well documented in social sciences
and there is consensus
the goal of equality is to limit
the grip of gender norms on
behaviors of individuals to
emancipate from these social assignments and
so in fine and we would like to see these
behavior differences fade
then disappear then justified access
women in positions of responsibility
by mobilizing the argument of the
complementarity of the sexes
complementarity that precisely
would like to see disappear if we
wants to bring legality as a principle of
justice was killed in the egg the idea
even of equality
this neo essentialism argument in no
case allow to reach and put
implement this principle of justice and
equality then let’s observe the day the
last channel which is that of capital
human the rhetoric is different
women are more educated they are
underused less active less
present in the posts at
responsibility and therefore allows them
to access positions of responsibility
particular would be a way to increase
our performance at the level of
the company or at the macro level
economic in general
take this argument seriously we
live in a world where posts to
responsibility are limited including
places in the councils
even though some
boards of directors have
expanded to make more room for
women and line still has a number
of limited places suppose we
be able to measure the
performance and competence of
individuals and assume that when
associates this skill with a job at
responsibility
we get a performance for
the company theoretically that makes sense
in fact it’s a little bit more
complicated than that then we have three
configurations either women are
less competent than men and
that’s why they’re not named
and in this case the quota policy
will be ineffective since it will lead to
place in these positions of responsibility
less competent people are
appointed men are less competent
than women who could be
their place in this process
discriminatory in this case the quotas
will produce performance
since they will lead to replace
less competent individuals by
more competent individuals than are the
women be women have less of
chance that men to be appointed to
equal skills
this is probably the most
current in this case the politics of
quotas will not bring any gain in
performance for the company
you see it well the question here is not
not that of resource allocation
rare here the positions of responsibility
but that of their righteous
redistributions it’s not about
think the economic performance that
we can expect companies but
to think the fight against
discriminations in other words put in
before the argument the performance
economic to defend a policy
to increase women’s access
in positions of responsibility is to deny
they are discriminated against
in their career and career
today more generally the
equality policies are always
articulated with this idea of performance
economic and this idea is dangerous
for the implementation of this principle
equality
of course it is possible that in the
egalitarian dynamics we are
economic benefits
it’s quite possible that’s what
I call the collateral benefits of
equality but by no means they do not
can be a justification or a
objective of these equality policies
to conclude the quotas are a
tool among others to fight
inequalities women men and that’s in
that they must be defended and
promoted thank you
[Applause]
today all over the world the
women are underrepresented in the
spaces of economic power and in
positions of responsibility in europe
only 5% of large companies
listed shares are headed by a
woman is only they do not
represent only a quarter of
members of the boards of directors of
these big groups to increase the
representation of women in
boards of directors
business
the European Commission proposed in
2012 a directive to oblige the
companies at a representation
balance of women and men in
their advice
among the objectives assigned to this
proposal
we find the best governance of
businesses and better performance
for her this justification
apparently innocuous of this proposal
endangers legality and I’m going
try to convince yourself of that so
my purpose is to show
that the justification of equality by the
economic performance endangers the
very principle of the equality
public policies are judged
the yardstick of their effectiveness that is heard
as their ability to reach
the goal we set them what is
the goal of a quota policy
the quotas are considered to be
fill this gap in the representation of
women in power instances
because this deficit is the result of a
malfunction of our societies
unequal process of discrimination
and as such it is contrary to
principles of justice that is equality
in this case the effectiveness of the policy
quota will be judged by the yardstick of its
ability to increase the presentation of
women in these tips
countries that have already
voted laws life
to force large companies to a
representation of 40% of
women in their councils
of administration like France or
italy are those in which one
observe a greater momentum of this
point of view there the quota policy
and therefore effective another perspective
is to say that among the
objectives of the quota policy there
improving governance and
business performance
so first question companies
in which women are more
represented in management positions
are they more efficient
there is an abundant literature on this
subject that does not lead to any consensus
some works show that the
positions of responsibility are more
feminized companies have a
best stock market performance
other works show that there is
no significant effect
finally some works show that
when there are more women in the
the administration’s advice
performance is degraded and
authors of these works to conclude this is
so certainly not on the basis of the
performance that must be justified
quotas then methodologically it is
very complicated to analyze the relationship
causal relationship between the place of women in
positions of responsibility and the
performance of these companies why
for example very businesses
dynamics can for other reasons
do more to make more room for
women in this case it’s not the
women where the presence of women who
produces this performance but that’s the
opposite
another case of companies in
difficulty may be less attractive
for men and actually feminizes
and in this case it’s not the presence
women who degrade their
performance but the opposite
you see it it is possible that
economists are not in capacity
to measure this possible performance
companies from a larger
representation of women in
positions of responsibility or in
boards of directors then
do we ask where can this
performance if it exists
there are two main channels the first
is the one I call the difference
gendered women and men do not
would not have the same risk face
facing the competition in the face of problems
to solve and therefore this complementarity
behaviors could allow
greater performance and diversity
of solutions
the second channel is the one that I
calls human capital women
today are more educated on average
that men does not have access
not to positions of responsibility
inefficiency and underutilization of
this human capital and its skills
so let’s go back to the first argument
of the difference of the sexes women and
men behave differently
this argument was rekindled at the time of
the financial crisis of 2008
outrageous risk taking
some banks have been analyzed
retrospectively as the fruit
of a masculine culture
if women had been more
present in decision-making
of these banks as they are
suppose more cautious at risk the
decisions and strategies of these
banks would have been less risky and
they would have made more decisions
balanced that’s what christine lagarde
funds when she says that if lehman
brothers had been lehman sisters the
bank would not have gone bankrupt
in other words, the complementarity of
behaviors between women and men
could draw a diversity of points
view of opinion analysis is therefore a
performance so what about it is this
that men and women behaves
differently
here again an abundant literature
experimental economy has developed
to try to watch to measure
this difference in behavior he in
actually shows that women
seem a little more chilly to
risks that men and I
competitors
these results are very sensitive to
the environment in which
individuals is besides these
differences in behavior remains pretty
low
and much less important than those
that can be observed between individuals
however, it is not surprising that
women and men and
different behaviors
after all women and men
girls and boys have experiences
different social
stereotypes gender norms
act from early childhood
we know it in the family at school
in society in general they these
behavioral injunctions of norms
of gender to women and men are
still very strong
they are the result of discrimination
against women who she is
well documented in social sciences
and there is consensus
the goal of equality is to limit
the grip of gender norms on
behaviors of individuals to
emancipate from these social assignments and
so in fine and we would like to see these
behavior differences fade
then disappear then justified access
women in positions of responsibility
by mobilizing the argument of the
complementarity of the sexes
complementarity that precisely
would like to see disappear if we
wants to bring legality as a principle of
justice was killed in the egg the idea
even of equality
this neo essentialism argument in no
case allow to reach and put
implement this principle of justice and
equality then let’s observe the day the
last channel which is that of capital
human the rhetoric is different
women are more educated they are
underused less active less
present in the posts at
responsibility and therefore allows them
to access positions of responsibility
particular would be a way to increase
our performance at the level of
the company or at the macro level
economic in general
take this argument seriously we
live in a world where posts to
responsibility are limited including
places in the councils
even though some
boards of directors have
expanded to make more room for
women and line still has a number
of limited places suppose we
be able to measure the
performance and competence of
individuals and assume that when
associates this skill with a job at
responsibility
we get a performance for
the company theoretically that makes sense
in fact it’s a little bit more
complicated than that then we have three
configurations either women are
less competent than men and
that’s why they’re not named
and in this case the quota policy
will be ineffective since it will lead to
place in these positions of responsibility
less competent people are
appointed men are less competent
than women who could be
their place in this process
discriminatory in this case the quotas
will produce performance
since they will lead to replace
less competent individuals by
more competent individuals than are the
women be women have less of
chance that men to be appointed to
equal skills
this is probably the most
current in this case the politics of
quotas will not bring any gain in
performance for the company
you see it well the question here is not
not that of resource allocation
rare here the positions of responsibility
but that of their righteous
redistributions it’s not about
think the economic performance that
we can expect companies but
to think the fight against
discriminations in other words put in
before the argument the performance
economic to defend a policy
to increase women’s access
in positions of responsibility is to deny
they are discriminated against
in their career and career
today more generally the
equality policies are always
articulated with this idea of performance
economic and this idea is dangerous
for the implementation of this principle
equality
of course it is possible that in the
egalitarian dynamics we are
economic benefits
it’s quite possible that’s what
I call the collateral benefits of
equality but by no means they do not
can be a justification or a
objective of these equality policies
to conclude the quotas are a
tool among others to fight
inequalities women men and that’s in
that they must be defended and
promoted thank you
[Applause]
Please follow and like us: