Press "Enter" to skip to content

Outer Space Environment – The New Frontier for Law and Ethics | Bayar Goswami | TEDxNMIMSBangalore


I’m sure most of you in this room today

must have gazed at the sky through clear

starry night and wondered what it must

be like in the vast outer space

immediately followed by a feeling of

existential crisis realizing how small a

part you are of the states antic

universe if you’ve had this feeling

thanks for sharing my daily crisis it

feels amazing to have found fertility in

this room today and I already feel well

good I’m a speech lawyer who loves

cosmology and interlinking the two

concepts I’m currently pursuing an

intuitive idea the idea is overwhelming

yet very basic rather innate something

we should come to a conscience in a very

similar form of how we experience

gravity something in a very intuitive

and neat natural form my talk today

elaborates on human activities in outer

space what have we achieved and where

are we headed in the next few minutes

I’m going to make you travel through

time from past to present the future but

not necessarily in the same auto so let

me start with what what in our space we

have come a long way from orbiting the

force several magnets satellite Sputnik

in 1957 and since then we have built a

society so dependent on space technology

but it is almost impossible to imagine a

day without satellite today while I’m

limited by time to detail all the fronts

where space technology is touching our

lives but in a snapshot

besides military and strategic

advantages of course space is helping

you communicate with ease space is

helping you travel in cities like

Bangalore and not only cities like

Bangalore but throughout the globe with

the help of satellite navigators civil

aviation it also alarms you of global

warming and helps you fight

environmental changes providing you data

which is monitoring deforestation

desertification and watershed management

and the list goes on

all well said and done what what what is

next

police tell my colleagues from the

exciting time to be alive and

generation and the next could possibly

witness space resource mining

colonization of celestial bodies space

dualism they might even possibly use an

elevator to climb to a floating space

station without having to launch oneself

in space rocket feeling three G’s of

force which trust me makes you in a

puker cut out so okay space is amazing

technology is great and human beings are

awesome at solving all problems problem

of the world and they lived happily ever

after

when much like Lau it’s not that simple

let us not deconstruct allow me to

exercise your imaginary mind and bring

the fiction writer inside you to think

let us use it on near future

the date is 38 January 24 50 25th

century I mean because life on Earth

became unsustainable by the end of 23rd

century and space technology advanced so

now human beings have habitations beyond

planet Earth and then as usual busy

scavenging resources from all the

planets including the earth

multiplanetary transportation has become

a usual activity and kids born in this

era

I mean 25th century aren’t even afraid

of going out of the orbit much like how

flying in an airplane has become mundane

activity for a generation so what is

wrong with multi planetary civilization

hogging all available resources let us

come back to the present for a moment

there are laws and when I say law it’s

not only the law promulgated by the

legal authority but laws of universe

nature and cosmos if you say but I will

start with the law of legal order this

is particularly where my legal knowledge

gets in let me tell you there actually

is something on international space law

merely comprising of five international

treaties which is sign in between

nations and they’re binding legal

obligations in between the nations who

have signed them enough with fiction the

reality is many of these space

activities are very practical and

scientific reality particularly space

mining and grabbing an asteroid from the

space good chance at all that the US

would benefit from space resource mining

or space resources within the next two

decades and it is indeed fascinating and

understand your fascination with the

traveler astronaut sorry our traveling

off asteroid or the mining resources but

honestly it is a legal complexity which

is which the world is facing today in

force please let us ask who does the

outer space belong to what enables the

u.s. Europe China India to claim

resources in outer space doesn’t really

belong to anybody the foundation law

regarding outer space the outer space

treaty prescribes that the exploration

and use listen to me very carefully the

exploration and use of outer space is

the province of all mankind so let me

turn a thought experiment here let’s

have some fun this let us imagine this

room to be outer space I am the US and

you’re all different nations you UK you

are you in there are you at China and

even my prophecies both favorites

favorite country Boston I sitting

somebody in the audience so what does

the law say the law says the exploration

and use of this room is that right

conferred upon all of us collectively so

my use of this moon this mic your use of

the asteroid and mass that you’re

sitting on your chairs and the

technicians perfect eye perfect angle to

find find the perfect angle for the

spotlight or satellite it’s the right

bastard upon all of us and only that in

sense as I right the right to explore

and use so does this provision from the

Outer Space Treaty of the foundation law

in your opinion make the outer space the

physical room of the the physical space

of this room province of all mankind

which is to be owned by all of us

collectively or is it only the use of

this mic chairs and spotlight common

heritage of mankind because there is a

big difference between what is a right

of ownership and a right of collective

use doesn’t in simpler term dust space

or the outer space belong to anybody or

nobody originally and one of the

greatest scholar what once said judgment

relax said that is the outer space in

itself with all its vacuum and celestial

bodies a thing which can be all owned by

all of us

even collectively furthermore there’s

one more provision in the other space

relieve it says that the appropriation

of celestial bodies is prohibited which

basically means that I being the u.s.

cannot claim any part of the Moon or the

moon as whole as a territory of the

United States of America well I echo

voice of numerous most qualified

scholars the outer space belongs to

nobody there’s always a popular

consensus far from the interpreted in

the intended interpretation and however

wrong which is that the outer space

belongs to everybody as much to the

India as to the US in between the subtle

friction and relying on the populistic

and rather ill intended interpretation

the u.s. enacted the law enabling

private companies to mine space

resources claim ownership commercially

benefit from it

if you truly understood what I said in

the last few minutes and I’d really hope

you did you should be disturbed by a

question how can somebody have

commercially protected right was

something we just decided not to be

owned by anybody but nevermind this by

all means is going to happen either by

bending laws of framing of new laws

which conform to the capitalist resource

mourning mongering and unsustainable

practice of the society and I only

discuss all of it to prepare you for

what I’m going to say next and it refers

suddenly more to the laws of the nature

of the universe

allow me once again to exercise an

imaginary mind and and let us now think

even bigger and stop opposing a simple

question in your opinion all of your

opinion it’s the universe in cosmos or

chaos by cosmos I mean it has some form

of harmony order and a mechanism in

place to bring in itself stability or in

your opinion universe is chaotic

exploring and dying stars twirling

galaxies pulling massive planets inside

them and all up there in the dark space

is random and wild and if I may use

quite horrifying to be honest but there

are different scientific and

philosophically Riis above on the stupid

or about the concept of cosmos of chaos

but I tend to formally believe that

there exist

a form of cosmic order no matter how

chaotic things are maybe the origins

were chaotic as well but the cosmic

system is continuously striving to

achieve a stability the grand cosmos is

bringing in themselves a stability a

cosmic balance in fact if we look at the

histories of cosmology it is very

interesting to note like histories of

cosmology at different point in time at

different places in the world all all

assumed some some form of cosmic order

in fact if we look at our very own Hindu

cosmology one of the most accurate

cosmological theory according to the

modern-day science prescribes that

assumes natural order don’t as it rest

even in the Chinese philosophy the

ancient Greek philosophy the

philosophies

proper pounded by Pythagoras Aristotle

and even almost scientific Newton

assumed a natural order so you I’m sure

you want to ask me what is really cosmic

balance well it is for me personally it

is not that difficult to understand or

that far let us zoom in a bit in the

cosmic universe and let us look at our

own planet Earth what is it doing it is

producing gases recycling them and even

losing it to outer space meeting in a

habitable environment its meaning the

thermal profile and precise temperatures

as required and cooling down accurately

to sustain the life which this earth has

it is maintaining the percentage of

water and so on and so forth so what we

really conclude from from this the

conclusion is the earth in itself is a

self-regulating natural system with a

natural order and an ax form of harmony

interestingly while I was researching

this concept I stumbled upon interesting

concept proposed by a brilliant NASA

scientist called dr. James now look it

is the Gaia hypothesis the Gaia

hypothesis basically prescribes the

earth itself is a you system a living

organism continuously interacting with

nonliving surroundings self-regulating

the complex processes to maintain a

habitable environment

and the human-induced climate change is

exactly disrupting this cost the eco eco

piloted eco harmony so what if like this

cosmic balance like the eco balance or

know it that really is a cosmic balance

what is to be done what’s to be done is

we dare not disrupt this cosmic balance

and instead we need to preserve it we

need to maintain the cosmic balance if

there exists a cosmic balance and the

universe is a natural system with

harmony in order we better preserve it

what needs to change and this math

central argument what needs to change is

the egocentric view of us human beings

and let me tell you where is ridiculous

parasite sucking all the available

resources with all the unsustainable

practices and now we are planning the

same in outer space the ego that we are

supreme intelligent species and we are

an ultimate control has in many ways

doomed us already and it might do my

son’s basement of health but I’m sure

you would won’t want me to ask if we as

human species or as race have gained the

capability of disrupting the cosmic

balance or cosmic harmony pessimists as

much I may sound the answer to this

question is yes this time allow me to be

a fiction narrator and my journal is

cosmic fiction horror today the date is

15 May 25:56 human beings mind the moon

to an extent that the gravitational pull

between the Earth and the moon has

gotten disrupted the effect of

gravitational pull between the moon and

the earth has a significant

consequential effect on the tidal pools

and the oceans and the ecological

balance on earth so now the earth looks

quite different than what it used to

look

furthermore we conducted such activities

in the electromagnetic shielding around

the earth which protects us from solar

storms and solar radiation we disrupted

that balance and now earth is unable to

hold the oxygen molecules in the

atmosphere and as a result we lost all

the water that was on earth and oceans

have disrupted oceans have vanished and

this is the exact reason why Venus has

no oceans how does it sound

quite harder right it is almost like

hollow obvious lumen race it ready to

face consequences of disrupting the

cosmic balance of cosmic environment and

I mean what in a sense how we understand

on earth today but environment in a

sense that it disrupts a very

fundamental need laws of the nature of

physics like the gravity or

electromagnetic we not this technically

is a fiction and it is not entirely

concluded science but is in fact

interesting to note then bender in the

industrial revolution started nobody

ever believed that industrial effluents

could have a little could have a local

impact environmental impact let alone a

global inspire and that friction is now

a reality and this was really a fiction

if you if you if you see the nose in 99

early 1920s or 1970s this was really a

fiction and this fiction is technically

now what dreadful reality as is already

but it is not a form that I’m talking

about it is the thought that I’m

reflecting on and let me tell you human

beings have already been quite

disruptive in the outer space and I will

in a in a snapshot I’ll describe what

outright crazy actions we have taken in

outer space

what are planning to take I was start by

what happened in the early Space Age

during the duration of 1958 and 1962

when the US and Soviet Union detonated

close to 21 nuclear bombs in outer space

and particularly a project called

starfish prime I don’t know what they

were doing the three guys this bomb was

hundred times more powerful than the

Hiroshima Nagasaki explosion and it was

almost equal to 1.4 million tons of TNT

and effects there was thousands of

kilometers of Earth experience the

phenomenon of sighting Aurora’s and

freely a song and so many talents but

PowerGrid of all the various towns what

take was taken down imagine if they

could do this in 1960s what are the

capabilities now and what could be the

consequences then second is are the

proposals of terraforming this is

basically a lobbied idea by the private

companies who want to

reform the mass or convert mass do a

habitable environment like Earth and

that process involves having a nuclear

explosion on the mass to melt its ice

caps basically then stored one of the

more scary scary part is contamination

that it’s not only about the outer space

and also about the earth while we are

conducting space research we’re bringing

back contaminants and we’re also

bringing the contaminants of Earth to

the outer space and that could have

significant consequential effect what

could be that but there are studies that

show that microbes that could in turn

get introduced to earth environment

could cover the whole planet within days

and that could have severe environmental

impact and due to many man-made debris

that is there’s a growing concern with

the orbital sustainability and we won’t

be able to flow satellites as well and

this is just the beginning of our

modern-day exploration or exploitation

of the space my idea is to leave you

with this let us change our egoistic

human centric perspective and understand

we are only a part of this giant

universe we need to change the

perspective and we need to understand

that we cannot continue to perceive the

nature as outside of us we are within it

it’s a symbiotic relationship and we

share this relationship with the nature

of the cosmos and this idea needs to be

instilled we need to formally believe

that the outer space much like the earth

is a self-regulated mechanism which has

a natural harmony in order and we need

to preserve it because if we don’t and

if we disrupt the cosmic balance there

would be no blame to put put on each

other as nations but it would be a

collective responsibility of entire

human class and so we’ll do the

consequences mind you we won’t be ready

for that and that is the idea worth spreading thank you

Please follow and like us: