
introduce a new phrase into
of public discourse but this lady
Kellyanne Conway managed to do it in
January of this year when she introduced
an unsuspecting world to the idea of
alternative facts now one of the very
curious side effects of this
pronouncement was that it sent this book
to the top of the Amazon bestseller
lists in fact so great was the demand
that all 326 editions of the English
version of 1984 were taken out of the
New York Public Library within a matter
of days all L wrote 1984 and 1948 he got
the title by Transport transposing the
last two digits of the year in it
he presents a very dark picture of an
England in the future which has become
part of a police state or what today we
would call a surveillance state the main
character Winston Smith works in the
Ministry of Truth and lives in a small
apartment which is dominated by a very
large telly screen which does two things
it blasts propaganda into his living
room all day but it’s also equipped with
cameras and microphones so it can watch
his every move and listen to his every
word we are well over thirty years past
1984 and very fortunately Orwell’s
dystopian vision has not happened but I
think if George Orwell had seen some of
the technologies that have developed in
the last twenty years like artificial
intelligence the Internet of Things
GPS systems he might have written a
slightly different book the most famous
line in 1984 is big brother is watching
you a more prescient vision of the
future might have been Big Momma is
making sure you cut down on the booze
and eat your vegetables now what do I
mean by that well one thing that did
happen in 1984 is I gave my first ever
academic paper I wasn’t an academic the
time I was actually a management
consultant but I had managed to win a
competition to present Ireland’s
national contribution to and I apologize
for this the International Federation of
operations Research Society’s annual
conference in Washington DC that’s why
I’ve got the capital building there
now in that paper I propounded a law
this law was a parody of Parkinson’s law
Parkinson’s law some of you may know if
you don’t it says that work expands to
fill the time available my variant which
I modestly called Bannister’s law says
that complexity increases to utilize the
technology available by that I mean that
we humans are really good at using any
new piece of technology to make our
lives more complicated than they already
are now I’m not making a judgment and
whether that’s a good or a bad thing but
if you want some simple proof just try
counting the number of applications on
your smartphone or if you really got
nothing better to do with your life try
working out the number of options and
features in almost any Microsoft product
I suggest word is a good example now
governments are no exception
government’s like to come together lies
in fact the entire history of government
is making our lives more complicated and
the way they do this is through
regulations rules and regulations and
regulations have a number of
characteristics of which I would like to
discuss three the first is that they
grow and multiply when Donald Trump
became president of the United States
one of his very first pronouncements was
that for every new federal regulation
created two had to be abolished
now this prompted various journalists
and others go out and say what how many
regulations are there in the United
States and this proved extremely
difficult to determine one wild guess
was about 95 thousand the answer is
nobody knows how many regulations there
are in the United States of America or
anywhere else come to that all we know
is that the number of them just keeps
getting larger and one of the reasons
for this is the second characteristic of
regulation is that they tend to hang
around long after their sell-by date for
example did you know that it is still a
criminal offense to die in the British
houses of parliament or as recently as
2006 if you were a Jew living in Ireland
you were forbidden for wearing a suit of
armor while one of my personal favorites
in the United States state of Vermont a
woman still technically needs her
husband’s permission in order to wear
false teeth
now the third characteristic of
regulation and it’s really the one that
redeems the other two is that
regulations are very hard to enforce
governments employ armies of policeman
wardens inspectors regulators Rangers
non Colombian oil to try and keep us in
line but the good news is there’s a lot
more of us than there are of them
so this means that if a rule is a bit
silly or bit archaic or even it’s a bit
rakonin we often don’t mind because it’s
so easy to avoid complying with that
particular regulation anyway the problem
is that information technology is about
to change this picture and this means
we’ve got to sit up and take notice we
think mostly of technology fuelled
intrusion into our lives is coming from
social networks Google Facebook who
Hoover up our information and then use
it to try and sell us things like
expensive watches and holidays in the
Seychelles or in my case anti-aging
cream I didn’t make that up by the way
and Google obviously knows something
that I don’t but governments are not
slow to use technology but they’ve a big
being a bit slow to catch on to this and
once they do they’re going to find
they’ve got a very powerful weapon for
enforcing regulation and I’d like to
give you some examples of what might
happen let’s start with this one
188 people were killed on the roads in
Ireland last year a large number of
these were caused by drivers who are
neither insured nor licensed now the two
major causes of death and accidents on
the Irish Roads are speed and alcohol
let’s just talk about speed if we could
cut down the amount of speeding people
breaking the speed limit we could
obviously save lives so how do we try to
do that at the moment well this is how
we do it we take an expensively trained
police officer or possibly two of them
we give her a radar gun and we stick our
behind a hedge somewhere in a country
road and wait for some unsuspecting
motorists to pass by well this is
expensive and it is hit and miss and
it’s very inefficient and I will not
make any comment on other recent
developments with regard to it but we
could solve this problem relatively
easily using the Internet of Things and
modern technology here’s
modern driving license modern driving
license contains the chip it’s either
buried inside the card or in the case of
the Indian driving license explicitly on
the outside now at the moment that chip
just contains basic biographical
information your name or address your
date of birth and then information about
your license what vehicles you’re
qualified to drive and maybe if you have
any endorsements but it would be very
easy to modify that chip to contain two
additional pieces of information
one is biometric information which is
already stored on modern passports and
secondly and most critically it could
hold information on any car that you are
licensed and insured to drive and ensure
it is the key word here so imagine the
future you get into your car you waive
your license or stick it in the slot on
the dashboard you put your finger on on
a panel which verifies that it’s you and
if it isn’t you and if you’re not
licensed to use the car the car simply
won’t start that gets rid of one problem
let’s assume that you are valid you
drive the car you go over the speed
limit the car will advise you that
you’re over the speed limit now we have
to have a bit of common sense here
there are times we all need to break the
speed limit for example while overtaking
or maybe in an emergency but after a
while the car will eventually say okay
that’s it you’ve had your limit I’m
reporting you to the police your bank
account will be debited with the find
your license will be docked and if their
offense is serious enough you’ll get a
summons in the post in a few days and
this isn’t just restricted to speeding
we could do it for people crashing red
lights taking illegal left turns are
using their mobile phones while driving
now imagine if this was done traffic
offenses would drop overnight I want you
to think about all the potential upsides
of this the most important is if we
could cut say by a third or even a
quarter the number of people die think
of all the heartache and destroyed lives
that are going to be avoided but it’s
much more than simply that we’re going
to save resources in our health system
through not having people being brought
into a and E in desperate condition so
not having long periods of
hospitalization we could reduce the
number of police that are standing round
and rows with radar guns and put them to
other socially useful purposes there
would be a contribution to national
economic output because people wouldn’t
be sick or we wouldn’t be losing
valuable members of society insurance
prices would almost certainly go down
and we probably even at the end of the
day get better emissions
what’s not to like about this well
something referencing I will hold on
whoa whoa whoa do I want my car shopping
me too the fuzz every time I break a a
rule cars are freedom you never forget
your first set of wheels some of you may
be lucky enough to already have yours
but it’s a freedom to go where you want
and do what you work the idea that some
police computer is keeping tabs on you
might make your relationship with your
car rather different let me turn to my
second example ask any academic which
part of the job they really dislike and
they will tell you it’s marking exam
scripts it’s not just having to mark
lots of bad handwriting or try to read
bad hand right it’s not judging there’s
quite a lot of cognitive strain in
trying to be fair give me a choice
between marking 200 exam scripts are
facing 200 freshmen engineers at 4
o’clock on a Friday afternoon I’ll take
the engineers at least if they like you
they’ll let you live but a bad toothache
fatigue a fight with your teenage
daughter over breakfast all of these
things can actually influence how you
mark and the academics get concerned
about this and if you’re marking a lot
of the same answer to the same question
it’s very difficult to keep consistent
unless you reduces some kind of box
ticking exercise now the traditional way
to do this was the multiple choice
question and multiple choice questions
are great for certain kinds of topic
like statistics and accountancy and
multiple choice technology has come in a
long way since the old lotto style just
fill in the box but it’s not good at for
example assessing literary criticism or
creative writing or critical thinking or
the ability to develop an argument until
now now we have artificial intelligence
and we have computers that can mark
English history sociology you name it
essays and the really good news is that
they can read handwriting okay now let’s
just imagine this applied to state exams
like the leaving certificate or the
baccalaureate or OU level something
along those lines first of all it would
cut down the cost of these exams
enormously it would mean that marking
was consistent and accurate and fair
computers don’t get emotional computers
do not have fights with their teenage
daughters okay so you’d have very
consistent it would mean that we know
more examiner is being videoed marking
leaving
papers on the upper deck of the 46 a bus
it would also mean you get your exam
results early your leaving cert results
early July may be just in time to spoil
your summer more than that the the such
a system could feed back to either to
students but possibly more so to schools
and teachers and teachers could find out
how what they were teaching well and
when students were answering well and
when they were not again this sounds
great saves money is much more fair all
the right boxes are ticked but at the
same time do you want to be marked by a
computer and if I’m a teacher and I am a
teacher so it’s the idea that somebody
is micromanaging my teaching and looking
over my shoulder might not make me very
comfortable let’s look at the third and
probably most significant of the three
main examples I want to cover and this
is DNA it took 13 years and about 1
billion dollars for the first sequencing
of a complete human genome today we can
do that job in about two days for under
a thousand bucks that’s the progress
that’s being made now DNA contains a lot
of informations about 3 million base
pairs the base pair of being a pair that
joins each side of the helix but when
you actually translate that into modern
computer storage is actually only about
one point five gigabytes that’s about
1/3 of a standard DVD population of
Islanders give or take a bit six and a
half million do a bit of math and you
discover that the DNA genome sequence of
everybody on this island could be stored
in a few racks in a modern data center
so let’s imagine in the morning that the
government at the Department of Health
decides that it’s going to DNA sequence
every newborn child in Ireland the
health benefits this are almost
incalculable it’s not just that we could
see traditional or well-known genetic
diseases such as cystic fibrosis or
hemophilia we are also now able to use
genetics to say predict proneness to
certain types of cancer and maybe even
to other kinds of conditions like
tendency to obesity or early onset
Alzheimer’s now at the very minimum with
such information your doctors or the
health services could provide you with
guidance on lifestyle may be on diet on
early medical intervention and this is
even before
the genetics advances that stage right
we’ll be able to correct a lot of these
things at birth you can imagine that
this will result in thousands then tens
then hundreds and millions of people
having longer better quality lives and
that’s almost impossible to calculate
the value of and yet nobody has proposed
yet that we have national DNA databases
because we might not be terribly
comfortable with the government no
matter how secure the computer systems
knowing all this information about it
some of us might regard it as private
might not even want our GP to know it
and this are just some examples let me
give you four others very quickly the
Irish government as you probably know is
talking about using drone technology to
catch people illegal dumping in Ireland
in Sweden they have been looking at the
use of getting rid of cache and if we
get rid of all cache then we have a
situation where every transaction
including the bag of chips you buy in
the way home from the movies can be
traced and recorded some people are
talking about having fitbit’s which
report your state of healthier doctor if
you a problem and believe it or not and
I’m not making this up either there are
actually people out there who believe we
should be microchipped the same way they
currently do with our pets you’d never
lose your passport again okay now all of
the technologies that I Drive all the
information technologies are with us
today nothing that I have described is
dependent on some future technological
breakthrough we don’t have the
infrastructure but that’s only a matter
of political will and of cash but while
all of these things are possible
none of them are inevitable we have
choices and we have to think about the
degree to which we want to allow our
governments however well-intentioned to
interfere with our lives we can choose
if we want to surround ourselves with a
ball of electronic cotton wool which
will protect us from society and from
ourselves or maybe we prepare to choose
to exercise other rights the rights to
take more of our own risks the right to
get into a motor vehicle self-driving or
not without the government knowing where
you are while you’re in there the right
to keep certain information private so
that the government doesn’t necessarily
know your entire biological makeup and
the right possibly even to
the rules occasionally take your chances
and hope to get away with it I want to
emphasize here I’m not talking about
auras 1984
I’m not talking about the police state
political compliance and fear of that
nature I’m talking about the caring
state or if you want to use a more
proactive term than nanny state and the
possibilities for what the German
sociologist Max Weber called technical
rationalism which is enabled by modern
computers so my appeal to you tonight is
this get aware of these possibilities
don’t leave them to the bureaucrats get
informed and stay informed and get
involved in the conversation and the
debate let’s make sure that as these
wonderful technologies become more and
more common we make active choices we as
individuals as communities and as a
society need to determine the degree of
government electronic powered
interference that we are willing to
accept into our lives but whatever path
we choose on whatever decisions we make
please let us not walk eyes wide shut
into a future of digital by default
thank you [Applause]