Press "Enter" to skip to content

‘Our Small Daily Freedoms’ | Frank Bannister | TEDxTrinityCollegeDublin


it’s not gifted to many of us to

introduce a new phrase into

of public discourse but this lady

Kellyanne Conway managed to do it in

January of this year when she introduced

an unsuspecting world to the idea of

alternative facts now one of the very

curious side effects of this

pronouncement was that it sent this book

to the top of the Amazon bestseller

lists in fact so great was the demand

that all 326 editions of the English

version of 1984 were taken out of the

New York Public Library within a matter

of days all L wrote 1984 and 1948 he got

the title by Transport transposing the

last two digits of the year in it

he presents a very dark picture of an

England in the future which has become

part of a police state or what today we

would call a surveillance state the main

character Winston Smith works in the

Ministry of Truth and lives in a small

apartment which is dominated by a very

large telly screen which does two things

it blasts propaganda into his living

room all day but it’s also equipped with

cameras and microphones so it can watch

his every move and listen to his every

word we are well over thirty years past

1984 and very fortunately Orwell’s

dystopian vision has not happened but I

think if George Orwell had seen some of

the technologies that have developed in

the last twenty years like artificial

intelligence the Internet of Things

GPS systems he might have written a

slightly different book the most famous

line in 1984 is big brother is watching

you a more prescient vision of the

future might have been Big Momma is

making sure you cut down on the booze

and eat your vegetables now what do I

mean by that well one thing that did

happen in 1984 is I gave my first ever

academic paper I wasn’t an academic the

time I was actually a management

consultant but I had managed to win a

competition to present Ireland’s

national contribution to and I apologize

for this the International Federation of

operations Research Society’s annual

conference in Washington DC that’s why

I’ve got the capital building there

now in that paper I propounded a law

this law was a parody of Parkinson’s law

Parkinson’s law some of you may know if

you don’t it says that work expands to

fill the time available my variant which

I modestly called Bannister’s law says

that complexity increases to utilize the

technology available by that I mean that

we humans are really good at using any

new piece of technology to make our

lives more complicated than they already

are now I’m not making a judgment and

whether that’s a good or a bad thing but

if you want some simple proof just try

counting the number of applications on

your smartphone or if you really got

nothing better to do with your life try

working out the number of options and

features in almost any Microsoft product

I suggest word is a good example now

governments are no exception

government’s like to come together lies

in fact the entire history of government

is making our lives more complicated and

the way they do this is through

regulations rules and regulations and

regulations have a number of

characteristics of which I would like to

discuss three the first is that they

grow and multiply when Donald Trump

became president of the United States

one of his very first pronouncements was

that for every new federal regulation

created two had to be abolished

now this prompted various journalists

and others go out and say what how many

regulations are there in the United

States and this proved extremely

difficult to determine one wild guess

was about 95 thousand the answer is

nobody knows how many regulations there

are in the United States of America or

anywhere else come to that all we know

is that the number of them just keeps

getting larger and one of the reasons

for this is the second characteristic of

regulation is that they tend to hang

around long after their sell-by date for

example did you know that it is still a

criminal offense to die in the British

houses of parliament or as recently as

2006 if you were a Jew living in Ireland

you were forbidden for wearing a suit of

armor while one of my personal favorites

in the United States state of Vermont a

woman still technically needs her

husband’s permission in order to wear

false teeth

now the third characteristic of

regulation and it’s really the one that

redeems the other two is that

regulations are very hard to enforce

governments employ armies of policeman

wardens inspectors regulators Rangers

non Colombian oil to try and keep us in

line but the good news is there’s a lot

more of us than there are of them

so this means that if a rule is a bit

silly or bit archaic or even it’s a bit

rakonin we often don’t mind because it’s

so easy to avoid complying with that

particular regulation anyway the problem

is that information technology is about

to change this picture and this means

we’ve got to sit up and take notice we

think mostly of technology fuelled

intrusion into our lives is coming from

social networks Google Facebook who

Hoover up our information and then use

it to try and sell us things like

expensive watches and holidays in the

Seychelles or in my case anti-aging

cream I didn’t make that up by the way

and Google obviously knows something

that I don’t but governments are not

slow to use technology but they’ve a big

being a bit slow to catch on to this and

once they do they’re going to find

they’ve got a very powerful weapon for

enforcing regulation and I’d like to

give you some examples of what might

happen let’s start with this one

188 people were killed on the roads in

Ireland last year a large number of

these were caused by drivers who are

neither insured nor licensed now the two

major causes of death and accidents on

the Irish Roads are speed and alcohol

let’s just talk about speed if we could

cut down the amount of speeding people

breaking the speed limit we could

obviously save lives so how do we try to

do that at the moment well this is how

we do it we take an expensively trained

police officer or possibly two of them

we give her a radar gun and we stick our

behind a hedge somewhere in a country

road and wait for some unsuspecting

motorists to pass by well this is

expensive and it is hit and miss and

it’s very inefficient and I will not

make any comment on other recent

developments with regard to it but we

could solve this problem relatively

easily using the Internet of Things and

modern technology here’s

modern driving license modern driving

license contains the chip it’s either

buried inside the card or in the case of

the Indian driving license explicitly on

the outside now at the moment that chip

just contains basic biographical

information your name or address your

date of birth and then information about

your license what vehicles you’re

qualified to drive and maybe if you have

any endorsements but it would be very

easy to modify that chip to contain two

additional pieces of information

one is biometric information which is

already stored on modern passports and

secondly and most critically it could

hold information on any car that you are

licensed and insured to drive and ensure

it is the key word here so imagine the

future you get into your car you waive

your license or stick it in the slot on

the dashboard you put your finger on on

a panel which verifies that it’s you and

if it isn’t you and if you’re not

licensed to use the car the car simply

won’t start that gets rid of one problem

let’s assume that you are valid you

drive the car you go over the speed

limit the car will advise you that

you’re over the speed limit now we have

to have a bit of common sense here

there are times we all need to break the

speed limit for example while overtaking

or maybe in an emergency but after a

while the car will eventually say okay

that’s it you’ve had your limit I’m

reporting you to the police your bank

account will be debited with the find

your license will be docked and if their

offense is serious enough you’ll get a

summons in the post in a few days and

this isn’t just restricted to speeding

we could do it for people crashing red

lights taking illegal left turns are

using their mobile phones while driving

now imagine if this was done traffic

offenses would drop overnight I want you

to think about all the potential upsides

of this the most important is if we

could cut say by a third or even a

quarter the number of people die think

of all the heartache and destroyed lives

that are going to be avoided but it’s

much more than simply that we’re going

to save resources in our health system

through not having people being brought

into a and E in desperate condition so

not having long periods of

hospitalization we could reduce the

number of police that are standing round

and rows with radar guns and put them to

other socially useful purposes there

would be a contribution to national

economic output because people wouldn’t

be sick or we wouldn’t be losing

valuable members of society insurance

prices would almost certainly go down

and we probably even at the end of the

day get better emissions

what’s not to like about this well

something referencing I will hold on

whoa whoa whoa do I want my car shopping

me too the fuzz every time I break a a

rule cars are freedom you never forget

your first set of wheels some of you may

be lucky enough to already have yours

but it’s a freedom to go where you want

and do what you work the idea that some

police computer is keeping tabs on you

might make your relationship with your

car rather different let me turn to my

second example ask any academic which

part of the job they really dislike and

they will tell you it’s marking exam

scripts it’s not just having to mark

lots of bad handwriting or try to read

bad hand right it’s not judging there’s

quite a lot of cognitive strain in

trying to be fair give me a choice

between marking 200 exam scripts are

facing 200 freshmen engineers at 4

o’clock on a Friday afternoon I’ll take

the engineers at least if they like you

they’ll let you live but a bad toothache

fatigue a fight with your teenage

daughter over breakfast all of these

things can actually influence how you

mark and the academics get concerned

about this and if you’re marking a lot

of the same answer to the same question

it’s very difficult to keep consistent

unless you reduces some kind of box

ticking exercise now the traditional way

to do this was the multiple choice

question and multiple choice questions

are great for certain kinds of topic

like statistics and accountancy and

multiple choice technology has come in a

long way since the old lotto style just

fill in the box but it’s not good at for

example assessing literary criticism or

creative writing or critical thinking or

the ability to develop an argument until

now now we have artificial intelligence

and we have computers that can mark

English history sociology you name it

essays and the really good news is that

they can read handwriting okay now let’s

just imagine this applied to state exams

like the leaving certificate or the

baccalaureate or OU level something

along those lines first of all it would

cut down the cost of these exams

enormously it would mean that marking

was consistent and accurate and fair

computers don’t get emotional computers

do not have fights with their teenage

daughters okay so you’d have very

consistent it would mean that we know

more examiner is being videoed marking

leaving

papers on the upper deck of the 46 a bus

it would also mean you get your exam

results early your leaving cert results

early July may be just in time to spoil

your summer more than that the the such

a system could feed back to either to

students but possibly more so to schools

and teachers and teachers could find out

how what they were teaching well and

when students were answering well and

when they were not again this sounds

great saves money is much more fair all

the right boxes are ticked but at the

same time do you want to be marked by a

computer and if I’m a teacher and I am a

teacher so it’s the idea that somebody

is micromanaging my teaching and looking

over my shoulder might not make me very

comfortable let’s look at the third and

probably most significant of the three

main examples I want to cover and this

is DNA it took 13 years and about 1

billion dollars for the first sequencing

of a complete human genome today we can

do that job in about two days for under

a thousand bucks that’s the progress

that’s being made now DNA contains a lot

of informations about 3 million base

pairs the base pair of being a pair that

joins each side of the helix but when

you actually translate that into modern

computer storage is actually only about

one point five gigabytes that’s about

1/3 of a standard DVD population of

Islanders give or take a bit six and a

half million do a bit of math and you

discover that the DNA genome sequence of

everybody on this island could be stored

in a few racks in a modern data center

so let’s imagine in the morning that the

government at the Department of Health

decides that it’s going to DNA sequence

every newborn child in Ireland the

health benefits this are almost

incalculable it’s not just that we could

see traditional or well-known genetic

diseases such as cystic fibrosis or

hemophilia we are also now able to use

genetics to say predict proneness to

certain types of cancer and maybe even

to other kinds of conditions like

tendency to obesity or early onset

Alzheimer’s now at the very minimum with

such information your doctors or the

health services could provide you with

guidance on lifestyle may be on diet on

early medical intervention and this is

even before

the genetics advances that stage right

we’ll be able to correct a lot of these

things at birth you can imagine that

this will result in thousands then tens

then hundreds and millions of people

having longer better quality lives and

that’s almost impossible to calculate

the value of and yet nobody has proposed

yet that we have national DNA databases

because we might not be terribly

comfortable with the government no

matter how secure the computer systems

knowing all this information about it

some of us might regard it as private

might not even want our GP to know it

and this are just some examples let me

give you four others very quickly the

Irish government as you probably know is

talking about using drone technology to

catch people illegal dumping in Ireland

in Sweden they have been looking at the

use of getting rid of cache and if we

get rid of all cache then we have a

situation where every transaction

including the bag of chips you buy in

the way home from the movies can be

traced and recorded some people are

talking about having fitbit’s which

report your state of healthier doctor if

you a problem and believe it or not and

I’m not making this up either there are

actually people out there who believe we

should be microchipped the same way they

currently do with our pets you’d never

lose your passport again okay now all of

the technologies that I Drive all the

information technologies are with us

today nothing that I have described is

dependent on some future technological

breakthrough we don’t have the

infrastructure but that’s only a matter

of political will and of cash but while

all of these things are possible

none of them are inevitable we have

choices and we have to think about the

degree to which we want to allow our

governments however well-intentioned to

interfere with our lives we can choose

if we want to surround ourselves with a

ball of electronic cotton wool which

will protect us from society and from

ourselves or maybe we prepare to choose

to exercise other rights the rights to

take more of our own risks the right to

get into a motor vehicle self-driving or

not without the government knowing where

you are while you’re in there the right

to keep certain information private so

that the government doesn’t necessarily

know your entire biological makeup and

the right possibly even to

the rules occasionally take your chances

and hope to get away with it I want to

emphasize here I’m not talking about

auras 1984

I’m not talking about the police state

political compliance and fear of that

nature I’m talking about the caring

state or if you want to use a more

proactive term than nanny state and the

possibilities for what the German

sociologist Max Weber called technical

rationalism which is enabled by modern

computers so my appeal to you tonight is

this get aware of these possibilities

don’t leave them to the bureaucrats get

informed and stay informed and get

involved in the conversation and the

debate let’s make sure that as these

wonderful technologies become more and

more common we make active choices we as

individuals as communities and as a

society need to determine the degree of

government electronic powered

interference that we are willing to

accept into our lives but whatever path

we choose on whatever decisions we make

please let us not walk eyes wide shut

into a future of digital by default

thank you [Applause]

Please follow and like us: