
hello everyone I’d like to start by
asking a simple question how do doctors
heal in the cut and thrust of a busy
teaching hospital like the one where I
work in Oxford’s
you could be forgiven for thinking that
storytelling is the very last thing on a
doctor’s mind we are far too busy doing
our jobs often with time running out we
are running crash calls cardiac arrests
major hemorrhages making life-and-death
decisions all of the time but in fact
storytelling has a unique importance in
medicine and that was recognized back in
the late 19th century by someone who is
widely regarded as the father of modern
medicine a professor called Sir William
Osler Osler urged his medical students
and his young doctors in training to
learn by seeing and crucially by talking
to patients he once wrote just listen to
your patient he is telling you the
diagnosis and those words are every bit
as true today in the 21st century as
they were when he wrote them for all the
high-tech wizardry of modern medicine
the scans the genomics the molecular
analyses all those array of technologies
at our disposal actually the way a
doctor invariably figures out what is
wrong with a patient is simply by paying
very close attention to what they tell
us
and so story telling you telling us your
physicians your own narratives of
illness is incredibly important in
medical diagnosis but there’s another
much more fundamental way in which
stories matter in medicine
and it’s something that was encapsulated
beautifully once by Philip Pullman the
author himself no slouch at telling
stories Pullman once said after
nourishment shelter and companionship
stories are the thing we need most in
the world nowhere is that more true than
in a hospital where what heals is not
only our drugs a doctor’s scalpel it is
smaller things too that matter holding
someone hearing them making sure they
know that they’re being hold held and
heard I think for me stories are
important because before I became a
doctor I was a television journalist I
made documentaries and so I told other
people’s stories for a living but now as
a doctor my job is to listen very
closely very attentively to my patient
stories and try with a team to help
shape those stories for the better
that’s the essence of what we all do in
medicine I’m a palliative care doctor
and so I specialize in looking after
patients who are at the end of their
life and we all know that the beginnings
and the endings of stories are often
they’re dramatic high points as with
birth so too in death great intensity of
emotion tends to dominate it’s therefore
incredibly important that as palliative
care doctors we try to get that
experience of dying for our patients as
right as it is possible to be and that
means more simply than the absence of
symptoms such as pain and distress it
means trying to ensure that a patient’s
end of life has grace and dignity and I
think something that’s incredibly
important which we learn early on in
palliative care is a person’s death is
not actually
end of their story because that story
and the manner of a patient’s dying
lives on in their loved ones it has a
life of its own after the death of a
person I think for me a very powerful
recent example that I heard of a story
in medicine came from the Royal Marsden
cancer hospital in London one of the
foremost centers for cancer treatment in
this country it came from one of the
play specialists there a woman who was
wrestling with the challenge of trying
to care for children who faced
radiotherapy for their tumors and
there’s a particular problem for these
children which is they have to undergo
the treatments alone inside a
radiotherapy machine we’re off necessity
they’re separated from their parents and
so they faced a loud distressing
threatening machine by themselves it’s a
very it’s a very challenging and
frightening experience sometimes for
children to cope with this challenge the
play specialist invented something very
simple but very ingenious and she called
it magic string the magic string was a
ball of multicolored twine one end of
which the child could hold the other end
of which could thread underneath the
door out of the room and be held by the
child’s parents she had invented a
literal story that was simultaneously a
narrative story a narrative threat a
story that that child could tell
themselves that even though they were
alone and cold behind a lead-lined door
still they were being loved and held and
cared for by their mother or father a
very powerful idea a hospice like the
wonderful place where I work is often
seen by members of the public as a
precipice people fear that
you cross the threshold all you will do
as plummets downwards there is nothing
left for you to experience but the
experience of dying and I was recently
struck by this when I met a new patient
for the first time somebody who was a
huge Star Wars fan and who happened also
to have terminal cancer he said to me
when he first met me somewhat ruefully
I’ve always thought of this place as the
Death Star and we smiled of course in
one sense he was absolutely right there
is no escaping the fact that many of the
patients who come to our Hospice will
not leave although that’s by no means
always the case but I think what strikes
me in the work I do is not my proximity
to death
it is the sheer quantity of life that I
observe every day at work and not just
ordinary humdrum everyday life I’m
talking about the very best bits of life
love compassion courage selflessness all
those things we see an abundance and in
fact so often as a patient approaches
the end of their life these things
predominate in a way they never have
done at any other point in their life
story it’s truly remarkable I’d like to
share with you a story from the end of
my very first week as a palliative care
doctor that I think exemplifies what
I’ve just described and it took place
one busy Friday afternoon I had been
caring all week for a gentleman in his
70s who was dying of cancer and on that
Friday afternoon he had taken a turn for
the worse he was clearly in the last
probably short hours of his life his
wife whom I’ll call Linda was incredibly
distraught when she realized he was
dying and she had so little time left
with him her cries reverberate it
through the entire ward she could only
scream her distress it was
in tents for her and I went into the
room to try to help I was confronted by
a woman consumed by grief by the patient
himself now deeply unconscious and
probably around 10 or 12 other family
members all of whom are crammed into
this chaotic environment and I had to
decide how to proceed I thought very
quickly and the first thing I did was
ask all of the other family members to
leave the room so now just the three of
us were left Linda her husband and me
and I placed my hands firmly on her
shoulders to try and distract her from
her grief she looked at me and when I
caught her eye I said to her Linda would
you like to say goodbye to your husband
as his wife would you like to lie beside
him now to say goodbye to him and she
was confused she said how I don’t know
how I can do that and if I’m honest at
that stage I wasn’t entirely sure how
she could myself there were high sides
on the bed and there wasn’t very much
room for someone else I just knew he had
to try and so with several of the nurses
excuse me with several of the nurses we
carefully maneuvered the patient to one
side of his bed and created a small
space where his wife of nearly 50 years
a woman who had met her husband when she
was 14 years old and had spent her
entire adult life married to him now lay
beside him she kissed him held his hand
whispered that she loved him stroked his
cheek cries did everything she wanted to
I withdrew gave them some privacy and
when I returned after about half an hour
her whole family had gathered in the
room as well and just moments after I
entered the room he inhaled his chest
rose as his lungs filled with air and he
exhaled one final time and he died in
the arms of the woman he had loved for
so many decades
I share that example because for me it
exemplifies two things first and
foremost that even in a hospice a place
that is so synonymous for many people
with fear and taboo and darkness there
is more than enough love to light the
rooms in fact I’m struck over and over
again by the fact that in my work in
palliative care it is for all the pain
and suffering and grief that accompanies
the work we do actually it is love from
which all of that stems and it is that
what that it is that that predominates
at the end of someone’s life I have
learned as surely as I know anything
through this work that grief is the form
love takes when somebody dies it is what
binds us it is our magic string perhaps
not literal but certainly metaphorical
and the second thing I have learned is
that here in this example was the very
best of health care we saw here a
medical team of doctors and nurses doing
their utmost to strive beyond the mere
statistics the hard facts of medicine
and reach out to the meanings and the
emotions that matter to a patient and
their family at the end of life there is
a wonderful quotation here from the
great poet Maya Angelou who said I’ve
learned that people will forget what you
said people will forget what you did but
they will never forget how you made them
feel all doctors not only palliative
care doctors I believe must strive to
hear those words and heed them we must
do our utmost to ensure that our
patients feel our care for them
and we do that by hearing their stories
we listen we respect we ensure that a
patient does not feel they are ever
abandoned they are ever by themselves
left alone in medicine so to return to
my original question how do doctors heal
I think we have an extraordinary array
of technologies in medicine at our
disposal to achieve that healing we can
enhance and prolong life in so many ways
we can use antibiotics chemotherapy
organ transplants so many different
technologies and yet all of us will die
we will all reach a point in our life
where the moment for all of that has
passed we have lost it there is no room
anymore for prolonging or enhancing the
message I take from working as a
palliative care doctor though is this
there is always capacity for healing
even when there is no option for cure
even when we can’t enhance we can’t
prolong we can still heal and that’s
because healing fundamentally at its
core is about our shared humanity it is
about ensuring we remain connected to
someone especially in the final days of
their life so that they never feel alone
we always ensure there is a magic string
and it is always embracing all of us the
great beauty of that aspect of healing
is of course that it is in no sense the
monopoly of doctors we can all do this
you can do this every bit as much as I
can as any of us can and I think we will
all you will all at some stage if you
haven’t already faced a situation where
you are grieving you are hurting because
you are losing someone
and perhaps in that grief you can hold
on to two facts the first is you can
heal if you can maintain that human
connection if you can embrace rather
than shrink away from the pain of having
to lose somebody you love you have the
opportunity to do something remarkable
and healing right when it matters the
most right at the end of somebody’s life
and if you can remember somehow although
it’s hard that that pain you are feeling
exists because grief is the form your
love is taking as you lose someone as
you see them die then perhaps that can
give you strength at that time if you’re
able to do that you’re doing something
remarkable because at the end of
somebody’s life when they need that
human connection and all the healing
that encompasses more than at any other
time you are being their magic string
and we can all do that thank you very
much
you
asking a simple question how do doctors
heal in the cut and thrust of a busy
teaching hospital like the one where I
work in Oxford’s
you could be forgiven for thinking that
storytelling is the very last thing on a
doctor’s mind we are far too busy doing
our jobs often with time running out we
are running crash calls cardiac arrests
major hemorrhages making life-and-death
decisions all of the time but in fact
storytelling has a unique importance in
medicine and that was recognized back in
the late 19th century by someone who is
widely regarded as the father of modern
medicine a professor called Sir William
Osler Osler urged his medical students
and his young doctors in training to
learn by seeing and crucially by talking
to patients he once wrote just listen to
your patient he is telling you the
diagnosis and those words are every bit
as true today in the 21st century as
they were when he wrote them for all the
high-tech wizardry of modern medicine
the scans the genomics the molecular
analyses all those array of technologies
at our disposal actually the way a
doctor invariably figures out what is
wrong with a patient is simply by paying
very close attention to what they tell
us
and so story telling you telling us your
physicians your own narratives of
illness is incredibly important in
medical diagnosis but there’s another
much more fundamental way in which
stories matter in medicine
and it’s something that was encapsulated
beautifully once by Philip Pullman the
author himself no slouch at telling
stories Pullman once said after
nourishment shelter and companionship
stories are the thing we need most in
the world nowhere is that more true than
in a hospital where what heals is not
only our drugs a doctor’s scalpel it is
smaller things too that matter holding
someone hearing them making sure they
know that they’re being hold held and
heard I think for me stories are
important because before I became a
doctor I was a television journalist I
made documentaries and so I told other
people’s stories for a living but now as
a doctor my job is to listen very
closely very attentively to my patient
stories and try with a team to help
shape those stories for the better
that’s the essence of what we all do in
medicine I’m a palliative care doctor
and so I specialize in looking after
patients who are at the end of their
life and we all know that the beginnings
and the endings of stories are often
they’re dramatic high points as with
birth so too in death great intensity of
emotion tends to dominate it’s therefore
incredibly important that as palliative
care doctors we try to get that
experience of dying for our patients as
right as it is possible to be and that
means more simply than the absence of
symptoms such as pain and distress it
means trying to ensure that a patient’s
end of life has grace and dignity and I
think something that’s incredibly
important which we learn early on in
palliative care is a person’s death is
not actually
end of their story because that story
and the manner of a patient’s dying
lives on in their loved ones it has a
life of its own after the death of a
person I think for me a very powerful
recent example that I heard of a story
in medicine came from the Royal Marsden
cancer hospital in London one of the
foremost centers for cancer treatment in
this country it came from one of the
play specialists there a woman who was
wrestling with the challenge of trying
to care for children who faced
radiotherapy for their tumors and
there’s a particular problem for these
children which is they have to undergo
the treatments alone inside a
radiotherapy machine we’re off necessity
they’re separated from their parents and
so they faced a loud distressing
threatening machine by themselves it’s a
very it’s a very challenging and
frightening experience sometimes for
children to cope with this challenge the
play specialist invented something very
simple but very ingenious and she called
it magic string the magic string was a
ball of multicolored twine one end of
which the child could hold the other end
of which could thread underneath the
door out of the room and be held by the
child’s parents she had invented a
literal story that was simultaneously a
narrative story a narrative threat a
story that that child could tell
themselves that even though they were
alone and cold behind a lead-lined door
still they were being loved and held and
cared for by their mother or father a
very powerful idea a hospice like the
wonderful place where I work is often
seen by members of the public as a
precipice people fear that
you cross the threshold all you will do
as plummets downwards there is nothing
left for you to experience but the
experience of dying and I was recently
struck by this when I met a new patient
for the first time somebody who was a
huge Star Wars fan and who happened also
to have terminal cancer he said to me
when he first met me somewhat ruefully
I’ve always thought of this place as the
Death Star and we smiled of course in
one sense he was absolutely right there
is no escaping the fact that many of the
patients who come to our Hospice will
not leave although that’s by no means
always the case but I think what strikes
me in the work I do is not my proximity
to death
it is the sheer quantity of life that I
observe every day at work and not just
ordinary humdrum everyday life I’m
talking about the very best bits of life
love compassion courage selflessness all
those things we see an abundance and in
fact so often as a patient approaches
the end of their life these things
predominate in a way they never have
done at any other point in their life
story it’s truly remarkable I’d like to
share with you a story from the end of
my very first week as a palliative care
doctor that I think exemplifies what
I’ve just described and it took place
one busy Friday afternoon I had been
caring all week for a gentleman in his
70s who was dying of cancer and on that
Friday afternoon he had taken a turn for
the worse he was clearly in the last
probably short hours of his life his
wife whom I’ll call Linda was incredibly
distraught when she realized he was
dying and she had so little time left
with him her cries reverberate it
through the entire ward she could only
scream her distress it was
in tents for her and I went into the
room to try to help I was confronted by
a woman consumed by grief by the patient
himself now deeply unconscious and
probably around 10 or 12 other family
members all of whom are crammed into
this chaotic environment and I had to
decide how to proceed I thought very
quickly and the first thing I did was
ask all of the other family members to
leave the room so now just the three of
us were left Linda her husband and me
and I placed my hands firmly on her
shoulders to try and distract her from
her grief she looked at me and when I
caught her eye I said to her Linda would
you like to say goodbye to your husband
as his wife would you like to lie beside
him now to say goodbye to him and she
was confused she said how I don’t know
how I can do that and if I’m honest at
that stage I wasn’t entirely sure how
she could myself there were high sides
on the bed and there wasn’t very much
room for someone else I just knew he had
to try and so with several of the nurses
excuse me with several of the nurses we
carefully maneuvered the patient to one
side of his bed and created a small
space where his wife of nearly 50 years
a woman who had met her husband when she
was 14 years old and had spent her
entire adult life married to him now lay
beside him she kissed him held his hand
whispered that she loved him stroked his
cheek cries did everything she wanted to
I withdrew gave them some privacy and
when I returned after about half an hour
her whole family had gathered in the
room as well and just moments after I
entered the room he inhaled his chest
rose as his lungs filled with air and he
exhaled one final time and he died in
the arms of the woman he had loved for
so many decades
I share that example because for me it
exemplifies two things first and
foremost that even in a hospice a place
that is so synonymous for many people
with fear and taboo and darkness there
is more than enough love to light the
rooms in fact I’m struck over and over
again by the fact that in my work in
palliative care it is for all the pain
and suffering and grief that accompanies
the work we do actually it is love from
which all of that stems and it is that
what that it is that that predominates
at the end of someone’s life I have
learned as surely as I know anything
through this work that grief is the form
love takes when somebody dies it is what
binds us it is our magic string perhaps
not literal but certainly metaphorical
and the second thing I have learned is
that here in this example was the very
best of health care we saw here a
medical team of doctors and nurses doing
their utmost to strive beyond the mere
statistics the hard facts of medicine
and reach out to the meanings and the
emotions that matter to a patient and
their family at the end of life there is
a wonderful quotation here from the
great poet Maya Angelou who said I’ve
learned that people will forget what you
said people will forget what you did but
they will never forget how you made them
feel all doctors not only palliative
care doctors I believe must strive to
hear those words and heed them we must
do our utmost to ensure that our
patients feel our care for them
and we do that by hearing their stories
we listen we respect we ensure that a
patient does not feel they are ever
abandoned they are ever by themselves
left alone in medicine so to return to
my original question how do doctors heal
I think we have an extraordinary array
of technologies in medicine at our
disposal to achieve that healing we can
enhance and prolong life in so many ways
we can use antibiotics chemotherapy
organ transplants so many different
technologies and yet all of us will die
we will all reach a point in our life
where the moment for all of that has
passed we have lost it there is no room
anymore for prolonging or enhancing the
message I take from working as a
palliative care doctor though is this
there is always capacity for healing
even when there is no option for cure
even when we can’t enhance we can’t
prolong we can still heal and that’s
because healing fundamentally at its
core is about our shared humanity it is
about ensuring we remain connected to
someone especially in the final days of
their life so that they never feel alone
we always ensure there is a magic string
and it is always embracing all of us the
great beauty of that aspect of healing
is of course that it is in no sense the
monopoly of doctors we can all do this
you can do this every bit as much as I
can as any of us can and I think we will
all you will all at some stage if you
haven’t already faced a situation where
you are grieving you are hurting because
you are losing someone
and perhaps in that grief you can hold
on to two facts the first is you can
heal if you can maintain that human
connection if you can embrace rather
than shrink away from the pain of having
to lose somebody you love you have the
opportunity to do something remarkable
and healing right when it matters the
most right at the end of somebody’s life
and if you can remember somehow although
it’s hard that that pain you are feeling
exists because grief is the form your
love is taking as you lose someone as
you see them die then perhaps that can
give you strength at that time if you’re
able to do that you’re doing something
remarkable because at the end of
somebody’s life when they need that
human connection and all the healing
that encompasses more than at any other
time you are being their magic string
and we can all do that thank you very
much
you
Please follow and like us: