
[Music]
hi have you found yourself worrying
about the state of the world recently
wondering if we can actually withstand
the tension that’s growing between
groups of people based on things like
nationality religion and politics as a
neuroscientist I find myself wondering
if we’re on the brink of a global
emotional crisis because we certainly
seem to be experiencing a lot more fear
anger disgust shame and sadness than joy
excitement or love trust in the world
recently what’s been interesting to me
is that we’re all talking about this at
home with friends and colleagues and
even debating quite passionately with
people we don’t know that well so what
can we all do to transform fear into
trust I want to answer using the science
of the brain the question that’s on
everyone’s lips at the moment can we get
through this peacefully so let’s start
by establishing what this situation even
is I want to be very clear it’s not
about your or my opinion or being right
or wrong or even our political choices
it’s about the evolution of the human
brain from tribal origins through ethnic
and geographic diversification to the
creation of the nation-state all the way
up to modern nationalism it’s about the
history of why we created in and out
groups in our societies whether we’re
hardwired to act on stereotypes or
whether we can change how we regulate
our fears and other emotions and perhaps
most importantly how we might reach our
fullest human potential by knowing how
our brains work part of understanding
where we’ve come to involves looking at
where we’ve come from it’s been
interesting you could say being British
or American recently I’m British I’m
employed by an iconic American
institution the MIT and we have felt
like our choices have been scrutinized
by the world and our decisions judged
and we’ve come out seriously one too
for looking like we have caused the
worst thing you can do to a human being
cast out because when we lived in caves
being cast out of the cave meant certain
death from the elements from predators
from enemies from lack of food and lack
of warmth both literally from the
shelter but also from the warmth of
interaction affection and love we became
the most successful animal on the planet
because we could exist in these large
groups 150 or more and the quickest way
to recognize who was in your group who
was friend or foe
was what you look like so skin color
hair color eye shape hair texture and
then later language now we live in
mixed-race families many of us speak two
or more languages but some of our old
wiring is holding us back notice I
didn’t say hard wiring because that
implies that it’s fixed and can’t be
changed I don’t mind the term soft
wiring because stereotypes do exist but
we can override our unconscious biases
and we can transform fear into trust the
history of our species has created and
inherently us-versus-them construct due
to these three main safety gearing’s of
the brain our survival emotions loss
aversion and unconscious bias we have
some pretty awful examples of us versus
them in our history slavery the
Holocaust apartheid to name a few
sometimes particularly with my work in
South Africa there are moments of true
joy and love in terms of moving forward
but at other times you still palpably
feel the opposite
but as Mandela said no one is born
hating somebody because of the color of
their skin you have to learn to do that
and if you can learn that then in the
brain you can unlearn or override that
pathway so let’s look at the brain and
the science behind human emotions like
love and hate deep in our limbic systems
which is the ancient emotional and
insured
part of the brain we have to
almond-shaped structures each called an
amygdala and this is where our emotions
like fear originate due to the wiring of
the brain the survival emotions fear
anger disgust shame and sadness have a
much stronger effect on the brain than
the attachment emotions joy excitement
or love trust the survival emotions
correlate to levels of the stress
hormone cortisol and we will do anything
not to feel the effects of high cortisol
like being afraid or ashamed
and that’s why historically it’s been
easy to motivate people based on fear
inducing scenarios or disgust at someone
else’s behavior the u.s. presidential
elections were actually a prime example
of this with candidates taking out TV
adverts highlighting scandals and
allegations about the other person
instead of focusing on what they
themselves had to offer stress and
cortisol bias our decision-making
systems to avoid risk avoid change and
anything we feel we can’t control in
this state the blood supply moves away
from the higher centers of the brain
down to what’s called survival mode and
here we can carry out our basic daily
needs and enough to keep our jobs and
family intact but then we don’t have
enough resources for the executive
functions of the brain
those that regulate our emotions
override our biases help us to think
flexibly and creatively and to solve
complex problems at the other end of the
spectrum we have the attachment emotions
love trust and joy excitement and these
correlate to the bonding hormone
oxytocin oxytocin is released during
childbirth breastfeeding and two
underlies the bond between newborn
babies and their parents it’s also part
of the chemical cocktail of falling in
love and social bonding like friendship
there’s evidence that when the fabric of
society falls apart to the point of
rioting or rebelling against Authority
this is related to lower societal
oxytocin levels and higher oxytocin
levels can even make men more faithful
and I’ve got a few scientific references
that
to prove that so in this state blood
flows freely to the higher centers of
the brain we lower our guard we feel
warm towards others we’re more likely to
take risks in a good way and to
collaborate because we have the
resources to trust rather than default
to the state of mistrust referendums and
elections touch upon human emotions to
gather votes because we have such a
strong need for that sense of belonging
which is essentially love and trust you
will notice that I mentioned mistrust as
a default state for the brain this is
because the strongest gearing of of our
brain is something known as loss
aversion this is our a preference to
avoid loss over trying to gain any
reward to our brains it’s better not to
lose five pounds than it is to find five
pounds studies suggest that
psychologically losses are twice as
powerful as as games and although
traditional economists consider loss
aversion and all its related effects to
be totally irrational this is exactly
why they play such an important part in
things like elections and recognizing in
and out groups in and out groups were
very useful concepts in primitive times
when mistakenly engaging with a member
of another tribe could have proved fatal
that’s less the case today but in the
intervening millennia that idea has
become ingrained into our brains and
with over a hundred and fifty biases
identified this goes way beyond race and
gender to include things like social
class wealth education religion politics
national and regional roots and even
physical attractiveness so the basis of
our unconscious biases is that even if
you don’t think you have a racist ageist
or sexist bone in your body if that
stereotype exists in the world then it’s
to some extent wired into our brains and
this was meant to keep us safe because
our brains priority is to ensure our
survival until we can reproduce
and we collaborated in these large
groups essentially to compete with other
groups so once our survival was ensured
our thoughts and activities naturally
turned to disadvantaging these other
groups and in fact when you even think
about groups of people that you don’t
like the disgust pathways of your limbic
system light up you’re more likely to
feel like that and be biased when you
are tired hungry or feeling threatened
tired and hungry indicate low resources
to your brain and feeling threatened
drains any resources that you might have
circulating in the blood flow making it
harder for you to override your
unconscious biases there are fascinating
examples of judges granting more parole
after recent meal and break times the
little circles are when the judges had
had something to eat and making more
unfavorable decisions based on racial
bias the further away they had got from
fuelling their brains and it doesn’t end
there with how we think about other
people there are also biases that we
perpetuate about ourselves so I’m a
woman of Indian origin if I was going
for a job interview at let’s say an
accountancy firm and it was for a job
where I had to be particularly numerate
and just before that interview someone
said to me I really like your dress
where did you get it from that would
inadvertently remind me that I’m female
and I would then be likely to
underperform in that job interview
because the stereotype in the world is
that women aren’t as good with numbers
as men
if however just before the same
interview someone asked me where in
India my parents were from I would then
be likely to over perform in that
interview because the stereotype in the
world is that people are good with
numbers
so who has felt inferior inferior or
cast out or treated unfairly recently
Europeans the British Mexicans Democrats
Muslims the list could go on and on the
increase in the rise of nationalism in
Europe and other parts of the world has
crept up on us wave after wave of
nationalism in response to the influx of
immigration due to economic stresses and
geopolitical crises elsewhere in the
world the negative brain response is
more marked initially if you look
obviously different so skin color or
recognizable feature it’s more insidious
and psychological if it takes more than
a first glance to realize that this
person is different to you usually
there’s integration within one or two
generations and this isn’t just
subjective this is based on brain
testing of people’s responses to groups
of other ethnicities and this happens
more quickly if people become proficient
at the language of the country that
they’ve moved to and it can take longer
if people live in ghettos and don’t
embrace some cultural norms at the end
of the day we all experience the full
range of basic human emotions and almost
all of us are in an out-group somehow I
could say I only want to be friends with
people in my age range or I could say
age doesn’t matter to me but I think
I’ve got more in common with
multilingual University educated people
that love to travel or I could choose to
have no barriers to friendship none of
us should believe that we can’t change
at any age given what we know now about
neuroplasticity which is the ability of
the brain to change itself well into
adulthood humans have evolved the
potential to reason to override our
emotions we don’t have to live by these
fear driven and emotion based decisions
that we’ve made we can think outside of
the box we can hold opposing views and
we can imagine a different future or
reality so let’s take a neuroscience
based look at what we could actually do
to move forward as a human race we could
start a new narrative which if properly
taken up and spread could help us to
finally realize that any hatred or
violence based on things like national
or religious loyalties could be
seriously endangering our sustainability
as a species
language is really powerful and if we
start to tell a different story based on
articulating our attachment emotions so
looking for what unites us rather than
what separates us then we can actually
change the way that our brains operate
we can override our survival emotions
our loss aversion and our unconscious
biases there are a wide number of
factors that policy and international
level could contribute to this but I
want to talk to you about the practical
things that could make the biggest
difference day to day make sure that
your brain is rested fueled and
oxygenated particularly around times
where you might be making an important
decision on a day after you haven’t had
a good night’s sleep you’re operating
with an apparent IQ loss of 5 to 8
points this could be crucial in you
deciding who’s in your in-group and
who’s not don’t skip meals remember the
judges granting parole and if you think
there’s any chance that you might judge
someone harshly based on a bias that you
have then go for a walk or at least take
ten deep breaths to oxygenate your brain
before you meet them try to raise your
awareness of the boundaries for your
in-group and broaden it learn a new
language travel to a place you’ve never
been before hang out with people with
totally different life experiences or
just smile at a stranger in the book
train your mind change your brain
there’s evidence that just making a list
of people you know you could turn to if
you really needed help can actually
reduce your bias against out groups but
most of all choose love and trust over
fear and hate whenever you can and role
model this to help other people to do
the same
remember we’re much more similar than we
are different if I couldn’t see your
bodies now sitting on all these chairs
and I could only see your brains then as
a neuroscientist and a medical doctor I
could probably take quite a good guess
at whether you were male or female if I
could dissect your brain or look at it
in a scanner then I’d be able to tell if
you had a disease like Alzheimer’s or
you’d had a stroke and many many more
things but nothing would tell me the
color of your
or what religion you are so what one
thing are you prepared to do to change
your brain and influence the brains
around you I believe that if we each did
one thing based on understanding how our
brains work we would not only touch the
people that we know but eventually we
could transform the world
you
hi have you found yourself worrying
about the state of the world recently
wondering if we can actually withstand
the tension that’s growing between
groups of people based on things like
nationality religion and politics as a
neuroscientist I find myself wondering
if we’re on the brink of a global
emotional crisis because we certainly
seem to be experiencing a lot more fear
anger disgust shame and sadness than joy
excitement or love trust in the world
recently what’s been interesting to me
is that we’re all talking about this at
home with friends and colleagues and
even debating quite passionately with
people we don’t know that well so what
can we all do to transform fear into
trust I want to answer using the science
of the brain the question that’s on
everyone’s lips at the moment can we get
through this peacefully so let’s start
by establishing what this situation even
is I want to be very clear it’s not
about your or my opinion or being right
or wrong or even our political choices
it’s about the evolution of the human
brain from tribal origins through ethnic
and geographic diversification to the
creation of the nation-state all the way
up to modern nationalism it’s about the
history of why we created in and out
groups in our societies whether we’re
hardwired to act on stereotypes or
whether we can change how we regulate
our fears and other emotions and perhaps
most importantly how we might reach our
fullest human potential by knowing how
our brains work part of understanding
where we’ve come to involves looking at
where we’ve come from it’s been
interesting you could say being British
or American recently I’m British I’m
employed by an iconic American
institution the MIT and we have felt
like our choices have been scrutinized
by the world and our decisions judged
and we’ve come out seriously one too
for looking like we have caused the
worst thing you can do to a human being
cast out because when we lived in caves
being cast out of the cave meant certain
death from the elements from predators
from enemies from lack of food and lack
of warmth both literally from the
shelter but also from the warmth of
interaction affection and love we became
the most successful animal on the planet
because we could exist in these large
groups 150 or more and the quickest way
to recognize who was in your group who
was friend or foe
was what you look like so skin color
hair color eye shape hair texture and
then later language now we live in
mixed-race families many of us speak two
or more languages but some of our old
wiring is holding us back notice I
didn’t say hard wiring because that
implies that it’s fixed and can’t be
changed I don’t mind the term soft
wiring because stereotypes do exist but
we can override our unconscious biases
and we can transform fear into trust the
history of our species has created and
inherently us-versus-them construct due
to these three main safety gearing’s of
the brain our survival emotions loss
aversion and unconscious bias we have
some pretty awful examples of us versus
them in our history slavery the
Holocaust apartheid to name a few
sometimes particularly with my work in
South Africa there are moments of true
joy and love in terms of moving forward
but at other times you still palpably
feel the opposite
but as Mandela said no one is born
hating somebody because of the color of
their skin you have to learn to do that
and if you can learn that then in the
brain you can unlearn or override that
pathway so let’s look at the brain and
the science behind human emotions like
love and hate deep in our limbic systems
which is the ancient emotional and
insured
part of the brain we have to
almond-shaped structures each called an
amygdala and this is where our emotions
like fear originate due to the wiring of
the brain the survival emotions fear
anger disgust shame and sadness have a
much stronger effect on the brain than
the attachment emotions joy excitement
or love trust the survival emotions
correlate to levels of the stress
hormone cortisol and we will do anything
not to feel the effects of high cortisol
like being afraid or ashamed
and that’s why historically it’s been
easy to motivate people based on fear
inducing scenarios or disgust at someone
else’s behavior the u.s. presidential
elections were actually a prime example
of this with candidates taking out TV
adverts highlighting scandals and
allegations about the other person
instead of focusing on what they
themselves had to offer stress and
cortisol bias our decision-making
systems to avoid risk avoid change and
anything we feel we can’t control in
this state the blood supply moves away
from the higher centers of the brain
down to what’s called survival mode and
here we can carry out our basic daily
needs and enough to keep our jobs and
family intact but then we don’t have
enough resources for the executive
functions of the brain
those that regulate our emotions
override our biases help us to think
flexibly and creatively and to solve
complex problems at the other end of the
spectrum we have the attachment emotions
love trust and joy excitement and these
correlate to the bonding hormone
oxytocin oxytocin is released during
childbirth breastfeeding and two
underlies the bond between newborn
babies and their parents it’s also part
of the chemical cocktail of falling in
love and social bonding like friendship
there’s evidence that when the fabric of
society falls apart to the point of
rioting or rebelling against Authority
this is related to lower societal
oxytocin levels and higher oxytocin
levels can even make men more faithful
and I’ve got a few scientific references
that
to prove that so in this state blood
flows freely to the higher centers of
the brain we lower our guard we feel
warm towards others we’re more likely to
take risks in a good way and to
collaborate because we have the
resources to trust rather than default
to the state of mistrust referendums and
elections touch upon human emotions to
gather votes because we have such a
strong need for that sense of belonging
which is essentially love and trust you
will notice that I mentioned mistrust as
a default state for the brain this is
because the strongest gearing of of our
brain is something known as loss
aversion this is our a preference to
avoid loss over trying to gain any
reward to our brains it’s better not to
lose five pounds than it is to find five
pounds studies suggest that
psychologically losses are twice as
powerful as as games and although
traditional economists consider loss
aversion and all its related effects to
be totally irrational this is exactly
why they play such an important part in
things like elections and recognizing in
and out groups in and out groups were
very useful concepts in primitive times
when mistakenly engaging with a member
of another tribe could have proved fatal
that’s less the case today but in the
intervening millennia that idea has
become ingrained into our brains and
with over a hundred and fifty biases
identified this goes way beyond race and
gender to include things like social
class wealth education religion politics
national and regional roots and even
physical attractiveness so the basis of
our unconscious biases is that even if
you don’t think you have a racist ageist
or sexist bone in your body if that
stereotype exists in the world then it’s
to some extent wired into our brains and
this was meant to keep us safe because
our brains priority is to ensure our
survival until we can reproduce
and we collaborated in these large
groups essentially to compete with other
groups so once our survival was ensured
our thoughts and activities naturally
turned to disadvantaging these other
groups and in fact when you even think
about groups of people that you don’t
like the disgust pathways of your limbic
system light up you’re more likely to
feel like that and be biased when you
are tired hungry or feeling threatened
tired and hungry indicate low resources
to your brain and feeling threatened
drains any resources that you might have
circulating in the blood flow making it
harder for you to override your
unconscious biases there are fascinating
examples of judges granting more parole
after recent meal and break times the
little circles are when the judges had
had something to eat and making more
unfavorable decisions based on racial
bias the further away they had got from
fuelling their brains and it doesn’t end
there with how we think about other
people there are also biases that we
perpetuate about ourselves so I’m a
woman of Indian origin if I was going
for a job interview at let’s say an
accountancy firm and it was for a job
where I had to be particularly numerate
and just before that interview someone
said to me I really like your dress
where did you get it from that would
inadvertently remind me that I’m female
and I would then be likely to
underperform in that job interview
because the stereotype in the world is
that women aren’t as good with numbers
as men
if however just before the same
interview someone asked me where in
India my parents were from I would then
be likely to over perform in that
interview because the stereotype in the
world is that people are good with
numbers
so who has felt inferior inferior or
cast out or treated unfairly recently
Europeans the British Mexicans Democrats
Muslims the list could go on and on the
increase in the rise of nationalism in
Europe and other parts of the world has
crept up on us wave after wave of
nationalism in response to the influx of
immigration due to economic stresses and
geopolitical crises elsewhere in the
world the negative brain response is
more marked initially if you look
obviously different so skin color or
recognizable feature it’s more insidious
and psychological if it takes more than
a first glance to realize that this
person is different to you usually
there’s integration within one or two
generations and this isn’t just
subjective this is based on brain
testing of people’s responses to groups
of other ethnicities and this happens
more quickly if people become proficient
at the language of the country that
they’ve moved to and it can take longer
if people live in ghettos and don’t
embrace some cultural norms at the end
of the day we all experience the full
range of basic human emotions and almost
all of us are in an out-group somehow I
could say I only want to be friends with
people in my age range or I could say
age doesn’t matter to me but I think
I’ve got more in common with
multilingual University educated people
that love to travel or I could choose to
have no barriers to friendship none of
us should believe that we can’t change
at any age given what we know now about
neuroplasticity which is the ability of
the brain to change itself well into
adulthood humans have evolved the
potential to reason to override our
emotions we don’t have to live by these
fear driven and emotion based decisions
that we’ve made we can think outside of
the box we can hold opposing views and
we can imagine a different future or
reality so let’s take a neuroscience
based look at what we could actually do
to move forward as a human race we could
start a new narrative which if properly
taken up and spread could help us to
finally realize that any hatred or
violence based on things like national
or religious loyalties could be
seriously endangering our sustainability
as a species
language is really powerful and if we
start to tell a different story based on
articulating our attachment emotions so
looking for what unites us rather than
what separates us then we can actually
change the way that our brains operate
we can override our survival emotions
our loss aversion and our unconscious
biases there are a wide number of
factors that policy and international
level could contribute to this but I
want to talk to you about the practical
things that could make the biggest
difference day to day make sure that
your brain is rested fueled and
oxygenated particularly around times
where you might be making an important
decision on a day after you haven’t had
a good night’s sleep you’re operating
with an apparent IQ loss of 5 to 8
points this could be crucial in you
deciding who’s in your in-group and
who’s not don’t skip meals remember the
judges granting parole and if you think
there’s any chance that you might judge
someone harshly based on a bias that you
have then go for a walk or at least take
ten deep breaths to oxygenate your brain
before you meet them try to raise your
awareness of the boundaries for your
in-group and broaden it learn a new
language travel to a place you’ve never
been before hang out with people with
totally different life experiences or
just smile at a stranger in the book
train your mind change your brain
there’s evidence that just making a list
of people you know you could turn to if
you really needed help can actually
reduce your bias against out groups but
most of all choose love and trust over
fear and hate whenever you can and role
model this to help other people to do
the same
remember we’re much more similar than we
are different if I couldn’t see your
bodies now sitting on all these chairs
and I could only see your brains then as
a neuroscientist and a medical doctor I
could probably take quite a good guess
at whether you were male or female if I
could dissect your brain or look at it
in a scanner then I’d be able to tell if
you had a disease like Alzheimer’s or
you’d had a stroke and many many more
things but nothing would tell me the
color of your
or what religion you are so what one
thing are you prepared to do to change
your brain and influence the brains
around you I believe that if we each did
one thing based on understanding how our
brains work we would not only touch the
people that we know but eventually we
could transform the world
you
Please follow and like us: