
what do you love doing that you’re
really bad at something that you royally
stink at but that you still enjoy doing
just hang on to that thought we’ll come
back to it later I’m going to talk to
you about rejection I am a reject
I am also and perhaps this is
uncontained and impolite to say but I am
also a high achiever and successful at
what I set out to do I am a writer of
fiction who has written an awful lot and
experienced years of rejection but I am
also a writer of fiction who is
experienced success won an international
award and has recently signed her second
book contract so how do i reconcile
these two things being a failure and
being a success I’m going to tell you
that one depends on the other that
rejection is a key ingredient to
creativity and success but pushing out
work that gets rejected that this makes
you a better creator it’s like making
the first pancake in the batch if all
you ever made was the first pancake and
it was crap people ate it you’d never
know you had a whole batch of great
pancakes in you thank you Rory Gilmore
because if it wasn’t for the work that
was bad there wouldn’t be the work that
was good these are Booker Award winners
Paul Beatty in Marlon James Paul beedis
book was rejected 18 times
Marlon James this book was rejected 78
times 78 times now I don’t know the
inner workings of these books but I
think it’s entirely possible that the
books that were rejected are not the
same as the books that they became we
too often console ourselves with tales
of famous creators whose seminal works
were rejected by fools who failed to see
their genius and we like to think that
these fools are probably cooked kicking
themselves for not seeing the brilliance
in the work but maybe we should rather
be thinking that those rejections were
stepping-stones on the way to the work
reaching its potential if you are
failing it means you’re trying if you
are failing it means you’re succeeding
at trying which is something right the
author Kim Lau talks about this in her
article why you should aim for 100
rejections a year the idea what she
borrowed from another author is this she
says collect rejections set rejection
goals I know someone who shoots for 100
rejections a year because if you work
that hard to get that many rejections
you’re sure to get a few acceptances too
now I asked you what is it that you love
doing that you’re really bad at and this
is a question that we often ask students
applying to our undergraduate program
it’s one of my favorite questions
because I feel like it’s really telling
what do you find joy in despite or
perhaps because you aren’t sissies
succeeding at it what does it say about
you that you are willing to continue to
do something that you’re bad at and
furthermore that you actually enjoy it
for me it’s card games and board games I
love them but I’m terrible at them
sometimes I’ll cajole someone into
playing a board game with me that
they’ve never played before and I’ll
teach them the rules and then lose to
them immediately it’s humiliating I also
love dancing but I have a feeling I look
like Elaine from Seinfeld when I do
it makes me wonder what is the
relationship between complete abandon
exposure and willful failure at one
thing something that doesn’t matter to
me and then returning to the things that
I know I’m good at but that continue to
present a challenge I would argue that
it’s like going to the gym it’s working
off the spare tire of pride if we are
willing to put ourselves out there and
fail on a grand scale we can take a deep
breath and return to the things at which
we are improving we work off the fat and
we increase the muscles we get stronger
and better I am an award-winning
professor and an award-winning author I
am also a reject I am a maker scholar an
artist thinker these compound identities
are important to me because together
they underpin the words when they’re
together
for example that artists don’t think on
an intellectual level or that scholars
don’t understand the struggle of making
art together they work they work in a
way that rejection goes with success the
way that failure is part of the creative
process I am a failure achiever but I am
also a deeply sensitive person who like
many creative people take it very hard
when the work that I put out there gets
a lukewarm response or worse none at all
I feel like I have crafted this special
thing and I’ve sent there to the nest
only to discover that it can’t fly
creativity is highly personal it’s
taking off the clothes of our ideas and
asking someone to love them just as they
are think of poetry and dance and
painting some of these art forms exposes
that our most vulnerable
creativity is often a glimpse into who
we are and what we love best because so
many artists can’t make a living with
their art it is often what people do
outside the confines of their family and
their occupations sometimes they are
only doing it because they love it as
for me when things don’t work out I am
prone to asking why is this so hard
to which Mad Men’s Don Draper would say
you’re good
get better stop asking for things
but we are now in a paradise for those
who want that kind of immediacy and to
circumvent the gatekeepers the people in
positions of creative power who wield
the sword that can anoint you and your
work worthy producers festival committee
members publishers agents granting
bodies traditionally the creative model
was this we worked and schemed and
slogged to get our approval of ex
producer or y publisher but perhaps the
power dynamic has shifted mostly for
young creatives who are coming of age in
a new creative model if you are a
musician or an artist or a journalist or
almost any other creative type you can
get your work out there you needn’t ever
seal your work into an envelope and send
it up to the upper echelons of taste
makers of the world and wait for an
excruciating number of weeks and months
to get the approval from ex publisher or
Y producer you publish your work
yourself in seconds you get feedback
immediately from your peers you can
watch in real time as you are approved
via likes and followers and shares we
become addicted to the immediate
approval social medias means of approval
is often our measure of success great
reviews and shares are currency we are
our culture of prosumers produce your
consumers in a creative democracy where
the cream rises to the top and our peers
or the taste makers there’s no waiting
in this scenario in a matter of moments
a creative maker could discover that
someone in Moose Jaw loves their work
and someone in Brazil thinks they should
never quit their day job we’ve all heard
stories of how Fifty Shades of Grey
started as fan fiction or of musicians
who are discovered on YouTube and
artists on Instagram there is a tendency
in this democratized model to reject the
rejecters to combat why you’re or
someone else’s work wasn’t chosen we
have all been on one side of this
conversation they don’t know what
they’re talking about it’s all about
marketing I’d like to see them try they
probably live in their mother’s basement
our friends our supporters in our own
secret hearts want to believe that our
work was rejected through some flaw
either in the system or the people who
rejected it
we believe that insidious monetary
reasons or nepotism or blindness
prevents people from seeing the
brilliance this is my story I have
written three books the first was picked
up by the first and only publisher I
sent it to the experience was wonderful
it was well received it was well
reviewed and I was signed with an
amazing agent I then wrote two novels
the first was good it was rejected by
all the top-tier publishers then all the
smaller ones and every single time my
agent sent me an email with a rejection
it stung I felt like I had no talent
most of the rejection letters said that
I was a new talent and they looked
forward to seeing more of my work as
though I hadn’t just spent years working
on this thing as though there was more
work spoiler alert there was there is
people told me to self-publish it but I
made the choice not to do that maybe I’m
old school maybe it’s because I came of
creative age during the era of
conventional publishing but mostly it’s
because I truly believe in the talent
and skills of those who make decisions
of what to publish I believe they know
what they’re doing these are the people
who make the books that I love and if I
continue to read and love books that
come out of the publishing industry it’s
because I believe in that system I kept
sending it out I kept getting rejections
many rejection letters begin thank you
for submitting thank you for submitting
it reminds me of being in high school in
dilly-dallying or so over some creative
thing or another and my brother who is
much wiser than I at the ripe old age of
17 said well no one’s going to thank you
for not trying I kept trying I decided
to write another book it was better it
was much better it was so much better
because I had learned an enormous amount
from reading those rejection letters I
learned that the reader saw something
different than what I saw what a gift to
have people with keen eyes and ears hear
and see and read your work I revised the
book many times there have been
countless dress
I added I took away I edited I polished
it to a sheen and then the new novel was
rejected many times I revised it I kept
working in the meantime I submitted it
to an international contest for
unpublished works that feature the inner
lives of women the half the world global
literati award and in the midst of a
summer of rejections when I thought my
agent was going to break up with me I
got a phone call telling me that I had
won the contest
beating out authors in 59 other
countries and winning a staggering
monetary prize they told me while I sat
on a rock up north with my family that
CBC would be interviewing me in half an
hour I had to go down to the lake to get
good reception my life changed in an
instant and still I continued to revise
my book to make it better the rejections
made me set my goals higher when I
started this talk I was still making the
book better and it is large part because
the rejections that beget the revisions
that beget success that beget more
revisions the first draft of this talk
was different than this one
it was worse it got better when I was on
the third draft of this particular talk
on rejection I got a phone call from my
agent she told me that HarperCollins is
going to be publishing my novel I think
I may have deafened her in my absolute
joy on the phone it turns out I’m not
quite as serene in the face of success
as I am in the face of failure it had
not come easily and because of that it
was so much sweeter and I will continue
to refine the book right up until they
tell me that it’s ready we too often
reject the rejecters they should be
thanked
rather than scorned because they had a
role in improving the work think of it
this way your best work could get better
your best work might be what you
consider your worse work in a few years
your highest achievement to date the
thing that took you years and that no
one has yet appreciated might be the
bottom rung of your creative ladder
what a wonderful liberating thought
think of projections as the food you
need the sustenance you require to reach
as well as thinking as fate a failure as
a stepping stone to success think of
failure our success as a stepping stone
to failure that it’s part of the journey
and not the destination I recently was
speaking to someone about the perils of
doing a PhD it is lonely difficult work
this is slog is akin to sending yourself
out on an ice floe is nothing but your
ideas to keep you company I don’t think
I’ve gotten it over it quite myself yet
at any rate the person I was speaking to
told me that they had received some
excellent advice and it is this your PhD
should be the worst work that you do
think of that the highest level of
education you can receive is only the
beginning it’s meant to be hard and it’s
only part of the journey maybe the
beginning it was for me I also recently
had coffee with a former student he is
early in his creative career and wanted
to meet because he was already feeling
like he was besieged with rejections
from granting bodies and festivals and
contests he asked me with a plea in his
voice where will I be in 10 years I told
him that by then he’ll have had many
successes that will seem small to him by
then a huge to him when they happened
that he will continue to get turned down
but that they will make his work better
and that because of them he’ll set his
goals higher than they are now out of
reach they are goals because they aren’t
easy they’re supposed to be hard or the
successes which we get because the
rejections taught us so much wouldn’t be
worth shouting from the rooftops this is
my advice set both reasonable and
impossible goals you might pass by the
reasonable ones on your way to achieving
the impossible consider that any act of
putting your work out there is not just
a chance to succeed but a chance to
learn be open to change listen to
feedback be gracious when you receive it
gratitude should be given not just to
those to deliver the news of our success
but to those who convey our failures
share the work of others absorb it read
listen watch and joy and finally
remember this we’re in this together
many many of our heroes have stories of
tales that they almost gave up they were
filled with despair and lacked
confidence they kept going and so can
you
difficulties rejections they are the
rungs on the ladder to success but we
are foolhardy to step on those who give
them to us on our way up this because of
them that we can climb so high thank you
you
really bad at something that you royally
stink at but that you still enjoy doing
just hang on to that thought we’ll come
back to it later I’m going to talk to
you about rejection I am a reject
I am also and perhaps this is
uncontained and impolite to say but I am
also a high achiever and successful at
what I set out to do I am a writer of
fiction who has written an awful lot and
experienced years of rejection but I am
also a writer of fiction who is
experienced success won an international
award and has recently signed her second
book contract so how do i reconcile
these two things being a failure and
being a success I’m going to tell you
that one depends on the other that
rejection is a key ingredient to
creativity and success but pushing out
work that gets rejected that this makes
you a better creator it’s like making
the first pancake in the batch if all
you ever made was the first pancake and
it was crap people ate it you’d never
know you had a whole batch of great
pancakes in you thank you Rory Gilmore
because if it wasn’t for the work that
was bad there wouldn’t be the work that
was good these are Booker Award winners
Paul Beatty in Marlon James Paul beedis
book was rejected 18 times
Marlon James this book was rejected 78
times 78 times now I don’t know the
inner workings of these books but I
think it’s entirely possible that the
books that were rejected are not the
same as the books that they became we
too often console ourselves with tales
of famous creators whose seminal works
were rejected by fools who failed to see
their genius and we like to think that
these fools are probably cooked kicking
themselves for not seeing the brilliance
in the work but maybe we should rather
be thinking that those rejections were
stepping-stones on the way to the work
reaching its potential if you are
failing it means you’re trying if you
are failing it means you’re succeeding
at trying which is something right the
author Kim Lau talks about this in her
article why you should aim for 100
rejections a year the idea what she
borrowed from another author is this she
says collect rejections set rejection
goals I know someone who shoots for 100
rejections a year because if you work
that hard to get that many rejections
you’re sure to get a few acceptances too
now I asked you what is it that you love
doing that you’re really bad at and this
is a question that we often ask students
applying to our undergraduate program
it’s one of my favorite questions
because I feel like it’s really telling
what do you find joy in despite or
perhaps because you aren’t sissies
succeeding at it what does it say about
you that you are willing to continue to
do something that you’re bad at and
furthermore that you actually enjoy it
for me it’s card games and board games I
love them but I’m terrible at them
sometimes I’ll cajole someone into
playing a board game with me that
they’ve never played before and I’ll
teach them the rules and then lose to
them immediately it’s humiliating I also
love dancing but I have a feeling I look
like Elaine from Seinfeld when I do
it makes me wonder what is the
relationship between complete abandon
exposure and willful failure at one
thing something that doesn’t matter to
me and then returning to the things that
I know I’m good at but that continue to
present a challenge I would argue that
it’s like going to the gym it’s working
off the spare tire of pride if we are
willing to put ourselves out there and
fail on a grand scale we can take a deep
breath and return to the things at which
we are improving we work off the fat and
we increase the muscles we get stronger
and better I am an award-winning
professor and an award-winning author I
am also a reject I am a maker scholar an
artist thinker these compound identities
are important to me because together
they underpin the words when they’re
together
for example that artists don’t think on
an intellectual level or that scholars
don’t understand the struggle of making
art together they work they work in a
way that rejection goes with success the
way that failure is part of the creative
process I am a failure achiever but I am
also a deeply sensitive person who like
many creative people take it very hard
when the work that I put out there gets
a lukewarm response or worse none at all
I feel like I have crafted this special
thing and I’ve sent there to the nest
only to discover that it can’t fly
creativity is highly personal it’s
taking off the clothes of our ideas and
asking someone to love them just as they
are think of poetry and dance and
painting some of these art forms exposes
that our most vulnerable
creativity is often a glimpse into who
we are and what we love best because so
many artists can’t make a living with
their art it is often what people do
outside the confines of their family and
their occupations sometimes they are
only doing it because they love it as
for me when things don’t work out I am
prone to asking why is this so hard
to which Mad Men’s Don Draper would say
you’re good
get better stop asking for things
but we are now in a paradise for those
who want that kind of immediacy and to
circumvent the gatekeepers the people in
positions of creative power who wield
the sword that can anoint you and your
work worthy producers festival committee
members publishers agents granting
bodies traditionally the creative model
was this we worked and schemed and
slogged to get our approval of ex
producer or y publisher but perhaps the
power dynamic has shifted mostly for
young creatives who are coming of age in
a new creative model if you are a
musician or an artist or a journalist or
almost any other creative type you can
get your work out there you needn’t ever
seal your work into an envelope and send
it up to the upper echelons of taste
makers of the world and wait for an
excruciating number of weeks and months
to get the approval from ex publisher or
Y producer you publish your work
yourself in seconds you get feedback
immediately from your peers you can
watch in real time as you are approved
via likes and followers and shares we
become addicted to the immediate
approval social medias means of approval
is often our measure of success great
reviews and shares are currency we are
our culture of prosumers produce your
consumers in a creative democracy where
the cream rises to the top and our peers
or the taste makers there’s no waiting
in this scenario in a matter of moments
a creative maker could discover that
someone in Moose Jaw loves their work
and someone in Brazil thinks they should
never quit their day job we’ve all heard
stories of how Fifty Shades of Grey
started as fan fiction or of musicians
who are discovered on YouTube and
artists on Instagram there is a tendency
in this democratized model to reject the
rejecters to combat why you’re or
someone else’s work wasn’t chosen we
have all been on one side of this
conversation they don’t know what
they’re talking about it’s all about
marketing I’d like to see them try they
probably live in their mother’s basement
our friends our supporters in our own
secret hearts want to believe that our
work was rejected through some flaw
either in the system or the people who
rejected it
we believe that insidious monetary
reasons or nepotism or blindness
prevents people from seeing the
brilliance this is my story I have
written three books the first was picked
up by the first and only publisher I
sent it to the experience was wonderful
it was well received it was well
reviewed and I was signed with an
amazing agent I then wrote two novels
the first was good it was rejected by
all the top-tier publishers then all the
smaller ones and every single time my
agent sent me an email with a rejection
it stung I felt like I had no talent
most of the rejection letters said that
I was a new talent and they looked
forward to seeing more of my work as
though I hadn’t just spent years working
on this thing as though there was more
work spoiler alert there was there is
people told me to self-publish it but I
made the choice not to do that maybe I’m
old school maybe it’s because I came of
creative age during the era of
conventional publishing but mostly it’s
because I truly believe in the talent
and skills of those who make decisions
of what to publish I believe they know
what they’re doing these are the people
who make the books that I love and if I
continue to read and love books that
come out of the publishing industry it’s
because I believe in that system I kept
sending it out I kept getting rejections
many rejection letters begin thank you
for submitting thank you for submitting
it reminds me of being in high school in
dilly-dallying or so over some creative
thing or another and my brother who is
much wiser than I at the ripe old age of
17 said well no one’s going to thank you
for not trying I kept trying I decided
to write another book it was better it
was much better it was so much better
because I had learned an enormous amount
from reading those rejection letters I
learned that the reader saw something
different than what I saw what a gift to
have people with keen eyes and ears hear
and see and read your work I revised the
book many times there have been
countless dress
I added I took away I edited I polished
it to a sheen and then the new novel was
rejected many times I revised it I kept
working in the meantime I submitted it
to an international contest for
unpublished works that feature the inner
lives of women the half the world global
literati award and in the midst of a
summer of rejections when I thought my
agent was going to break up with me I
got a phone call telling me that I had
won the contest
beating out authors in 59 other
countries and winning a staggering
monetary prize they told me while I sat
on a rock up north with my family that
CBC would be interviewing me in half an
hour I had to go down to the lake to get
good reception my life changed in an
instant and still I continued to revise
my book to make it better the rejections
made me set my goals higher when I
started this talk I was still making the
book better and it is large part because
the rejections that beget the revisions
that beget success that beget more
revisions the first draft of this talk
was different than this one
it was worse it got better when I was on
the third draft of this particular talk
on rejection I got a phone call from my
agent she told me that HarperCollins is
going to be publishing my novel I think
I may have deafened her in my absolute
joy on the phone it turns out I’m not
quite as serene in the face of success
as I am in the face of failure it had
not come easily and because of that it
was so much sweeter and I will continue
to refine the book right up until they
tell me that it’s ready we too often
reject the rejecters they should be
thanked
rather than scorned because they had a
role in improving the work think of it
this way your best work could get better
your best work might be what you
consider your worse work in a few years
your highest achievement to date the
thing that took you years and that no
one has yet appreciated might be the
bottom rung of your creative ladder
what a wonderful liberating thought
think of projections as the food you
need the sustenance you require to reach
as well as thinking as fate a failure as
a stepping stone to success think of
failure our success as a stepping stone
to failure that it’s part of the journey
and not the destination I recently was
speaking to someone about the perils of
doing a PhD it is lonely difficult work
this is slog is akin to sending yourself
out on an ice floe is nothing but your
ideas to keep you company I don’t think
I’ve gotten it over it quite myself yet
at any rate the person I was speaking to
told me that they had received some
excellent advice and it is this your PhD
should be the worst work that you do
think of that the highest level of
education you can receive is only the
beginning it’s meant to be hard and it’s
only part of the journey maybe the
beginning it was for me I also recently
had coffee with a former student he is
early in his creative career and wanted
to meet because he was already feeling
like he was besieged with rejections
from granting bodies and festivals and
contests he asked me with a plea in his
voice where will I be in 10 years I told
him that by then he’ll have had many
successes that will seem small to him by
then a huge to him when they happened
that he will continue to get turned down
but that they will make his work better
and that because of them he’ll set his
goals higher than they are now out of
reach they are goals because they aren’t
easy they’re supposed to be hard or the
successes which we get because the
rejections taught us so much wouldn’t be
worth shouting from the rooftops this is
my advice set both reasonable and
impossible goals you might pass by the
reasonable ones on your way to achieving
the impossible consider that any act of
putting your work out there is not just
a chance to succeed but a chance to
learn be open to change listen to
feedback be gracious when you receive it
gratitude should be given not just to
those to deliver the news of our success
but to those who convey our failures
share the work of others absorb it read
listen watch and joy and finally
remember this we’re in this together
many many of our heroes have stories of
tales that they almost gave up they were
filled with despair and lacked
confidence they kept going and so can
you
difficulties rejections they are the
rungs on the ladder to success but we
are foolhardy to step on those who give
them to us on our way up this because of
them that we can climb so high thank you
you
Please follow and like us: