Press "Enter" to skip to content

Design of Everyday Places and Homes Can Heal Wounds | Shelagh McCartney | TEDxRyersonU


every day I get up and I walk through
the large park near my house down the
hill
up the hill I walk across the land then
I walk into our warm home a home I
designed because to me the design of
everyday spaces improves people’s lives
my happy daughter’s run towards me
they’re well nourished and they lots of
fresh food from the shop around the
corner I take my daughters behind the
hand walk out of our home and walk
through our community sometimes they
skip sometimes I skip I do all of this
across the land land that I’ve learned
to recognize as Turtle Island governed
by the dishes one spoon covenant to
peaceably share and care for the
resources around the Great Lakes this
land is the territory of the
Mississauga’s at the Credit River and
through their kindness generosity and
trust we are all here today and I get to
walk the land each morning land that is
so valuable that mineral extractors
stake it real estate developers
speculate on it and we build communities
on it and most importantly it nourishes
us and if we as Canadians cared for the
land that indigenous people shared with
us have we been generous and kind with
them I got to choose where I lived I got
to have a baby less than two kilometers
away from my house with my husband at my
side my family can walk to the hardware
store if we need something to fix in our
home and we’re able to practice our
culture I am the daughter of amazing
parents they taught me that I have many
things in life including that I have
choice what to do with my time what I
pursue for a career who I spend my life
with and that I’m a catalyst in my own
life without these choices I would have
been a very different person today I
would have been a completely different
person I used to make sand castles
cities and imagine that people lived in
them I would imagine those people and I
saw a direct connection between design
and the happy lives that they lived
buildings and the landscapes they are
situated in shape who we are who we meet
and how we interact with each other
space shapes us
so I went to architecture school and in
our church to school I learned that in
order to build for people you must
understand their culture but in this
globalizing world recognition comes to
those who prioritize interesting forms
like crystals or waves while iconic
these examples are not everyday
buildings and they affect so very few so
with all this creativity what more could
we do how could the design of everyday
buildings affect and improve the lives
of many people not just a few when I
graduated I went to South Africa for a
year to build community halls those
communities just didn’t want a box so
the communities made mud bricks by hand
and opposing sides of ANC and IFP work
together just five years after post
apartheid violence and together those
bricks that the community made made that
Hall and filled it with light and awe
with simple materials we invested in
dignity when I returned from South
Africa I sawed up positions in Canadian
government agencies focused on
development and I was told they didn’t
need fancy buildings but I knew that the
design of everyday buildings could
change lives even if I had the skill set
they wanted they were asking for 25
years experience heck I was even 25
years old yet but I knew that there was
a place for an architect because the
buildings that we inhabit shape our
lives our interactions with each other
with ourselves so I set it to become a
licensed architect and I wanted to
design spaces that would fundamentally
change lives and then it’s meant not
just valuing the building so I went to
get my doctorate and urban planning and
design and met this man
Juwan busca he taught me that it was my
responsibility to every single building
or space that I designed to bring social
justice and to ask people for their
vision and to make their future better
he taught me how to do this not just in
the notion that I already knew but the
true how to listen and synthesize and
all the work that I do to hold in my
hands opposing ideas from different
people and to synthesize and make
propose
and then listen and to iterate do it
again iterate listen do it again over
and over he taught me that the design of
cities and communities aren’t even by
definition and that design gives us the
ability to have social justice that
social justice is a very important part
of the city and no one will pay
designers for this work but the
designers have a role in responsibility
to design for social justice the same
way that doctors have a responsibility
to treat people regardless of their
economic status design gives us the
ability to have and create social and
sustainable justice so I worked with
marginalized communities across the
global South and the thread that links
all of my diverse work together is the
importance of how space and place do not
simply exist but they are actively
created by us and then for me it’s about
how I’m passionate exposing where those
created spaces that we’ve made have
profound negative impacts for the
marginalized and then doing something
about it I also wanted to spire others
to feel the same way when I came home to
Canada I realized that indigenous
peoples were marginalized and that many
had declared states of emergencies in
their own communities due to the needs
for clean water shelter and suicide when
I was invited into indigenous
communities I heard their stories I saw
that they were not determining what
their own futures would look like they
were living in communities that didn’t
work where buildings in space have been
used to commit cultural genocide but by
building boxes they were committing this
genocide by stripping the land of the
natural boreal forest to create
communities that look like moonscapes in
fact these created spaces were killing
people overcrowded homes and mold and
these build spaces were directly
contributing to the death due to mental
health problems that was resulting in
ten times the Canadian suicide rate
that’s right a group of psychologists
have proved that housing was responsible
for a large part of the physical and
mental issues in remote communities so
it’s changing the
housing and establishing more of a
positive place could be the key in
reducing the suicide rate in these
communities so I asked myself how is I
going to design everyday buildings homes
in this case and improve people’s lives
especially with indigenous communities
where I got to choose where I lived they
were told where their home would be and
for many of them it’s far away from
their traditional lands they did not
choose to live in these suburban
buildings I got to have a baby less than
two kilometers away from my home if you
live in a remote community in Canada you
could be flown 400 kilometers away from
your community for weeks in advance by
yourself I would have been extremely
lonely and scared to fix our home I can
walk to a hardware store to get all the
pieces that I need and in their case if
they wanted to go to a place that sold
those materials in the wintertime they
would be driving for 15 hours on an ice
road and in the summertime flying for
one and a half hours and paying over
$800 to make that trip that is a very
long and expensive errand to the
hardware store we are able to practice
our culture and I know that as long as
I’m a good parent that my children will
not be taken away from me and in
Canada’s history that has not always
been the case and in many ways still is
not diving deeper into the topic of not
only how spaces choose and shape how we
are do to the ones we immerse ourselves
in but into indigenous homes and
communities if they were allowed to
build a house they were given it or
given a house they had to select from
pre-designed Indian houses designed for
them by Indian Affairs and they were
given an instruction book on how to live
in it they apparently needed
instructions a clear sign they were they
were not part of the process of
designing and selecting their own homes
if a house was culturally appropriate
for you would you need an instruction
book and how to put things away in your
living room they had no way of saying
where they were going to live they were
told reserved boundaries and also what
their home would be like imagine if you
wanted to buy a condo here in this
Canadian city and I told you that even
though you work downtown
your family was here that sorry you need
to move 100 kilometres away and gave no
other reason other than the fact you
happen to have coffee there one day and
when you got to your new place 100
kilometres away your downpayment would
now allow you to live in a nicer place
with a great outdoor deck and I said oh
sorry that place that you want to live
in that has a garden and trees it
doesn’t follow our modesty standards the
house is both too big and you’re not
allowed to have a deck oh and there’s a
bad fire in your mum’s community as well
so your mother your sister her husband
and there are three kids are coming to
live with you you think you need five
bedrooms to house those seven people
sorry
you’re going to have to make it work
with two bedrooms three generations and
one bedroom how cozy Oh and that nice
couch that you love I’ve specified all
of your furniture and it kind of looks
like elementary school for school desks
the only other time in history when a
house and all of its furniture it was
provided for people is when you’re in
jail and then when you open that box
full of that furniture all of the screws
are missing and now you remember how far
away that hardware store is right
indigenous people had been moved off
their lands moving them out of the way
of companies that wanted the resources
in the land beneath them and to
assimilate them into the dominant
mainstream culture reserves were built
to be temporary and well documented plan
by the Canadian government was that all
indigenous people would move south and
leave their culture behind reserves were
built to be suburban wastelands to
prepare indigenous peoples to live
suburban lives in houses that reorder
domestic life and cultural practices
it’s time for a paradigm shift in policy
planning and architecture and we’re
standing forward looking at it reserves
that once acted as fences to keep
indigenous people out of the way of
extraction have now become fences to
keep globalization out and culture in
indigenous people are practicing their
culture or not however they want to this
is very important to myself and many of
the communities I have partnered with
over the last two decades that they want
to have choice to be how they want to be
through the government support of
Canada’s Truth and Reconciliation
Commission and their endorsement of the
United Nations declaration on the rights
of indigenous people Canadian
governments are recognizing that we as
in all Canadians are to share the
resources and wealth of Turtle Island
instead of reconciliation I like to
refer to this as reconciliation because
doing nothing is a policy that has
existed for far too long and we need
action to me sharing is to truly share
to truly partner by letting indigenous
voices lead and not retaining levers of
control over resources it is no longer
okay to ask oh you must be decide but
only from within these parameters that’s
not partnership that’s not even not even
consultation these communities have
waited 10 to 15 years for any new homes
10 to 15 years for any new homes it is
not really letting them decide to be
self determinate if you control the
funding the type of houses to be built
the federal fiscal year deadlines that
are artificially controlled the access
to resources and make an official
timeline indigenous communities need to
be able to make their own destiny and
there is a need to decolonize the
systems that we’re working within and
the houses within them essentially we
need to let indigenous communities
design their own destiny its 2017 now
and we’re supposed to be commemorating
150 years of Canada but a lot has
happened over the last 150 years that
were not very proud of so what better
time to think that along the way how we
can walk alongside in just indigenous
communities civic discussion has begun
accompanying by new federal government
looking to begin a new relationship with
indigenous peoples planning and design
need to be leaders in the shift’
indigenous communities are in crisis
their families are the housing system
the federal planning policies have not
allowed for the provision of adequate
nor appropriate homes we need to rethink
housing do
colonizing the houses and the system to
make them more community-focused so why
are houses and the spaces around them so
important because the design of everyday
buildings improves lives the link
between mental and physical health and
housing is widely recognized and that
the housing crisis facing Canada’s
indigenous populations is the physical
manifestation of Canada’s assimilative
policies the ability to live well and in
a community designed with other
community members should not be the
privilege of some Canadians but for all
indigenous people should get the choice
of where and how they want to live to
choose the spaces that will shape them
their children and three generations
forward in one of my community visits
the chief told me how sad she was that I
was there and that she could not wait
for the day that I left she was sad
because she had caught needed to call
experts to speak to the youth within her
community in an effort to solve the
housing and suicide crisis in her
community decolonizing planning is about
ensuring that in the future these
decisions will be able to come from
within that design principles and
capacity is instilled and nurtured in
youth families and children so that
sorry continuing the cultural practices
handed down through generations of
elders so that one day I won’t be there
as an expert but as a granddaughter that
in houses and designs they create they
are theirs they build them they maintain
them and they will grow well in them
it’s important to recognize that the
time for assimilation is passed reserves
are growing and growing rapidly it’s
time for a paradigm shift reserves are
here to stay the design of communities
matters it will save lives but how do we
get there how do we get good design I
may be a white settler with formal
degrees but I’m not done learning as I
walk alongside indigenous communities
that we partner with we listen learn and
share with each other and their fight
becomes mine
and really it’s the fight of all
Canadians to do this we still spend time
building long-term relationships with
community leaders elders and youth
reimagining their community together
many of you are thinking
isn’t that just consultation or duty to
consult no it’s not
it goes beyond a presentation in front
of a big group with little to no
feedback or a vote between two different
options instead it’s about asking
questions that you don’t know the answer
to building models together listening to
stories of important values it’s about
making reimagining your community a fun
and safe place a conversation that
welcomes all voices and looks to build
understanding across different views not
only in one meeting or in one day it’s
true partnership that there’s no sole
contributors and no sole beneficiaries
that everyone gives and takes learns and
shares together investing in dignity in
the design process during the building
and at every opportunity to source
locally higher locally higher diversity
and train so that you are no longer
needed people tend to think of design as
an outcome but it’s the process without
that process you cannot achieve the
outcome built form alone is not the
answer the solution cannot just appear
it has to come from within the community
especially here where bill form has been
used as a tool of assimilation
destroying the culture that we now look
to support because design matters
because families will feel differently
in their homes their children will be
proud of themselves and their community
and their culture the culture we once
tried to erase will once again have a
proud place in the Canada that I want to
be part of housing will help end the
suicide crisis that has existed for far
too long and close the the well-being
gap that has grown far too wide to do
this we as Canadians need to demand
better of our decision-makers our
funders and ourselves we enjoy a very
high standard of living in this country
increasingly based upon the resources
that we extract out of indigenous land
yet as I often remind myself be
conscious of your worldview
and do not assume that you have all of
the answers but instead listen listen
for indigenous voices and allow them to
lead remember that your education comes
from a particular worldview and that
it’s not the only one in your work
remember that the final product alone is
not the solution so take a risk be
willing to walk into the boardroom and
not have the answer have questions make
it safe for make it a safe place for all
ideas recognize that the process of
design that’s going to help me and
partnering with indigenous communities
that I work to assist them in creating
their future can guide you in the work
that you do and give up on being right
all of the time listen learn and share
build stronger communities because
design matters by investing in value
investing in dignity design can bring
social justice and heal communities as
Canadians you cannot decolonize the
building it’s the process that we need
to decolonize and then get out of the
way and let them decide for themselves
I believe the design needs to be focused
on the process of listening and sharing
through partnership and that that will
help us positively shape the future of
our country it’s a choice they need to
build houses not just more houses but
appropriate ones we need to walk
alongside communities through the design
process and not just create an outcome
it’s a choice but design can truly
improve people’s lives
thank you
you
Please follow and like us: