Press "Enter" to skip to content

Lake Superior’s Future | Nancy Langston | TEDxNMU


twenty-one years ago when I first came
to Lake Superior
I went kayaking at the Apostle Islands
National Lakeshore and I was on this
really big lake in this really tiny boat
and I thought oh my god this is the
biggest lake in the world and I’m in the
smallest boat in the world and I am
terrified this is pretty scary and I was
right about all those things it is the
biggest freshwater lake in the world and
it’s one of the scariest lakes in the
world but my next thought boy this Lake
is so pristine and so remote and I was
dead wrong about both those things this
Lake may be remote for many big cities
but it is at the absolute core of
Anishinaabe homelands and it has been
for many many generations its waters are
intimately connected to distant places
because atmospheric currents bring
chemicals from China’s building boom
they bring pesticides from Russian and
African fields what is most global
building booms global markets industrial
farming practices become as local as
possible as they accumulate within the
fish that swim beneath our shores and in
the waters that we drink and as they
gather on the plates that we eat and
right now we are facing one of the
biggest challenges of our lifetime and
that’s the challenge of climate change
climate change is actually causing our
lake right here to warm faster than
possibly any other large lake on earth I
have a friend who’s a really somber
scientist john burns and he told me
Nancy the climate change scenarios
predicted for like superior utterly
boggle the mind I mean that’s not how
scientists talk right underly boggle the
mind what he told me was that we face
the risk of a migrating climate if we
don’t control our emissions what that
means is by the end of the century we
could basically become Oh
Oklahoma by August and I’m sure Oklahoma
is a wonderful place but I want to live
in the North Woods not Oklahoma but what
I’m here to tell you is that there’s
real reason for hope and paying
attention to the story of Lake
Superior’s past which is not a story of
pristine untouched landscapes but a
story of resilience and recovery offers
us hope and concrete strategies for a
resilient future so after I fell in love
with kayaking and got over a little bit
of that fear I bought a tiny little
cabin ten feet by 20 feet right outside
of the Apostle Islands and I didn’t put
in running water or anything because I
figured with plenty of water right in
front of me who needs running water but
each morning I go five months of the
year and sit out there with my cup of
coffee and this bird comes for a visit a
pileated woodpecker and if I’m lucky the
next bird that comes down is a bald
eagle swooping from the winter’s ice
pack swings down and grabs a lake trout
to feed the chicks in the nest just down
the lake many days eight young floater
male loons swim by practicing their
calls and it turns out loons need a lot
of practice before they sound like the
loons of our dreams and then if I’m
really lucky we can hear at night the
howls of the wolves that are Denning in
the county forest just across the road
and you know many days bears come by and
they are so common now they become a
pest and what’s really cool about all
these species is that nobody expected
any of these critters to make it here
fifty years ago when I was a kid none of
these species were around they had all
almost gone extinct and people thought
that’s the way it would be we’d had a
century of the fur trade which pulled
out the beaver that had helped create
our watersheds and our ecosystems then
we had some of the world’s most intense
mining followed by deforestation faster
and more intense than any the world has
ever known that was followed by failed
farming attempts an erosion like this
picture of Wisconsin that devastated
both
streams the fisheries and the many human
cultures that depended on those
fisheries and after the 20th century
began things actually got a little worse
for a while there many communities
around the lake who hoped to build jobs
for people who’d lost their jobs from
the failure of the early industries
encouraged pulp mills to cut the last of
the remaining trees and those pulp mills
brought jobs for a little while but they
were allowed to pour their effluent
their waste products
right into our watersheds and those
chemicals accumulated in the fish that
we now eat and that combined with
distant chemicals from the new post
world to world war ii chemical boom DDT
PCBs all the ones you’ve heard of all
this began to accumulate in our lake so
by the 1960s when I was a little kid the
lake was at a tipping point many people
thought we were about to become another
Lake Erie and it was doomed for us so
the story that I think we need to learn
is a story of amazing recovery we didn’t
become a collapsed Great Lake instead of
only seeing these kind of stumps when we
go to our parks beautiful as they are we
see resilient young healthy growing
forest with cores of old growth we see
fish like this the lake trout are
amazing this is one of Conservation
great success stories lake trout almost
went extinct because of invasive sea
lamprey and habitat loss and now they
spawn abundantly in the lake again which
is so amazing and you know it’s not a
complete recovery the forests are
different women have to worry about how
much lake trout it’s safe to eat when
they’re pregnant we have a new mining
boom underway driven not by local
demands but instead by Asian demands
largely but those jobs that might be
brought about by the new mines each
community has to balance when the
possibility of toxic pollution so
everything isn’t perfect but there’s
still an incredible story of resilience
and hope that can guide us
in the future as we face this new
challenge of climate change and climate
change is a particular importance for
lots of reasons it can threaten our
health you can threaten our resilience
but one of the things that also does so
many of the toxic chemicals from around
the world gathered in Lake Superior and
accumulated here and they were buried in
the sediments and in the soil so they
became relatively safe but now with
climate change we have new storms
stirring up sediments we have new
invasive species like zebra mussels and
quagga mussels in the lower Great Lakes
that love warming water and they also
recirculate these contaminants in the
water and so the stories of the past may
become our future again unless we figure
out how to create a more resilient
future you know why does it matter
I had a friend asked me in New York City
it’s like Lake Superior who cares and I
said you should care right we’re 12% of
the world’s fresh water right out that
door
I mean that’s amazing so the head of a
basin that contains 20% of the world’s
fresh water now Mark Twain quite a while
ago said Bourbons for drinkin waters for
fighting over and what we don’t want the
world to do is to fight over our water
we have a resource that will be of
incredible importance in the future
this Basin alone is 90 percent of the
America’s fresh water surface water so
it really matters what we do right here
because we’re at the head of a basin
because we’re so far to the north and
still a relatively cold lake
contaminants actually gather in this
water we have what’s called a really
long retention time much of the year
we’re still covered by ice right and
what that means is a drop of water that
falls in the lake stays for a really
long time we only have one little outlet
at the sue Saint Marie someone averaged
a drop of water sticks around for nearly
two centuries a hundred and ninety-one
years compared to Lake Erie which is
just a
matter of months what that means is that
a contaminant can stay almost as long so
whatever we do has repercussions for the
rest of the Great Lakes and the world
what this also mean is contaminants such
as toxaphene which is kind of a
wonderfully named chemical back in the
days when they named things honestly
right so toxaphene was banned three
decades ago and it used to be used just
on cotton we don’t have a lot of cotton
around here right it’s still too cold
for cotton but toxaphene is rising
really quickly and our Lake Superior
fish even though the chemical hasn’t
been used in the US for decades and
that’s partly because it’s still being
illegally used in Russia and Africa and
it’s partly because the old chemicals
every time they plow the soil in
Mississippi and Alabama those chemicals
bounce up into the air like grasshoppers
get rained down onto a lake the
evaporation bounces up rains down and
then when it hits our lake it’s cold and
it acts like a big sponge a big sink it
sticks around we’ve become a sponge for
many of the world’s contaminants the
interesting thing though is people
realized this was happening a long time
ago
it wasn’t like everybody sat around and
said oh great let’s just pollute all we
want jobs are all we care about starting
in the beginning of the 20th century a
lot of people in our communities right
here said you know what we don’t want to
become the world’s toxic dump we want
jobs but we also want water for the
future what can we do about that they
saw this pulp mill pollution and said
that’s not what we want for our children
so they came up with two really
important ideas one that dilution is the
solution to pollution that didn’t work
so well basically they thought the lake
is this huge bathtub you stick a drop of
poison and it just vanishes like water
when you pull the plug in the bathtub
but the second key idea was really
powerful I haven’t heard of this it’s
called the simile of capacity and what
that means is a recognition that humans
are part of natural
ecosystems it recognizes that in healthy
watersheds healthy forests say a deer
goes out and poos in the woods the
entire ecosystem isn’t following apart
for the rest of history natural
ecosystems can break that down can
assimilate that bacteria healthy
ecosystems can break down our pollution
and so early planner said we are part of
natural systems and we can just figure
out how much the landscapes can
assimilate but what they didn’t realize
at the time was at the same time they
were pouring new pollution into the
waters they were ripping apart the
watershed connections that formed the
basis of our watersheds ability to break
down pollution
you know those beaver they pulled out of
the system it turned out those beaver
created wetlands which absorb carbon
absorb pollution and broke it down
though sparsh they chopped down so
quickly though spars were grabbing
pollution and carbon from the air
pulling it down into the roots and
holding onto it in the soil so when they
made those huge landscape
transformations just when they most
needed the ability of our landscapes to
heal they pulled it apart and scientists
such as Rachel Carson began to recognize
this right in the mid 1950s there’d been
a bunch of nuclear testing right after
the war those data were classified the
military wouldn’t let anybody see and in
1954 it was Declassified Carson and a
lot of other scientists went out
thinking that near the Pacific Island
should see really high levels of
contamination of radiation and then they
went in measured in the Arctic the Sami
people the Alaskan people the reindeer
and thought there won’t be any
contamination there but they found the
opposite in the Arctic and in Lake
Superior they found really high
concentrations of these radioactive
isotopes so it turned out distance
wasn’t protecting us that
bioaccumulation and biomagnification
meant these chemicals and contaminants
were working their way up the food chain
until they ended up in us and Carson
said pay attention and to
a woman looked at one of the biggest
developments that had just been approved
in our watershed the reserve mine
processing plant over in Minnesota it
was stumping 400 million tons of waste
products from taconite a form of iron
mining and processing directly into Lake
Superior and the state had said big
bathtub it’ll be fine they’ll break it
down it’s all natural and these two
women said you know what we just read
Rachel Carson they read Rachel Carson
thought she’s a women we’re women we can
do this so they stepped up and said you
know what we don’t think that’s such a
great idea dumping all this stuff in the
water and they talked to some scientists
who said you know what kind of fibers
those are that’s what we call asbestos
in those tailings and so Arlene and
Verna went to the International Joint
Commission in Canada and said do you
know they’re dumping asbestos in our
drinking water just upstream of Duluth
and the scientists said oh don’t worry
about it your housewives what do you
know and so verna and Arlene instead of
shutting up they took on the world’s
second biggest mining company they went
and they talked to scientists they
talked to union members they talked to
tribal councils they talked to fishermen
they talked to the brand-new EPA and
they never gave up they pushed and
pushed and eventually they shut down
that processing facility they didn’t
destroy the jobs they made them dispose
of their waste in clean inland
facilities and so what can we learn from
these incredible lessons three key
things one never give up hope Arlene and
Verna didn’t the second key lesson is
Arlene and Verna persevered by talking
across boundaries you know housewives
talking to scientists Canadians talking
to Americans tribal members talking to
commercial fishermen unions getting
involved Republicans talking to
Democrats and they realize that for all
the things that divided them what
brought them together was their love for
the lake and the third biggest lesson is
what gives us hope what we need to
restore are those ecosystem connections
the healthy wetlands the healthy water
the healthy farce because fundamentally
Carson Verna and Arlene were right we
are all in this together
thank you [Applause]
Please follow and like us: