Press "Enter" to skip to content

IQ The Educational Elephant in the Room | Richard Summers | TEDxBrighton


so my clearest memories of primary

school and you can guess from the title

is we’re going to talk about my clearest

memories are of sexual molestation

physical violence and emotional cruelty

and for me I always look back when I

talk to my peers have helped my

schooling and I feel that what I

experienced was closer to a Dickens

novel than what most people do it listen

far obviously inside me I had a mantra

if only I was stronger

if only I was smarter and that kind of

that mantra although it’s very unstable

and it’s very misguided obviously what

happened to me had nothing to do about

being strong or by about being smart and

it also has nothing about being happy

which is what I then dedicated my life

to is how do I help other children other

people get stronger and smarter so they

can be happier but what I find

interesting is I’m luckily or wisely I

don’t really know how it happened I made

my life about trying to achieve that for

other people and even though I had this

sort of misguided sense of the world

where I was trying to go it put me on

this amazing journey which has been

incredibly diverse and I hope it’s a

unique perspective on the world and it’s

taken in all sorts of areas so I’m a

scientist I’m a entrepreneur I’ve been

an educator and yes I’ve even worked as

a martial artist and an anti-terrorism

trainer I’ve got to work with Stephen

Hawking which was a great privilege when

I was at Cambridge I have traveled the

world and worked with all sorts of elite

forces and tried to save lives there but

I’ve also traveled to Libya and seen

firsthand what that was like when

Colonel Qaddafi was in power so I’ve

been into a number of places and where

that’s led me now is is I now run a

company I spend most of my days running

a company what we do is roll back the

great mysteries of how the brain works

and we do in a way that you wouldn’t

imagine you’d think that was some sort

of education business and it’s not we

work in digital marketing what we do is

we map and measure and respond to the

cognitive processes that consumers go

through as they interact with brands but

interestingly

we get to work with as many as 26

million people in a day and it’s it’s

kind of like a lab on a scale that’s

utterly unprecedented and it gives me

the chance to it’s kind of a dream come

true to look into the mysteries that

kind of always perplexed me before I got

into this area because they just didn’t

have enough information or data to solve

them and what I want to talk about today

is what I call the elephant in the room

with education it’s something that has

been dear to my heart for well I mean

since the beginning but this particular

topic for at least 10 years and what I

think is true is that there’s a problem

at the heart of education that we all

know we know that although it works for

some for many it crushes creativity and

it destroys their confidence and the

reason for that or one of the reasons I

believe is that about 30 years ago

essentially IQ was trying to tell us

something we didn’t want to listen we

didn’t want to hear what it was trying

to tell us because it seems so

unpalatable and so because we wanted

lives to be better for our kids we kind

of ignored it we didn’t know you might

not know directly that’s what you did

but that’s what happened and ever since

then we’ve been kind of making mistake

after mistake in education what I want

to do today is to take you on a journey

I want to turn the world upside down I

want to talk go straight into that

uncomfortable place with what IQ is

telling us but then to show you that if

you’ve got the courage to sit with that

to not try and deny it but also to not

accept it straight away there’s a

journey through that and interesting or

I found is that journey goes back to

what we all know is true what we really

want for our kids and what we know is

right for if you like for education so I

suppose the best place to start is well

what is IQ and it’s obviously a very

well-known thing it is basic your

general intelligence your ability to

solve problems the average is a hundred

most people range from 85 to 115 and

there’s the odd genius out there one in

a million that’s over 170 and so what

does IQ why is it so important because

it’s the most predictive psychometric

that’s ever been discovered it strongly

predicts your peak income for instance

it even predicts how likely you are to

get divorced and Moe

significantly it is incredibly strongly

correlated with your academic

performance so what’s the problem the

problem is really simple IQ is basically

inherited how do we know that well we

knew that 30 years ago by studying what

happens to twins for instance when

they’re adopted and brought up in

different families obviously if they’re

brought up in the same family by

comparing it and by doing that they

created studies that could show which

bits of your IQ came from your genes

which bits came from your family from

your parents putting input in and which

bit came from your school essentially

and the most interesting of those I find

is this one which was a fantastic study

that looked at a group of I think it was

250 children roughly through their

lifetime and what I find the most scary

thing about this is if you look at the

age of five as a parent you’re

contributing hugely maybe not the

dominant thing to you almost as equally

to to their genes in terms of their IQ

but the message here if you look at the

chart sort of goes downwards it’s not

just that as the child approaches 12

we’re no longer in putting into their IQ

it’s that our input has been completely

wiped out now the thing is with IQ is

you don’t need infinite amounts of it in

fact by the time you reach 115 points

you can pretty much do anything you want

so IQ is really predictive between 85

and 105 where most of us fit the problem

is yes if we could raise IQ on average

in education by 15 points then lives

would be transformed but science is

telling us you can only raise it by

about four points and reality is saying

you’re not even doing that so what do I

mean by reality one of the things we do

with schools is we rank them through SAT

tests the standardized academic tests

they correlate very well with IQ and we

use that as somehow a way of

benchmarking how good a school is but

what we’re actually doing is

benchmarking how smart the children were

always destined to be in terms of IQ

when they entered the school and when

they left the school it’s all the same

now if we take that away if we just look

at what’s the difference between when

the children enter the school and when

they leave the school we get a radically

different picture between the bottom two

percent of schools and

top 2% of schools there is only a six

and a half percent swing in performance

now I don’t know if that sounds

significant it should be a hundred

percent it should be two hundred percent

it should be massive but it isn’t it’s

tiny and that’s practically saying

something that is very difficult to hear

we’re born with a certain amount of IQ

or destined to have a certain amount of

IQ that determines a certain amount of

factors one of those is how well you’re

going to do at school and there is

nothing you can do from the day that

you’re born to the day you finish school

to change that very much now there’ll

always be exceptions to that rule but

I’m talking about the rule of the

average and yet we’re using that to

measure the performance of Education so

that’s what I mean by the dark place the

place that was unpalatable and we didn’t

want to go now what’s interesting to me

as a neuroscientist is it’s the last

thing I would ever expect to be true of

the human brain that there would be this

one parameter this one thing that could

measure your intelligence there’s a sort

of a single number and I don’t mean that

from kind of my heart place that I look

around me and there’s such diversity in

the world of people that’s true too but

the brain isn’t really built in a way

that you’d think that would work so just

as a starting point I just want to bring

across the power of the brain so when I

started in computers the be the most

powerful computer world is a Cray – it’s

shown up there at the moment it was this

massive thing at least fill the stage

probably more it was so powerful it had

to have liquid nitrogen to cool its

cause and it’s roughly the power of the

iPhone 6 in your pocket today right now

if the iPhone 6 is a walking pace in

terms of computers then it would take

you about a year to walk from here to

Sydney as you’ll foot touch the pavement

on your first step your brain would go

around the world 200,000 times that’s

the difference between your iPhone 6 and

what you’re carrying in your head right

now it’s absolutely vast but even more

interestingly it’s so diverse it’s

nothing it’s the last thing you would

expect from what I just told you you’re

not one computer you’re a hundred

billion computers and in fact the

intelligence that you are is encoded in

a hundred trillion connections between

those computers are those connections

built from your genes no they’re not

they’re built on a user or lose it

principle in fact your brain goes

through the equivalent of a trillion

years of human evolution

over its lifetime it’s also a very it’s

got lots of little localized clusters of

things that work so there’s a little bit

that deals with grammar and there’s a

little bit that deals with recognizing

faces and there are hundreds of these

centers across the brain so when you

look at it you wouldn’t think that there

would be a single measure of

intelligence you’d think that where

there would be thousands and they would

be based on the environment not on

genetics now by the work that I’ve done

and simply the number of people we’ve

been able to unlock this a little bit

further and then to understand other

studies that have been there about kind

of other properties that people have and

in fact what we’ve discovering what

we’re working with is they’re actually

three sorts of intelligence one is

abstraction intelligence what we’ve been

talking about the ability to layer

abstract ideas IQ problem-solving then

there’s artists and our ability to learn

new things whether that’s chess music

you know do all those skills that we can

pick up and then complex the

intelligence which is the last thing you

expect it to mean if it’s social it’s

more like an emotional intelligence and

if it’s kind of pointed inwards it’s an

aesthetic intelligence so like I said

not quite what you might expect and

although you can’t study them exactly

we’ve worked out a huge amount about

these and being able to relate them to

various functions and studies around the

brain now the first thing I cover off is

how on earth can i Q be singular and the

best way I can explain that to you is

that although the IQ test it’s

misunderstood it’s very very test it’s

got verbal reasoning new memory skills

spatial awareness it works using your

conscious mind all the time and by doing

that there’s a feature it’s very hard to

define conscious but there’s a feature

you can define quite easily and that’s

can be seen in these pictures if you

look at the pictures you can either see

one version or the other your mind can

flip between the two but seeing both at

the same time it’s pretty much

impossible your conscious brain brings

the world into a single scene it’s the

most amazing thing our brain does it’s

done by billions of connections bringing

your whole neocortex your upper brain

into synchrony in about half a second

and IQ has to do with the performance of

that system which is why it’s a single

measure now let’s go to something else

art design intelligence the clearest bit

of information I give you about that is

when scientists studied what I call

skill athletes chess players muse

Editions and they look to the difference

between the world’s best and the

professionals and sort of the people in

the middle they found one consistent

thing that linked them together and that

was the number of hours of practice the

people at the top about 20,000 the

people who are just kind of on the

professionals out of 5,000 everyone else

in between what’s interesting is we’ve

gone from having something that’s

completely almost inherited to something

that’s completely based on our behavior

and choices now the next thing

complexity intelligence is very hard to

study whether that’s aesthetic or social

or emotional but what we have discovered

by studying a number of these kind of

thousands of factors that make it up is

it is related to your personality

development and what I’m showing on the

screen is is called the big five it’s

your fundamental package kind of set of

traits in personality and what you

should be able to see here is really

interesting that yes you do inherit it

to an extent but the pivotal part of

this that you that isn’t inherited comes

from your school life so what does that

mean for education what should we be

doing and I just want to propose

something isn’t really groundbreaking

that we should be firstly focusing on

what we can actually change what we can

actually empower people to do and not on

a very narrow perspective of something

that’s hard to change or we can make a

little difference in so if we look at

education through that principle we see

two things will actually shine out the

top two things on that list the first is

to focus on artisan intelligence what

does that mean it means understanding

that everybody’s got a different brain

that they’re actually on a creative

journey from you know the moment they’re

kind of they’re born all the way through

their lives working out what matters to

them how they work and how they can use

themselves to get what matters to them

and a lot of people think oh if you’re

talking about our talent agents you’re

talking about just you know bit of

design technology and will you be an

apprentice and are you going to go into

carpentry but I’m not I mean music and

martial arts are more pure but actually

what we’re talking about is inspiring

kids to practice it could be BMX riding

it could be tiddlywinks it really

couldn’t matter less because what

they’re doing is discovering how they

work how to get themselves to be better

at something and that’s immensely

important that’s something that 100%

that we can change and the second factor

which I think is utterly

critical is that schools play this

pivotal role in terms of our personality

development and there is the science

there to measure whether they’re doing a

good job now personality is very

individual I’m not suggesting we’re all

trying to conform people like SAT tests

to one thing but think about personality

a different way if you’ve been nourished

you’ve had good loving experiences your

personality is kind of well-rounded and

smooth and it’s comfortable with itself

and if you haven’t it’s jagged and

they’re kind of a little off set and

uncomfortable it’s not about the sort of

general space it it feels it’s about

it’s sort of shape and quality but we

can measure that can you imagine a

school system where we ranked schools by

measuring the personality development of

the children within them and how well

they were supporting each teacher in

each classroom each year each school was

doing that it would be a radically

different process right at the bottom

you’ll see I put abstract intelligence

because that’s about discovering if

you’ve got those abilities and then

taking them further but it’s not a place

of this is central I think what we need

to do is really ask the question what

matters and I think we do know what

matters the problem is by making

everything about SAT scores by making it

all about peeking comes or a limited

amount of professional development we

focus on IQ and we disenfranchise a lot

of kids by doing it but if we ask

ourselves what we want for our kids I’ve

got five of them I couldn’t give a stuff

how much they earn in their lives and I

don’t care if they turn into doctors or

lawyers but what I care about is are

they happy are they at current do they

contribute to the world around them can

they form great relationships and in

fact economically I haven’t got time to

go into here this is a great you knows a

lot of evidence there that actually what

you’re looking at with education

performance isn’t a full predictor of

that so really what I wanted to say was

by looking at that idea of IQ and by

going through it we come to a completely

different place with it with education

and by going somewhere dark and having

the courage to face it you come through

to something kind of a different vision

and what I hope now is here we have

teachers with what they’re trying to

achieve in the skills they have and

actually they can do this job we have

governments that need to measure it and

they’ve been at war for twenty thirty

years with kids in the middle and we

actually have the technology to overcome

that war and to end that fight

thank you [Applause]

Please follow and like us: