Press "Enter" to skip to content

Inaccuracy in self-knowledge assessments impacts our decisions | Creed Tumlison | TEDxDicksonStreet


[Music]
I’d like to start with a quote from
Donald Rumsfeld it was in response to a
reporter’s question regarding the war in
Iraq there are known knowns there are
things we know we know we also know
there are known unknowns that is to say
we know there are some things we do not
know but there are also unknown unknowns
the ones we don’t know we don’t know so
this statement sounds fairly convoluted
difficult to follow and Roosevelt was
made fun of quite a bit after making
this statement but I think there’s
actually quite a bit of truth in this
statement that impacts how you make
decisions in our daily lives and in
society as a whole and the quality of
those decisions when we talk about
knowledge we think about actual
knowledge levels we think about things
like facts we think about do we know the
state capitals do we know who our
senator is do we know how to do long
division that kind of thing we also
think about skills do we know how to
change a tire do we know how to bake do
we know how to drive a standard
that kind of thing so we have these two
kind of generally thought of ways of
thinking about knowledge facts and
skills and when we think about that in
terms of solving our problems in our
daily lives or in public policy we come
up with easy solutions think about
things like health care whether it’s
vaccinations cancer screenings that kind
of thing we think if we just educate
people more provide them with more
information they’ll make better
decisions have better outcomes
individually and then better outcomes at
the societal level as a whole but as we
can see with things like Surgeon
General’s warnings we don’t always get
those outcomes that we expect from
educating individuals because when we
think about these think about knowledge
in this way of actual knowledge we
ignore what people think they know
ultimately what people think they know
is the actual driver of our behaviors
it’s not our actual knowledge that leads
us to choose to do something or support
a politician or anything like that it’s
what we think we know so when we have
these two kind of ways of thinking about
knowledge actual knowledge and our own
perceived knowledge levels we can come
up with some conditions so thinking
about actual knowledge it operates on a
continuum we can know nothing about a
topic or know everything about a topic
or anywhere in between receive knowledge
is the same way we can think we know
nothing about a topic or think we know
everything about a topic or anywhere in
between
you put these cut two together we can
come up with some conditions we can
accurately assess our knowledge by not
thinking that we know that much and
being correct we can also accurately
assess our knowledge by thinking we know
a lot about a topic and be correct we
don’t typically have problems with these
these are kind of the ideal right
however when we misidentifying our own
knowledge levels we can run into some
problems there’s this idea of knowledge
humility where we underestimate our
actual knowledge levels we don’t think
we know that much but we actually know
more on the flip side we have this idea
of knowledge hubris where we think we
know a lot about a topic but we actually
don’t know that much so together we had
this idea of knowledge congruence how
congruent is our actual knowledge level
with our perceived knowledge levels so
what is this matter a lot of outcomes
are associated with this in congruence
for example how we perceive risk is
important there was a study done that
looked at junior high and senior high
girls and their knowledge on safe sex
practices and the study found that the
more that the girls thought that they
knew about safe sex practices the more
likely they were to become pregnant over
the next year so exactly the opposite
outcome that you would expect from
knowing a lot about safe sex practices
so what happens here is that when we
overestimate our knowledge levels we
actually don’t see the risks that are
available
or we think that we are able incapable
of handling those risks leading to more
risky behaviors negative outcomes there
on the flip side of that when we
underestimate our knowledge levels we
end up seeing risk that may not exist we
we don’t know in how much we actually
know and we make up risk and in turn
don’t go through behaviors or the
decision-making process in the
appropriate way there
information-seeking is also very
different depending on how we assess our
knowledge we all think think about
looking at purchasing a new vehicle or a
new television and wanting to get
information we all look at expert
reviews that kind of thing but what
happens when we overestimate our
knowledge levels we ignore our friends
family acquaintances because we assume
that we know more than they do so we
completely leave a source of information
out on the flip side when we
underestimate our knowledge levels we we
look to much we don’t recognize what we
know and the ability that we already
have to make a decision and spend more
time than necessary looking for
information to help guide us in our
decision making a lot of those same
lines we have issues with learning when
we overestimate our knowledge levels
learning becomes a challenge because we
don’t see the need to do it right we
already assume that we know a lot about
the topic when we hear information that
conflicts with what we already think who
we know we reject it we prevent
ourselves from learning on the flip side
when we underestimate our knowledge
levels we try to learn more than we need
to we and we end up potentially
confusing ourselves even more actually
decreasing what we know on the specific
topic and then finally our attitudes and
perceptions are affected by this
knowledge congruence or in congruence
when we overestimate our knowledge
levels we end up with more extreme
positions not only are these positions
often more extreme but they’re less
malleable we get stuck we have very
rigid attitudes and view
on whatever the issue is on the flip
side when we underestimate our knowledge
levels we by default go to a more
moderate position whether that’s
appropriate or not not only do we go to
a more moderate position and have more
moderate attitudes
those attitudes are very malleable a
little bit of information can move this
one way or the other whether it should
or not so with this in mind how do we
get there we can see that the knowledge
congruence in impacts our
decision-making and ultimately our
outcomes so what leads to this here I’d
like to share a story a few years ago I
was talking to someone who worked as a
data analyst and in this conversation he
mentioned that he didn’t believe in
climate change because he hadn’t seen
any data that supported it so because of
his position I was curious and I asked
what data have you looked at and after a
little bit of back-and-forth he admitted
well I haven’t actually looked at any
data so he came to this conclusion about
climate change based on the information
or based on his skill set we didn’t
actually use it to decide what he
thought there are at least a couple of
things going on here a little bit of
background his values in ideology would
not allow him to accept the idea that
climate change was real it just it
wouldn’t fit with who he was so our
values in our ideology are very
important to us and when something
conflicts with that we don’t accept this
challenge to who we are we don’t seek
information and try to actually learn
more we defend ourselves by raising what
we think we know about that issue in
turn creating a graph in creating a gap
in having challenges in terms of
actually learning and gaining the
knowledge that we think we already have
second in this story he used this
experience in data analysis analysts
analysis to justify his position not
having gone through any actual data
analysis we draw on our experience to
justify
what we already think very often in in
this case that’s what he did a second
issue with experience is that while it
does raise our actual knowledge levels
very often making us experts while our
actual knowledge levels raise what we
think we know often raises much higher
than the things we actually learn
creating a gap that may not have existed
before we developed the experience in a
given area so we’ve talked about
specific ideas right like things
specific areas of knowledge personality
can impact our knowledge congruence
across an array of areas for example
narcissists we all expect those people
to think that they know a lot more than
they actually do across topics on the
flip side you have people who are more
conscientious who take the time to
evaluate what they actually know and are
better able to figure out what they need
to do to either learn more if they need
to learn more so a lot of personality
characteristics can come into play in
terms of assessing our own knowledge
levels and then finally much like our
values in ideology our emotions impact
the knowledge congruence when we feel
angry about something we assume that
it’s because we know something about
whatever made us angry we don’t get
angry and think well I don’t know
anything about that but I’m still very
upset so our emotions can significantly
impact not our actual knowledge levels
but our perceive knowledge levels and
creating a gap there so we can see that
this in congruence in our knowledge can
lead to a lot of negative outcomes which
leads through the question of what can
we do unfortunately there’s not really
any simple answer there are a couple of
things that can kind of help guide us
first what we think we know is not
developed in a vacuum we compare
ourselves to others when we think about
how much we know it’s in comparison to
others so thinking about who you’re
comparing yourself
is one of the first steps that we can
take to figure out just how much we
actually know about an issue are you
comparing yourselves to peers or to
experts are you comparing yourself to
someone if you’re having a Facebook
argument with that kind of thing
second they say the first step to
recovery is admitting you have a problem
none of us are immune to these issues
estimating our own knowledge levels is
something because of our values because
of different emotions that we have that
is going to impact us all so simply
accepting that at some point there will
be issues that we will have these
problems with is the first step in being
able to recognize that we are maybe too
emotionally involved to accurately
assess our knowledge to be able to take
a step back think about where we what we
actually know and then go from there
ultimately by being able to be more
introspective and analyze what we
actually know we’ll be able to make
better decisions in our daily lives at
work and then as a society as a whole
so the challenge for all of us then is
to always seek to discover the things
that we don’t know that we don’t know
thank you
[Applause]
[Music]
you
Please follow and like us: